11 Baffling Moments From WWE Extreme Rules 2018

This ain't no Mensa meeting.

EXTREME RULES TAG TEAM
WWE

If WWE proved anything this past Sunday, it's that any lingering conceit of internal logic permeating through their show has all but evaporated. Every single aspect of the product is completely free of any suggestion of coherent sense, from the broader narratives to the minor match details themselves. It's a warped world to make only the most skeptical of quantum physicists excited: things happen, non-linearly, with no regard to how they came about, or whether they should. And the next second - flash! - it's all erased.

You pull back the curtain even a smidge, and the whole bloody building collapses. That's a load-bearing curtain rail, don't you know. By now, we've been trained to sit idly by, as matches are made seemingly through the dart-at-a-board method, the 'good guys' continue to leave Mensa membership forms totally undisturbed, and the commentary team are either watching a different channel or think they're the second coming of Paul McKenna (and he's not even dead). It's ludicrous, ridiculous, ludiculous.

Pittsburgh's latest voyage into the unexplained was particularly fecund in the 'what-the-f*ckery' stakes. It was logical Gruyère, with a fresh hole to fall into around every corner. These were just some of it's most baffling moments.

11. Is Andrade Almas In Purgatory?

001 RULES 07152018cm 0078  Dfbceccfd20e16e96361d0b2a809f62c
WWE

Repeatedly confronted with Sins, you have to say yes. Why was the former Ls Sombra forced to jump through hoops once more, against an opponent he'd handily defeated just days earlier on SmackDown? "Cien" again dispatched the lucha libre - albeit this time with assistance for Zelina Vega - proving the do-over was completely superfluous.

Look at this way: Croatia won't get another shot at the World Cup next Sunday after failing their first attempt. But hey, we all know Nikki Bella's Axiom ("wins and losses don't matter! *giggle*).


10. Why Was Killian Dain Wearing A Shirt?

046 RULES 07152018cm 0349  F850a86a464a461dc84ad5705d381f14
WWE

As a Brit, Killian Dain will be familiar with the custom of going topless the minute there's the sniff of a heatwave. It's good enough for the scrawniest of loiterers to expose their pasty pigeon-chests the moment the temperature gauge hits 25, but apparently not Dain, a professional wrestler with an intimidating, impressive physique.

What's the logic behind his 'chaotic' crewmates causing (mostly) bare-breasted havoc whilst he stands around all coy, scarcely involved? Don't tell us: we can probably guess. And it's depressing.


9. Are All WWE Babyfaces Dumb As Paint? (Part I)

134 RULES 07152018dg 2012  0a37e40a465d9b9535d6386c2f9f2271
WWE

The moment James Ellsworth's cage was ludicrously raised around one inch above the canvas, it was pretty clear some skulduggery was afoot. It's sort of his MO, so when he dropped a chain through the bars to his belle, it should have been extra obvious to a once-over astute Asuka that he was planning to scupper her night.

Nope. Since losing the streak, The Empress has also lost her wits, and was happy to stand there watching the hapless dangler whilst Carmella sneaked up behind her, after ten hours of dithering about, to claim another 'shock' win. Except it's not a shock: Asuka's thick as Hacksaw's 2x4.


8. Are All WWE Referees Dumb As Paint?

154 RULES 07152018cm 3568  011681c00f1fb124d68a29d0577c0c64
WWE

Surely it's time we had VAR introduced to pro-wrestling. If a referee, standing no less than two feet away can't see a man punch his opponent right in the Lapland pre-bell, and furthermore can't deduce that, hang about, something must be afoot as one of the two competitors rolls around clutching his goolies, then clearly they are not up to scratch.

Commentary suggested the official didn't see anything. Did they presume we viewers are blind as a cave salamander as well?


7. Are All WWE Heels Dumb As Paint?

194 RULES 07152018ej 4082  B671392a934eae9473cd9799d5d3b355
WWE

Kevin Owens: it's not been his month. Poor guy had his vehicle destroyed, publicly cacked his pants, and was then flung off a steel cage in some sort of disturbed birthday tribute to an idiotic albeit iconic spot twenty years ago. Hey, at least he won.

It could have been so much simpler - and less painful - for the Prizefighter-turned-Prize Idiot. Yes, he had Braun Strowman handcuffed, but this is a man who can single-handedly push over an ambulance. He should have known he'd break free within about four seconds. He did. All the while, Owens stood them laughing like a prick instead of just escaping. Oh well, all's well that ends well.


6. Just What ARE The Tag Team Rules?

205 RULES 07152018cm 4684  3db5586630788b8398ea264abdbf5f65
WWE

A few months back, Braun Strowman was categorically told in no uncertain terms that no, he absolutely could not fight The Bar for their Raw tag team titles without a partner. To which he bantered off Lou Thesz, Bruno Sammartino and all those other people in WWE's Legacy Hall of Fame wing people pretend to have watched by picking a kid as his buddy, and winning the straps anyway.

Apparently things are different on SmackDown. Even if you have a very public history of concussions, and even if there is recorded footage of your tag partner's leg being crushed to smithereens by an evil door, you'll still be forced out there to challenge a set of tag champs known for hitting people with hammers. Paige, man, what're you doing?


5. Are All WWE Faces Dumb As Paint? (Part II)

283 RULES 07152018cm 6901  20098354253559096f7d062c1a06fdf3
WWE

This presumes Nia Jax actually is a face, given her alignment is likely to oscillate as rapidly as a politician's preferred football team. What do you do when your opponent, a known scrappy thug, unearths a series of potentially match-ending weapons from beneath the apron?

Hoist her by own proverbial?

Of course not! You craply fling them into the ring into the waiting hands of her second, so you can later be beaten by all of them. Meanwhile, your own pal (in this case, a useless Natalya), looks on from afar.


4. Are All WWE Faces Dumb As Paint? (Part III)

383 RULES 07152018cm 10621  D0bd5ff02cf8f83e6ea7082689fa7dda
WWE

Seth Rollins decidedly is a face, despite destroying Elias' priceless guitar like a c*nt last month. Which means very basic cognitive operations - such as, for example, counting to three - are completely and hopelessly beyond him.

After hitting the not-curb Stomp in the closing moments, Rollins had a full twenty seconds to make the decisive pin. Instead, despite contesting literally thousands of matches and having better ring awareness than a jeweler, The Architect completely lost track of David Diggler within a 400 foot-square square, just long enough to fail to win. Funny, that.


3. Does Jonathan Coachman Actually Know Anything?

385 RULES 07152018ej 10337  1e7730ddbdfbe5edde8dda881fce4308
WWE

In the aftermath of Seth's failure to find his away around an empty canvas, Jonathan Coachman bleated stupidly, "All he needed was five more seconds!"

Five?! Keep in mind, this man worked for ESPN, covering actual sports, yet doesn't know the most basic of all wrestling laws that it's three seconds for a pin. He was called the 1-2-3 Kid, not the 1-2-3-4-5 Kid. Did he think Big E. Langston was in there or something? At this point, you really have to question what the point of it is. Not Coachman. Of it all.


2. Why Doesn't Anybody Know What's Going On?

386 RULES 07152018cm 10744  867dc1a7207947113fe243e8a4a63b99
WWE

Look, WrestleMania XII was 22 years ago. The Bret Hart Rule - that an Iron Man draw must lead to overtime - is very well established. The Hitman threw a little hissy fit and everything. It was not edifying.

David Diggler didn't seem aware of the fact this Sunday, attempting to high-tail it out once the clock struck zero with the scores all square. Why doesn't he know though? This is his profession. At the very least, had Gorilla Monsoon not ruined it for champs way back in Anaheim, he should have expected the title to be held in abeyance pending a rematch.

Even Kurt Angle - ostensibly, a wrestling administrator - seemed clueless, barging out redder than a boiled Roy Keane to insist the pair continue, as though that wasn't already the company's established precedent. Everybody needs retraining.


1. Are All WWE Faces Dumb As Paint? (Part IV)

388 RULES 07152018dg 6132  6a54ca2006878507d052273770ac1622
WWE

In Seth Rollins' case, we already know the answer to this from three slides back, but his lack of forethought was again in evidence once the Iron Man match restarted. Sure, he'd been through a grueling thirty minute contest, but Seth must have remembered that one of his falls came via a DQ after Drew McIntyre assaulted him.

Why then, did the former-Shield builder feel it necessary to go after Diggler's Scottish Diesel when the whistle blew for extra time? Why not just take another DQ fall, and the title? I think we all know why.


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.