10 WWE Star Making Moments That Changed Nothing

Don't you just love it when WWE produce a new star?! They're reeeeeally good at it, you know...

Mankind WWF Title
WWE.com

You'd think that making stars for the future would rank pretty highly on Vince McMahon's list of things to-do in order to keep his darling WWE afloat. After all, the likes of Brock Lesnar and even AJ Styles are fast heading towards the end of their runs at the top, so the next generation need to be primed and ready to fill those spots.

Yet, time and time again, WWE have showcased a complete lack of vision in terms of setting up talents to become the next big thing, and we now face a future where superstars in the vein of 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin and The Rock seem increasingly less likely to break out of such an ill-managed system.

It's not like they haven't had ample chances to create the stars of tomorrow, either!

Throughout the history of the company, high-level performers have produced moments which suggested they were next in line to take WWE by storm, only to have this momentum scuppered due to nonsensical booking or a loss of interest in said performer.

You always hope for the best when a new star is thrown into the spotlight, yet often these exciting breakouts are fleeting and the dreary status quo is quickly re-established.

Here's a reminder of just a few of those frustrating instances...

10. Kharma Wreaks Havoc (2011)

Kharma On SmackDown Live
WWE.com

AEW's Awesome Kong is currently being booked as the absolute force she brilliantly lends herself to embodying and (surprise, surprise) it's getting over with the crowd.

So, how did WWE manage to c*ck up such a blatant open-goal for a division that desperately needed an injection of something new?

Well, all signs seemed to point to a debuting Kharma (as she was known inside the company) devastating all those who stood in her way, with Michelle McCool first falling victim to her at Extreme Rules 2011.

Yet, this star-making momentum would come to a screeching halt just a month after her debut, when Kharma looked as though she was about to wreak havoc on an eight-woman tag match on Monday Night Raw.

Instead of the expected massacre, Kharma instead fell to her knees and started to cry. It later came to pass that she was in-fact pregnant and therefore had to cease competing until she'd had her child.

Was this really the best way to write her off television?

Her terrifying aura was permanently damaged after this incident and she would leave the company after taking part in the 2012 Royal Rumble - her first and only official WWE match.

The women's division quickly went back to its underutilised norm and the once exciting Kharma influx had succeeded in changing just about nothing.


9. Tye Dillinger's Royal Rumble Entrance (2017)

Tye Dillinger Royal Rumble
WWE

Tye Dillinger successfully carved out something of a career resurgence during his time on NXT.

Going from developmental talent to finding his footing on the independent scene, Dillinger eventually morphed himself into a crowd favourite on the black and gold brand - with his 'Perfect 10' gimmick proving to be a masterstroke in crowd engagement.

This all led to a Royal Rumble moment that - although expected - nearly blew the roof off the Alamodome in 2017. Entering the match at his signature number ten, Dillinger strutted down to the ring to the approval of 50,000 strong and it looked as though WWE had a new main roster star on their hands.

Four months later, Dillinger arrived on SmackDown Live and fans were eager to see what the fuss was all about after his breakout moment in the legendary over-the-top-rope match.

He would conquer Aiden English in his first feud on the brand before challenging AJ Styles for the United States Championship, and followed up these matches by spending the next few months floating around the mid-card title picture.

His initial main roster momentum was finally stunted a year after his initial crowd-popping appearance, when Sami Zayn jumped Dillinger on his way to the 2018 Rumble match and killed off any hope of Dillinger being considered as a marketable talent for the rest of his WWE tenure.

After an exciting arrival onto the scene, Dillinger's absence from the SmackDown Live mid-card was barely even noticed following his departure from the company in February 2019.


8. Curtis Axel Knocks Off Triple H (2013)

Curtis Axel Triple H
WWE.com

When you're the son of one of the greatest in-ring technicians ever to ply their trade in the business, people are always going to expect a lot from you - and in the early stages of Curtis Axel's WWE career, it was looking as though he was actually going to live up to the legacy of Mr. Perfect, Curt Hennig.

As things would turn out, the former Michael McGillicutty's shocking victory over the indomitable Triple H proved to be both the biggest and only real high-point in his underwhelming run as a WWE employee. The fact that the victory came due to an oddly executed concussion being suffered by The Game, still didn't take away the full shine of a 'W' over one of the company's biggest names on his first night as the newly christened, Axel.

As Paul Heyman's newest advocate, the star looked as though he had the world at his feet. However, fans quickly realised that this push wasn't destined to last and as quickly as he'd won his first Intercontinental Championship, he was being used as a pawn in the CM Punk/Heyman feud.

Failed attempts at tag team success followed and Axel now finds himself out of the company, having been let go in April 2020.

If only he'd been allowed to add a few more notable scalps to his initial knocking out of The King of Kings.


7. Gallows And Anderson Attack The Usos (2016)

gallows anderson usos raw
WWE.com

By all accounts, this debut should have been the dawning of a new era for WWE's ailing tag team division, yet the rug was pulled from under Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson's feet merely a few months after their arrival.

Exploding through the live crowd to take out one of the company's stand-out teams, The Usos, the former Bullet Club members felt legit and the excitement surrounding the newest members of WWE was palpable.

So, how did Vince McMahon manage to screw this one up?

Well, things started out well enough, with the duo eventually rekindling their alliance with AJ Styles and aiding the Phenomenal One in his matches against both Roman Reigns and John Cena. They were billed as The Club. Then, before they even had the chance to really put a stamp on the roster, the team was disbanded after Styles was drafted to SmackDown Live in the 2016 brand split.

It was the beginning of the end of their initial buzz and the pair were never able to string a decent run of performances together, often going missing on television for months.

Though re-established as The O.C. towards the end of their WWE run, aligning once more with AJ Styles, Gallows and Anderson still played goons until their April 2020 releases.

Here lies another victim of WWE's complete lack of interest in their own tag team division.


6. Damien Sandow Turns On The Miz (2015)

Damien Sandow Miz
WWE.com

Damien Sandow had an odd WWE career, didn't he?

Embodying everything from an intellectual heel to a lovable stunt double, Sandow showcased a chameleon-like ability to adapt to whatever material he was given and somehow got many of these questionable concepts over with the live crowd.

Yet, it was his hilarious knack for impersonations that really forced fans into falling in love with the former Mr. Money in the Bank and his employment as The Miz' stunt double led to some of the most unlikely highlights of 2014/15.

After winning and subsequently losing the WWE Tag Team titles, Damien 'Mizdow' would find himself relegated to the role of Miz' personal assistant. Yet, The Miz finally received his long-awaited comeuppence from 'Mizdow' in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania 31.

This led to Sandow turning face for the first time in his career and fans couldn't wait to see just what the future would hold for their appointed hero.

Annoyingly, he would lose the follow-up feud with his former employer and soon found himself attached to Curtis Axel (him again!) with the two being saddled with a career-killing parody gimmick.

His buzz was killed off before it even had a chance to breathe, and by 2016 it was as if Sandow's star-making moment at 'Mania 31 had never happened. He was released in May that year, after WWE deemed he did not fit in with their plans.


5. Bray Wyatt Wins The WWE Championship For The First Time (2017)

bray wyatt wwe champion
WWE.com

Long before The Eater of Worlds had the epiphany of splitting his psyche into that of a children's TV presenter and diabolical 'Fiend', Bray Wyatt was the company's most prolific producer of hot air.

Multiple feuds came and went with some of the biggest stars available, yet - despite routinely babbling a good game - Wyatt found himself on the losing end of anticlimactic feuds with the likes of John Cena, The Undertaker and Roman Reigns.

Incredibly, these numerous setbacks hadn't completely murdered the buzz surrounding Wyatt and after the 102938th revival of his Wyatt family on SmackDown Live, Wyatt found himself somehow holding the WWE Championship over his head at the end of Elimination Chamber 2017.

The seeds were clearly being planted for a (Royal Rumble winning) Randy Orton turn on Wyatt - with Orton becoming a part of the family in late 2016 - and when the trigger was finally pulled on the two's implosion, fans were left questioning the execution of the break-up.

A babyface Orton burned down Wyatt's compound (a heelish move, you could say) and forced Wyatt into accepting a WrestleMania 33 showdown between the former brethren.

Both the 'Mania match - which Wyatt lost - and their subsequent non-title House of Horrors sh*t-show nullified any further main event prospects for the former world champion.

Wyatt disappeared from the upper reaches of the card and WWE stuck to their usual big hitters (apart from the Jinder Mahal detour) from there on out. Re-emerging with The Fiend in 2019, he has since returned to obscurity, having wrestled only once in 2021.


4. Dolph Ziggler Cashes In (2013)

Dolph Ziggler cash-in
WWE.com

He was 'here to show the world' and he definitely did... for a few months.

Dolph Ziggler had the potential to be the kind of athletically gifted babyface that the company had struggled to replicate since the days of a young Shawn Michaels super-kicking his way to the main event of WrestleMania XII.

That's not to say that Ziggler was a carbon-copy of Michaels, it's just that his similar characteristics excited fans into thinking that a successful run at the top of the card was inevitable and it did eventually happen - albeit not for long.

Ziggler's crowning cash-in moment on Alberto Del Rio went down in history, producing one of the loudest crowd reactions ever heard in a WWE arena. The second that the official brought his hand down for the three count still sends shivers up your spine today.

That's why it was such a let-down when Ziggler's reign was derailed by an ill-timed concussion and the foolish decision for him to drop the World Heavyweight Championship back to Del Rio at Payback, just two months on from his stirring victory on the Raw after WrestleMania 29.

Ziggler never recovered and his brief spell with the gold wasn't revisited, leading many current fans to even forget that he was once a credible world title challenger at all.


3. Jack Swagger Cashes In (2010)

Jack Swagger World Heavyweight Champion
WWE.com

Another cash-in and yet another missed opportunity.

Back in 2010, Jack Swagger had ticked all the necessary boxes to be considered as WWE's next big thing. He'd already enjoyed a world title run - albeit with the ECW Championship - and even managed to seal that all-important Money in the Bank briefcase win at WrestleMania XXVI.

He would cash in this opportunity on Chris Jericho on the SmackDown after 'Mania, winning the World Heavyweight Championship for the first time and it looked as though WWE had found their newest top star.

Swagger adopted the fashionable over-serious persona which the likes of Jericho had made cool and managed to retain his title against the aforementioned Y2J, Edge, Randy Orton and Big Show.

So far, so good.

Then, the wheels fell off his push when Rey Mysterio stole his title away at the *shudder* Fatal 4-Way PPV, and he then failed in trying to recapture the gold at Money in the Bank.

Swagger fell back down the card and - similarly to Dolph Ziggler - it seemed as though the Swagger experiment had failed, leaving WWE with no intention of taking another chance on the former champ.

Despite finding a bit of success as part of The Real American group - getting 'We the People' over to a substantial degree - Swagger left the company in 2017 and took up a new career as a legit MMA badass, before eventually joining AEW.


2. Mankind Wins The WWF Championship For The First Time (1999)

Mankind WWF Title
WWE.com

This isn't to suggest that Mankind's WWF Championship victory in January 1999 wasn't one of the greatest moments in WWF/E history, but did it actually do much to change the landscape of the company?

At this time, Mankind found himself embroiled in an epic feud with The Corporation. After spending weeks trying to get one over on The Rock, Mankind was finally (with the help of one 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin) able to steal the title away from McMahon and co. Yes, this move won WWF a huge ratings battle with WCW, but McMahon clearly had no intention of following through with Mankind as one of the company's new faces.

Mankind quickly dropped the belt back to The Rock in a brutal 'I Quit' match at the Royal Rumble, before later reclaiming it. Eventually, he would lose the title in a ladder match on Raw to The Rock (again) - due to some more Corporation shenanigans - and after winning it back upon his return from a three-month injury layoff, he lost it for the last time against Triple H.

That would be that and Mick Foley would never be given the honour of being world champion again, even though he was never truly allowed to feel like the real 'man' in the company during his numerous sporadic runs as champ.

Mankind's first win could have signalled the beginning of a whole new Foley era in the company and fans obviously would have backed him, yet WWE always held their reservations over his marketability and instead opted for the safer heroes they'd grown used to seeing as champion.


1. Shinsuke Nakamura Wins The Royal Rumble (2018)

Shinsuke Nakamura Royal Rumble 2018
WWE

The King of Strong Style was once considered a bit of a big deal, but you'd be forgiven for not thinking that if your only experiences of the current Intercontinental Champion have come in the last year or so.

Long before his putrid mid-card title-run on SmackDown, Nakamura was being positioned as WWE's next breakout star and his time with NXT had only highlighted just how easily he could translate his hard-hitting style over to a western audience.

Fans lapped up his ferocious matches against Sami Zayn and Finn Bálor, with his NXT title feud involving Samoa Joe also being hailed as one of the best in recent memory - before he eventually dropped the belt to Bobby Roode. His main roster debut was impending and even casual fans couldn't wait to witness the hottest act in the company ply his trade on either Raw or SmackDown.

He arrived on the blue brand by kneeing his way through Dolph Ziggler and set-up an eagerly anticipated NJPW-rematch with AJ Styles by staring down the Phenomenal One in the midst of a Money in the Bank ladder match. That dream would become a reality by the time WrestleMania 34 rolled around; with Nakamura winning the 2018 men's Royal Rumble match and choosing to face Styles for the WWE Championship at the show of shows.

'How could this not be amazing?' fans asked.

Quite easily, it turned out.

WWE opted to ground the two megastars and their subsequent feud involved more d*ck punches than 5-star classics, leaving Nakamura's WWE run wobbling. The Japanese star has since flirted with the top of the card on several occasions, but "flirted" is the key word there. Not once has Nakamura felt as important on the main roster as he did in NXT and Japan.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Mankind
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!