10 WWE Wrestlers Who Were Nothing Without Their Managers
The Big Boss Men.
Managers have never been a Vince McMahon thing, according to a billion different sources over the last billion years and the actual product for the last 20 or so.
It's a weird one. Bruce Prichard was one of the first to tap into why the Chairman wasn't really into tag team wrestling (before he got back on the payroll), noting that he believed he was paying double for the "same" as what he'd get from a singles match. This felt incredibly short-sighted - tag matches offer a totally different dynamic that only make a card more diverse and theoretically more appealing. A easy battle to win, you'd think, but a harder one to argue if you're trying to sell it to the famously stubborn man signing the cheques.
It's apparent that nobody's picked managers as their hill to die on. Paul Heyman and Zelina Vega have slipped through the cracks (more on them later), but the shows haven't exactly encouraged trainees to give speaking a shot in place of taking all those bumps. Managers cut promos when that word still had literal connotations, stepping in for talents that perhaps weren't skilled enough to do it themselves or needed that extra bit of support.
The good ones helped, and that's perhaps where the pleas to bring them back collapsed. Sentiment like that has carried less weight by the year. Get over or get f*cked, pal.
Not always...
10. Tatanka
The above picture promotes and promises a brand new chapter in the Tatanka story, but the fact that it barely materialised on television explains why nobody really would have bought that book.
The Native American gimmick felt as passé as his credibility after losing a lengthy undefeated streak to Ludvig Borga in 1993, not least after injuries prevented the pair having a particularly satisfying blowoff to the programme before Borga's exit. More losses normalised him entirely, with his heritage the subject of his final babyface programme with IRS before Dibiase revealed their plot at Lex Luger's expense later that summer.
It could and probably should have reheated his career had Tatanka himself gone all in on abandoning the principles of the persona. Instead, he was just the old him with a snarl and the pretence of wealth thanks to the one new set of trunks he invested in at the time. Dibiase worked at it with his serviceable style, but - as was the case with several of his Million Dollar Corporation members - couldn't carry the load with a laugh.
9. Dino Bravo
Dino Bravo's tragic end was well documented in the Dark Side Of The Ring special, but the documentary was kinder to his WWE legacy than actual footage of it ever could be.
Montreal megastar Bravo had that localised appeal, but his limitations working for the biggest wrestling organisation in the world were painfully apparent even with the multiple seconds he was paired with during his run.
Joining The Dream Team with Johnny Valiant after WrestleMania III, he was then given the rather toothless Frenchy Martin and finally Jimmy Hart. In none of those cases was he the star of his own show.
The New Dream Team were as prosperous as every other unit with that prefix, Martin chased cheap anti-USA heat as Bravo grinned in the background and 'The Mouth Of The South' routinely fed Bravo to Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior to try and wear them down for Earthquake during his big runs against them.
In the final case, he was at least purpose-serving in the role, but even a kind rewatch of his best work in the company reveals a spot that probably could have been filled by one of several other super-muscled supervillains.
8. Mantaur
Well, he wasn't nothing, obviously, he was a f*cking half-man half-bull. But what little chance he had of getting over relied entirely on the reception Jim Cornette was able to generate for him during their less-than-impressive 1995 tenure together.
Your writer takes every opportunity to defend the New Generation for the exceptional (and that point, best ever) in-ring standard and some fantastic angles masked by...giant cow masks, but there's a reason why Mantaur rocks up on those patronising video packages they play alongside shots of Issac Yankem DDS, the original Hunter Hearst Helmsley gimmick and the worst version of Doink.
Soz for the repetition but he was a f*cking half-man half-bull - getting the 'Prince Of Polyester' by his side was the least the company could have done for him. Cornette himself thought it was a rib at his expense, but he mustn't have sold it because it didn't last. After first appearing in January, he had disappeared back to the woods by July. As if to atone, Camp Cornette took on Davey Boy Smith, Owen Hart and Vader, gathering up countless title matches and programmes for the following year.
7. The Red Rooster
Wrestling apocrypha has it that either Terry Taylor or Curt Hennig were set to get the Mr Perfect persona before the company settled on the latter. Could ice cool Curt done a better job with that chicken strut?
A doomed gimmick for the current Performance Center coach saw Taylor installed as Bobby Heenan's "little Red Rooster" as a vanity project for 'The Brain' more than for Taylor himself.
Heenan was tacitly abusive even as he unveiled his new project, noting to Brother Love that "he's limited when it comes to wrestling, he's limited when it comes to size, he's limited when it comes to a win/loss record, but I'm gonna make this man the next big star in professional wrestling".
From the off, the gimmick was set up for Rooster's babyface turn, but it was dead without 'The Weasel' at its core. Taylor slapped him about at WrestleMania V to gain a measure of revenge, then started strutting and pecking his way through the midcard as if he were anthropomorphic.
His failures ultimately proved Heenan's original assessment right, which wasn't ideal for a babyface already literally comparing himself to a chicken.
6. The NWA (1998)
If it felt like Jim Cornette was being ribbed by Vince Russo in the early stages of 1998, it's because he probably was.
The NWA was a stable less ancient than it actually felt as the Attitude Era took shape in a rapidly changing organisation but Barry Windham, The Rock & Roll Express and Jeff Jarrett in his most dated persona looked and wrestled as if they were 30 years older than themselves, let alone their peers.
The group floundered quickly, without presence or purpose during a time where virtually everything got over, but what sucked the most about this half-baked bullsh*t was its origin story.
Cornette had incinerated the ills of modern wrestling in some hugely powerful promos at the backend of 1997 that didn't seem to have an end destination beyond getting fans to consider absolutely everything they were watching and make WWE seem less insular in general. They were tweaked to turn this into this. James E, as he always used to, deserved better.
5. King Kong Bundy
It may seem a little harsh on WrestleMania 2 main eventer King Kong Bundy to suggest that he was the right big guy at the right time with the right manager in Bobby Heenan. But the 93,173(ish) that turned out for Andre The Giant the following year almost certainly wouldn't have been as keen for their cage match.
He'd been given Jimmy Hart and a record-setting win at the inaugural 'Show Of Shows' to help enhance his aura up to that point, and he was a very serviceable heel from the factory Vince McMahon ran to keep Hulkamania running, but the one-and-done spot at the top was both the measure of the machine and his work at the time.
This was made all the clearer by his 1994 return. Installed as The Corporation's heavy with Ted Dibiase, Bundy's natural size should have been a free hit for the company during testing times , but he never once felt threatening to the likes of Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels - those once rendered miniscule by his kind a decade earlier.
4. Andrade, Austin Theory & Angel Garza
It was worth waiting a few weeks to see if it was possible that WWE had birthed and broken a new stable in the short window between WrestleMania 36 and Money In The Bank, but they have managed it with the still-unnamed trifecta managed by Zelina Vega.
It's the strangest thing. Vega is an excellent empty arena performer - bombastic, boisterous and believable, she provides much-needed noise over top of that dreaded ceiling fan. Andrade still hits hard, Angel Garza gets his lothario schtick over thanks to a running gag with Charley Caruso, and Austin Theory has literally never had a main roster match in front of fans despite getting the call-up before WrestleMania. The trio should be well placed to cope with the circumstances otherwise working against them, but they can't work as hard as booking doomed to fail them.
The night they formed, they lost. The week after that, they lost. And the week after that. Vega talks an amazing game - maybe the best in the whole company - but forming this group as little more than a goon squad has rendered her words worthless too. She's all they currently have unless all that incredible talent they have magically becomes a recipe for success.
3. The 1996 WWE Tag Team Division
Wrestlers being nothing, rather tragically, was the whole point of all of this.
In 1996, Sunny helped guide The Bodydonnas to the Tag Team Titles during the WrestleMania XII pre-show back when such a placement on the card was seen as sacrilege. It confirmed the reality of a league in need of every kind of TLC, but 'The Golden Haired Fox' was already the key focus by then anyway.
She linked arms with The Godwinns via lovesick Phineas, turning on Skip and Zip for the hog farmers to take the titles to Arkansas. She repeated the act with The Smoking Gunns, romantically involving herself with Billy and sort-of-but-not-really revealing that this was the main plan from the off.
Sunny was a world class performer and - by virtue of her AOL download figures if not television ratings or pay-per-view buyrates - a draw, but the sacrifice of an entire league to this fairly laboured subplot barely shielded the company's profound lack of depth and interest in the division.
2. Curtis Axel
Curtis Axel's recent release might have been separated from the Black Wednesday bloodletting, but it needn't have been.
The company saw it fit to release countless names during a time they couldn't get work elsewhere, with some already victims of a machine that had neglected them while they were still employed. Michael McGillicutty (Michael McGillicutty for f*cks sake) got one notable opportunity that he blew badly, but he was blessed with a lineage in the industry that was bullishly squeezed out of him before WWE even tried to push it.
It was very Vince McMahon to believe he could put toothpaste back in a tube. Curtis Axel was selected as a new moniker in tribute to father and grandfather Curt and Larry 'The Ax' Hennig respectively when he was rebranded alongside Paul Heyman in 2012. The name was in the same orbit as Rocky Maivia, but Joe Hennig wasn't in the same galaxy as his 'Most Electrifying' training buddy.
Heyman talked a good game, talked him up, and used CM Punk's "Paul Heyman Guy" line as if it was all Axel needed. A pathetic effort from Triple H to get him over kiboshed that, and the third generation star bounced from the gimmick into sillier ones when the experiment was acknowledged as the failure it had become.
Noble effort and all that. But far from perfect.
1. Big Boss Man (1998)
Yes, The Big Boss Man's storylines with Al Snow and The Big Show were the height of Attitude Era stupidity and never unwelcome, but it took Vince McMahon - or more specifically Boss Man's protection of him - in 1998 to give that character renewed currency several years on from its original peak.
The pitch was an inspired reinvention. WWE were so obsessed with avoiding their past (not least because half of it was on the other side) that Ray Traylor only retained his name when he made a surprising comeback as corporate security.
The blue shirt was gone along with the ripping "Hard Times" theme, and for one month this angry and bitter piece of sh*t was perfect foil for Stone Cold Steve Austin, especially when armed with his trusty nightstick. He was a crucial component in the complex plan set up by The McMahon Family to screw 'The Rattlesnake' at Survivor Series 1998, and hung around in the tag title picture thanks to his corporate-mandated partnership with Ken Shamrock after the fact. He was, under McMahon's thumb, relevant yet again as his ruthless enforcer.