10 WWE Wrestlers Who Could Be The New Fiend

Wrestling has more than one...Fiend. Who could take the infamous gimmick to the next level?

Cody Rhodes Fiend
WWE

At Hell In A Cell 2019, Vince McMahon did more to kill his own creation than Mr McMahon ever managed to with the New World Order 17 years earlier.

Back then, he asserted that Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash and Scott Hall would be a lethal dose of poison, injected into an organisation with Ric Flair also sat at the top table. Rapidly, they slotted into life in the upper midcard and McMahon himself killed the group in July when he couldn't be a*sed with them any more.

It was the same but worse for The Fiend in only his second televised match. Failure to beat Seth Rollins at cartoonish props and dollar store horror shlock was a bigger hammer blow than Rollins' own to the toolbox rested gently on Bray Wyatt's face. The supernatural murder clown winning the belt at the second attempt didn't even have time to scan as rehabilitation before Goldberg speared any remaining mystique out of him just four months later.

A big shame for since-released star, not least because WWE has never felt so perfectly equipped for such a character. Sub-2000 WCW Nitro sh*t occurs on a weekly basis now, with expectations set so low that much of the browbeaten audience are too tired to care. Alexa Bliss was pretty much The Fiend after Wyatt got released in 2021, all until the company lost interest in her after weeks of segments reimagining the gimmick.

The door to The Fiend's blackened soul is open. Who will Let Him In?

10. Otis

Otis WWE
WWE

Having looked lost at sea following the needless split of Heavy Machinery in 2020, Otis became the latest wrestler to gain a new lease on life thanks to Chad Gable.

Alpha Academy have been a riot as part of a partially rejuvenated Monday Night Raw tag division, but what happens next for Otis in particular when they're inevitably split? Jason Jordan never achieved singles heights that matched American Alpha's golden era. Shelton Benjamin's Hurt Business partnership with Cedric Alexander was even more doomed than his run with Gable, and Bobby Roode's Dirty Dawgs partnership with Dolph Ziggler hasn't ever summoned the charm nor match quality so frequently on offer during his time with the former Shorty G.

All of this is to say that sooner or later Otis will be staring into the abyss of a post-Gable future, and scary WWE monster is just about the only thing the company hasn't let him try yet. They all become dancing fools in the end, but Fiend Otis can hurt before he heals.


9. Shotzi

Shotzi Megan Morant
WWE

The green-haired SmackDown star's got a black heart, this much we know. Or we did, until WWE robbed her of a surname upon arrival on the main roster.

This needless change was made worse for the rationale dissolving just as rapidly. "Shotzi & Nox" was thought to be catchier than Shotzi Blackheart & Tegan Nox, but this syllabic stupidity was rendered irrelevant after Nox was released following their call-up. Maybe all of this had something to do with Shotzi's heel turn on Sasha Banks as her singles run kicked off. Maybe, because WWE never bothered to flesh any of that out either.

Lined up like that, it's easy to see why Shotzi could easily veer off to that dark place. The same place that sent Seth Rollins off the deep end, sent Finn Bálor back to NXT and sent Alexa Bliss on to the swings. If WWE have any of that green goo left from the Shane McMahon/Braun Strowman angle last spring, her conversion would be complete.


8. Finn Bálor

Finn Balor
WWE.com

Finn Bálor was the first high profile performer to fall afoul of The Fiend following a fantastic SummerSlam 2019 squash. Has he ever truly recovered?

A return to NXT didn't stop the black-and-gold brand taking a thumping from AEW in the Wednesday Night Wars, a second run with that brand's strap fell massively short of expectations when the rancid Capitol Wrestling Center needed something to light it up, and The Demon became an even bigger clown than Bray Wyatt himself when he fell flat on his f*cking a*se during the ludicrous Extreme Rules 2021 match with Roman Reigns.

Before he was tumbling from the top of a haunted turnbuckle, Demon lore had it that Bálor could sacrifice a bit of the man to become the monster within. But that monster's been tamed by 'The Tribal Chief', and the man himself has floated aimlessly ever since. Time to find the fight. Time to find the fright. Time to find The Fiend.


7. Dominik Mysterio

Dominik Mysterio
WWE

On the post-WrestleMania Raw, Dominik Mysterio was defeated by The Miz in thirty pathetic seconds. Seven days later, he was leaving the show on a stretcher having taken a battering by Veer. Back-to-back humiliations, and all off the back of an ego-bruiser of beating from Logan Paul at WrestleMania.

This could drive anybody to Fiendish tendencies, let alone a son that will never ever step out of his father's shadow otherwise. Few imagined the 'Biggest Little Man' could cast such a long one, but Rey Mysterio's legacy is such that WWE still can't book a single lucha star to replace him. What chance has his kid got of playing suitable surrogate?!

Having profoundly proven himself the wrong fit to replace his Dad, it's time for Dominik to don a mask of a different kind. When the inevitable electric-chair-on-the-ramp finally occurs, the turn should be motivated by a hitherto unseen spirit-crusher lurking within his second generation soul. The Fiend was obsessed with being let in. Mysterio is a young man just waiting to let his out.


6. MACE

Mace WWE
WWE.com

What's going on with MACE?

Right as WWE's schedule increased as pandemic restrictions eased, MACE found himself with less work than ever before.

RETRIBUTION typically found themselves examining the ThunderDome lights from flat on their backs, but they were featured as Raw's biggest losers nonetheless. Following their split, Mace went from tagging with T-Bar to...nothing. He last wrestled in November 2021, missing the entire Road To WrestleMania as well as the random post-WrestleMania push.

And speaking of those, remember that time a sock puppet buzzard burst forth from a box?

Unbeknownst to a bewildered Barclays Center crowd in 2019, this strange vignette turned out to be the birth of The Fiend himself. Bray Wyatt's final match, box-like-structure-and-all might have been just as daft, but few could have predicted the gooey middle at the core of all the lore. MACE may seem a random choice for developing Fiendish traits, but he's worn a mask to protest the ills of society before. Could the next one sport The Fiend's sadistic smile?


5. Doudrop

Doudrop wwe
WWE.com

Doudrop's done nothing of note since losing to Becky Lynch at the 2022 Royal Rumble, and based on how quickly her persona pivoted from one emotion to another, that might not bode well.

A standout in contests against Lynch, Bianca Belair and Liv Morgan, she's since been ignored by WWE bosses despite several makeshift teams coming together to compete in a pointless and futile Tag Team Championship multi-woman match.

Could this creative indifference spark a Fiend within?

She went very nice then very nasty during programmes with Eva Marie and Belair in 2021, going as far as to dress up in a fashion not too dissimilar from the one Alexa Bliss adopted when she too was taken in by Bray Wyatt's insidious alter ego. With nothing else better to do (and a wandering mind making the worst possible decisions) the likes of Abbey The Witch and Mercy The Buzzard could be unearthed from the WWE warehouse as figments of Doudrop's imagination for the first of several psychotic episodes.


4. Wendy Choo

Wendy Choo
WWE

The only mask Wendy Choo currently needs is the one that blocks out all those colours in the Performance Center when she's trying to get some sleep. This wasn't always the case though.

As Mei Ying, she obscured herself with a mask made of magic powers, which presumably still linger underneath the onesie. At one thousand years old, she's got even more experience than the youthful Damian Priest, and few others might well be equipped to assume The Fiend's powers.

She knows her way around the prop sh*t too. On a recent edition of NXT 2.0, she blasted Toxic Attraction with a water pistol that contained fluids so apparently dangerous that the women's champions were sent into a total tailspin. The Fiend knows all about that - or did before the black substance that once collected in Randy Orton's stomach started leaking out of Alexa Bliss' forehead.

If Choo can utilise the goo, it spells doom for me and you.


3. Rick Boogs

Rick Boogs
WWE

Rick Boogs is currently on the injured list following a torn quad suffered at the worst place and time for a wrestler to absorb such a blow.

WrestleMania 38 should have been a memorable night for the noodling buffoon. Working the main show for the very first time and for a title no less, Boogs was in a sweet opening spot alongside Shinsuke Nakamura until he crumpled under the weight of trying to lift both Usos at the same time.

He's taken to his recovery like - you guessed it - a Fiend! Spotted hobbling around his neighbourhood with the bad wheel completely covered by his cast, the moustachioed man mountain looked largely unbothered by his nightmare knock, in much the same way The Fiend did whenever anybody tried to use normal of-this-earth offence against him.

Boogs was a rather unorthodox gentleman to begin with. Has something that would permanently park a normal human instead driven him to Hurt after he's Healed?


2. Cody Rhodes

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Wrestling has more than one royal family.

It's got more than two, too. Though "McMahon" has dominated contemporary conversation and "Rhodes" has featured prominently in the building of both the WWE and AEW rosters, "Rotunda" had quite the deep footprint until very recently.

Pandemic-era cuts saw Bray Wyatt (Windham Rotunda), Bo Dallas (Taylor Rotunda) and the former IRS (Mike Rotunda) all let go by WWE, ending a relationship with the legendary family going back decades. The return of a Rhodes in 2022 to restore some wrestling history to WWE's make-up was crucial, but what dramatic twist could The Codyverse take if and when he's relegated to the midcard as presumed?

It might sound like an American Nightmare, but this is somebody who got a skull tattoo on his neck and - depending on who you ask - has just sold his soul to the devil just six years after claiming it back. There are wilder shouts to go off the deep end than the often-erratic former AEW EVP.


1. Edge...

Edge, the biggest nerd around
WWE.com

...and any mates he's about to make as part of his recent heel turn.

The Hall-Of-Famer has already teamed up with Damian Priest and rumours have swirled that he's set to add to his blue house with its blue windows any day now. Rhea Ripley and Tommaso Ciampa are the bookies favourites (or would be if William Hill gave odds on this sh*t), but WWE care so little for the "why" that it might not ever matter who fills the spots.

Edge has told us all on multiple occasions that it's our fault he's gone mad. Bunch of sheep we all are, following the status quo instead of the dark path he now chooses to walk. This is Fiend-like behaviour of the highest order, and if he's not going to unlock the blackest corner of his soul, perhaps one of his new stablemates might get there instead.

The Firefly Funhouse walls were bright blue. Think about it.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.