10 WWE Things That Are Impossible To Believe In
TL;DR: Everything.
Suspension of disbelief is the tenet on which pro wrestling was built.
It had to be, given the inherent artifice of the medium; a simulated form of combat that unravels under the scantest of scrutiny - hence why so much of the populace is aghast at its very existence - those open to its charms require a form of world-building necessary to keep their interest in the enterprise from falling apart at the seams. If this meticulous world-building isn't in place, the promotion itself falls apart, which is how one arrives at Goldberg refusing to go up for powerbombs.
Jerry Jarrett's booking philosophy was genius in its simplicity: If you can persuade the audience to believe Plausible Premise A, they will more likely be receptive to Implausible Premises B and C. This used to be the case in the old WWF, even with a patently absurd cast of characters dominating the landscape. With cards set in advance, governed by a man of great authority in Jack Tunney, you could just about allow yourself to believe that a state athletic commission wouldn't balk at it. Even if you balk at the idea of conflating traditional pro wrestling with sport, ludicrous pro wrestling, too, requires internal consistency. Lucha Underground makes more sense in its own context that WWE does in the context of WWE.
Suspension of disbelief has fallen apart in 2018, even if WWE's immense corporate financing means it hardly matters...
10. Commentary
While misty-eyed recollections of the Attitude Era are often the preserve of the forgetful, there was something magical about JR and the King's commentary. JR's moral compass steered the rampant WWF just far enough away from the gutter, his passion doing so much to immerse the crowd into the action. The King meanwhile was a terrific, giddy wit in his pomp. Sharing a wonderful, ineffable chemistry, Ross and Lawler were as invested as the white hot crowds, creating a wonderful cacophony.
Michael Cole is an automaton bellowing emotionless marketing jargon (and, to stretch the comparison further, Charly Caruso and Dasha Fuentes are actual robots assembled on literally the same production line).
You cannot believe a word Cole is saying despite the best efforts at repetition we can only infer is used to bludgeon us into acceptance. Vince McMahon's infamous aversion to pronouns, pal doesn't help. With this mentality married to Stephanie McMahon's marketing checklist, the result is an endless churn of nicknames and clichés made even more unbearable than it appears on the surface; they do this because they deem the audience too stupid to grasp what is hardly arthouse cinema. The irony is that this method of "storytelling" only serves to "create separation" between the desk and the armchair.
Unenthusiastic; repetitive; insulting to the intelligence: WWE commentary is propaganda without the conviction. Unlistenable, at its worst.
9. Finishers
There is a way of protecting finishers without reverting back to an unrecoverable, subjectively duller age. In the All Japan Pro Wrestling scene of the 1990s, main event acts Mitsuharu Misawa and Kenta Kobashi devised dangerous super-finishers when the best of their arsenals - and their veneer of sportsmanship - failed them. In New Japan, finishers are sold before they're even struck; something as devastating as Kenny Omega's One-Winged Angel is put over as a veritable bomb by his opponent's desperate, dramatic struggle to avoid it.
Instead, WWE opts, invariably, for the cheap short-term finisher kick-out pop at the expense of the long-term integrity of the move.
Invariably is no exaggeration; on every 12+ minute televised match, the finisher kick-out trope threatens to undermine any real sense of drama. It's easy enough for the live crowd to get swept up into the action, which accounts for the heat, but those watching at home, without the benefit of the in-your-face thrill, cannot take Miz's Skull Crushing Finale seriously. That is because it isn't a Finale; it's a means of eliciting a reaction only.
This renders the action predictable, and the performers weak, eroding any sentiment that any of this is in anyway consequential.
8. The Match-Making Process
On this Monday's RAW, Kevin Owens played the role of sentient (that's questionable) MacGuffin: The moron who talks himself into a match through interfering in the opening segment, which in turn portrays WWE's heels as chickensh*t and as thick as pigsh*t.
If they are that scared of wrestling, why a) be a wrestler and b) contrive, week after week, to wander into Kurt Angle's (completely unintended) snake pit? It's just plot hole on top of plot hole on top of plot hole. The Inception of terrible sports entertainment.
This talking out of turn inevitably results in the "punishment" of fulfilling one's contractual obligations, which also leads one to wonder exactly what Kurt Angle has planned in the 15:00-30:00 minute slot on the off-chance a match doesn't materialise in front of his hapless eyes via the squabbling losers engaging in playground arguments. We're left to assume that these slots would otherwise go unfilled, since the camera never pans to a despondent Mike Kanellis removing his wrestling gear. Incidentally, there's a decent and coherent running gag ripe to exploit there - will Jobber X ever get the chance to lace his boots? - but no.
It's all so obviously scripted that the enterprise is revealed as phony a full five minutes into the broadcast.
7. The Women's Evolution
WWE does not care about women's wrestling. It cares about the PR perception pretending to care about it affords them.
This is fine, obviously; all fiction is to an extent manipulative, especially the great work that is pro wrestling. The problem is that WWE left the women's rosters at home as they flew away to the Saudi Arabian desert to propagandise a regime change in which women are still treated as second-class citizens, and homosexuals are still brutally executed if they twice engage in consensual same-sex activity flaunted outside of the private home. This is less fine, obviously. WWE's more genuine commitment - to the Saudi reform drive - earns considerably more money than progressivist points.
Prior to this, it was almost possible to believe in WWE's commitment, despite the off-putting desperation with which it was put over. Though WWE told us relentlessly about the Women's Evolution, they did just enough to show it, in parallel, to stave off rejection. Tellingly, the word "first" hasn't been completely drilled into our skulls since WWE pocketed the money, but give it a few months. We still have the "first ever" Women's TLC match to look forward to, the "first ever" time women headline WrestleMania.
This will feel as empty as the soul screeching those words.
6. Promos
Samoa Joe, with his intense, menacing delivery, is really the only top tier promo in WWE right now. The Miz remains good value, cycling though he is through the motions of his incendiary 2016 game.
Largely, the heel verbiage, though indistinct, is halfway credible. Babyfaces are invariably portrayed as witless tossers, with the stark, earnest exception of Daniel Bryan. Seth Rollins cuts good enough promos that garner reactions, but nothing memorable, let alone iconic. Finn Bálor smiles his way through sheer anonymity, which is far preferable to the material handed to AJ Styles earlier this year - "Kami" acting as the latest evidence pointing towards WWE's decade-plus patter crisis. Lame, stilted, obviously rehearsed: even the words that aren't worthy of a Peter Engel production barely carry any weight because the smiling babyface jackasses, who just love to have fun out there, laugh them off. Whatever happened to the terrifying threats of Scott Steiner? Whatever happened to the powder-fuelled bragging of Ric Flair? Whatever happened to my pro wrestling?
We know where it's gone: it's gone to die in a room full of redundant hacks who'd bail at the first crack at a Big Bang Theory gig, only they're nowhere near good enough even for that drivel.
5. Wins And Losses
Roman Reigns lost cleanly to Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania.
It doesn't really matter how bravely he fought, how much blood he lost, how many F5s it took to put him away. This wasn't used as justification for his Greatest Royal Rumble rematch: he was simply awarded it, with no storyline explanation, and still complained about management mistreatment in this brain-melter of a narrative. This is the top babyface in the company subject to WWE's nothing-matters storytelling. The interchangeable cogs stand no chance of anything but the most phoned-in any-old-b*llocks imaginable.
On the 15 January 2018 RAW, Titus O'Neil and Apollo Crews defeated Tag Team Champions The Bar. This entitled Titus Worldwide to a title match on the 29 January RAW. The challenge was unsuccessful. There is a lyric in the Of Montreal song 'The Past Is A Grotesque Animal' that neatly sums up the sheer pointlessness of it all:
The sun is out, it melts the snow that fell yesterday / Makes you wonder why it bothered.
This served only to weaken the champions, did not tell a logical or particularly exciting story, and had no bearing on future storylines. It existed to fill TV time.
That's all so much of WWE content exists for.
4. (Too Many Of) The Performers
There are several WWE performers - an astonishing number, given the 2018 industry standard - simply incapable of wrestling the part.
Nia Jax is dangerous and limited, inspiring reactions of anxiety and boredom. In many ways, she is the opposite of a good worker; a good worker is meant to simultaneously thrill and reassure the audience that they are, despite the brutal visual, watching a professional at work. Carmella can draw mild heat, but cannot wrestle a dramatic match, instead relying on the cheapest of shortcuts to irritate fans into caring. She is a one-dimensional performer.
They are the champions of their respective divisions.
Big Cass used Carmella's deathly dull approach on the same show (Backlash) by leading Daniel Bryan around the ring in a borderline insulting display of irony. At least his height alone conveys that he hovers around threat-level; the work of Mandy Rose is so error-strewn and reliant upon the contortion and protection of her opponents that you don't so much wonder who's going to win her matches, but wonder how she was deemed adequate enough for promotion. Tamina is worthless. Alicia Fox is a suplex. Baron Corbin is serviceable. He's also a mooted future WWE Champion.
In too many cases, these aren't jobbers we're missing the point of. They are at the forefront of a future McMahon has never been more secure enough to make a present-day reality.
3. Championships
A brief state of championships address:
WWE Championship: Bulletproof, but not for lack of trying, what with AJ Styles' in-ring and storytelling disappointment of a second reign.
Universal: Barely warrants the designation of title, held as it is in a state of glorified abeyance. Feels less prestigious than the Big Gold Belt, and Triple H used that as a weapon in a midcard murdering spree at this stage of its existence.
Intercontinental: In rude health around the waist of Seth Rollins, who has nicely supplemented the importance placed upon it by proud predecessor The Miz.
United States: Dolph Ziggler (!) deemed himself above it. Was correct to do so on the basis of the subsequent meaningless merry-go-round.
RAW Women's: Held by a reckless worker in order to promote WWE's hypocritical anti-bullying campaign. Match quality has worsened considerably since late 2016.
SmackDown Women's: Is a trinket buried to elevate the Carmella act, which while mildly entertaining is not championship material.
RAW Tag Team: Used variously for a cheap 'Mania pop and a means of maximising the Matt Hardy investment and doing something, anything, with the failed Bray Wyatt experiment. Even prior to all this, everybody had a turn.
SmackDown Tag Team: Has lost the impressive lustre boasted last year, but still worth contesting for.
Cruiserweight: The curse has lifted, but does anybody really anticipate a defence of it?
Verdict: Titles ostensibly act as the very motivation to sign along WWE's dotted line. With precious few exceptions, this crucial premise does not translate. At all.
2. The First Match Of A Major Programme
At the Greatest Royal Rumble, there was more chance of a woman entering the stadium than there was a decisive conclusion to the WWE Championship match between AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura.
Sure enough, the match ended in a double count-out purely as a means of prolonging the wider programme. It was simply the latest Sisyphean narrative spun by a company with no obligation to entice new pay-per-view punters in the Network Era. Hence the Rule Of Three, or in this case Four: outside of WrestleMania season and the subsequent Superstar Shakeup, particularly as we angrily stumble into the late spring months, WWE tends to regurgitate. The effect isn't sickening, however; it is a matter of acceptance.
We accept that the first match of a major programme isn't likely to end conclusively because there is so much recent precedent telling us to know better. AJ Styles vs. Kevin Owens; Finn Bálor vs. Bray Wyatt; Seth Rollins vs. Bray Wyatt; Everybody vs. Bray Wyatt, prior to his merciful marginalisation into the tag team ranks: each 2017 rivalry was stretched out, manifesting, in the end, as pure filler - which in the case of Wyatt was particularly rancid viewing, given the dismal premise of his incompetent boogeyman act. "They're saving something better for the blowoff" has entered the wrestling lexicon with a disturbing insidiousness.
But when we get to that blowoff, the intrigue has all but dissipated, adding to the malaise.
1. Pushes
This is critical.
This is a crucial area of WWE so infuriatingly inconsistent, and ultimately pointless, that it erodes any sense of goodwill or hope or anticipation. You can only approach a push with apprehension because they never go anywhere. Christ, even Roman Reigns isn't worth the bother in 2018. If you can't believe that, what can you believe in? This fosters complete emotional detachment from the product so methodically it's akin to Randy Orton wrestling the interest out of you.
Is Finn Bálor, in the fiction of WWE, a main event-level performer? Or is he simply a midcard wheel-spinner? Even if we eventually find out, WWE would doubtlessly retcon the development weeks or months later to make way for the next guy's turn. Looking at this malaise quantitatively, it is astonishing how many WWE stars have fallen into a pattern of meaninglessness from the initial wave of momentum/conviction with which they debuted. In addition to Bálor, Kevin Owens has devolved from one of a select few to cleanly defeat John Cena to a perennial loser in the title hunt. Baron Corbin has devolved from Money In The Bank briefcase holder to an almost Diva-esque terminal roll-up victim. Bayley is a bust. Sasha Banks is ratchet again. Bobby Lashley was knackered in a month. Bobby Roode won't get a BluRay bio release, but if he does, it will be called 'From Glorious To Geek: The Bobby Roode Story'.
Everybody joins the club, which is only a slightly better position to be in than the Club.