11 Match Star Ratings From AEW All In

Was The Biggest Show In Wrestling History also the best?

Jon Moxley All In
AEW

AR Fox wearing a vest stained with Nick Wayne's blood before being forgiven by his opponent and dumped out of the only well-booked match outside of the superbly promoted main event.

A third match between the two best tag teams of the 21st century built questionably at best. FTR Vs. Young Bucks I saw the latter behave like sulky teenagers, the second was welcome if very random and even more sudden, and, ahead of the third, both teams just said the name of the other out loud before a really good eleventh hour sit-down interview.

A Road To All Out trios match depriving UK fans - 81,000 of them - the dream epic Kenny Omega singles match in favour of a head-canon Bullet Club lore "special".

CM Punk working Samoa Joe despite caring about him less than, what, at least 10 other AEW wrestlers?

A Stadium Stampde match that was basically booked via spreadsheet with zero believable grudge outside of the core Blackpool Combat Club Vs. Eddie Kingston dynamic. A "get stars on the card" match more than a violent grudge affair.

The build to AEW All In London wasn't just slapdash, apathetic: it was at times positively Russo-pilled.

The show itself?

Show absolutely ruled...

11. Zero Hour: Aussie Open Vs. Better Than You Bay-Bay - ROH World Tag Team Title Match

If you've never heard the expression "gentleman's three", it essentially refers to a good match with zero flaws that for whatever reason - a lack of importance, energy, emotion, something - means it is rated politely without anybody doing cartwheels over it.

This was the best possible version of a gentleman's three.

It was not ambitious, the work was solid, and there wasn't much drama to it. All of this was understandable - MJF and Adam Cole had the more important task of headlining the biggest show ever with the only hot storyline in the promotion - and immaterial.

In terms of what the babyfaces and heels should do and when, this was the most basic match you'll see all year - but also amongst the most effective. It was over to a preposterous, joyful extent.

The epitome of "did exactly what it needed to do": the match preserved the mystery that has captivated fans through an uneasy summer.

Star Rating: ★★★


10. Zero Hour: Jack Perry Vs. HOOK - FTW Title Match

In a match that will be forever overshadowed, HOOK defeated Jack Perry for the FTW title. It was uneven. Great when it rocked, but uneven.

They brawled up the ramp and, paying off the build, worked some cool spots with the car in which Perry made his entrance. Perry drove HOOK through the windshield and bragged about it, drawing the ire of CM Punk backstage. Or, maybe a pissy shoulder barge did. Nobody knows, and even fewer care about this match in retrospect. While very good, as a referendum on Perry's heel character, it was...not a success.

Teasing the Van Terminator of all moves and instead telling the crowd to f*ck off was a tremendous update on that modern heel bit - there are few moves a crowd would want to see more, and he'd done Rolling Thunder so it was certain he'd do it - but elsewhere, the crowd was never quieter than when Perry worked a long and uninteresting heat sequence. They weren't exhausted, either. It was the second match. They just didn't care.

They did get up for HOOK and his annihilation of Perry. Every suplex drew a pop. Ultimately, though, Perry is lost. He had to turn heel but the turn didn't take.

He isn't perceived as a prospective headliner.

Star Rating: ★★★½


9. CM Punk Vs. Samoa Joe

CM Punk Vs. Samoa Joe was a superb match, so good and so hot that it was surreal. Joe was over to an inconceivable level.

80,000 people adored him and in turn 80,000 people more or less wanted him to kill CM Punk. Punk had his supporters, and while it can get draining on TV, this performative culture war is amazing to participate in live. The level of emotion projected at this match was why you watch wrestling. It was phenomenal. The action was great, too: hard-hitting, witty, cathartic with beautiful stooging, pissy body language, maulings: this was the stuff.

Punk thought he had outsmarted Joe with a feint, anticipating the nope spot, but Joe instead waited to do it when Punk ate the dirt on the floor. Joe visually called him a w*nker. Certain AEW fans haven't stopped doing that for a full calendar year. The eruption in that stadium, which was so gorgeous and massive and deafening, was life-affirming to a lot of fans. Punk is a genius at this.

Throughout, he endured loads of punishment to give that crowd what they wanted and to tell the most logical story. He finished Joe off with the Pepsi Plunge. This was inspired: it was a special move, saved for a special occasion, and it protected Joe heavily in defeat.

A nice little match on paper was something bordering on a religious experience on the night.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


8. Kenny Omega, Kota Ibushi & Hangman Page Vs. Jay White, Konosuke Takeshita & Juice Robinson

A match that incited a lot of fierce discourse on Twitter within the fandom, on the night, it was excellent (though it could have been three minutes shorter). It was never not going to be.

That reaction to Kenny Omega, and the sustained 20 minute singalong, indicated that he must work a singles dream match next year. He was superb in what was a mostly breathless 20 minutes, a typically stunning genre effort from two members of the core Elite faction. Kota Ibushi did not look good at Blood & Guts, but he looked sharper and more switched-on here. His interactions with legendary NJPW opponent Jay White were rewarding and very entertaining - Ibushi does a better "You're trying to hit me? Me?" face than most - and in general, Ibushi was used well and sparingly. Everybody performed their own role brilliantly, and the match achieved its objective by showing the fans just enough of Omega and Konosuke Takeshita to convince them that their singles match will be incredible.

As far as an underwhelming Road To All Out match goes, this was superb, and much of the credit belongs to Jay White: the man was outstanding at strategically finding himself in position to counter the Elite's momentum. His timing and ingenuity was next-level. He looked like the most crafty, intelligent wrestler in the world in there at times. The man is excellent at playing that role, and the dizzying chaos of the trios format allowed him to hide in plain sight frequently before dramatically reversing the momentum.

A waste of talent, yes, but the talent was exceptional on the night.

Star Rating: ★★★★¼


7. FTR Vs. The Young Bucks - World Tag Team Title Match

One elaborate sequence didn't entirely land early.

Dax Harwood and Matt Jackson worked a long, long suplex exchange/counter spot. The idea was to get the crowd on their feet and make them go increasingly banana the longer it went. Wembley was meant to be in disbelief at the cardio and the spirit, and then give them the stranding ovation, but when it didn't materialise, the sequence felt a bit slowy and flat. The next couple of minutes were eerily quiet, the sort of flattened atmosphere that threatened an unfathomable disappointment. And then the last eight minutes happened. The volume of earned, loud, convincing false finishes here was unreal even by the standards of a Young Bucks match. They subverted the rule of three in incredible fashion.

After nearly defeating FTR twice, Cash looked on with a look of resignation on his face moments before eating a BTE Trigger. The rhythm of the match, pacing of the sequence and the fact that Cash, given his legal situation, could well have done the job, all converged to create an all-timer of a near-fall. The pulsating action was electric by the finishing stretch. The callbacks to and updates on the first match - Cash spearing Nick from Wembley Stadium to King's Cross Station, Cash actually hitting the 450 - were mind-blowing. That Full Gear 2020 match was bittersweet, a dream match in a nightmarish time. This, in beautiful contrast, was the best possible occasion on which to run it back. Elevated immensely by a special second half, this was a masterful display of crowd psychology.

Everybody rejoiced, and with the biggest wrestling crowd ever, the old tweet was almost literally true.

Star Rating: ★★★★¾


6. Stadium Stampede Match

Stadium Stampede was a blast live, even if it was impossible to follow. You miss the odd spot in Anarchy In The Arena live, but that's more feature than bug. The chaos, the idea that you sacrifice a weapon shot to watch a high spot, creates the illusion that everybody in the match wants to kill each other so much that they don't care who's watching. It's a performance and a fight at the same time. In Wembley, it was easy to lose track of story beats.

Very few people realised that Penta had been brutalised and ostensibly removed from the match. When he made his triumphant return as Penta Oscuro, many if not all people thought his music had been played accidentally. That didn't matter. The action was so gross and committed and nasty and thrilling that everybody just went along with it. A skewer spot in Wembley man, Jesus Christ. That is a spot people should remember, including your writer, when AEW misses on TV at times. Perspective should never be lost. It's insane and awesome that such a thing could happen on that stage.

This was peak AEW at its peak.

In every plunder match, including this one, weapons suddenly materialise. It's a bit contrived, if you're pedantic. Here, when Sue drove into town, Trent used the baking sheet on which Sue had made cookies for the roster to beat up the Blackpool Combat Club. It was silly, but warm - an only-in-AEW spot that was actually really, deceptively clever. The baking tray had a reason to be there!

On the subject of Trent, he was incredible. He took a sickening amount of punishment in various, exhilarating sequences of ultra-violence. In the end, after it almost backfired, Orange Cassiy won the match by learning the arts of the Tai Pei death match. The glass-assisted Orange Punch was wonderful.

The uncharacteristic badass spot brought the house down in a match overflowing with the thought and creative expression that separates this company as the best of the best on its day.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


5. Hikaru Shida Vs. Dr. Britt Baker Vs. Toni Storm Vs. Saraya - Women's World Title Match

Lean, exciting, dramatic and well-worked, the women's four-way match was a shockingly good over-delivery.

The basic story gist is thus: the Outcasts imploded when Toni Storm accidentally popped Saraya's mother in the face, Ruby Soho said to hell with it all, Britt Baker with an inspired spot almost stole it when she stomped Storm's head when trapped in a submission, and Saraya emerged with the win and the title. It was short and punchy. The use of Saraya's family was controversial, since they don't have the nicest reputation at all within British wrestling, but, furthering the theme, it was inspired. It was a very convincing way to split the Outcasts and Knight did a tremendous job of trying to climb over the barricade. She looked feral!

When Saraya entered the ring, a not inconsiderable amount of people jeered her. When she won, and the emotion of a hard life redeemed set it in, the fans sensed everything that she had suffered to reach that point. It was moving. A pretty terrific bit of business all round, even if the match wasn't blow-away great or anything. A lesson should be learned from this and Tony Khan should apply it to every PPV.

Every emotional beat was nailed and every performer was allowed to shine within a brisk runtime that didn't go long for the optics or the sake of it.

Star Rating: ★★★½


4. Darby Allin & Sting Vs. Swerve Strickland & Christian Cage

Sometimes, you know a match is going to rule before the opening bell, and when Sting and Darby Allin entered to Seek & Destroy by Metallica, the tone was set. A bit slower than the usual crazed Sting party match, this was nonetheless fabulous.

Each character has such presence about them, and all boast a very high wrestling IQ. Between the unhinged set pieces, the spaces between moves and the genre-specific takes on near-falls soared. Sting keeping the lid from closing with the use of his bat was inspired, and Swerve's slow-dawn realisation that he hadn't won was great ass-showing heel work. At times, it did feel a bit stilted between the set pieces, but mostly, this was yet another different match in the signature AEW buffet.

Every great moment and twist was pure wrestling theatre worked by four outstanding performers with a superb grasp of how to make the big moments count. Fun, creative and violent, watching Sting be Sting live was surreal magic.

"It's showtime!" is his catchphrase, but it's never been more apt than in AEW.

Star Rating: ★★★★


3. Chris Jericho Vs. Will Ospreay

Chris Jericho said that every person who doubted him ahead of All In was a dipsh*t.

Everybody person who doubted him ahead of All In was a dipsh*t because his match with Will Ospreay was awesome, the stadium was never louder than it was when he sang live his own iconic self-penned entrance theme, and he did the job because it was the right result and he's selfless enough to deliver it. Crucially, they did not muck about.

They didn't step on the toes of the main event by crafting a slow-burn 30 minute epic that transparently chased a five star rating. They beat the piss out of each other in a tight, blistering back-and-forth in which they cared more about winning than forcing a "classic". In doing do, the match was fantastic. Jericho got a little too ambitious down the stretch. Some sequences fell a bit flat when his timing went awry, but he otherwise did a job that was nothing short of outrageous by keeping up with Ospreay, who is so good it's stupid. Impossible.

In one unfathomably awesome spot, Jericho reversed a Stormbreaker with a hurricanrana. He had no right to play his role in it, and Ospreay's timing and agility was not of this realm. While wavelength issues did threaten to undermine the match, the finish itself was incredible. In a shocker, Jericho kicked out of the Stormbreaker, and in a priceless moment, flipped Ospreay off before Ospreay effectively smashed his face in with the Hidden Blade. A second Stormbreaker won it, and if there's a time to do the big finisher kick-outs, it is at the biggest show in wrestling history.

Extra quarter star for Ospreay's neck-first German suplex bump on the apron. It actually made sense in the context of the story, in that Jericho was telling Ospreay that, if he wasn't going to listen to his plea to tone it down, he'd exact ironic revenge.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


2. The House Of Black Vs. The Acclaimed - World Trios Title Match

he Acclaimed won the Trios titles in a match that was more nice than it was great.

Time and time again, the House of Black isolated members of the Acclaimed. This is a signature sequence of theirs - it portrays them as expert strategists who can manipulate matches to their liking - but they possibly leaned on it too much here to work around the fact that Daddy Ass can't exactly work the complex all-action in-house genre style. As a result, the match was a bit stilted at times, but it didn't matter.

When the comebacks happened, the live crowd ate everything up. Eventually.

In truth, these two teams haven't worked a classic match in this series, and they should have inserted a retirement stipulation to maximise the emotional heft that the match did have going for it. That's what the story was about!

Again, it didn't matter.

The pop for the win was enormous, and Tony Khan has solved the selection headache he endured last year even FTR and the Acclaimed got red-hot in parallel.

Star Rating: ★★★


1. MJF Vs. Adam Cole - World Title Match

MJF Vs. Adam Cole was a masterpiece of a brand new genre of main event that nobody else should mimic. It is wholly unique to their incredible dynamic.

Yes, it played with WWE-style melodrama, but there's a good and bad version of everything in wrestling and WWE melodrama takes itself too seriously at the main event level. Also, nothing is automatically bad, except Billy Corgan's NWA. In a tremendous, uniquely creative start, MJF and Cole engaged in friendly banter through the medium of pro wrestling. The crowd ate up both men taking the piss out of each other with their various taunts, cheating and crowd appeals. Then, the tone mutated. Cole realised that MJF is the World champion for a reason, and set about trying to take him out with a procession of sick plunder spots that were actually earned in the context of the story. MJF couldn't bring himself to do it, and if there's ever a reason to do the polarising inner conflict trend, it's when a character has their first real crack at friendship and outright redemption.

The second of two ref bumps was so unbelievably great. Convoluted but funnier for it, Bryce Remsburg ate Cole's Panama Sunrise. Cole's incredulous expression was a riot. People in the stands were pissing themselves laughing at this, and the laughter intensified when Cole and MJF threw a chair at each other in order to win the race to do the Eddie Guerrero cheating spot. In a genius twist, the double clothesline took on a different meaning as they each pinned one another off a double down. They've built this thing for ages. They put over their tag team finish in their singles match for Christ's sake!

The match restarted - in "f*cking Wembley!", to a massive pop - and in the end, Roderick Strong's attempted interference counted for nothing. Cole refused to go through with the full turn, MJF caught him off guard, and then rolled him up. Or was this a very, very advanced chess move from MJF? Who knows.

The mystery, thrillingly, continues.

The dirt-worst cliché of a great show, in any medium, is that it will make you laugh and make you cry. MJF and Cole somehow managed this, in the context of pro wrestling, in a match that was also Canadian Destroyer-pilled and exhilarating as a result.

This is hack stuff, sorry, but for possibly the first time ever, this match actually had everything. With a record attendance to manipulate, the genius of MJF Vs. Adam Cole is that they made the fans make virtually every noise.

(Not sure why Cole would want a count-out win, though).

Star Rating: ★★★★¾


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!