10 WWE Superstars Who Seriously Need Repackaging

Your gimmick sucks. Change it or just go away, please.

Character building takes time, especially in front of a WWE crowd. But time can also be a character's worst enemy. Superstars need to constantly evolve in order to keep earning a reaction, and to stay relevant to storylines. We don't like seeing the same thing every single week. And while it's a tough job for Superstars to adjust themselves - especially given the amount of time they spend on our television screens - it's completely necessary. If we ate the same meal every day, we'd get bored of it. It's the same concept here. Unfortunately for some, however, they are at a disadvantage right from the off. Some would be better served going back behind the curtain and locking themselves in a bathroom cubicle rather than appearing on television, purely because of their on-screen persona. There are characters that are simply that bad. It's time to take a look at ten Superstars who are running around with a gimmick that just isn't working. Not having a character of relevance is damaging, and when it's repeatedly shoved in our faces every week it can end up ruining careers. The men behind some of these characters stand at risk of losing all credibility if things don't change. They're not all that bad, but my, there's some shockers.

10. Kane

If we were compiling a list of guys who should just retire, Kane should be on that one too. But the 'Big Red Machine' currently being known as 'Corporate Kane' isn't doing him too many favours. He's moved in to suit trousers as ring-wear, and is currently being wrapped around the little finger of WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins. A turn back to the old Kane was teased recently as he chokeslammed Rollins, though he did eventually lie down for him and take a pinfall. At the moment, Kane continues to weigh up what's more important: his pride or his job as 'Director of Operations'. The way it's going, Kane is likely to go back to his former self. But the trouble is he's completely lost all believability as a monster - especially in heel terms. There's not too many ways of freshening Kane up, but throwing that mask back on and having a babyface run looking to take down the Authority might be as good as it gets.

9. Fandango

As far as novelty goes, Fandango is right up there with the top acts. Fandango even recently underwent a character tweak; finding a new dance partner in the completely useless Rosa Mendes, new entrance music, new dance moves and new attire. But altering his music had an adverse effect. The one established thing Fandango could use to interact with the crowd had been taken away, so it's no wonder WWE have hastily gone back to tried-and-tested. But lets be honest, Fandango needs a new name, to drop the dance act altogether and get serious. He's never going to amount to any kind of level of recognition with this gimmick chaining him down. As it is at the moment - and has always been in his case - Fandango will just be a tool to gee up live crowds. It's a good thing, but it's not what every wrestler gets into the business for.

8. Bo Dallas

Nobody Bo-lieved in the first place and we certainly don't Bo-lieve now. Bray Wyatt's real-life brother is not having a great time of it on the main roster at the moment - and that's because he's got very little to work with character-wise. To be fair to Bo Dallas, he took the idea and tried to run with it. But being a pure cheeseball can only get you so far in WWE. His character never seemed to identify with either live crowds or with people watching at home, with very limited reactions in one way or the other. That's not because the guy himself is bad, but just because he's just been given a raw deal. On the plus side, Dallas does get more microphone time than most - when he appears on television, anyway - but given he's been jobbing for jobbers in recent weeks it seems WWE have even realised their balls-up.

7. Damien Mizdow

Damien Mizdow is one of the hottest properties on the WWE roster at the moment. Credit has to go to The Miz for the role he's played in re-establishing Mizdow's (usual name Sandow) relevance, as he's been playing the perfect antagonist to his former buddy. Obviously, Mizdow has since gone through with the long-time-coming babyface turn we've wanted to see, clocking Miz on WrestleMania's pre-show and since entering a feud with the guy he used to 'stunt double' for. While their rivalry is great fun, it's important that it doesn't go on for too long. He can keep the name for now, but they'll need one blow off match with Mizdow going over very soon. But WWE need to capitalise on Mizdow when he's in the spotlight, re-brand him and set him off in another direction. Now that he's not alongside Miz, he can't have anything to do with him once their rivalry ends. He'll go back to Sandow, but he needs a number of tweaks.

6. Erick Rowan

He's moved away from Bray Wyatt, turned babyface and lost his way. It's Erick Rowan. It perhaps doesn't help that Rowan - along with his sheep mask - was made to look decidedly weak right off the bat when placed into a series of matches with former tag-team partner, Luke Harper. Harper more often than not took the upper hand following each guy's break off into singles competitors, while Wyatt himself has had a number of televised victories over what seemed to be the weak link of his former family. The best thing for Rowan at the moment is to go back to where he came from and join back up with Wyatt, or at least turn heel. If he's not going back to Wyatt, it's perhaps time to lose the overalls - he's still too similar to Harper in that sense - and the mask. But of course they'll sell pretty well at the merch stand, so that's not going to happen. What the heck is his music about, by the way?!

5. Heath Slater

The one man southern rock band barely gets any time on television any more. Perhaps it's for good reason, but lets argue otherwise. Whenever Heath Slater does get his time to shine, he's booed right out of the building. Is this because he's got a great, heat-garnering gimmick or because he's having fun with annoying the heck out of people? Perhaps the latter. Facts are, his character sucks. He's going out there when he gets the opportunity like a lamb to the slaughter and while he's having enjoying it, he's never going to amount to anything other than resident jobber. He's just another guy on the roster at the moment who's likely been told 'creative has nothing for you' and is just waiting to be future endeavoured. Slater's got to rack his brain to find himself a fresh start, because it blatantly seems nobody there is going to help him out. Slater's shown enough proof though that he's able to think on his feet and get a reaction, even with his terrible current package. Imagine what he could do with a better one. He might win at least one match.

4. Cesaro

Cesaro is ranking at only number four on the list because his character transformation isn't urgent. He's currently going well alongside Tyson Kidd as one half of the tag team champions, and at the moment he's getting the chance to show what he can do in the ring on a regular basis. He's always been afforded that opportunity - whether in a pair or as a singles competitor - but the Swiss Superman's downfall so far (in Vince's eyes, anyway) is his inability to connect with the audience. He'll say that, yet Vince is the first to give the OK to edit out Cesaro's huge pop on an episode of Raw when it comes his way. When Cesaro and Kidd run their course as a team - which likely won't be for a while yet - Cesaro is going to be in the same predicament as he was before. He needs repackaging in the singles game. Since it's not particularly up to scratch, get him down the Performance Centre to perfect his promo ability, it's going to reap rewards in the long run. Cesaro is freakishly strong, can have a great match with anybody and has a great physique. Now it's just time to find the final piece of the jigsaw.

3. The New Day

Since they're all sinking as badly as each other, this three-man stable is going down as one Superstar for the purposes of this list. But good lord, I actually sat through one of the New Day's promos last week. I can't quite remember ever cringing so much, but the television was so tragic I couldn't take my eyes off it. Needless to say it's the last time I won't be fast-forwarding through one of their segments. And what in the world is with Big E's stupid posh accent?! The WWE Universe thinks they suck, too. For good reason. They're consistently encouraging us all to clap, but the New Day are that bad that some would perhaps even prefer picking up 'the clap' over tolerating these guys with a gimmick like this. Sorry for going there. In a sense it's good that WWE have got three talented guys a way of getting themselves noticed on TV, but it's just not working.

2. Roman Reigns

He was always going to appear on here, our new John Cena. WWE's next golden boy is going places, whether we like it or not. But in order for him to feel legitimate, we need to see Roman Reigns in a different light. He's got the foundations of a good character but he's not ready to carry the company yet, since that's all he's got. Foundations. They can be be built upon, but tweaks need to be made. These tweaks list as follows: he needs one or two more identifiable moves at least (and that's being kind, though he even showed one on London's Raw), he needs a completely revitalised entrance - music, ring walk, the full shabang - and he definitely needs some new ring attire. Reigns needs to break away from his Shield character completely. As of now, that's not happened, and if anything it looks like WWE have no ideas for him other than to cling on to a gimmick that died when Seth Rollins landed that chair shot. Reigns has got the essentials, but now it's time to do some necessary fine tuning.

1. Adam Rose

For goodness sake, man. Why is Adam Rose still on television? He may have been something completely fresh after being introduced on the main roster last year, but he's already entered Fandango territory - only far worse. His theme music and ring entrance is about the best thing he's got going for him, but even now nobody particularly enjoys seeing it. Novelty wears off, and since he's this character has outstayed his welcome, Rose has just become a pure annoyance. And let's not get started on that ridiculous bunny - though at least that's gone. If you ever saw footage from his FCW and early NXT days, Rose used to be known as Leo Kruger - this freaky South African fellow who had one bad ass ring entrance (the music was great to boot) - and he was damn sure a little deranged. Why can't we have him back?! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SUZo9Eo5d94 Is there anyone else on the roster you think has a terrible gimmick? Do you have any ideas for character changes? Let us know with your comments!

In this post: 
Eric Rowan
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Football writer (predominantly) with work previously published by Mail Online, Manchester Evening News, Daily Mirror, USA Today and Chelsea FC. Regular contributor for Huffington Post, who holds tempestuous relationships with WWE and FIFA 15.