10 WWE Wrestlers Who Retired In Their Prime

Forever Young.

Lita Mickie James
WWE.com

You'd think wrestlers would be pleased to call it a day.

It's a punishing, punishing life clocking in and out of the office when your office isn't a desk but a load of desks flattened and fashioned into a 20x20 square with a thin layer of canvas on top. Where you don't so much park yourself listlessly on an ergonomically-efficient chair as throw yourself hard onto a surface about as kind as the retrograde carpet glued to most corporate floors. Where your office politics don't revolve around who used the last of the milk but who conspired with the boss to steal your spot, your job or your entire livelihood over something as inconsequential as a "creative difference".

It is, admittedly, a process that expedites ageing, wear and tear. With the mundanity the rest of us endure, our minds and bodies will at least theoretically allow us to plod on well into the Autumn of our existence. Wrestlers, historically, don't tend to run the ropes as well when their Summer draws in. Some, however, don't have the money not to.

These, for the most part, are not those wrestlers. These still had it all to play for until they got out, were taken out or simply parked a period of their career for something new.

10. CM Punk

CM Punk
WWE.com

Only in wrestling could a retirement be all but confirmed by an instantly memeable red carpet rant, but CM Punk's "NEVER EVER EVER" wail when asked in 2014 if he'd be returning to WWE several months after his acrimonious departure reflected yet another significance severance of a once-financially fruitful relationship.

A podcast with Colt Cabana controversial enough to land both in hot water legally in the months that followed drove into the details, but his follow-on pursuit of UFC glory was halted by two damaging defeats in his maiden efforts. 'The Voice Of The Voiceless' was gone from the two large arms of combat sports/Sports Entertainment.

Until now.

CM Punk: WWE Superstar really does appear retired for good, but that says nothing about the future of CM Punk: Pro Wrestler in the wake of the hugely successful All Elite Wrestling launch show Double Or Nothing. Their soft launch ALL IN hailed from Chicago, with Punk appearing for one signing the day before, but rumours haven't subsided about his involvement, not least if they want a Lex Luger moment for the debut edition of their live weekly show.


9. Trish Stratus

Trish Stratus Unforgiven 2006
WWE Network

The fleeting Trish Stratus comebacks over the past few years have solidified one thing - she was bang right to retire in 2006 with her health and wellbeing in tact.

A gifted, natural talent during a period in which much of her skillset wasn't even valued in the way it should have been, Stratus' appearances amongst the women of the current era have been a joy to behold. Not short a step for her decade-plus away, the former Women's Champion has managed to enjoy the fruits of her labour and that of those that followed in her footsteps.

The decline following her exit was sharp and unpleasant, but she missed virtually all of it starting her own business and a family with the time and financial freedom she'd accrued as a battle-worn WWE star. That last word being the operative one - few women from her era or now carried with them the respect and reactions she'd been able to harness.

A lesson to all wrestlers and promotions, Trish's Unforgiven 2006 farewell match is a masterclass in making nice with a departing star rather than the usual horror shows spitefully deployed. Such as...


8. Lita

Lita 2006
WWE.com

Lita's exit just two months after Trish Stratus' may as well have happened in an alternate universe, let alone in a different city on a different show.

The Toronto and Philadelphia locales were all that separated Unforgiven and Survivor Series respectively in 2006, but the booking team weren't half as keen on being kind the second time around. Unlike Trish, Lita was beaten. Unlike Trish, Lita's match wasn't placed in a position of prestige. Unlike Trish, Lita's underwear were stolen and sold to the crowd by babyfaces to send her on her way.

And her absence didn't just make fans' hearts fonder for the former Team Extreme star - it created a mutual feeling from the woman behind the gimmick herself.

Amy Dumas walked away from wrestling entirely - seemingly rather happily so - until wrestling called her back and asked for Lita.

Forming part of an improved narrative around her time as WWE rebuilt their women's division, Lita was considered a cornerstone and viewed on television as such. Never the tightest between the ropes, Lita didn't need to damage her own legacy in the process - despite WWE's efforts to do just that all those years ago.


7. The Rock

The Rock 2004 WrestleMania XX
WWE.com

There are several moments between 2001 and 2003 that could be classed as points at which The Rock became Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson in his own mind, but each elective exit finds 'The Great One' still in a seemingly never ending prime.

There's the Raw after WrestleMania X-Seven, a night removed from headlining what was then the biggest and best pay-per-view in company history. There's his summer 2002 departure after putting Brock Lesnar over clean as a sheet for the WWE Championship. He lost to Booker T, The Hurricane and Bill Goldberg as a part time heel in 2003. He gave everything to a ripper of a handicap match with Mick Foley at 2004's WrestleMania XX.

Each one selfless but no less satisfying, The Rock spent four years retiring just to ensure the company and the audience enjoyed the benefit of his presence whilst they both still could.

It took a long seven years before he came back for a three-year WrestleMania arc against John Cena that sucked in The Miz, CM Punk and others, but the Hollywood megastar that returned from the sliver screen was by this point more of a made man than any Sports Entertainment escapee in history.


6. Molly Holly

Molly Holly
WWE.com

One of the finest moments from any WWE Hall Of Fame ceremony in recent years occurred during Beth Phoenix's long and at-times rambling recollection of a relatively young life and career well-lived.

Buried deep within the anecdotes, she noted how Molly Holly had paid for her wrestling training in an unsolicited gesture of goodwill due to Beth's efforts. It was a touching tribute to a person that appeared from the outside to be one of the nicest to have ever entered the industry, doing everything she could afford to for those still traversing through it.

It also spoke to how careful she'd been with her money during her prime earning years. Holly got in via WCW's mad money machine in 1999, but rapidly improved her workrate to the point where she was far too good for a flailing and failing female division.

A steady hand for WWE from 2000 through to her 2005 departure, she left wrestling full time to focus on other pursuits, but took with her a raft of enjoyable matches and angles that ensured that fans would still pine for her occasional one-off returns.


5. Rowdy Roddy Piper

Roddy Piper Adrian Adonis WrestleMania 3
WWE.com

A serial wrestling retiree when as and when he could do good business with the stipulation, Rowdy Roddy Piper's WrestleMania III retirement was an earnest attempt by the 'Hot Scot' to leave wrestling behind and try and break into Hollywood for good. A glorious encounter with Adrian Adonis anchored the classic pay-per-view's midcard with more heft than the 'Adorable' heel had piled on in his later years.

Babyfaced after years as the hottest heel in the territory, Piper left the Pontiac Silverdome as an industry icon, accepting the end his full time career years before he perhaps needed to.

Spending an entire second career as a part time wrestler after his 1989 return, Piper's effort to exit two years prior was earnest in its intention. Early signs were promising too. "They Live" was a bonafide cult classic, with Piper's performance praised in particular. Failed projects such as "Hell Comes To Frogtown" were steps too great in the wrong direction though, and his true calling always giddily called him back on the strength of his original drawing power.


4. Paige

Paige Raw Retirement
WWE.com

Modest cinema success Fighting With My Family profiled the years leading up to Paige's historic title-winning WWE debut, but there's perhaps just as much left in a slightly more challenging sequel following the heartbreaking news she was forced to deliver four years later.

Old enough to know better but young enough to not care, Paige was giving her body to wrestling before she was even born, but the 25 years she'd spent taking bumps sadly culminated in her being forced into retirement at...25.

Tragic in its timing (as if such news is ever really anything but tragic at such a young age), Paige had barely returned from an extended injury absence in late-2017 before absorbing a hard kick to the neck that reaggravated substantial problems she'd dealt with for many years.

Tear-soaked, Paige bid the ring farewell in the same building she'd debuted on the WWE main roster in 2014. The comeback had been all-too-brief for anybody to digest, though she'd at least spent long enough on the roster to ensure there'd be space for her to thrive in other roles post-retirement.


3. Corey Graves

Corey Graves Commentary
wwe.com

Corey Graves was forced to tearfully bid farewell to his in-ring career on-air, but it was as much in an effort to aid his rehabilitation and reinvention as an NXT commentator in the aftermath of the devastating news he had to deliver.

It was during the TakeOver: R Evolution special in December 2014 that he explained the extent of the head injuries that had kept him absent from in-ring action for several months, all while suiting up for life behind the desk instead of smashing opponents through it. He was 31-years old at the time, and having already dedicated a decade to his craft, the unexpected shift could have been debilitating.

Graves instead made the change appear seamless. Settling into his spot as a superb colour analyst for what was by then one of the hottest products in the world, he was becoming the voice of every scintillating TakeOver special. Indispensable to the company's output at large, he was stationed on Monday Night Raw's team as part of a 2016 aesthetic overhaul following the relaunched brand spit.

A trusted McMahon solider with a headset, he's remained one of the few to never be assigned a brand. Clearly too valuable a voice, his services across every show have made him omnipresent in a way he most likely never could have been with his Plan A.


2. Dean Ambrose

Dean Ambrose
WWE

Jon Moxley's inspired New Japan Pro Wrestling debut was perhaps one of the best in wrestling history - not least because he spent much of the match bidding farewell to Dean Ambrose.

WWE couldn't have been nicer about the retirement of a much-loved character - it was almost as if they simply didn't believe he'd follow through with his intent to exit. The maiden NJPW match was one of several confirmation that his departure was for keeps.

He failed to break a table with the intended original spot, but caught himself realising he could just do another spot to smash it up instead. Opponent Juice Robinson kicked out of his Dirty Deeds DDT, forcing Moxley to debut a spiked Death Rider version to claim the United States Title in his first match. He smiled in a sicking smile in between the moves - it was as if the gimmickry of old was being exorcised via his screaming and gurning grins.

Dean Ambrose really had retired. On evidence of Night One in the new old gimmick, he may never come back.


1. AJ Lee

AJ Lee Kaitlyn
WWE.com

Former longest-reigning WWE Divas Champion (the award was taken from her for reasons that are about to become clear) AJ Lee was a more crucial component in driving forward the Women's Revolution than the company will ever give her credit for, not only because of her on-camera incinerations of the sh*t state of the league at the time but also the brave manner in which she tried to smash payscales and archaic structures by herself.

Challenging the patriarchy backstage and Stephanie McMahon on Twitter, Lee went for everybody she could reach, whilst working beyond rock bottom expectations whenever the company gave her matches time.

The definition of this list's title more than just about anybody else in it, Lee had her prime years remaining to perfect one of her passions, but instead decided to walk away in 2015 just after her 28th birthday. Settling into life as an author and mental health advocate thanks to the rich response to her exhaustive and open-door autobiography, AJ has remained almost entirely absent from the wrestling industry, despite relentless rumour-mongering that she will one day return, possibly in line with husband CM Punk's own improbable comeback.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Lita
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.