10 WWE NXT Flops Who Should Have Been Huge

WWE's finishing school brings no guarantee of success, or even graduation...

Hideo Itami
WWE.com

NXT has been a reliable source of fresh main roster talent since its inception as a game show in 2010, with the brand's alumni comprising a huge percentage of WWE's current top stars. From Finn Bálor and Kevin Owens to Charlotte and Sasha Banks, some of the company's most important performers cut their teeth in NXT, and the Performance Center has proved itself as a fertile breeding ground for the next wave of talent.

Intended as the ultimate pro-wrestling finishing school, it takes wrestlers from a wide variety of different backgrounds and sculpts them into TV-ready superstars. It has been extremely successful in doing so, but adding "NXT" to your resumé is no guarantee of success, and dozens of talented wrestlers have lost their way in developmental.

NXT has served up plenty of disappointment over the years. It's an effective system, but not a flawless one, and its history is laced with squandered potential. Excluding any wrestler who ever transitioned into a permanent, long-term main roster spot (a success in itself, regardless of card position), here are the wrestlers who should've been stars, but couldn't live up to their own hype, even if it wasn't entirely their own fault...

10. Raquel Diaz

Raquel Diaz Shaul Guerrero NXT
WWE.com

Professional wrestling is built on the names of its greatest dynasties, and some of the sport’s most decorated performers have come from their family’s second or third generation. Guys like Terry Funk and Randy Orton have built outstanding careers on their pedigree, but while coming from a celebrated bloodline certainly helps a wrestler break into the business, staying there is a lot harder, as Raquel Diaz found out.

Born in El Paso, Texas, she is the eldest daughter of Vickie and Eddie Guerrero, making her a part of one of the sport’s most decorated ancestries. Her time in WWE developmental was full of ups and downs, however. Debuting in 2010, she starred in FCW, holding the territory’s Divas Championship for 197 days, and maintained a strong televised presence following the NXT re-branding in 2012.

Guerrero was granted her release to attend school that September, but returned the following year. The second run didn’t last, and she was gone by April 2014, having not made a single televised appearance. An eating disorder reportedly prompted her decision, and Diaz’s incredible pedigree has since gone to waste, as she hasn’t wrestled after leaving WWE.


9. James Storm

James Storm NXT
WWE.com

A TNA mainstay for over 13 years, James Storm’s time with the promotion looked to be coming to an end in 2015. The former Heavyweight Champion’s contract expired that June, though he continued on a pay-per-appearance deal for a few more months, before showing-up unannounced at a set of NXT TV tapings that October.

Storm drew a hearty pop from the Full Sail University faithful, who were wise to the good work he’d done in TNA over the years. He defeated Danny Burch in a quick match, before returning in December, scoring his second WWE victory over Adam Rose, but everything went quiet shortly after. Having previously signalled his desire to join WWE, it was later revealed that Storm had turned their contract offer down, and opted to re-sign with TNA instead.

Perhaps it’s harsh to call Storm a “flop,” as he was barely there long enough to brew a cup of coffee. It’s impossible to view his short run as anything other than a disappointment, however. His skill, charisma, and experience would have made him the perfect choice for a gatekeeper’s role on the developmental brand, but it wasn’t to be.


8. Richie Steamboat

Richie Steamboat NXT
WWE

One of the biggest highlights of NXT’s early shows, Richie Steamboat is the spitting image of his father Ricky, and a solid wrestler in his own right. Working a classic, ‘80s-influenced style, he brought bags of technical ability to the brand, and featured prominently, feuding with the likes of Kassius Ohno following FCW’s re-branding in 2012.

Unfortunately, Richie’s career started to unravel shortly after. He suffered a nasty back injury in November 2012, and this ultimately brought his professional wrestling career to an end. Steamboat was released following over a year of inactivity in 2013, and in April 2015, Richie’s father claimed that due to the injury and subsequent surgery, he’d never be able to wrestle again.

Steamboat’s demise came through severe misfortune rather than any fault of his own, but his potential still went unfulfilled. His family name would have given him immediate credibility had he ever made it to the main roster, and with a few years of extra developmental seasoning, Richie could have been an exciting prospect on Raw or SmackDown. Fate was not on his side, however, and his demise highlights how cruel and unforgiving this sport can be.


7. Sofia Cortez

Sofia Cortez WWE
WWE

Had Sofia Cortez stayed with NXT, she’d likely be a multi-time Women’s Champion by now, both in developmental and on the main roster. Signed through Tough Enough in 2011, she lasted just over a full year before leaving the company in August 2012, following an alleged bust-up with controversial head trainer Bill DeMott.

Cortez has since stated that she was one of the first wrestlers to report DeMott for alleged misconduct, and believes that reporting him to WWE’s higher-ups was the reason for her release. DeMott would later resign from his position following widescale accusations of mistreatment and abuse, adding weight to Cortez’ claims, and if it weren’t for him, she’d likely still be with the company today.

Again, “flop” could be perceived as a harsh term here, but Cortez’ post-WWE work demonstrates just how big an asset she should’ve been to the company. She has developed into a tremendous wrestler as Lucha Underground’s Ivelisse, standing out for her toughness, charisma, and willingness to go toe-to-toe with anybody, regardless of size or gender. Her performances speak for themselves, and had things gone differently, she’d be remembered as a major WWE Performance Center success story.


6. Kaval

Kaval WWE Survivor Series 2010
WWE.com

Low Ki is one of the most decorated performers in independent wrestling history. An intense, hard-hitting striker, he’d made his name through stunning performances for companies like ROH and PWG, before eventually signing for WWE following his second stint with TNA in 2008.

Ki was renamed Kaval, and started working with the likes of Wade Barrett and Alberto Del Rio in FCW. His NXT affiliation began in 2010, when the brand was still a reality show, and her entered the second season under the tutelage of Michelle McCool and Layla. Kaval was a huge success, and soon stood out as the show’s most noteworthy performer, before eventually winning the season on August 31st.

Anticipation was high, but Kaval’s push didn’t live up to expectations. His style just didn’t mesh with WWE, and after being moved to SmackDown, his career went down the pan. Kaval racked-up regular losses throughout the year, with the most notable being an unsuccessful Intercontinental Title challenge in November, before leaving the company the following month. His televised run lasted less than six months in total, and he soon returned to the indies, where he continues today.


5. Andrade Almas

andrade cien almas
WWE Network

There’s a chance that Andrade ‘Cien’ Almas could still turn his ailing WWE career around, but this seems extremely unlikely at this point. Unfortunately, the former CMLL standout hasn’t found his niche in NXT, and while his heel turn has coincided with a big improvement in his work, it hasn’t brought him a stronger push.

WWE flubbed their lines by bringing the former La Sombra in as a babyface and immediately booking him against Tye Dillinger, whose popularity was going through the roof. This made it incredibly difficult to cheer for Almas, and he was given little opportunity to further his bland character over the coming months, before eventually snapping on Cedric Alexander and reverting to a watered down version of the heel persona that made him famous in the first place.

Almas’ current gimmick is that he’s too focused on his life outside the ring to win consistently, and it has left him dead in the water. Once one of Mexico’s most exciting high flyers, ‘Cien’ has become a non-entity, and each new NXT debutant seems to surge past him in the pecking order, with Roderick Strong and Aleister Black the latest examples. A hyped signing at the time, he now looks consigned to the scrapheap.


4. Solomon Crowe

solomon crowe
WWE.com

Solomon Crowe’s WWE run marks him as one of the biggest busts in NXT history. A former tag partner of Dean Ambrose on the indie circuit, Crowe joined his former friend in WWE in May 2013, but his career never really got off the ground, and it took over a year before he eventually featured on television.

Saddled with a hacker gimmick, Solomon would use a tablet to take control of the arena’s lights during live events, utilising the tactic to distract opponents before their match. He was supposed to make his televised debut in February 2014, but the appearance was scrapped, and his big debut didn’t come until a full year later, when he attacked CJ Parker.

Crowe’s appearances were sporadic at best however, and it didn’t help that WWE had him coat himself with fake tan and style his hair to the point where he looked like a cartoon character. Frustrated with his role in the company, Crowe was granted his release that November, and returned to his old Sami Callihan moniker on the indies. He has since become one of the scene’s hottest commodities, and is once again showing the aggressive qualities that made him a hyped prospect in the first place.


3. Derrick Bateman

Derrick Bateman
WWE.com

Derrick Bateman is a unique NXT flop in that he has definitely become huge over the past few years, but without WWE’s help. As Ethan Carter III, his performances have been a rare bright spot throughout one of the most difficult periods in TNA’s history. He’s one of their most important wrestlers, and someone who has proved WWE were wrong to let him go by succeeding in Impact’s main event scene.

A former FCW trainee, Bateman’s NXT run began in the reality show’s fourth season, when he was paired with Daniel Bryan. He failed, but reappeared in the fifth season, before entering a turgid romance angle with Maxine and Johnny Curtis. By 2012, Bateman became a full-time developmental wrestler once again, and was restricted to playing a losing role to the brand’s more celebrated prospects.

He was released in May 2013, and his subsequent work proves that WWE had no idea what they had in him. EC3 isn’t exactly AJ Styles between the ropes, but his charisma is through the roof, and he oozes the star-power that Vince McMahon usually demands from his top stars. Hindsight’s 20/20, of course, but he was a huge WWE developmental flop.


2. Kassius Ohno

Kassius Ohno
WWE.com

Widely regarded as one of the greatest independent wrestlers of all time, Kassius Ohno should probably be one of WWE’s biggest stars by now. The former Chris Hero was always a standout during his first developmental run, and was even considered for Roman Reigns’ spot in The Shield at one point. He was disappointingly released in 2013, however, and returned to the sport’s smaller stages thereafter.

Hero picked-up exactly where he left off, and resumed his role as an independent all-star. This culminated with an immensely successful 2016 that saw him churn out stunning Match Of The Year calibre bouts on a near-weekly basis, which eventually caught WWE’s attention once again. By January 2017, Kassius Ohno was back in an NXT ring.

He has done little of note since returning however, and doesn’t look like breaking into the brand’s crowded main event scene anytime soon. Unless the likes of Roderick Strong and Bobby Roode fall off, Ohno is going to find it exceedingly difficult to make it in NXT, and will likely remain on the fringes. There’s still time, of course, but the prognosis isn’t looking good at all.


1. Hideo Itami

Austin Aries Hideo Itami
WWE.com

At this stage, it’s impossible to label Hideo Itami’s NXT run as anything other than a complete failure. Once one of Japan’s most respected wrestlers, the former ROH and Pro Wrestling Noah star retains a significant fanbase, but his act hasn’t translated at all. The former KENTA feels very much like a watered down version of his old self, and while his heel turn could rectify this, time is running out for the 36 year old.

Itami arrived in 2014, and has been plagued by injury problems ever since. A severely dislocated shoulder suffered in May 2015 kept him out of action for over a year, and he succumbed to major neck damage soon after returning, sidelining him for another seven months. His most recent comeback began in April 2017, and Itami challenged Bobby Roode for the NXT Championship at TakeOver: Chicago, but was unsuccessful.

Injuries aren’t Hideo’s only issue, however. WWE’s in-ring restrictions have curbed his aggressive, hard-hitting wrestling style, and Daniel Bryan’s use of stiff kicks and running knees coupled with CM Punk’s adoption of the Go 2 Sleep have robbed him of his best moves. He has since recovered the G2S, but Itami clearly isn’t the competitor he used to be, and his pre-debut hype feels like a distant memory.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.