10 WWE Stipulations That Only Had One Good Match
Nuggets of gold floating in a sea of (hog) crap.
Pro wrestling has been obsessed with stipulation bouts for the longest time, and it's not hard to see why.
Placing two (or more) warring rivals into a gimmick match and letting chaos reign should theoretically result in increased fan interest. That's certainly what WWE were hoping for with 2020's latest attempts - they knew that "Greatest Wrestling Match Ever" branding for Edge vs. Randy Orton would get people talking, just as they know this ongoing 'Eye For An Eye' business involving Seth Rollins and Rey Mysterio has piqued curiosity.
WCW also tried to throw absolutely everything Vince Russo could think of into fans' faces as it died a slow death in 2000. The sheer number of object 'On A Pole' matches they promoted could be a list all on its lonesome, but nobody wants to relive such horrors. How about reliving some WWE ones instead?
There are a remarkable number of McMahon-inspired stips that only produced one noteworthy match. Maybe the gimmick itself sucked, or the line-up of opponents chosen just didn't cut it, but 99% of bouts promoted under these quirky attempts to freshen up pay-per-view selling points fell flat.
Except this bunch of anomalies. They somehow pulled off miracles...
10. Chairs Match (The Undertaker Vs. Batista - TLC 2009)
The 'Chairs Match' is WWE stretching the lure of TLC a little too far.
Why watch wrestlers dangle from ladders, crash through tables or use everything not nailed down when you could watch... some chair shots, and ones that are only delivered to the back so nobody gets a concussion. That's this lame gimmick in a nutshell, and it has repeatedly failed to enchant anyone on pay-per-view.
Somehow, The Undertaker and Batista made the best of things in 2009 though. They combined to make this 'Chairs' guff an unexpected delight (imagine their faces when Vince said, 'OK, my dudes - you can use chairs, but don't use anything else').
No, it wasn't going to win 'Match Of The Year', but it was damn better than any subsequent 'Chairs Match' WWE has put on. That owes a ton to the chemistry these guys have always enjoyed, and possibly Batista's fresh-as-they-come heel turn.
9. Blindfold Match (Jake Roberts Vs. Rick Martel - WrestleMania VII)
On the surface, the 'Blindfold Match' gimmick sounds like a rib someone in the office is playing on the roster, and that seems even more plausible when one considers Jake Roberts and Rick Martel were asked to work it at WrestleMania VII. Yep, they had to stumble around "blind" on the biggest show of the year.
No wonder ol' Jake wanted out one year later.
The incredible thing is that Roberts and Martel smartly stalled and worked in easy pantomime spots. "He's behind you" springs to mind, although fans in LA were more likely to chant, "DDT" than that. That's all they wanted to see from this gimmicky midcard distraction, and they got it.
Criticise this all you like, but it played before a loud live crowd and ended the right way. That's more than one can say about follow-ups like D'Lo Brown vs. Triple H from 2002 or Santino Marella vs. Drew McIntyre in 2012.
8. Flag Match (John Cena Vs. Rusev - Battleground 2017)
Isn't xenophobia dressed as patriotism fun?
The premise of a 'Flag Match' is steeped in national pride. Wrestlers fight to fell the other long enough that they might grab their country's banner and either wave it around like Mr. Fuji preparing for a Yokozuna bout or place it in some pre-arranged spot for the win.
Usually, they suck. Talents as varied as Bret Hart, Hulk Hogan and Jim Duggan have all failed to elicit much excitement from the gimmick, and that only makes John Cena vs. Rusev from Battleground 2017 all the more extraordinary. Three years ago, they actually worked a good match around a restrictive, nationalistic stip.
If you're only going to watch one 'Flag' scrap, make it this one. Rusev was enjoying his renaissance as a dominant heel, and Cena was typically full of beans as he fought to defend 'Old Glory'. Better than expected, you might say.
7. Kiss My Foot Match (Bret Hart Vs. Jerry Lawler - King Of The Ring 1995)
Despite failing to make anything of the 'Flag' fluff, Bret Hart definitely did make something of his 'Kiss My Foot' nonsense opposite old foe Jerry Lawler at the 1995 King Of The Ring. Indeed, this is the only match worth seeing from that pay-per-view (unless watching Shawn Michaels go to a time limit draw with Kama is your bag).
It was goofy, over-the-top Federation fun.
Hart and Lawler worked through their issues in 10 succinct minutes, which was just long enough to satisfy but not long enough to bore. Lawler's facial expressions were stunning, as usual, and fans got a rare laugh by roaring in approval as Bret shoved both his own and Jerry's smelly foot in the 'King's' mouth.
One warning though: Lawler's next attempt, against Michael Cole at Over The Limit 2011, was so atrocious that you might prefer munching toes over watching it. That was bad comedy, whereas KOTR '95 was gimmickry done right.
6. Hog Pen Match (Triple H Vs. Henry O. Godwinn - In Your House 5)
Nobody was laughing when Vickie Guerrero and Chavo Guerrero slipped around in slop at Extreme Rules 2009. Their pig-sh*t infused brawl with Santino Marella in drag (as his "sister" Santina) was an abomination; asking people to pay pay-per-view dollars to see that rubbish was an insult.
In Your House 5's 'Hog Pen' try? Slightly different.
Yours truly will defend this one to anyone who will listen. It fit Henry O. Godwinn's farmer gimmick, and was designed to be everything the silver-spoon, stuck-up Hunter Hearst Helmsley would hate. The pair also didn't try to work Flair vs. Steamboat - they went out of their way to present the match as Triple H's worst waking nightmare.
Trips himself has admitted that taking Godwinn's slop was his idea in the first place. He loved working the silly match, and viewed it as a means to connecting with the WWF's casual audience. Lord only knows what Vickie Guerrero thought of her own 'Hog Pen' horror show.
5. Texas Bullrope (JBL Vs. Eddie Guerrero - Great American Bash 2004)
This is a bit of a contentious one, admittedly.
The 'Texas Bullrope' gimmick is, for all intents and purposes, a 'Strap Match' that was handed the Texan tag to make it seem more dangerous. At WWE's Great American Bash 2004 show, that moniker also fit the home state of hated heel JBL and cherished babyface Eddie Guerrero.
WWE put on a few 'Texas Bullrope' spectacles over the years. JBL would have another with Batista on the 9 September 2005 episode of SmackDown, and Randy Orton tangled with Dusty Rhodes at Great American Bash 2007. Some may have enjoyed those, but they couldn't hold a candle to Bradshaw vs. Guerrero.
That, unlike those to come, had an intensity aided by the pair's bloodbath one month earlier at Judgment Day. Later 'Bullrope' battles might've been decent, but only one can claim to have been good-to-great, and it was 2004's effort.
4. Lion's Den (Matt Riddle Vs. Timothy Thatcher - 27 May 2020 NXT)
This might be another controversial pick because WWE promoted Matt Riddle vs. Timothy Thatcher as taking place inside NXT's 'Fight Pit' on the 27 May 2020 episode. Fancy new name or not however, it was effectively Ken Shamrock's old 'Lion's Den' with a twist, and it should be judged against those UFC-inspired gimmick matches.
Y'know, the same way one might compare apple pie to fruit with a big old worm in it.
Despite boasting Shamrock's real-fight credibility, his 'Lion's Den' scuffles with Owen Hart and Steve Blackman at SummerSlams 1998 and 1999 weren't that good. Both failed to incorporate enough drama or pro wrestling histrionics to make them worthwhile, and that's why Riddle vs. Thatcher was streets ahead.
Kurt Angle's presence as special guest referee was a masterstroke in booking, and the ferocity of strikes and submissions on offer was complemented by some big bumps and blood. This was what Shamrock's speciality fights needed to be 20+ years ago.
3. Boiler Room Brawl (Mankind Vs. The Undertaker - SummerSlam 1996)
In total, WWE produced four 'Boiler Room Brawls' between 1996-1999, and all of them starred human punching bag Mick Foley. He worked one with The Undertaker at SummerSlam '96, one with Big Show at Backlash 1999, and two against Triple H on the 23 September SmackDown and 20 December Raw that same year.
Forget the latter three.
They were all useless compared to the ominous, odd charm the original against 'Taker had. Nobody had ever seen anything like this largely pre-taped lunacy, and it should be considered a light precursor to the kind of cinematic craziness WWE are trying today during this ongoing empty arena era.
Although it hardly offered strong technical wrestling, that wasn't the point - the shadowy 'Boiler Room' was Mankind's domain, and the manic brawling once again helped show another side to The Undertaker. The duo would continue that quest to expand horizons mere months later...
2. Buried Alive Match (Mankind Vs. The Undertaker - In Your House 11)
Only one of the five 'Buried Alive' gimmick matches put on by WWE is truly essential.
There's perhaps an argument that The Undertaker's showdown with Vince McMahon at Survivor Series 2003 deserves more credit, but the novelty of Vinnie Mac working slow-paced brawls was beginning to become old hat by that point. By comparison, Mankind vs. 'Taker at In Your House 11 was sensational in terms of execution.
Even more impressively, the pair didn't have any blueprint to work with. They had to create the drama for this new spin-off 'Deadman' stipulation all on their own, and they whisked fans in Indianapolis into a frenzy by teasing that The Undertaker might finally be reborn as something totally fresh upon his return.
Other dirt-throwing matches against Steve Austin, the Rock N' Sock Connection and Kane failed to carry as much weight as the first. If WWE ever revive this one, which they sorta' did for 'Mania 36's 'Boneyard' brilliance, then they should force those working it to relive IYH 11.
1. Casket Match (The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels - Royal Rumble 1998)
The Undertaker's 'Casket' stip might hold the record for most duff matches; 19 have been sprinkled throughout WWE history, and yet they're rarely been anything other than huge disappointments. Hell, even the gimmick's video game intro in SmackDown 2: Know Your Role was a massive letdown.
Then, Shawn Michaels came along.
It might've been the night that caused HBK to take a four-year sabbatical from the ring after doing his back in, but the 1998 Royal Rumble's headliner was special regardless. It was the first time that the coffin-based gimmick had actually been framed by a solid match. That's something 'Taker had never managed before.
Clashes with Kamala, Yokozuna, Kama, Goldust and Mabel had all been stinkers. Post-Michaels, those problems would resume. Nobody, including The Rock, Kane, Mark Henry, Big Show, Randy Orton or Rusev, managed to get as much out of the idea as Shawn did.
-
What other WWE stipulations only led to one good match? For more content, check out Madden 21: 10 Things We Already Know and 10 Ridiculous Tag-Teams WWE Missed Out On!