10 WWE Royal Rumble Eliminations More Significant Than You First Thought

The surprising backstage stories behind some infamous eliminations

Bret Hart Royal Rumble
WWE.com

Since its inception, the Royal Rumble has often served as a breeding ground for WWE's headline storylines leading into its biggest show, and is regarded by many fans as the most must-watch show of the calendar year.

Unfortunately, these matches often have unintended consequences. In the last decade, fans have almost become accustomed to being disappointed by the Rumble match itself, and for good reason - at times, it does seem like Vince McMahon and his cronies have went out of their way to p*ss them off. Oftentimes, it can be a single elimination that sends the WWE Universe into meltdown - be it a fan favourite getting eliminated early, a heel getting a win he didn't deserve or even a disappointing return, even a single elimination can prove to have a butterfly effect, going on to drastically change WWE's plans for the rest of the year.

Be it good or bad, there's almost too much to say about some of WWE's booking choices in the last 30 years - here are some of the most unintentionally significant eliminations in Royal Rumble history.

10. Chris Jericho (2012)

Royal Rumble 2012 Sheamus Chris Jericho
WWE

In November 2011, ominous vignettes started airing promoting the return of an unknown wrestler. These vignettes showed a, well, creepy young boy and girl standing in an empty classroom spouting vague, prophetic lines such as “The power will come with vengeance, to render his anger with fury” while rapidly alternating between shots of the children and shots of “scary” images, such as swing sets or erm…. trees.

The internet immediately began swarming with rumours that these vignettes were promoting a returning Undertaker, or maybe even the debut of Sting. They were for Chris Jericho. Maybe was undergoing another character transformation? Well, he was slightly snarkier now, but thats about it. Jericho ended up debuting weeks later, announcing he was going to win the Rumble and it would be “the end of the world as we knew it”. He came close, entering at #28 and eliminating two people in five minutes. He then traded near-eliminations with Sheamus, before he was thrown out following a failed codebreaker attempt. Sheamus, who just months earlier had been feuded with Mark Henry over Henry being “a bully”. All that hype… to be trolled?

What makes this elimination so significant?

It was just another reminder to the fans that Vince McMahon pushes who he wants, and it was a prime example of WWE taking the more complicated route just for the case of suspense. And what about the first ever Undisputed Champion? Well, he ended up facing CM Punk for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 28 anyway. Was it really worth the trolling? Imagine if he had just won the Rumble instead - it would have been a legitimate storyline worth investing in.

It's easy to forget how Sheamus’ title shot went, but it doesn't take more than 18 seconds to remember.


9. The British Bulldog (1995)

Shawn Michaels Royal Rumble 1995
WWE.com

Both feet must hit the ground to be eliminated. Both feet must hit the ground. Is it clear that both feet must hit the ground? Don’t forget, both feet must hit the ground. Yeah, this is where every commentator’s favourite trope began.

When The British Bulldog knocked Shawn Michaels over the top rope during the climax of the 1995 Royal Rumble, it really did look like he had been eliminated, for all the home viewers could see was Shawn appearing to hit the ground. Bulldog began to celebrate, and the cameras quickly cut to a shot of Bulldog celebrating. However, Davey’s celebrations were quickly cut short as the 'Heartbreak Kid' appeared out of nowhere, tossing Bulldog over the top rope before collapsing in victory. There was an immediate state of confusion in the USF Sun Dome. Hadn’t Michaels been eliminated? He went over the top rope after all…

When Howard Finkel announced over the microphone that only one of HBK’s feet had hit the ground, the people of Tampa erupted, realising that they’d been had. Besides Shawn being the first person to win from #1, this elimination is incredibly significant as it opened the door for some of the Royal Rumble’s most iconic spots, such as Kofi Kingston’s legendary handstand in 2012 and John Morrison’s insane parkour at the 2009 edition of the Rumble.

Several superstars (such as the aforementioned Kingston) crafted some of their biggest rumble moments out of the template that Shawn had laid out for them, all due to one simple rule: Both feet must hit the ground.


8. Mark Henry (1999)

Chyna Mark Henry Royal Rumble
WWE.com

With wrestlers like Becky Lynch, Charlotte and Alexa Bliss being part of the company's most memorable storylines and even main-eventing pay-per-views occasionally, it's easy to forget how WWE's treatment of women rarely went beyond objectifying them until the very recent past. Think back to the late 90s and ignore all the valets, managers and announcers - try and think of a woman who was taken seriously as a wrestler.

Even when the company was at its creative peak, only a handful of women were taken seriously as wrestlers. It would be years before WWE's acclaimed Women's Revolution, but there was one woman who was laying the groundwork decades in advance - Chyna.

Chyna's elimination of Mark Henry in the 1999 Royal Rumble marked one of the first times that women began to be seen as serious wrestlers. And while it would take 16 years for WWE's actual Women's Revolution, the 'Ninth Wonder Of the World' laid some groundwork for it here.


7. The Big Show (2004)

Chris Benoit Royal Rumble 2005
WWE Network

The Royal Rumble that never happened.

On June 24th, 2007, the day of the Benoit family murder-suicide, the 2004 Royal Rumble erased from the mutual consciousness as the company made immediate efforts to disassociate themselves from its winner, Chris Benoit. The blackballing of this match is truly unfortunate, as it is undeniably one of the greatest Royal Rumble matches ever produced by WWE.

From start to finish, the match was a heartbreaking, gripping story that culminated with Chris Benoit eliminated The Big Show to win the Royal Rumble from the #1 spot, lasting the full 60 minutes in contrast to the half an hour Shawn Michaels grafted through just under a decade earlier. Although the elimination was a defining moment in Benoit's career, it became known as one of WWE's darkest moments in retrospect.

After Benoit's death, WWE made efforts to distance themselves from the former World Champion, and this Rumble would seldom be mentioned.


6. Bret Hart (1997)

Bret Hart Steve Austin
WWE.com

Professional Wrestling in the 1980s was simple. Flashy superstars such as Hulk Hogan, Randy Savage and the Ultimate Warrior were the faces of the company, with their chiseled bodies and natural charisma skyrocketing them to the top. Of course, they needed heels to defeat, and slimy, crafty wrestlers like Ric Flair and Jake Roberts served as the perfect foil to them. For years, heels and faces had defined roles... until a certain Steve Austin made his debut.

While Austin had already kicked off his rise after winning the previous year's King Of The Ring, it could be argued that his character wasn't entirely defined until this match. Entering at the #5 position, Austin eliminated eight people before being eliminated by Bret Hart. However, in the chaos that was Terry Funk and Mankind's brawl, none of the officials noticed the Texas Rattlesnake being eliminated, so he just jumped back in.

Hart would eventually eliminate the other remaining wrestlers, but was eliminated by Austin when celebrating what he thought was a Royal Rumble victory - Austin had won the match, not Hart.

The elimination defined the 'Stone Cold' character, and gave birth to a character unfamiliar to the WWE - the 'cool' heel. Austin's popularity as a 'bad guy' laid the groundwork for hundreds of men after him, and it can't be overstated just how important this match was to that.


5. Roman Reigns (2018)

shinsuke nakamura roman reigns royal rumble 2018
WWE.com

Having won the 2015 match, finished 2nd in the 2014 and 2017 editions and 3rd in the 2016 match, Roman Reigns entered the 2018 Rumble boasting an average Rumble finish of 2nd place. That statistic alone is incredible, let alone the fact that Reigns had only been a singles competitor for 3 years.

It was no surprise, then, that Roman found himself one of the final 2 competitors of the 2018 Royal Rumble match, but this time it was different - Reigns was face to face with one of the greatest Japanese wrestlers of all time in Shinsuke Nakamura, and Nakamura had the entire Wells Fargo Center singing his theme song minutes earlier.

While the WWE universe had been teased before with the prospect of an 'indie darling' dethroning the 'Big Dog', they had never seen an independent wrestler thwart Reigns in a Rumble match, which is what made Nakamura's victory so much sweeter.

Reigns' elimination gave the fans a much-needed breath of fresh air, and although Nakamura's victory never really amounted to everything, it's still an iconic moment and the perfect ending to one of the greatest Rumbles ever.


4. Daniel Bryan (2015)

Daniel Bryan Bray Wyatt Royal Rumble 2015
WWE.com

One of the most genuinely shocking eliminations in Royal Rumble history, especially due to how early into the match it occured, the elimination of Daniel Bryan by Bray Wyatt in 2015 is often cited as a reason that this is one of the worst Rumbles ever.

If Bryan's WrestleMania 30 triumph was a sign that WWE cared about what their fans thought, his 2015 Royal Rumble elimination burned that sign to the ground. Despite the ludicrous decision, however, it's difficult not to step back and admire WWE for just how little they gave a sh*t. Specifically about ever making this version of Bryan champion again.

He'd spend the next few months in the midcard while Reigns skyrocketed to the top, and it's hard to debate that this elimination was prophetic of Reign's rise - the most natural babyface of the modern era being pushed to the side for possible the most forced face in WWE history.


3. Alex Reily (2011)

Alex Riley Royal Rumble 2011
WWE Network

The 2011 Royal Rumble gets a lot of (admittedly earned) flak because of its size and winner, but it had some truly memorable moments. Among them, the Nexus running rampant for much of the match, the return of Diesel and... Alex Reilly's infamous botch.

It's since been confirmed that Reilly was booked to play a massive role in the ending of the match (and likely in the elimination of John Cena) but that all went to sh*t when Reilly was accidentally eliminated by Cena ten whole minutes before the contest was to end. Everything ended up being alright, however, when Cena was eliminated by an interfering Miz instead - but what was supposed to happen?

When the topic of Royal Rumble screwups arises, this is probably the first one that comes to mind, but this elimination could really place anywhere on this list because no one knows exactly how much damage it caused - beyond the growing dissent between The Champ and A-Ry that we later learned of.


2. Rusev (2015)

Rusev Royal Rumble
WWE Network

"ROMAN WINS LOL"

If there was ever an appropriate time for the grim meme, this was it - after arguably the worst Royal Rumble match of all time, Roman Reigns stood tall as the Wells Fargo Center booed him relentlessly. In an attempt to stifle the boos, WWE sent out The Rock to beat off the Corporation and raise Reigns' hands in victory.

SPOLER: it didn't work.

Then, just as this horrid show seemed to be over, Rocky discovered a prone Rusev laying under the ring and tossed him in. Realization set in - Rusev had never been eliminated, meaning he could still win the match! It was a far cry from fan favourites Dolph Ziggler or Dean Ambrose, but it was still an alternative to a greener 'Big Dog'. And suddenly, that sliver of hope was snatched away just as quickly as it arrived when the Samoan brawler tossed Rusev over the ropes and out of the match.

If anything, this elimination would prove to be a dark foreshadowing for the next 5 years - WWE simply didn't give a f*ck about what the WWE Universe thought about Roman Reigns. Once again, "ROMAN WINS LOL"


1. CM Punk (2014)

CM Punk Royal Rumble 2014
WWE

CM Punk's shock departure from WWE caused one of the most unforeseen ripple effects in WWE history, and it's difficult to debate that its biggest cause was his elimination from the 2014 Royal Rumble match.

While Punk had been dissatisfied for weeks with the company's creative direction, it was his elimination from the Royal Rumble by Kane that ultimately prompted him to leave the company. Not only did this mean WWE was losing one of its most beloved superstars, it also sent the company's WrestleMania plans into question.

Originally scheduled to face Triple H at that year's event, Punk's walkout (and Triple H's desperate need for a big match at WrestleMania against a younger, hotter star) prompted Triple H to set his sights on... Daniel Bryan.

The 'Yes' man had originally been booked to face Sheamus, but it's likely that the former WWE Champion's walkout prompted WWE to change direction and have Bryan walk out of WrestleMania as a champion.

This single elimination indirectly ended up boosting Daniel Bryan into the main event spot he deserved, ironically at the expense of fellow independent icon CM Punk.


WWE Quiz: CM Punk - How Much Do You Remember About The Voice Of The Voiceless?

CM Punk Promo Pic
WWE.com

1. Who Was CM Punk's First TV Match In ECW Against?

Contributor
Contributor

Twitter: @Rohan_Bodas Instagram: @RohanTheBodas