10 WWE Wrestlers Who Are Impossible To Care About

A rogues' gallery of heat vacuums.

Erick Rowan
WWE.com

A professional wrestler can get over in a number of different ways. For the likes of AJ Styles, their popularity stems from the strength of their ring work, and for others, like Hulk Hogan, it's their magnetic charisma and showmanship.

Some do it with their company's full support (Triple H), while others get there in spite of the bookers' actions (Daniel Bryan). Whatever the case, getting over is never easy, and maintaining heat is even harder.

One of the modern WWE product's biggest failings has been its complete inability to establish and sustain stars comparable to those forged in bygone eras. The current roster isn't totally devoid of star power, but wrestlers just aren't getting over like they used to, with much of it down to the performers and the way they've been presented.

The current talent pool is flooded with wrestlers that fans just don't care about, because they haven't been given a reason to do so. It's both the performers' and the company's job to build a level of investment, but they've failed. Badly.

Some of these wrestlers may eventually recover, but for now, their popularity has either stalled, or is stuck on a steep downward trajectory.

10. The Ascension

The Ascension
WWE.com

The Ascension have always been pretty lame.

They were NXT Tag Team Champions for a record 344 days, but this came at a time when the division was woefully underdeveloped, with most of their defences coming through quick squashes. They've got awesome entrance music, but one of the worst looks in the company, and neither is particularly exciting between the ropes.

That being said, WWE have put precisely zero effort into getting them over on the main roster.

Konnor and Viktor were immediately blighted by unfavourable Legion Of Doom comparisons upon arrival, and were then thrust into a lame storyline that saw them beaten down and humiliated by old-timers like the New World Order, Acolytes, and New Age Outlaws. The Ascension's intrigue ended there, and it was impossible to care about them from that moment onward.

They soon became a listless enhancement team, and though the short-lived Cosmic Wasteland group gave them a smidgen of shine in 2015, they've never been given a spotlight. They've been fun additions to the Fashion Files, but unless The Ascension are rebranded (Surf Dudes With Attitudes, please), it's hard to see their popularity problem ever easing.


9. TJP

TJ perkins
WWE.com

TJ Perkins felt like one of the hottest wrestlers in the company coming out of the Cruiserweight Classic. The former independent standout produced an awesome series of performances to win the tournament, and his earnest post-finals promo appeared to set him up as a major babyface, but his momentum went off a cliff as soon as the division made it to Raw.

Perkins was Cruiserweight Champion, but didn't even feature as part of the division's main roster debut. From there, WWE saddled him with some awful 8-bit entrance music, and a cringeworthy gamer gimmick that saw him recite lines like "you just need to hit hard reset on your career, dude," during his feud with Brian Kendrick. TJP became a goof, and he lost his belt at Hell In A Cell, just over three months after becoming champion.

It originally looked like TJP was to be built as the cruiserweight division's ace, but he quickly became just another guy on the roster. Neville has replaced him as the cornerstone, and TJP spends his days bouncing from one dull midcard feud to another, lost at sea on 205 Live - WWE's least interesting brand.


8. Mickie James

Mickie James
WWE.com

Mickie James earned a full-time WWE contract on the strength of her performance against NXT Women's Champion Asuka at TakeOver: Toronto. At a time when 'The Empress Of Tomorrow' had ran through everyone else on the roster, James, a five-time Divas Champion, was brought in to put an end to her all-out dominance. She was unsuccessful, but regardless, it was a tremendous match that proved she could still go, and helped her win the respect of NXT's partisan audience.

Unfortunately, WWE have done little with James since the big match. She returned to SmackDown in January and forged a brief alliance with Alexa Bliss, but it soon fell apart. James quickly slid down the rankings, and was sent to Raw as part of April's Superstar Shake-Up, but this hasn't resulted in an upturn in fortunes.

Mickie is barely even being used anymore. She has wrestled just eight matches on Raw, and has only tasted victory in two of those. The Asuka matched proved that she can still go toe-to-toe with anyone, but she has become driftwood, and her lack of televised opportunities has made it impossible to invest in her.


7. Erick Rowan

Erick Rowan Luke Harper
WWE.com

Erick Rowan was always The Wyatt Family's least interesting member. He's a decent brawler, and a very effective tag wrestler, but he lacked Bray's intoxicating charisma, Luke Harper's unreal athleticism, and Braun Strowman's brute force. He's a supporting cast member, not a lead role player, and his career falls apart every time he is split from his brothers.

WWE first tried to push Rowan as a singles wrestler back in 2014, when they turned him face ahead of Survivor Series. Unsurprisingly, Erick's new vintner gimmick flopped, and he was eventually reunited with Harper the following year. The Family have endured a tumultuous 2017, but they were eventually split when Bray left for Raw in April, and Rowan is a lost sheep once more.

Rowan, like Harper, barely features on TV anymore. Luke is a talented enough performer that people still care about, but the same can't be said for his former partner, who has never drawn any kind of crowd reaction as a solo act, and probably never will. Reuniting him with Harper may be the only way to save his career at this point, but given their combined lack of recent appearances, success is far from guaranteed.


6. Apollo Crews

apollo crews
WWE.com

WWE have jumped the gun on a number of NXT call-ups in recent years, but few were more premature than Apollo Crews. A tremendous athlete and an eye-catching wrestler, he was a good prospect, but left the Performance Center while still in the formative stages of his developmental as a WWE superstar. He arrived on the main roster as an unseasoned performer with a glaring charisma deficiency, and this hasn't changed.

Crews' character has never evolved beyond "bald guy who smiles a lot." He has been locked into a number of programs, but he has never been given microphone time, and has no discernible personality traits. We're at a stage where half the main roster referees probably have stronger characters than Crews, whose Raw/SmackDown existence has been relatively pointless.

Linking up with Titus O'Neil hasn't benefited Crews at all. Akira Tozawa has since supplanted Apollo as his manager's favourite client, and he has been relegated to a sidekick role. Sending him back to NXT would be of great benefit to him, but it'd take some heavy convincing to turn even the Full Sail University crowd to his side, such is the apathy surrounding him.


5. The Miztourage

The Miz Maryse Curtis Axel Bo Dallas
WWE.com

This isn't a slight on The Miz and Maryse - they're fantastic, and constantly among Raw's most enjoyable acts - but their two sidekicks: Bo Dallas and Curtis Axel.

The idea of Miz recruiting a couple of goons isn't a bad one. He's exactly the kind of character who benefits from having two lugs to boss around, or hide behind when things get dangerous. Sadly, WWE couldn't have picked a bigger set of goobers than Dallas and Axel, who've been booked as enhancement guys for the bulk of their runs.

These two have been squash match fodder for years, so why would anyone care about them in 2017? They've been placed with one of the company's best acts, but rather than elevating the lowly duo, this association drags Miz down. His Miztourage couldn't have less credibility, and while they make for effective cannon fodder, nobody's ever going to invest in them again.

Their flaws become even more apparent when compared to The Singh Brothers, whose big-bumping antics have been the only thing saving Jinder Mahal's WWE Title defences from complete disaster. They're not the most popular act on the roster either, but at least they add excitement.


4. Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler Hair
WWE.com

Once a consensus pick for the dubious title of WWE's most under-pushed wrestler, Dolph Ziggler has become one of the company's least interesting performers. His fanbase used to be massive, but their number has been chipped away by years of terrible booking, and his interest levels have never been lower than they are today.

Ziggler is an unsalveagable midcard gatekeeper. He had a great feud with The Miz in 2016, but that's the only highlight on his recent resumé. Terrible storylines like the Rusev/Lana/Summer Rae love quadrangle and endless losses in big matches have made it impossible to care about the guy. It's a shame, because none of this is his own fault, but 'The Show-Off' has fallen apart.

WWE tried to turn his lack of direction into a storyline this week, with Dolph openly complaining about his shortage of TV time, making indirect references to other wrestlers who've risen while he has slid. The critical response to this has been largely negative, and it looks like there's no way to save Ziggler on the main roster. His supporters have abandoned him, and a trip down to NXT may soon be on the cards.


3. Enzo Amore

Enzo Amore
WWE.com

Splitting Enzo Amore and Big Cass has been disastrous for both men. The charisma-less Cass is lost without his livewire mouthpiece, while Enzo needed the big man's power to help cover his glaring in-ring deficiencies (though Cass is no Ricky Steamboat himself). Both are deeply flawed, but they complimented each other's weaknesses, and they've sunk like stones on their own.

With Cass now set to miss nine months of action following an ACL tear, Enzo has been sent to 205 Live, where his popularity will keep dwindling, and he'll probably be fed to Neville. He's still drawing crowd reactions, but they're noticeably less enthusiastic than they once were, and all signs point towards him continuing on this trajectory.

There are a number of reasons for this. Enzo's once unique promos have become increasingly repetitive, with little variation from one to another, and he gets beaten up or humiliated almost every time he appears. Speculation suggests that huge backstage heat is the reason behind this, and if that's the case, Amore is doomed. WWE have done one hell of a job in cooling him off, that's for sure.


2. Bayley

Bayley Injury
WWE.com

Bayley used to be one of WWE's most popular acts. Her NXT "coming of age" storyline was perfect, and the moment she finally became Women's Champion will go down as one of the developmental brand's most important moments. She drew a huge reaction when she debuted on the main roster at Battleground 2016, and when Raw hit Glasgow that November, Bayley was so well received that the crowd's constant cheering, chanting, and singing completely derailed her in-ring promo.

Now, Bayley's lucky if she even gets a polite cheer from the crowd. In fact, her reactions have diminished to the point where she's often booed by the WWE Universe, which seemed unthinkable a year ago.

This is entirely WWE's fault. They have completely destroyed one of their biggest babyface commodities by presenting her as as an overawed loser who's in way over her head. The damage started with her destructive Raw Women's Title reign, but escalated during her awful feud with Alexa Bliss, which would finish as the year's worst if Randy Orton vs. Bray Wyatt didn't exist.

They're clearly trying to recreate Daniel Bryan's rise by having Bayley lose so often, but WWE can't capture lightning in a bottle twice, and must rethink Bayley's push if they're to regain her lost fans.


1. Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt Laughing At The Punchline That Is Himself
WWE.com

The way WWE have dismantled Bray Wyatt's intrigue will go down as one of the most spectacular hatchet jobs in the company's history.

Once one of the most uniquely intoxicating characters the sport has ever seen, Bray descended into self-parody a long time ago. It started when he and the Wyatt Family were needlessly buried by John Cena, and continued through every ensuing feud. "Bray never wins big matches" has become a meme, such is his lack of in-ring success, and it has killed his credibility as a performer.

Not only that, but Wyatt's character direction has nosedived in recent years. His promos are 90% repetitive, babbling nonsense, and 10% sharp intakes of breath/wacky facial expressions. They're beyond awful, and while his delivery is still unique, it's hard to take anything the guy says seriously anymore.

People are still into Wyatt, but only to a certain point. Fans will gladly pull their phones out for his awesome ring entrance, but their volume plummets as soon as the bell rings, and while Wyatt hasn't yet become a heat vacuum, it's impossible to invest in a wrestler who can never back his bold claims up.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Eric Rowan
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.