10 WWE Legends Who Had AWFUL Pay-Per-View Debuts
Things can only get better.
When one thinks of the iconic career Steve Austin lived, thoughts immediately turn to beer-soaked bashes, Stunners, middle fingers and Vince McMahon p*ssing his pants. Nobody (of sound body and mind anyway) thinks, 'Gee, that Ringmaster gimmick was fabulous'. Unfortunately for Austin, that's how he got his start in WWE.
As if being treated as a flat in-ring technician who paled in comparison to hokey, cartoonish gimmicks like wrestling plumbers and garbage men wasn't bad enough, one of the most famous faces in pro wrestling history had a rough pay-per-view debut on top of that. Surprised? Don't be, because apparently legends having an awful first supercard experience is some weird tradition us lowly fans don't know about.
Until now.
Austin isn't the only one. After all, he didn't have to play second fiddle to a man dressed as a block of cheese, never had to pretend he was a schmuck who was just lucky to be there and didn't face the indignity of being ignored by a merciless crowd when he was supposed to be booed out of the building...
10. Triple H (SummerSlam 1995)
As Curt Hawkins might say, it's time to face the facts: Hunter Hearst Helmsley wasn't over before he aligned with Shawn Michaels and formed D-Generation X. Pre-1997, and even for most of that year, Helmsley was a struggling mid-carder who had decent matches. That was about it.
SummerSlam 1995 marked his pay-per-view bow against Bob Holly, a man moonlighting as a race car driver who wrestled on the side. The seven-minute match they worked was solid aside from some sloppy spots, but it would have been more at home on Superstars than the summer's biggest card.
For their part, fans in Pittsburgh didn't care a jot.
They'd just witnessed a surprise hit from The 1-2-3 Kid and Hakushi. That opener offered something different to the usual WWF fare while Triple H vs. Holly didn't, and (rather quickly) this snooty new heel looked like he had quite the task on his hands convincing anyone he was a heat-seeker.
9. The Ultimate Warrior (WrestleMania IV)
WrestleMania IV's 14-man WWF Title tournament is largely to blame for why so many fans regard it as one of the worst 'Mania shows of all time. Quality matches were few and far between that day, and that includes the short sprint between Hercules and the rope-shaking, face-painted, all-energy newcomer The Ultimate Warrior.
As future US President Donald Trump looked on from the front row, Warrior ran through some rudimentary spots and eventually powered out of Herc's Full Nelson hold for the win. This was a curious start for someone Vince McMahon was about to strap a rocket to and fire up towards the main event scene.
Warrior missed some moves (including a Clothesline that Hercules still sold) and just didn't come across as the megastar he'd become down the road. At around four minutes, the match was also inconsequential filler on a show people considered too busy to begin with; 'Mania IV had 16 matches.
Things would improve by the time Warrior mowed down The Honky Tonk Man at SummerSlam.
8. Trish Stratus (WrestleMania 2000)
You'd rightly be scratching your head when viewing the attached pic above. Trish Stratus, the feature of this entry, isn't even there. Instead, martial arts hard nut Steve Blackman is booting a human block of cheese in the stomach as Al Snow looks on helplessly.
By the time that was happening, Trish was already backstage eyeing up the showers.
Yes, one of WWE's best female talents ever played second fiddle to Chester bloody McCheeserton during her WrestleMania debut in 2000. It's a wonder she didn't immediately inform the company that this wrestling thing wasn't for her, and fancied going back to glamour shoots.
Stratus' job that night was to manage T&A against Snow and Blackman in a seven-minute nothing of a match that made fans question whether or not Sunday Night Heat was over. Surely this couldn't be 'Mania's main card? It was, and future Hall Of Fame inductee Trish was hidden behind the ongoing 'Head Cheese' nonsense stinking up screens.
7. Batista (Armageddon 2002)
In fairness, neither Batista nor Kane were to blame for their match at Armageddon 2002 sucking. Both were hampered by the circumstances surrounding their first meeting, and there was absolutely nothing wrong with the idea that a veteran like Kane might be able to teach someone WWE had high hopes for a thing or two.
Necrophiliac, drink-driving, murderous Kane.
Batista's big moment came around two months after that nasty Katie Vick angle that made it hard for people to sympathise with Kane. Suddenly, a man WWE were about to thrust into top heel stable Evolution was up against a babyface who had (fans were told) performed sexual acts on a corpse several years ago. Read that again, then skip lunch.
With that kind of backstory, the pair had no chance at Armageddon. Add to that the fact their match fell after a classic between Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit, and it's not difficult to see why Batista doesn't talk much about his first supercard showing.
6. Edge (SummerSlam 1998)
Edge would probably rather people forgot all about his, too.
Following a disaster of a televised debut, in which Edge accidentally injured his opponent's neck during a dive spot, against José Estrada Jr, the Canadian must have been hoping for better things come SummerSlam 1998. He wouldn't get them, because he was a bit-part player thrust into the real story between Marc Mero, Jacqueline and Sable.
Weeks had been spent on TV pondering who Sable would pick to be her mystery tag-team partner on the pay-per-view, and that was a mistake. When it turned out to be a fresh-faced newcomer like Edge who fans weren't familiar with yet, Madison Square Garden groaned for a brief second, then fell completely silent. That had to be crushing for Edge. He was surely banking on a bigger response.
Being ignored by the most famous arena on the circuit can't have been fun, and there was a further sense of apathy whenever Edge entered the ring. People in New York didn't want to see him; they wanted to see Sable get in and kick Mero's ass.
5. Randy Savage (The Wrestling Classic 1985)
There's even a place for beloved super worker Randy Savage on this list, and (again) he's another who isn't fully to blame. Long before WrestleMania IV's aforementioned 14-man tournament, the WWF ran another 16-man tourney called The Wrestling Classic in 1985.
It was anything but a classic.
Savage wrestled four times that night, beating Ivan Putski, Ricky Steamboat, The Dynamite Kid before dropping to The Junkyard Dog at the final hurdle. All of those men were fine performers in their own right, and the matches could've been more significant had 15 matches not been scheduled. Due to those time constraints, Randy couldn't show how gifted an in-ring talent he was.
This was a chance for Savage to prove himself at the highest level, but he was limited to 21 minutes of ring time across his quartet of bouts. Bizarrely, he and future 'Mania III dance partner Steamboat were only handed four measly minutes in the Quarter Finals.
4. Chris Jericho (SummerSlam 1999)
"I gotta' be honest with ya, I'm disappointed".
Those were Chris Jericho's own words as he stood bickering on the stage with Road Dogg at SummerSlam 1999. His frustration wasn't misplaced. A little under two weeks before SummerSlam 1999, Y2J had burst onto the scene with a poodle hairdo amidst much fanfare, and pouted as The Rock tore through his act. It was a debut moment Jericho would come to view as a slight disappointment, but it was still noteworthy.
At SummerSlam, Jericho's only job was to interrupt Road Dogg and kill some pay-per-view time before Al Snow vs. Big Boss Man for the Hardcore Title took over. That was it. No match, no killer intrusion on the main event scene and no direction. Jericho meekly ranted about Raw being a "snore" and called SummerSlam "SummerSham" before Dogg told him to "Suck It".
His segment lasted a few short minutes, didn't lead to anything of any worth and should have taken place on Raw instead. The first time an incoming WCW star like Jericho was on WWF pay-per-view, it should've been in a major spot, not a forgettable promo.
3. The Dudley Boyz (Unforgiven 1999)
In the original ECW, Bubba-Ray and D-Von Dudley were foul-mouthed, violent, confrontational and (above all else) threatening to everyone. They were a throwback of sorts to a time when tag teams could realistically dominate top singles stars because of their teamwork, and they didn't take a back seat for any other duos.
When they signed for WWE in August 1999, they had to eat some sh*t and learn to like it, most notably during their pay-per-view debut at Unforgiven the next month.
Against WWE stalwarts Faarooq and Bradshaw, The Dudleyz were stripped of the aura they'd spent years building in ECW. During the short, TV-style match, they came across as just another tag act instead of a viable threat to anyone; Bubba's lame stutter gimmick didn't help. That only made the Boyz look like idiots.
Fans barely registered a response to the match at all, and that's something The Dudley clan can't have been used to. They'd been working wild brawls to big reactions in the land of extreme, so it must've been quite the shock when The APA pasted them stiffly to mild, rather unenthusiastic cheering before jobbing them out.
2. DDP (King Of The Ring 2001)
At least Kurt Angle had a bright future to look forward to when his pay-per-view debut flopped. By 2001's King Of The Ring, poor Diamond Dallas Page could only stare back at his glory days in WCW and wonder why he'd agreed to a buyout of his AOL/Time Warner contract to join the WWF in 2001.
It wouldn't be worth it.
After being badly rethought as a stalker who wanted The Undertaker to make an example of him ("Make Me Famous"), DDP was then swept aside in a one-sided brawl that wasn't even on the official card. The message was clear: WCW's biggest stars were no match for the WWF's premier names, and Page was barely in the same league as 'Taker.
All he could hope to do was catch The Undertaker's attention by threatening his wife Sara, and none of that added up to fans who did know Page's history. In '01, he was still married to the smoking hot Kimberly Page of Nitro Girls fame, and he'd been one of WCW's headliners for years. Why did he suddenly become a creepy stalker obsessed with Sara?
1. Steve Austin (Royal Rumble 1996)
12 months after this debacle, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin would be booked to pull a fast one on Bret Hart and win the 1997 Royal Rumble. Despite being eliminated, Austin snuck back in and cheated the referee's watchful eye. If only he could've done that in '96.
Entering as #24 in the match was a decent spot for Austin's first Rumble. Despite playing the boring Ringmaster character and being a newcomer to the company, he was scheduled to last until the final four and play a role in the bout's conclusion. Then, it all went wrong.
Instead of catching the bottom rope and escaping elimination after charging at Fatu, Austin tumbled out of the ring prematurely and landed next to the guardrail. On his podcast a few years ago, he'd own up to the botch and reveal his worry over messing up one of WWE's biggest annual occasions.
It was a nightmare pay-per-view debut for the man. Although it didn't end up ruining the night (Shawn Michaels still won as planned and everyone else involved managed to improvise), Austin was highly embarrassed by what had happened and apologised profusely.
What other WWE legends had inauspicious pay-per-view debuts? Let us know your memories in the comments section below!