10 WWE Stars TNA Should Totally POACH For NXT Crossover

TNA stars have popped up in NXT, but which WWE wrestlers should be recruited to show up on Impact?!

R-Truth The Miz Awesome Truth
WWE

Jordynne Grace appearing on WWE television in both the Royal Rumble and at NXT Battleground has been a great start to what's been billed in some circles as a 'talent exchange' between WWE and TNA Wrestling. But so far, that's basically all we've seen from this collaboration, and with any relationship, communication cannot be a one-way street.

TNA obviously gets more publicity and exposure by being promoted on WWE, hoping to draw those viewers in to boost Impact's numbers. If all goes well, fans are intrigued and decide to check out TNA and hopefully become recurring fans.

Of course, another way to attract attention is to advertise WWE wrestlers appearing on TNA programming—be it Impact or the pay-per-views—so fans of those stars want to follow them over to TNA and watch that action.

Luckily, there are tons of WWE wrestlers on both the NXT and main roster who would be great options to make appearances on TNA, if not outright be poached to join the roster full-term if and when their contracts allow for it.

So, let's take a look at over a dozen of the standout WWE stars who should be invited to The Impact Zone!

10. AJ Styles

AJ Styles
WWE.com

Before jumping to conclusions, no, AJ Styles shouldn't join the TNA roster in any long-term capacity, nor would he  - based on recent comments, he'd like to end his career in WWE - but when talking about one-shot appearances or guest roles, AJ is uniquely suited to the task.

Styles was a franchise player that TNA was built around in many ways. He was the TNA guy for so many years, to the point it felt like he would never go to WWE. Thankfully, after leaving TNA in 2013 and hitting New Japan Pro-Wrestling, Ring of Honor, and the independent scene for a few years, AJ made his WWE debut at the 2016 Royal Rumble and has achieved Hall of Fame-worthy success.

However, The Phenomenal One's current storyline teases he doesn't have much time left as an in-ring performer, suggesting opportunities to return to TNA and wrap up any loose ends are dwindling.

Ideally, a match against Moose for the TNA World Title would garner the most buzz, with TNA getting the boost of using Styles even more if he were to beat Moose, and Moose boosting his own legacy should he defeat a legend like P1.

Even if AJ Styles just wanted to work alongside some of his TNA friends outside of any title picture, anything he did would be welcome.


9. Tatum Paxley

Tatum Paxley
WWE

It was established during her partnership and feud with Lyra Valkyria that Tatum Paxley has an obsession over the NXT Women's Championship, which then extended to her lusting over the NXT Women's North American Championship before losing a qualifying match to compete for that prize.

With only a few seconds of effort, WWE perfectly set Paxley up for a guest stint in TNA by allowing her to pivot her attention to another title, as the 4 June episode of NXT had Tatum eye up Jordynne Grace's TNA Knockouts World Championship. Following that, Paxley interfered at NXT Battleground, attempting to steal that title before she was stopped by TNA's Ash by Elegance (formerly WWE's Dana Brooke).

Grace will defend the Knockouts Title in an open challenge at the upcoming Against All Odds event, which opens up opportunities for any number of WWE women to answer that call - and Paxley now seems the perfect fit for that role.

Tatum Paxley can lose to the Juggernaut without doing any damage to her own standing, and it would still come across as an exciting surprise and fitting for her more deranged character to be the one to make that leap over to another company.


8. Natalya

Natalya Zelina Vega Sharpshooter
WWE.com

If Tatum Paxley doesn't head over to TNA, there's a laundry list of other ladies who could fit the bill, and Natalya would have to be at the top of the pecking order.

Naturally, TNA would want the biggest names possible and would love to have top stars like Bianca Belair and Liv Morgan appear, but WWE needs to be selective in allowing TNA to utilise stars who are well-known but not otherwise involved in major WWE storylines.

The Queen of Harts is in a lull period, with her feud against Lola Vice over, her protege Karmen Petrovic injured, and small chance of her challenging for the Women's World Championship any time soon. Instead of sitting around with little to do, wrestling for TNA would check off another accolade for the Canadian's already legendary career.

After being with the company for closing in on 20 years, Nattie has long been a den mother to the women's division. If anyone could put on a great contest with Jordynne Grace and the Knockouts roster and carry themselves with poise and represent WWE well, it's The B.O.A.T.


7. Brooks Jensen

Brooks Jensen
WWE

Ever since losing the NXT UK Tag Team Championship at Worlds Collide on September 4, 2022, Brooks Jensen's career has spiraled downward.

Jensen's romance with Kiana James turned out to be a ruse, his friendship with Josh Briggs and Fallon Henley was put aside indefinitely as those two decided to focus on their singles careers, and the 22-year-old was largely left in the dust.

This has all resulted in Jensen lashing out on social media, posting about going on drinking benders, talking about leaving the company, and ultimately being "silenced by WWE" before also posting a video with a Joe Hendry reference behind him.

To further sell this storyline, Brooks absolutely must go to TNA, with that a next logical step for someone angry at his spot on the roster and who wants to find success on another brand where he feels he'll be more appreciated.

Brooks Jensen isn't involved in other storylines where his absence from NXT would be felt, throwing up the potential for a substantial stay in TNA where he could build up his name, feud with multiple talents, and eventually make his way back to the Capitol Wrestling Center with renewed vigor.


6. Awesome Truth

R-Truth The Miz Awesome Truth
WWE

The Miz is, no pun intended, awesome and criminally underrated, and "The Most Must-See WWE Superstar" is in a spot in his career where he's having fun as a babyface partnering up alongside R-Truth for some hijinks as the current WWE World Tag Team Champions.

While yes, hosting an episode of MizTV on Impact is just another promo segment, having a WWE-lifer bring his act to TNA would make MizTV feel much more special. It'd also allow The Miz to flex his mic skills against a whole new set of performers.

The extra added bonus, if this were Awesome Truth and not just The Miz, is how R-Truth is not only one of the funniest sports entertainers, but he's the second-ever TNA champion... sort of.

Ron Killings defeated Ken Shamrock on the eighth TNA show to win the NWA World Heavyweight Championship, and even won that belt a second time two years later before TNA branched off onto its own and rebranded itself and its World Title.

What if, when R-Truth steps foot in TNA, he suddenly isn't as absent-minded and silly, which throws The Miz and fans off with a fun swerve?


5. Wes Lee

Wes Lee WWE NXT
WWE.com

In a companion piece to this, discussing TNA wrestlers who should cameo on NXT, Zachary Wentz and Trey Miguel were both mentioned as potential allies to reform The Rascalz alongside Wes Lee.

As such, Lee could return the favor, returning to TNA as a much bigger star than when he left in 2020, and not only tagging alongside his former partners but he could even challenge for some singles championships.

Wes Lee would make for a great contender to any belt, but the one that particularly stands out is the X Division Championship currently held by Mustafa Ali. Wes and Ali never had the opportunity to properly feud when Lee held the NXT North American Championship, with injuries and creative plans putting a halt to that, and other wrestlers were also thrown into the mix to prevent any straight-up singles match between the two.

It could be time to rectify this by having Wes Lee face Mustafa Ali for the X Division Title, rekindling their previous storyline and giving a conclusion to what was seen in NXT.


4. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews
WWE

Most of this list is speculative, but when it comes to Apollo Crews, we know he flat out has interest in going to TNA, making this pitch significantly easier.

In an interview with Vicente Beltran, Crews specifically named his former tag team partner Moose as someone he'd want to face from another company, as they remain good friends. The two would have a killer match, and anyone who has followed either of their careers would be quickly into it, while casuals unaware of their previous history could be educated with minimal effort.

This is the type of no-brainer situation that is so clear-cut, if WWE and TNA don't do something with Apollo and Moose, it would be baffling - especially as Crews is currently in a doldrums period on the SmackDown roster.

By involving Apollo Crews in TNA - potentially with or against Moose - that would bring renewed energy and clout to his name while also giving TNA fans someone who can put on quality matches, with a Moose rivalry even worthy of main-eventing a TNA PPV.


3. Tegan Nox

Tegan Nox
WWE

Speaking of someone who hasn't been up to much and could use a shot of adrenaline, Tegan Nox is going on a whopping seven years in WWE without being able to gain any real traction.

Nox's run has been snakebit from the start, with injury problems and minimal creative often forcing the Welsh star back to square one. Even after the 2024 WWE Draft, there's been no indication anything is about to change for Tegan, so why not change up the formula and allow her to wrestle for TNA? It's not as if WWE would be losing anything form their own programming, as she barely appears on TV, and when she does, it's usually in a losing capacity.

Tegan Nox is better than this and is currently being wasted. For her benefit, as well as her fans, she should be allowed to flourish. And if WWE isn't giving Nox the opportunity to soar, she should look to fly somewhere else. In fact, the Girl with the Shiniest Wizard is someone who might even be better outright leaving WWE and joining TNA full-time, rather than just making some guest appearances.


2. Honorable Mentions: Dijak, Chase University & More

Dijak WWE
WWE.com

Since there are so many options of fantastic WWE stars who would be interesting to see in TNA, this list deserves a speed round of honorable mentions to quickly summarize a few more.

Dijak's contract status is currently up in the air, and appearing for TNA would certainly get fans talking. He might even enjoy himself enough there to be persuaded to sign with TNA rather than renewing with WWE, with the underutilized, overlooked talent someone who could feasibly be TNA World Champion.

In NXT, Edris Enofé and Malik Blade cannot break their string of bad luck. Similar to Brooks Jensen, a change in scenery could be good for them, allowing them to go for the TNA World Tag Team Championships as they don't seem to be anywhere close to ready to win the NXT Tag Titles.

For Chase University, they could stand to recruit some new students from TNA as well as feud with The System. Also, how about giving Giovanni Vinci something to do, or have Katana Chance and Kayden Carter go after the TNA Knockouts World Tag Team Championships? You could even pair Arianna Grace up with her father, Santino Marella, who nowadays serves as TNA's Director of Authority.


1. Baron Corbin

Baron Corbin
WWE

Sometimes, it's better to be a big fish in a small pond, and considering how big Baron Corbin actually is, he could finally get a World Title run that he has yet to achieve in WWE.

Corbin just got out of a successful partnership with Bron Breakker where it seemed he was having some of the most fun he's had in a long while. However, since they both were drafted to separate brands, Breakker's doing his own thing on Raw as a heel while Corbin is quickly becoming a resident babyface enhancement talent on SmackDown.

While he's done fine in his current role, it's a step down and not as natural for Baron as a heel persona, with a heel Corbin likely to be a breath of fresh air against the TNA roster rather than he face the same names in WWE that he's fought time and time again.

Baron Corbin's also more than credible enough to beat anyone in TNA, believably, but in a flexible enough spot where he could also lose and it wouldn't be a travesty. That allows plenty of room for experimenting on where Corbin would fit best, while giving WWE fans time to start missing him and appreciate him more.


Contributor
Contributor

Founder of pro wrestling site Smark Out Moment (https://www.smarkoutmoment.com) and geek culture site Fanboys Anonymous (https://www.fanboysanonymous.com).