10 WWE Matches That Completely Fell Short Of Expectations

Six months of build and we got a creepy-crawly lights show at WrestleMania?

Triple H Shane McMahon
WWE

Sometimes, despite the big names, the promotional efforts and all the will in the world, the way a match pans out in real-life isn’t quite the same as the way it sounds in theory.

We don’t have to look too far back to find proof of that point. Just a few weeks ago at Survivor Series, we saw one of the most star-studded main events in history end in lacklustre fashion following a screwjob finish – and a rather convoluted one, at that – which put the old-guard in the spotlight while guys like Finn Bálor, Samoa Joe, and Shinsuke Nakamura sat firmly in the back seat.

Over the years, there have been a fair number of similar instances of matches falling short of expectations, whether that’s due to overpromising with the pre-match build or under-delivering with the end-product.

And interestingly, ther’ve been some repeat offenders along the way, including some of the bigger names the company has to offer. Sometimes there have been contributing factors outside of their control. Other times, that excuse doesn’t quite sit, as we'll soon see in counting down ten WWE matches that completely fell short of expectations.

10. Dean Ambrose Vs. Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania 32)

dean ambrose brock lesnar.jpg
WWE.com

Following a build that had seen Mick Foley proffer Dean Ambrose his signature barbed wire bat, as well as Terry Funk gifting him an actual chainsaw, the street fight between Ambrose and Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 32 was presumably going to be a belter.

Presumably being the operative word.

The match proved to be a thoroughly one-sided affair and a fairly tame one given the stipulation. Lesnar had beaten Ambrose silly in the lead up to the show and it was the same old story come the pay-per-view, while those weapons that Ambrose had been accumulating weren’t even put to good use.

Granted, he did retrieve them from underneath the ring, but that was as far as it went. Not that anyone’s saying he should’ve used a chainsaw on Lesnar, although it does make you wonder why they teased a weapon spot that was too dangerous to even go through with…

In the end, this was little more than a flurry of suplexes, kendo stick strikes and chair shots – so pretty much your average, run-of-the-mill street fight, and a bit of a let-down given its potential.


9. John Cena Vs. Alberto Del Rio (Hell In A Cell 2015)

John Cena Alberto Del Rio
WWE.com

In 2015, a pair of United States title reigns had seen John Cena put on some of the best matches of his entire career, and on free television, too. His US Open Challenge had been a big hit, transforming critics’ perception of him and giving a bunch of mid-card guys a chance to step into the limelight along the way.

However, all that good work came to a grinding halt when the Open Challenge made its way to PPV at Hell in a Cell 2015.

Things had gotten off to a good enough start, with Alberto Del Rio making a surprise return to answer Cena’s call, but after less than eight minutes their match was over.

Of the 21 defences across Cena’s two reigns, only three had been shorter than this one, with some of his Raw matches topping 15, 20 or even 30 minutes.

The match wasn’t necessarily terrible, it was just ended far too soon, and given the way the title had been booked over the preceding seven or so months, the whole thing was a massive anti-climax.


8. Bray Wyatt Vs. Randy Orton (WrestleMania 33)

WWE WrestleMania 33 Bray Wyatt Randy Orton Maggots
WWE.com

Maggots.

After a six-month build, in which Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton went from rivals to partners to rivals again, their feud was ultimately overshadowed by projections of maggots that were plastered across the canvass. Really.

One of the most drawn-out stories of the year degenerated into a glorified special effects show, when just 90 seconds into Wyatt vs Orton – a WWE Championship match, no less – the camera cut to a bird’s-eye view, showing a mass of maggots projected onto the mat below. In fairness, the trick was initially applauded. Second time around, not so much. Upon seeing it happen a third time, most people had already stopped caring.

The stop-start action was in stark contrast to a dramatic build that had seen the pairing go from feuding with one another to winning the tag titles, with Wyatt shunning Luke Harper for Orton, only for the latter to reveal the whole alliance had been a ruse before burning down the Wyatt Family compound and essentially disbanding the faction.

A ten-minute match, regularly interrupted by some hocus pocus light show, wasn’t the pay-off that backstory needed.


7. Goldust Vs. Stardust (Fastlane 2015)

Goldust Stardust Fastlane 2015
WWE.com

When a returning Goldust clashed with his half-brother, Cody Rhodes, at the 2013 Royal Rumble, fans were firmly into the idea of this sibling rivalry amounting to something.

At first, nothing came of it, but when Goldust came back – permanently this time – nine months down the line, a successful run as a tag team suggested the possibility of the feud being revived once their time as partners was over.

Eventually, that’s exactly what happened, but by then it was far too late. Rather than striking while the iron was hot, in the spring of 2013 or even 2014, the company waited until the following year to pull the trigger on this one. By then, no one was really interested in the story anymore. The initial momentum from Goldust’s two returns had been lost, while Rhodes was now portraying the Stardust gimmick, which simply wasn’t as popular.

A feud that had twice piqued fan interest and had all that Rhodes Family history behind it, ultimately became an afterthought on a forgettable B-show PPV. A shame, when you think back to what this could've been in 2013 or ’14.


6. Triple H Vs. Scott Steiner (Royal Rumble 2003)

Steiner Triple H
WWE.com

Credit where it’s due, Scott Steiner got a pretty strong reaction when he returned at Survivor Series 2002 in front of a Madison Square Garden crowd. Fast-forward to the Royal Rumble, though, and it was quite a different story.

In his two months with the company, Steiner hadn’t wrestled a single match, while the build to his Rumble meeting with Triple H had seen minimal contact between the pair, with arm-wrestling segments and a ‘posedown challenge’ in place of any physical confrontation. As such, nobody knew how good – or rather, bad – this one was going to be.

Together, the pair had zero chemistry, and Steiner relied far too heavily on his overhead suplex. The pace was too slow, the crowd stopped caring, and then there was the ultimate sucker punch in the form of a DQ finish.

To cap it off, Steiner beat Triple H up with a sledgehammer after the bell, but even that got booed.

Fans weren’t expecting a masterclass, but the idea of another WWF vs WCW feud was at least appealing on paper. Unfortunately (in this case, at least), wrestling matches don’t take place on paper.


5. Royal Rumble Match, 2015

Big Show Kane Dolph Ziggler Royal Rumble 2015
WWE.com

The 2015 Royal Rumble match often gets a bad rap for its closing scene, but really there were faults top-to-bottom with this one.

First, there was the Daniel Bryan debacle. Retaining his spot in the match on the go-home Raw gave fans a glimmer of hope that he may actually win it, but despite being the overwhelming fan favourite, he entered early at No. 10 and was dumped out in under 11 minutes.

Then, there was the issue of the final four, which included a 42-year-old Big Show and 46-year-old Kane, both of whom eliminated a bunch of younger guys with consummate ease, making them looks like absolute chumps in the process. Their victims included Dean Ambrose, Dolph Ziggler and Bray Wyatt, the latter of whom had lasted 48 minutes and earlier gone on something of an elimination spree, only to see all that work undone in a flash by these two old-timers.

The icing on the cake came in the form of Roman Reigns' win and the failed attempt to use The Rock’s endorsement to help get his cousin over.

The Rumble’s meant to be one of the more exciting matches of the year. This was anything but.


4. Elimination Chamber (December To Dismember 2006)

Paul Heyman December to Dismember Facepalm
WWE

In 2006, at the ECW-branded December to Dismember show, the Elimination Chamber main event was supposed to be the saving grace on a card that featured just two matches announced ahead of show time.

And even though this was WWE’s watered-down version of ECW, at least there were two ECW originals in the match in the form of Rob Van Dam and Sabu, as well as the increasingly popular CM Punk for fans to get behind.

Of course, that changed early in the show when Sabu was written out of the match in a backstage injury angle. And things went from bad to worse when Punk was the first man eliminated half-way through proceedings.

Van Dam would follow shortly after, leaving Bobby Lashley – hand-selected by Vince McMahon and perhaps the most un-ECW guy in the mix – to pin both Test and the Big Show and capture the ECW Championship.

That series of booking choices, each of which was something of a slap in the face of the old ECW name, meant that the longer the match went on, the more disappointing things got. Pretty much the opposite of what you want from a pro wrestling show, then.


3. Shawn Michaels Vs. Mr Perfect (SummerSlam 1993)

SummerSlam 1993 Mr Perfect Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

Two-and-a-half years after their only previous meeting, Shawn Michaels faced Mr Perfect for the Intercontinental title at SummerSlam 1993. Billed as a match to determine the greatest IC Champion of all time, you could argue that neither man was worthy of the claim coming out of this one.

Viewed as your average, one-on-one match, it wasn’t particularly poor, it just wasn’t as good as you might have expected considering the talents of the two guys involved. Perhaps they were having an off-night, but the two just seemed to lack that chemistry and, for whatever reason, things didn’t quite click.

In short; we were promised a classic but didn’t get it.

Plus, after the match had denied Perfect the chance to become the first-ever three-time Intercontinental champion, Michaels went on to vacate the belt anyway the very next month. The storyline reason was for not defending his title for 30 days. In reality, he’d tested positive for steroids.

Factor in the count-out finish and all-in-all, the whole thing was something of an anti-climax.


2. Goldberg Vs. Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania XX)

Lesnar Goldberg WrestleMania XX
WWE

Though they had the Toronto crowd well-and-truly on their side at Survivor Series 2016, things weren’t quite so rosy for Goldberg and Brock Lesnar in Madison Square Garden at WrestleMania XX.

The first-ever meeting between these two freaks of nature should have been one for the ages but instead, all that interest was essentially killed by real-life goings on outside of the ring.

With both guys coming to the end of their contracts, WrestleMania XX was to be last of Goldberg’s and Lesnar’s matches in WWE, and this wasn’t a particularly well-kept secret. With fans inside MSG aware that the pair were on their way out, they responded by completely turning on the match.

In the two-and-a-half, long minutes before they even locked up, the pair’s staredown was overshadowed by a chorus of boos and “you sold out” chants. And even when they did get into it, the big power spots were greeted by even more boos. You can't even say that people didn’t care – they cared alright, they just cared more about voicing their displeasure than anything else.

In hindsight, and as Survivor Series proved, WrestleMania XX was just the wrong time and place for this particular match-up.


1. Triple H Vs. Randy Orton (WrestleMania 25)

Orton Triple H WrestleMania XXV
WWE.com

Having been scheduled to close out a show that had already staged Shawn Michaels vs. the Undertaker – arguably the greatest ‘Mania match of all time – Triple H and Randy Orton were facing an uphill battle right off the bat.

Also, with a backstory as personal as this one, in which Orton had attacked and then kissed Stephanie McMahon after Triple H had “broken into” Orton’s home, the eventual match felt like it needed a No Disqualification type of stipulation. Unfortunately, it lacked one, while there was also the added condition that Triple H would lose his title in the event that he was disqualified, making this about as far from being a No DQ match as reasonably possible.

As such, you could argue this one was always likely to struggle to live up to the pre-match hype, and that ultimately proved to be the case. Both guys hit their finishers early, in an attempt to start the match off hot when it might have been better to have allowed the fans to come back down to earth following that ‘Taker match before gradually building back to a grand finale.

From there, the action just never really picked up. And to top it all off, Triple H used a sledgehammer anyway, nullifying that stipulation about him losing the title.

All things considered, and for a number of reasons, this just felt like too flat of a finish for the 25th edition of WrestleMania.


Contributor
Contributor

Elliott Binks hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.