10 WWE Storylines From 2017 That Will Never Be Resolved

Multiplayer Gaming.

Triple H Jason Jordan
WWE.com

It looked for all the world as if SmackDown creative had no idea of the direction in which to take the Fashion Files throughout 2017.

Presented as a bunch of admittedly amusing filler skits, WWE went mystery mad for a few weeks in the late spring, and thus Breezango were assaulted backstage, leading to some surreal TV show homages in an attempt to uncover the identity of the assailants. It became clear that the whole thing was made up as it went along, but the farce only added to the intentionally naff charm. It didn't matter that it made no sense, really; it was welcome respite from the Months Of Mahal. The two dunces eventually stumbled on a clue: "2B", following which the debuting Bludgeon Brothers bludgeoned them at December's Clash of Champions pay-per-view in less than two minutes.

This was not the fruit of some grand plan.

SmackDown creative didn't have any idea of the direction in which to take the Fashion Files, given that Luke Harper and Erick Rowan did nought but wrestle one another on the house show circuit in parallel - but as bizarre an ending as it was, it was, at least, an ending...

10. Lusty Bayley

Bayley Corey Graves
WWE Network

Following the events of Extreme Rules - in which Bayley essentially forfeited the sort of match she knew she was getting herself into at some point, as a lifelong sports entertainment superfan - the Hugger was interviewed by Corey Graves on RAW. After the pro wrestler explained her peaceful protest, she beamed and leaned heavily into Corey Graves with a hug more sensual than platonic. "I'll just rub your back," she said, exhaling. "That felt good, right?"

"I need a cigarette," Graves responded.

"I didn't think you had it in ya!" Michael Cole said, as the cameras cut back into the arena.

"It was the hardest thing I've done in weeks!" Graves exclaimed.

Prior to that p*ss-poor match, WWE creative also leaned heavily into the idea that Bayley wasn't child-like, but an actual child. The abysmal 'This Is Your Life' segment portrayed Bayley as sheltered. Was this new development part of an overarching plot to set Bayley on a path on which she underwent various rites of passage, from the first kiss Alexa Bliss chided her for not having, eventually evolving into a weapon-wielding sh*t-kicker?

Of course not; Bayley exited 2017 having performed in no further programmes of note, and enters 2018 as a ruined nonentity.


9. What Does Sister Abigail Look Like In The Flesh?

Bray Wyatt Sister Abigail
WWE.com

As good as Finn Bálor Vs. AJ Styles was at TLC, the sort of great match we are treated to on a fortnightly basis - the result of which was meaningless, 24 hours later - was really scant consolation for what promised to be a moment of unparalleled schadenfreude.

Sister Abigail wasn't the typical Bray Wyatt spooky nonsense. It was hilarious; pitch-shifted to sound like a chipmunk, adopting a selective lisp in a laughable attempt to further "gender" the character - and dressing like a comprehensive school goth - Sister Abigail was phenomenal car crash television while it lasted: an absurdly misjudged development thought beyond even Bray Wyatt circa 2017. Sadly, it didn't last long: Wyatt succumbed to a bout of the mumps, at which he must have been bloody relieved.

To clarify: the idea of a wrestler in drag isn't funny, in and of itself. The idea of WWE expecting this not to be a hilarious disaster was the source of humour here. What would Wyatt have looked like out there? Would he have tripped up on that shawl? Would that have even been the most embarrassing element of the match?

Less facetiously, this promised such disaster that it may even have compelled WWE to finally shatter the Wyatt holding pattern, once and for all.


8. The Demon Vs. The Beast

Finn Balor Paul Heyman
WWE.com

WWE storylines, understandably, are roundly criticised for their brutal treatment of continuity, tedious overwriting, and for often devolving into sheer pointlessness as a result of dreaded 50/50 booking.

To the credit of the writing staff - well, Paul Heyman - the prospect of The Demon Vs. The Beast was teased expertly, throughout virtually the entire calendar year, with a reassuring use of foreshadowing. Heyman made sure to mention Finn Bálor's name at every opportunity, achieving two objectives: creating anticipation in the mind of the audience, and putting the Demon over. This wasn't a one-man crusade; Bálor himself was scripted to retain some of his storyline focus on Brock Lesnar. The gambit paid off: a huge swathe of the fandom all but accepted it as an inevitability. What's more, Bálor's supernatural alter-ego acted as a neat compromise to the jarring size difference between the two men, in much the same way as AJ Styles' phenomenal essence.

Now, murmurs of "overrated" and "vanilla midget" lurk on social media and wrestling website comments sections - a natural consequence of the fatalistic and harebrained booking to which Bálor was subjected just 24 hours after he defeated AJ Styles at TLC.

The Demon Vs. The Beast may yet happen - but it won't be the same. Not now.


7. No Vengeance For Explosive Men

Randy Orton Great Khali
WWE.com

At the climax of Jinder Mahal's Punjabi Prison WWE Championship defence opposite Randy Orton at Battleground, the Great Khali hobbled to the ring, miraculously scaled the bamboo, and cost the Viper his chance to reclaim the gold.

This was the sort of transition into a new feud WWE deals in frequently. Much like Orton's own RKO, these new antagonists often appear from out of nowhere, purely as a means of setting up the next month(s)of TV, while nominally ensuring the heel retains his chicken-sh*t "heat". It's rote, it's incongruous, but it at least yields something worthwhile on occasion (see: Braun Strowman's interference in the Universal Title bout at Royal Rumble).

Orton, one of the most protected stars in the modern era, was made to look like just another geek in the aftermath. While the prospect of Orton Vs. Khali was as bleak as a kitchen sink drama, logic dictated that it should have happened. Orton, never one to suppress his anger, remedied his Intermittent Explosive Disorder by simply choosing to ignore the events of Battleground, along with just about everybody else.

He didn't call out Khali. The voices in his head probably said something along the lines of "Randy, mate, you're boring enough. Just let it go."


6. Is Triple H Not Bothered About His Wife?

WWE WrestleMania 33 Triple H Stephanie McMahon Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Nobody else is, to be fair, but he did marry her.

At WrestleMania 33, after a gruelling match, Seth Rollins struck Triple H with a Superkick. A dazed Trips made a beeline from the ropes, inadvertently knocking his missus off the apron and sending her crashing through a table. Now, this was sort of his own doing - but Trips, in any incarnation, isn't really tied to the concept of accountability. As a heel, he should have deflected the blame entirely onto Rollins and sought vengeance; after all, when Randy Orton RKO'd Steph, he was left a grunting, hilarious mess. Perhaps he's well past the seven year itch at this point, and who can blame him?

And therein lies just one of several issues with the part-timer era, in which logic, as well as full-time talent, goes to die. Triple H shuffled quietly back into his executive role once WrestleMania faded to black; Payback, though appropriately named, was beneath a performer of his stature. It's a B-level PPV. Let the B+ Players perform on it: Trips only rears his head when the stage is big enough to contain himself and his ego. What's a plot hole, anyway?

Besides which, Trips had a fresh 'Mania match to look ahead to. Plural, come to think of it...


5. "Am I F*cking Going Over? How Many Times?"

Shane McMahon Triple H
WWE.com

The events leading up to Survivor Series 2017 built towards a main event in which Triple H more or less foreshadowed his next four marquee matches.

In order to announce himself as the fifth member of Team RAW, he indulged in one of his favourite pursuits: by Pedigree-ing Jason Jordan in the b*llocks, he planted a seed for a match that probably won't grow into anything - either because Jordan isn't on his level, or because Jordan will join him in the heel ranks come April.

He taunted Braun Strowman throughout the Survivors main, at the climax of which this tension spilled over, all but confirming a clash in New Orleans. This was textbook Triple H; his knack of snagging the hottest stars to wrestle for himself has long since devolved from coincidence to satire. The idea is to "put" (read: "get") Strowman over, even though the Monster Among Men excels in the sort of dynamic matches well beyond Triple H at this point. He also turned on Kurt Angle, allowing Shane McMahon to pin him, before kicking Shane's head in, too.

With the Royal Rumble '18 card looking stacked, and years of B-Level PPV refusal, it's looking like only one of these teased matches is actually happening.

Meanwhile, there is a fifth man...


4. A King In Your Ear

Triple H Kevin Owens Universal Champion Raw
WWE

Ahead of the incredible Festival Of Friendship segment, Triple H was seen in full Littlefinger mode, whispering in the ear of Kevin Owens, orchestrating some Machiavellian plot. This set in motion Owens' gut-punch of a betrayal. Very quickly, rumours of a retooled Evolution 2.0 - Trips was also responsible for promoting Samoa Joe to RAW - ran rampant. Who was the fourth man? Pete Dunne? Adam Cole? Would WWE continue their march towards progressivism, and instal Charlotte in the group?

That plot never materialised - possibly because WWE has no idea of or care for what happens one week to the next, we can't be sure. Something was definitely brewing - nothing happens on WWE TV by accident, save for a Kalisto botch - but, for whatever reason, said plot was abandoned despite its genuinely major ramifications. Triple H is so deliriously focused on setting up his mandated 'Mania match, his next programme, that twice now he's positioned Owens as a puppet devoid of any agency.

They might revisit this in a few years' time, settling this clandestine business at WrestleMania 35, or something. Three years of foreshadowing in order to yield a 25 minute match nobody in the stadium cares about.

It's all about The Game.


3. Natalya Is Leaving

Natalya Clash Of Champions 2017
WWE.com

No, she isn't.

After failing to recapture the SmackDown Women's Title from Charlotte at Clash of Champions, a teary Natalya, already a heel, turned on the fans after grabbing the microphone from one of the robots. Dasha probably.

"Tonight, Charlotte did what Charlotte does best. She used her family's name to cut corners."

That, presumably, was a rib.

"I have given the WWE Universe some of the best matches the women in this company have ever seen, and I have carried this entire division for 10 years. All of you have treated me with nothing but disrespect. You wanna turn your back on me? Well, now I'm turning my back on all of you!"

Dolph Ziggler did something similar on the next episode of SmackDown. Between that, the Kevin Owens third foreign menace wheel stuff, and the consecutive guest commentary fits, this is a brand incapable of not plagiarising itself. It's so weird. It's so terrible.

At least Ziggler did b*gger off for a few weeks; Natalya simply announced herself in the Women's Royal Rumble match in a dot com exclusive a week or so later, clarifying that she meant she was just going to mute fans on Twitter.


2. Bray Wyatt's Mandatory Rematch Clause

Bray Wyatt WWE Champ
WWE.com

In WWE, every titleholder receives a mandatory rematch clause - which is convenient, as it provides the company with the most unimaginative means possible of padding out the stupid amount of hours of television time they are obliged to fulfil. It's yet another arrow in the heart of creativity, but mourning that is pointless.

In WWE, every titleholder receives a mandatory rematch clause - with the stark exception of Bray Wyatt, who didn't bat an eyelid when it was announced that he would not receive the opportunity to recapture the WWE Heavyweight Title in the Payback House Of Horrors match. It was madness necessitated by...well. Wyatt apparently had to win, to restore his heat, cooling Orton's own momentum as champion in the process. This was prime 50/50 booking, a farcical copout of a farcical storyline. In the end, Orton Vs. Wyatt was both hysterically awful and completely pointless.

Wyatt never did receive his rematch. Moreover, having pinned Orton in that putrid non-title affair, he laid a new claim to a Heavyweight Title match. Bray Wyatt is owed two WWE Title matches.

That's about the only terrifying thing about him.


1. Stephanie McMahon Vs. Mick Foley

stephanie mcmahon mick foley
WWE.com

Stephanie McMahon spent months, and months, belittling Mick Foley for his apparent mismanagement of RAW.

Foley accused Steph of conspiring with Triple H to wrest the Universal Title away from Seth Rollins in the summer of 2016. Nothing came of this, aside from the subsequent months of boring passive aggressive bickering, the sort of mundane sh*te from which wrestling should act as an escape - but Steph couldn't take that sitting down, even months later. She had the following to say on the February 27, 2017 RAW:

"Every year, Triple H seems to get stronger and stronger while you Mick, you do the opposite. You just seem to get weaker. I mean, I don't think I calculated just how far you have fallen from grace into the abyss of despair and misery. You're a shell of yourself, Mick. You just get more feeble and more pathetic."

It was par for the course of counterproductive castration the Stephanie McMahon character has embarked upon since 2013 - and a month later, Foley took his balls and went home. Steph fired him as RAW General Manager, and after a token mandible claw - just to create the illusion that this wasn't a rampant ego trip - Steph struck him with a low blow. Why he sold it, having long since given up his sac, is anybody's guess.

There was no resolution to any of this, in the traditional sense - no catharsis for the audience, no stakes-laced blowoff. Foley simply left, after months of tedious tension failed to materialise into a genuine, marketed ending worth shelling out for.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!