10 WWE Stars Who Were TRULY Buried

Journey to the centre of the earth.

Asuka WrestleMania 34
WWE.com

Christ, is there a more irritating debate in the entire wrestling discourse than the word "buried"?

Appropriately enough, the take never ages well: it rots. Many thought WWE buried Dolph Ziggler by demoting him from the World Heavyweight Title picture in 2013. This caused hysteria, but the subsequent years have legitimised the decision: Ziggler was a firecracker of a worker, by the standards of a time surpassed now by orders of magnitude. Ultimately, he was an upper midcard-level talent whose fetish for bumping proved fatalistic. He got too good at doing jobs, to paraphrase a lesson imparted by Terry Funk, and he never showed enough on the mic to distinguish himself.

EC3 has received piss-poor treatment in 2019 - but you can't botch that disastrously, on Main Event, and escape blame. Several online fans bemoan the treatment of perennial title match loser Samoa Joe - but this protest isn't echoed in arenas. He isn't the same force was he in the 2000s - his performances are often sluggish - and WWE makes best use of his formidable promo game to promote inessential B-level pay-per-views. Terribly, but you get the idea.

This list is reserved for those WWE truly didn't value, whether through cruelty or ineptitude or both.

10. Harper

Lol Harper
WWE.com

Harper is a victim of a chronically f*cked WWE system in which creative freedom is verboten.

Dave Meltzer reported that Harper was blamed for Braun Strowman's botch at the WrestleMania 35 André The Giant Memorial Battle Royal (!), and that Vince "hated" his (favourably received) Axxess match with Dominick Dijakovic. That is a weird tidbit: the f*ck is Vince doing watching Axxess matches, when he, in Triple H's words, doesn't even watch NXT? Moreover, Vince wasn't happy with Harper's post-'Mania dark match with EC3, either. He "hated" the Drake Maverick spots the agents came up with.

In TV masterpiece The Wire, Homicide Detective Jimmy McNulty is loathed by his boss Bill Rawls. McNulty claims that Rawls has "a hard-on" for him, in this context meaning a grudge he spends a disproportionate amount of time dedicated to upholding.

It seems this phenomena applies to the Vince/Harper relationship.

Where McNulty's maverick, not-by-the-book methods informed Rawls' hatred, Harper's inability to speak in a southern accent has informed Vince's. It's an oddly specific stance from which Vince will not be moved. Harper is of course a great pro wrestler, an agile colossus with offence that is legit jaw-dropping - Skinner, but great.

Vince pushed Skinner more than Harper as a singles player.


9. The Revival

the revival
WWE.com

Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder were plunged under a tidal wave of Vince McMahon's worst, eternal impulses.

They are a tag team, and worse, they were proudly indebted to the southern wrasslin', in physique and work, to which Vince McMahon is allergic. They also had the temerity to each suffer injuries early in their main roster run, which seemed to indicate to Vince that they lacked the constitution for the relentless WWE grind.

The events of 2019 aren't justifiable but they are understandable, when viewed through WWE's super-f*cked up optics. They requested their release in January, which promoted Vince to both strip them of the RAW Tag Team Titles and humiliate them, ritually, in a programme with The Usos. Scooting across the ring with burning hot a*sholes, they couldn't even take a shower to soothe themselves because they'd already been booked to look eurgh gay together in the locker room a week prior.

But even before that, shortly after their return in late 2017, the Revival were effectively buried into the core of the earth by DX on RAW25 in a senseless, pathetic and totally counterproductive segment, just because the geezers were high on how cool they used to be. Hilariously - as in, all-hope-is-gone gallows humour - this was intended as a "rub".

A tag act able to engineer incredible drama in awesome matches that unify all fans and all sensibilities, they were also over-produced and broadened in their main roster showings.

Top guys: out, with any luck.


8. The Ascension

Ascension WWE
WWE.com

Right.

The Ascension were never going to make it; if a goofy '80s-inspired gimmick weighed down the far more talented Bludgeon Brothers, the audience was hardly about to take Viktor and Konnor, and their Road Warriors riff, with much seriousness.

But.

For f*ck's sake, they never stood a bloody chance.

Their cards were marked on the 19 January 2015 Monday Night RAW, on which they were dealt a remonstrative lesson by WWE for... performing a gimmick handed to them within the WWE system.

"You're both big lads, and you're a tag team. Here, do something like the Road Warriors used to do."

"Sure."

"HOW DARE YOU BETRAY THE NAME OF THE ROAD WARRIORS, A TEAM, INCIDENTALLY, WE DIDN'T EXACTLY PUSH WITH THE MOST CONVICTION!"

Weird as f*ck, man. Weird. As. F*ck.

When the Ascension disrespected the nWo, in accordance with the f*cking script, JBL didn't take too kindly to it. He blasted them as if this was wrestler's court, and not a scripted segment on the scripted Monday Night RAW television programme. And, when he took Viktor's head off with the Clothesline From Hell, he looked down upon him with just the weirdest sense of satisfaction - the sinister smile of the vigilante.

Weird as f*ck.


7. Diamond Dallas Page

Ddp Comfort Zone
WWE.com

Somebody should have told Vince McMahon, and chief henchman The Undertaker, that the Monday Night War wasn't a *real* war, because they each seemed to believe that Diamond Dallas Page was some kind of evil invader, trapped behind enemy lines, that they had to bury alive.

He wasn't so much a luckless, captured soldier as a "contracted talent" whose primary function, ideally, was to "make Vince McMahon more money".

This was made impossible when McMahon sacrificed him to The Undertaker in a more ceremonial fashion than that of Mideon. Beyond the usual "He was from WCW and thus must be made unrecognisable and or humiliated" thing, which was probably the birdbrained mentality, there must have been something else about Page that inspired so much fury. Page made advances on 'Taker's then-wife, Sara, in accordance with the (f*cking s**t) storyline WWE dreamed up.

Did 'Taker have a bit of the old Randy Savage in him? Had he convinced himself, in a fit of jealousy, that he shoot wanted to bang her? Or did Page suffer because nobody told him how to feed a comeback, WWF style?

You know, the style in which WWE, the company with the stars who know how to work, demands its heels continually get up, as if impact has a magical, strange recuperative property and isn't something that normally hurts?


6. Lita

Lita Survivor Series
WWE.com

The one f*cking time Vince McMahon gave the fans what they wanted, because of course it was.

WWE crowds were ruthlessly awful in their treatment of Lita in the mid-2000s, by most definitely projecting their own bullsh*t onto her, and there is no counterargument. Did those fans chant anything remotely similar to, for example Bret Hart, following Shawn Michaels' "Sunny days" comment? Or did Julie Hart not fall through enough tables for their satisfaction?

Lita was a "slut" to these people, when news emerged of her affair with Edge in 2005. Edge, incidentally, was not a "slut". Message boards everywhere put him over as a "great heel".

At Survivor Series 2006, Lita wrestled her last match for WWE as a full-time performer. "I know what you're gonna say," Jim Ross said on commentary, as Lita applied a sleeper on the canvas. "She's used to working on her back." When she lost, JR said "Lita, ending her career on her back."

"I'm not going to say 'How apropos'," Jerry Lawler said.

Slut-shamed during and after the match, the scene that followed was revolting. Vince McMahon dispatched Cryme Tyme to the ring, who couldn't even rescue it with their trademark charming charisma. They held a "ho sale" in which Lita's yeast infection cream, panties and vibrator were sold to the audience and JBL.

Lita literally broke her neck for the cause.


5. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Stupid pale short guy we only hired because he had buzz doesn't even watch TV and is a vegan and is deformed and has no charisma and wrestles in front of high school gyms even though that gym is a sold out Hammerstein Ballroom and the guys next to him, the real future stars that look like 'WWE guys', sports entertain in front of empty chairs in FCW as if that somehow is better, and if we're not acknowledging that then they simply have never performed in front of people before because there are only two areas of wrestling: WWE, which they are debuting in, and the "indies", which is where vermin like this Bryan geek break each other's necks because they don't know how to work.

And relax.

What a profoundly detestable spree of toxic WWE bullsh*t this was, godd*mn, not that it mattered, because Bryan's talent in literally every criteria other than the one that counts ("being tall") was so transcendent that he got over to a point at which he was the only acceptable choice to headline WrestleMania XXX in front of 60,000 people.

Which WWE did everything, everything possible to not make happen because he is a stupid pale short guy we only hired because-


4. Rusev

Rusev Unhappy
WWE.com

Rusev is in exile, currently, reportedly exhausted by a machine that has failed him.

And it has failed him. Rusev is genuinely a very, very good performer who might yet prove himself to be better than that beyond the confines of the WWE system, like Jon Moxley, PAC and KENTA before him. His grasp of selling is superb, and his registering is indicative of an exceptional talent, too. At his motivated best, Rusev boasts an ability to project himself as a star, as well as an artist. He got over as a retrograde foreign heel, an act he wasn't even best suited to, but Vince McMahon "got" that. He has booked acts in that vein for years and years.

But he doesn't "get" the Rusev of such endearing, irreverent comedic instincts. It isn't broad enough for his "such good sh*t" sensibilities, which was achingly clear when he never got behind the Rusev Day bit in spite of palpable crowd support.

His conduct on Twitter is not shrewd - "Bury me softly brother" was a curtain-revealing in-joke too far - but by that point, you sense Rusev had lost patience and hope. Perhaps that whole mess accelerated the parting of Rusev Day - a senseless waste of an act that were grassroots popular among live crowds, and have individually achieved nothing since.


3. Asuka

Asuka Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

Asuka is Japanese.

That is, legitimately, the reason why WWE refuses to acknowledge her talent, irrespective of how universal that talent is. And it is universal.

Asuka carries herself like the most deadly performer on the planet, but wrestles comfortably within WWE’s safe in-house style. She conveys danger, with a mischievous wiggle of the fingers, a lick of the lip, and a flash of menace in the eyes. She is the purest worker in the company, arguably, but she doesn’t speak English, and Vince isn't sexually attracted to women of Asian descent. Asuka gave Becky Lynch her best effort of 2019, starred in the brutal spectacle that was TLC '18's main event, and used her superlative body language and physical comedy to make Mixed Match Challenge even vaguely worth the effort.

Effort, incidentally, is the other issue.

WWE’s institutionally lazy approach to television storytelling has failed Asuka. For obvious reasons, she cannot operate in opening talk segments or contract signings, and WWE never bothered to conceive of any other vehicle to maximise her appeal, because they couldn't copy and paste anything for her.

Asuka in micro indicts WWE's macro problem. The complexion of the roster is immaterial; within the current formula, WWE simply refuses to book around the performer. It's the other way 'round, and backwards is very much the word.


2. Sami Zayn

Xavier Woods Sami Zayn
WWE.com

WWE's treatment of Sami Zayn is shocking. WWE's treatment of Sami Zayn reveals its various charity and PR concerns as carefully strategised bullsh*t.

Sami campaigns for the stricken, war-torn people of Syria as part of his Sami For Syria campaign, but WWE has never promoted this on TV, even when the Underdog was a babyface, because it's either politically inconvenient or too "middle easty", one of the two. It's not something that unifies all people as something to rally behind, and so it isn't deemed worthy of supporting. Sami's ancestry forbids him from performing in Saudi Arabia, too, and while his principles might see him refuse voluntarily, it's still bullsh*t.

Onscreen, meanwhile, Sami Zayn borders on the genius as a performer. As a face, he boasts that intangible sympathy to connect with crowds, in tandem with an elite level of skill WWE has barely maximised. As a heel, he's even better: so grating that he can actually draw real heat, the performer who stole the post-WrestleMania RAW ate losses to Tucker (!) a month or so back, and missed out on a SummerSlam payday because Vince McMahon deemed his match with Aleister Black surplus to requirements.

Disrespected, under-utilised, and literally abandoned, in virtually every way, Sami Zayn is too good for WWE.


1. CM Punk

Cm Punk
WWE.com

WWE never truly liked CM Punk.

He was told he didn't know how to work; Paul Heyman's ardent endorsement achieved the opposite of the intended effect; WWE sold him down the river, in 2008, when they felt buyer's remorse; and, in 2009, his ascension to the main event meant nothing, ultimately, because he worked a dark match in the same year as his Heavyweight Title breakthrough. Just 112 days separated his violent SummerSlam classic opposite Jeff Hardy and his humiliation to R-Truth at TLC, and all because Punk wouldn't wear a suit.

WWE, quite literally, never liked the look of him.

And so Punk, the best working heel in wrestling at the time, didn't get the WrestleMania XXVII main event, even after he reinvented himself as the most interesting villain in several years. That honour went to The Miz, a talent who displayed the necessary work ethic in the "right" way. Short of star power, WWE persuaded Punk to re-sign in 2011, complete with a renewed main event push. They "tried to f*ck on him" by marketing him as the Best In The World in 2012, but he rarely if ever headlined pay-per-views as WWE Champion.

The guy who enhanced the legacies of part-time stars, in a fitting act of revenge, left as a martyr to become the most elusive, biggest return pop of them all.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Asuka
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!