10 WWE Nightmares That Thankfully Never Came True

Scare Stories

Ultimate Warrior Steve Austin WrestleMania XV
WWE

The present day is a rare time when Vince McMahon's wildest dreams are, for now, marrying up with those of his audience. At WWE's September supercard No Mercy, Brock Lesnar will defend his Universal Title against Braun Strowman in an end-of-days monster mash, whilst John Cena and Roman Reigns compete for his affection in the ultimate McMahon machine cockfight.

But alas, the times feel a little rare. Longterm fans will know that a stinking storyline or creative calamity aren't ever that far away, even when the entire product is at its hottest. Now more than ever McMahon has the freedom to try anything he likes, and perhaps appropriately not, ensure his relatively stable boat remains un-rocked.

This removes much of the company's propensity for unpredictability, rendering certain three-hour flagship broadcasts virtually unwatchable, but also restricts the key decision-maker from engaging in something so ridiculous it threatens to tank an entire industry.

CM Punk once infamously accused Vince McMahon of surrounding himself with "glad-handing nonsensical douchebag yes men", but that thankfully wasn't always the case. Had it not been for whichever particular voice of reason got in the ear of the Chairman, some of his worst throwaway concepts could have been legendary low-points.

10. Screwed: The Bret Hart Story

Bret Hart Vince McMahon
WWE

It was with some trepidation that Bret Hart returned to the WWE fold in 2005, but the mutually beneficial compromise at least ensured one of the finest performers in company history wouldn't be immortalised by a low-rent hatchet job designed to sell out a legacy the man himself cared deeply for.

'Bret 'Hitman' Hart - The Best There Is : The Best There Was : The Best There Ever Will Be' was the DVD boxset the five-time WWE Champion desperately wanted. Criticised for his occasionally sanctimonious self-aggrandising, the 'Hitman' was at least correct in his assertions about his own skill. There were few ever better than Bret, and the exhaustive documentary and carefully curated match selection summed up the commitment and dedication to a career not defined by one ugly peek into wrestling's grim reality.

It was ever so nearly a very different story.

Lacking Bret's involvement in the project for a period, the company had started work on 'Screwed: The Bret Hart Story', focusing predominantly on the infamous 1997 night in Montreal at the expense of his 20+ years as one of the finest to ever step between the ropes. Hart had only to view 'The Self-Destruction Of The Ultimate Warrior' (and already-recorded criticisms form Jerry Lawler, Hulk Hogan, and others) to realise how his own profile would turn out, and got involved to steer the ship to safety.


9. The Next Big Thing, Brother

Brock Lesnar Hulk Hogan Smackdown 2002
WWE.com

Hulk Hogan's 2002 resurgence was to some, the most satisfying period of his entire career.

By merely returning to work for Vince McMahon after a tumultuous nine year absence, Hogan represented a necessary shot of nostalgia injected into an audience struggling to stay in love with a product sagging after the golden days of the Attitude Era.

But when it became apparent how limited he looked in comparison to some of the company's best and brightest, his uncharacteristic unselfishness became an even more rewarding return from the company's initial reinvestment.

Hogan first put over The Undertaker to conclude his brief run with the WWE Title, then tapped out to Kurt Angle, and most notably took an unthinkable thrashing from Brock Lesnar on 'The Beast's road to SummerSlam.

It was Hogan's best ever torch pass. 'The Next Big Thing' annihilated 'The Hulkster', bloodying him up and forcing a submission through a simple bearhug. Such willingness to look weak had seemed unthinkable just two years earlier as Stone Cold Terry Bollea battered The New Blood in WCW, but this was clearly a new man.

Sort of, anyway.

As it turned out, Hogan thought, with penance served, he could comfortably get his win back on a much bigger stage. Suggesting that he end Brock's title reign and unbeaten streak at Madison Square Garden's Survivor Series, he was furious when the assertion was laughed off, and disappeared from the company entirely until the following year.

McMahon's Big Show solution wasn't much better in truth, but he was at least a literal giant, and briefly considered Lesnar's equal. Hogan then, as he is now, was a beatable relic.


8. Bieber Fever

justin bieber bray wyatt
WWE.com

Revealed by former WWE writer Kevin Eck after his departure from the company, divisive popstar Justin Bieber was at one point pencilled in to join John Cena and The Big Show in a match against The Wyatt Family at SummerSlam 2014.

'The Biggest Party Of The Summer' had a distinctly showbiz theme for a number of years thanks to its repeated presence at Los Angeles' Staples Center, and as inarguably one of the biggest stars in the world, Bieber's appearance would have surely brought forth enormous mainstream attention.

Past the point where anything could logically be planned in time though, the idea collapsed. WWE had by then started making him part of their own 'Universe', when heel Seth Rollins was referred to as the company's 'Justin Bieber' in derisory terms by various babyfaces, which showed paradoxical understanding from the creative team that he'd likely be booed even if presented as a fan favourite.

The potential for disaster in a Bieber appearance was great, and the thankful sidestep away from the sideshow afforded fans one of the most intense SummerSlam main events in company history. Free from the celebrity spinoff, John Cena defended his newly-won WWE Title against Brock Lesnar in a match many consider to be as significant and decisive a win for 'The Beast' as his WrestleMania XXX streak-ender was earlier that year.


7. Baron Von Bava

Heidenreich Undertaker Survivor Series 2004
WWE

Required watching for sitcom aficionados, the 2014 BBC series Detectorists beautifully charts the regular non-adventures of a pair of metal detector enthusiasts who scan the ground day and night ostensibly looking for gold but subconsciously searching for a greater meaning to life in general.

It's a measured and realistic take of a niche hobby, and adds depth and gravitas to a pastime many would consider obscure, and most would consider pointless.

Wrestling fans have themselves been beaten with a similar stick, and it's perhaps that aspect of the utterly absurd Baron Von Bava gimmick that first appealed to Vince McMahon. That, or the fact he had the opportunity to promote a cryogenically frozen 1940s Nazi!

Ex-writer Dan Madigan spilled the beans on the daft gimmick. Having crafted the plot for WWE Studios' moderate success story See No Evil, Madigan pitched the persona, noting also that it should be noted Jewish star Paul Heyman that 'unfreeze' the dangerous monster. Unsurprisingly, Madigan wasn't long for WWE after such an audacious pitch, but elements of Von Bava's overall presentation did seem to land surreptitiously in the lap of John Heidenreich.

Alongside Heyman and with a fearsome chanting entrance theme soundtracking the spring in his goose-step, tiny fragments of the defrosted Von Bava did make it to air, if not in quite as farcical a mould they were perhaps intended.


6. WrestleMania VI: No Holds Barred

Hulk Hogan Zeus WrestleMania VI
WWE

The Ultimate Warrior's WrestleMania VI WWE Title victory over Hulk Hogan didn't end up as an industry-defining elevation of the wrestling business' next big megastar, but the lengthy and rewarding main event between the two superhero superheavyweights did everything possible to try and achieve its goal.

Working way beyond their selective limitations on the 'Grandest Stage', the pair surpassed even the wildest expectations of most, and crafted a spectacle that ensured the Toronto 'Show Of Shows' would go down as one of the most memorable.

When compared to Vince McMahon's original idea for the show's 'blockbuster' main event though, it's perhaps the finest turnaround in company history.

Having tried and failed to make Hulk Hogan's 'No Holds Barred' turkey a cinematic success, McMahon had, by late 1989 accepted that a match featuring the two main stars was a dual box office flop. Before this point, his blind faith that the movie would be a monster hit resulted in Zeus earning the biggest payday of the year against Hogan in a final battle between the two.

Zeus’ (restricted) input in the SummerSlam and Survivor Series matches highlighted just some of the obstacles the pair would face, and a December pay-per-view experiment featuring the movie back-to-back with a Hogan/Beefacke/Zeus/Savage cage rematch failed to live up to financial expectations. By now, Vince had accepted defeat on the entire Hollywood debacle, and began lining up Warrior not only for the April superclash, but as Hulk's long-term replacement.


5. All The Gold

King Mabel
WWE

Commonly considered WWE's creative nadir and irrefutably the organisation's darkest day financially, 1995 is still overly maligned in company canon thanks largely to some wilful neglect of the state of the mainstream wrestling industry at the time. ECW was loudly trumpeted but by a minute minority, and WCW was a long way from truly kickstarting a second boom period with the New World Order. The former market leader remained trapped in a constant state of flux until the next move became apparent.

In that time, Vince McMahon continued to experiment, usually with increasingly detrimental effect. Never was that more apparent than at June's King of the Ring, when a partisan ECW crowd in the Philadelphia CoreStates Spectrum loudly jeered the crowning of Mabel and flooded the final match in particular with chants of the renegade group's initials.

It was very, very bad, but it could have been so much worse.

It was clear how high McMahon was on the Men on a Mission giant for a brief spell at least, and the real-life Nelson Frazier confirmed as much in a 2010 interview with Arda Ocal four years before his unfortunate passing. In reference to his WWE Title match against Diesel that headlined SummerSlam '95, he claimed, "actually Vince was leaning towards me (to win the WWE title) but if anyone knows about The Kliq they can change things around and that's what happened. The finish was changed."


4. Boy Wonder Blunder

Shane McMahon, Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

After Brock Lesnar has gleefully left half of the contents of Randy Orton's skull on the SummerSlam 2016 canvas, he elected to extend the beatings to SmackDown Commissioner Shane McMahon.

'The Boy Wonder' had arrived at ringside to try and protect his investment. A month or so before the August supercard, WWE had reverted to the split brand format, with the Lesnar/Orton clash facilitating a Raw vs. SmackDown element to the pay-per-view as well as offering name value atop the card.

Standing up to the fearsome Lesnar (as just about nobody on the roster would ordinarily be permitted to do), Shane went nose to nose with 'The Beast' and ultimately took an F5 for his moxie.

Astonishingly, despite 'The Beast' being the most destructive and fearsome force the company has managed to promote for over a decade, this pedestrian beatdown of the boss' boy was designed to lead to a WrestleMania match between the pair.

Wrestling Observer doyen Dave Meltzer reported that only Bill Goldberg's October signing resulted in the bout being scrapped, so it's the former WCW Champion who should really be thanked for sparing an embarrassing scene.

As per rules of booking 'Shane-O-Mac', he'd have to look on par with Brock's hybrid style. And then perhaps even threaten to tap him out. Fortunately, the impending Goldberg feud spared viewers of such a ludicrous conceit.


3. Jackasses

Jackass Umaga WWE SummerSlam 2007 Poster
WWE

The WWE brand was poisonous in 2007 following the Chris Benoit double-murder suicide. So much so, that despite teaser trailers and extensive co-promotion, a planned union with the crew from MTV's Jackass for a contest with Umaga was abruptly binned at the requests of the stunt stars.

Initially, the plan called for the group to cost 'The Samoan Bulldozer' a match at July's Great American Bash pay-per-view, but as the news media rounded on the company in the wake of the Benoit tragedy, Johnny Knoxville elected not to appear at the show, nor at previously discussed television tapings in the aftermath.

The deal between the two parties was allegedly brokered by Shane McMahon and likely co-signed by his father in a typically transparent grasp at mainstream attention, but the damage done to the company's public perception was forcibly felt when a change of plans were suddenly required.

In hindsight, WWE may have actually avoided a worst case scenario. Jackass members Steve-O and Chris Pontius had appeared on a 2006 edition of Monday Night Raw to take a beating from the superlative Samoan, however they somewhat missed the point of the segment. Despite taking an impressive sh*t-kicking, the pair chuckled and smirked their way through the massacre, with Steve-O in particular suffering quite the pasting as a result of his perceived disrespect.

Umaga was a character that constantly walked a credibility tightrope, and the prospect of a full match derailing as this segment did wouldn't have remotely helped his cause.


2. Austin. Tyson. Warrior?

Ultimate Warrior Vince McMahon 1996
WWE.com

Just days before his untimely passing, the Ultimate Warrior was pictured tightly embracing Vince McMahon, signifying yet another hatchet buried on what would turn out to be the final weekend of his life.

Hindsight rapidly presented the 1996 re-signing of the former star as a major creative and financial blunder. McMahon himself even alluded to it in online interviews at the time, tacitly criticising Warrior's dated persona and unprofessional conduct, effectively confirming what many fans had felt before he'd even made his ill-advised WrestleMania XII return.

By late 1997, Warrior had been gone again 18 months, and WWE itself had changed irreversibly. Stone Cold Steve Austin was nailed on to be the next breakout act, with his ascension timing out perfectly with the controversial exit of Bret Hart and physical and mental unravelling of Shawn Michaels.

Absolutely unthinkable until it was leaked in 2014 though, was that McMahon still believed Warrior would be a better fit to lead his organisation than Austin and the host of competitive and exciting new talents at his disposal.

In a contract offer dated 17 December 1997, Vince offered Warrior a 5-year deal at $750,000 per annum guaranteed, only two months removed from telling Bret Hart he couldn't afford his $1million p/a contract. Working only 14 days a month for that wage with a very lucrative merchandise agreement and promise of a fresh run on top, the prospect of Warrior steamrolling over Austin, Michaels, The Rock, Triple H (again), Mankind, and numerous other megastars of the era must have seemed ludicrous to most then as it still does now. 'The Rattlesnake' and Warrior main eventing three WrestleManias against one another seems even sillier.


1. Mac Daddy

Stephanie McMahon Vince McMahon Linda McMahon Shane McMahon
WWE

When Vince McMahon used his own DVD profile to confirm a rumour that he'd pitched several variations of an incest storyline utilising his nearest and dearest, it blew apart the traditional method of story-sharing between fans of his bizarre product.

The Internet Wrestling Community is built upon discussion of every unique aspect of the peculiar past-time, but speculative debate on the rumour, gossip and hearsay reported by those with links and leaks within the WWE system usually takes precedence.

A longstanding point of contention centred around McMahon's apparent interest in working the birth of daughter Stephanie's first child into storylines. To the 'Billion Dollar Princess' bewilderment, he pitched an idea where he'd be the father. When this was sensibly blocked he kept swinging, instead proffering Shane as having done the dirtiest of deeds. It was again, disgustedly rebuked.

That this anecdote wasn't snuck out via an inside source but delivered from Stephanie's own talking head remains possibly the most shocking thing of all. “I don't know who would find entertainment in a storyline like that,” she said, sounding more discerning and logical than her character ever had done on screen. Clearly she'd overlooked WWE's most dedicated supporter, its audience of one - her own father.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.