11 Match Star Ratings From AEW Double Or Nothing 2023

Literally EXPLOSIVE Match of the Year contender elevates uneven AEW PPV...

Kenny Omega Bryan Danielson
AEW

The road to Double Or Nothing wasn't quite NXT TakeOver of 2019 tier - unremarkable and generic TV storytelling as the obligatory phase before the signature rave-reviewed big show - but the Four Pillars storyline simply didn't connect as a worthy, main event-level concern.

A story about four young men finding their identity and value system through their journey in a new major outfit, certain characters in it played the role almost too well. Is Sammy Guevara a heel or a babyface? Is Jack Perry doing this immature trash talk stuff on purpose? Why is Darby Allin celebrating a bye?

The three challengers didn't do enough to draw interest, and in opting for a worked shoot approach - Perry, remember, is part of a "Cali kliq" - Tony Khan misjudged the demand for this sort of thing in AEW. It can only suffer in comparison to the very real rivalries playing out offscreen. This approach threatened to undermine the Elite Vs. Blackpool Combat Club feud, at least until the BCC's motives started to reflect Bryan Danielson's mission statement promo (as opposed to CM Punk's opinion of the Young Bucks).

Elsewhere, it was strange to see the epilogue of Matt Hardy Vs. Ethan Page given valuable PPV time, when their storyline was never really over. AEW did however present us the sight of Satnam Singh in overalls, which puts DoN 2023 in the top five AEW PPV builds.

Was DoN as good as the phenomenal all-timer that was Revolution?

10. BUY-IN: Ethan Page & The Gunns Vs. The Hardy Party

Hardy Party
AEW

A quick note on the pre-show match before the review proper, since there wasn't a great deal to it. The fans loved it.

They love the Hardy Boyz. They literally can't get enough, since the love affair has endured for a quarter of a century. They didn't mind that the match went 15 minutes, but if you aren't pissed up on Delete nostalgia, this was flabby and dragged towards the finish. The Gunns are slowly mastering the wild, flailing bump to the outside of the ring. HOOK and Ethan Page have clearly developed chemistry on the House Rules circuit. Matt Hardy says "Delete!", and fans say it back. It's fine if you like it, not worth 15 if you don't, and the match almost fell apart completely when Jeff Hardy seemed to hurt his leg, seconds after which he lost his footing when attempting Whisper In The Wind.

He spent what felt like several minutes lying down after that. He fought through the pain to play his role in the finish, which nudges his team closer to World Tag Team title contention.

That doesn't seem like a capital idea, since a loud house show quality match is their ceiling in 2023 - and the they limped badly to get there.

Star Rating: ★★½


9. 21-Man Blackjack Battle Royale For The International Title

Blackjack Battle Royale
AEW

Being there live, this might be a biased take, but that was the best traditional battle royal in history.

The finishing sequence between Orange Cassidy and Swerve Strickland, a suspenseful thriller of a chess match, was up there with the two best Royal Rumble finishes (2007 and 2023). Big Bill was incredible. Remember the 2015 Royal Rumble, in which Kane and the Big Show unceremoniously dumped your favourites as part of a terrible meta attempt at heat? Imagine the awesome version.

That was Bill's role here. His best night in AEW by some distance, he loved gobbling your tears, like he'd spent the last few days with glued lips in the remote Nevada desert, as much as he loved rampaging around the ring and kicking f*ck out of and throwing people out. His black hole slam variation drew an enormous pop in the building. I've personally rarely seen a performer so motivated to get over in a PPV slot.

This wasn't even the only great hoss sequence in the match: Brian Cage acting not so much as a base but actual velcro for the luchador contingent was a great sub-plot in a match loaded with them.

Kinetic in action, layered in storytelling, as tense as anything on the night, AEW advanced or initiated scores of stories and generated just as many pops. Jay White cutting off Komander's second rope walk before being eliminated himself deeper in the match was the perfect example of its rhythm: a relentlessly dramatic pendulum of action.

(Komander's rope walk was spectacular live, incidentally. It feels like he floats somewhere between the top rope and the rafters before crashing down to earth.)

Star Rating: ★★★★½


8. Adam Cole Vs. Chris Jericho - Unsanctioned Match

Adam Cole Chris Jericho
AEW

This was a massive let-down, sadly.

Tonally, it was uneven; AEW in 2023 in microcosm. Guest Enforcer Sabu put a JAS lackey through a table (!) in order to prevent the stable interfering throughout (and filling a plot hole in the process). The problem is that, between this wacky spot and Jericho's very essence, it was difficult to take seriously as a vicious grudge match no matter how the wider story had unfolded on TV. The fans vocally rejected the finish, possibly because they don't see Cole as a badass despite loving him for what he is. A chain-wrapped fist knocking a man unconscious?

That would be bold even for Jon Moxley.

It felt like events were conspiring against both throughout. A miscommunication led to an awkward scramble to get out of the wrong position ahead of a lionsault. It took an eternity for Cole to reach for and set off a fire extinguisher when breaking up a Liontamer, which undermined the visual gag. And again: was crafting a visual gag that great an idea ahead of that super-serious finish?

This was a failure despite some lovely sequences, Britt Baker's assault on Chris Jericho and Cole's dramatic tumble through Chekhov's table in particular.

Star Rating: ★★¾


7. FTR Vs. Jeff Jarrett & Jay Lethal - World Tag Team Title Match

Karen Jarrett
AEW

FTR Vs. Jeff Jarrett and Jay Lethal while fantastic wasn't the best match I've seen live, but it was very likely the most fun.

Watching Planet Jarrett frantically thumb through the carny bullsh*t playbook in real time was such an unbelievable blast. I covered Double Or Nothing live from Las Vegas. After some exquisite southern tag sequences, cardiovascular feats the likes of which Jeff Jarrett should be commended for pulling off, I turned to Michael Hamflett and said "This is great: and we haven't even got to the bullsh*t yet!"

And then the glorious bullsh*t happened, and it was so unbelievably effective. A respectful crowd lost their collective minds when Jeff inadvertently hit guest ref Mark Briscoe with the guitar, which eventually summoned Aubrey Edwards. Sonjay Dutt, with the most smug and obnoxious facial expression, blocked her off. Then, when she budged past him, Karen Jarrett smashed her with the balsa wood. This was incredible. A true transgression. With this, and her skin-crawling facials throughout, Las Vegas was not ready for Karen Jarrett. This wild story beat informed Jeff's unreal Stroke near-fall. Aubrey was the one who had prevented him from capturing gold twice before. Her being removed from the fray made it seem like Jeff had finally cleared the last hurdle.

Jeff ate sh*t in the end and took a slap from Mark, but before the happy ending, this was an excellent version of two matches: an improbably straightforward southern tag affair and subsequently the most note-perfect excessive TNA special.

Star Rating: ★★★★¼


6. Wardlow Vs. Christian Cage - TNT Title Ladder Match

Wardlow Swanton Bomb
AEW

Wardlow Vs. Christian Cage was a very good if strange, subdued match.

It wasn't a hollow, cheap spot-fest. Cage, like the rat that he is, scurried away from the action, only popping his head up, literally, when thought safe from Wardlow's relentless ass-kicking power move blitz. Fans reacted only to the spots, though, which flattened the atmosphere at various points. This wasn't helped by a malfunctioning prop late on, when Wardlow crushed the rungs of a ladder when jumping onto it to confront Cage. Wardlow's might warped the ladder. This is the sort of cool moment that should if anything put over the spontaneous dangers of the genre, but the modern audience expects cleaner, meticulous set-pieces.

The match relied on the presence of seconds Arn Anderson and Luchasaurus, an exhausting theme across the night, and while AEW should do something to stamp out the excess of it all, it did work for the big stunt set-piece here: Wardlow performed a senton off a ladder from an absurd height. I was terrified watching head-on, but the execution was flawless. Just as well, too: fans had started to get into Christian's weasel act so much that his name was chanted heavily minutes beforehand.

Cage deserves immense credit for some of the bumps he took and the way in which he crafted the set-pieces to flow so organically into the next.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


5. Jamie Hayter Vs. Toni Storm - AEW Women's Title Match

Toni Storm Jamie Hayter DoN
AEW

In the sort of bait and switch that absolutely wouldn't have happened had the men's World champion suffered an injury ahead of a PPV - that title is considered too important to switch in a glorified angle on a weekend night - Toni Storm defeated a legitimately injured Jamie Hayter in a brief match not unlike one of the better WWE Money In The Bank cash-ins: short and tense, with the champion threatening to stave off the inevitable with a couple of acute kick-outs. Storm however won after interference from the Outcasts in a carny development.

The match played out as advertised only in the strictest sense.

Star Rating: ★★½


4. The House Of Black Vs. The Acclaimed - World Trios Title Match

Acclaimed House Of Black
AEW

In what was another disappointment, the House of Black went over the Acclaimed in an Open House match. I expected this to be a sleeper hit; live in the MGM Grand on Wednesday, they were the two most over acts in the building.

Was the crowd on Sunday split in their affections?

Was the spooky lighting too distracting?

Or was the match just not particularly good?

The crowd did have fun mocking Buddy Matthews after Max Caster in his rap said that Dominik had cucked him, but they weren't properly engaged in a match that didn't have a great deal to it. The House's heat spot was laboured, the match wasn't anywhere near as exhilarating as AEW fans have come to expect from the Trios division (and its quality ceiling on pay-per-view), and the entire thing led to a deadpan note of black comedy.

The match was built and built and built towards Daddy Ass getting the hot tag, and his salvo lasted less than a minute before Malakai Black kicked him in the face to win. If it was meant to scan as a cruel and unexpected shock, it didn't really work. The House didn't get any real heat as a result.

It wasn't outright bad - Brody King's monster spots were as popular and gruesomely entertaining as ever - but it added to the malaise that was the bloated middle portion of the card.

Star Rating: ★★¾


3. Jade Cargill Vs. Taya Valkyrie - TBS Title Match

Jade Cargill Taya Valkyrie
AEW

Jade Cargill Vs. Taya Valkyrie was over in the building: helped by the superstar entrances and the sort of action you wouldn't associate with the performers, this was an over-delivery.

Taya did Taiji Ishimori's sliding German suplex! While they did get lost very noticeably deep into the match, and at one point collided very awkwardly when it was impossible to determine what they were even trying to do, they each deserve credit for engineering the Road to Valhalla near-fall. Banning it in the storyline through some fake legal nonsense was nonsensical, and it was infuriating that Tony Khan suddenly just said it was fine to do, but it worked.

That was the most convinced that fans had become of Jade losing her title before she actually lost it to Kris Statlander immediately afterwards in an open challenge (Star Rating: ★★).

A babyface capitalising on a tired, weakened heel is a dangerously WWE thing to do, but it was difficult not to feel happy for Statlander, whose recovery sounded hellish and who was on course to becoming the top star of the division early last year.

Star Rating: ★★★


2. MJF Vs. Darby Allin Vs. Jack Perry Vs. Sammy Guevara - AEW World Title Match

Four Pillars
AEW

The Four Pillars match was outstanding. If it felt more like a passion project on the part of the creators than something the consumer was crying out desperately to see, it was put together with such thought and detail that those fans went apesh*t across its 27 minute duration.

They demanded the fans accept it as a worthy main event, and it paid off: this was an incredible achievement of a match.

Think of the worst "turn-taking" WWE triple threats. This was the opposite; how every four-way sequence flowed beat by beat without being too contrived, mostly, was astonishing. Now imagine every move, counter, reversal in this match listed down on a page. Imagine going through where you needed to stand at any given time. The memory recall required for this incredibly complex, twist-heavy match was unbelievable. Now, you could obviously make the argument that this worked against a match that felt stilted as a result, and while that is fair, wrestling, fundamentally, is about working to the audience - and this audience loved the lung-bursting, twist-loaded aerial warfare because and not in spite of the fact that it felt like there were about 10 insane destroyer variations in it.

The three-way pinfall exchanges towards the climax were scorching, incredibly creative. They didn't need to drop each other on their heads to get a pop, but when they did, Jack Perry looked like he'd broken his neck. The offence was demented at times.

While this accomplished a lot story-wise - Perry teased out a heel turn through being punished when refusing to cheat, Sammy Guevara drew closer to actually growing up - the match seemed to serve as an acknowledgement that it lacked a deep emotional core.

Instead, the Pillars opted for total brain-melting exhilaration, and delivered a genre masterpiece in the process despite the crowd psychology being off at times. They were always going to resent the three babyfaces for ganging up on MJF.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


1. The Elite Vs. Blackpool Combat Club - Anarchy In The Arena

Anarchy In The Arena 2
AEW

I had enormous expectations for Anarchy In The Arena, and gauging by the deranged sounds I made in the T-Mobile, it exceeded them.

This was a masterpiece: in Anarchy In The Arena, Tony Khan has created a gimmick match that stands up to the very, very best. Somehow engineering an organic sense of chaos, the genre is perfect for the modern scene. The form enables dives, brawling, emotional set-pieces when the action converges in the ring. It folds in Attitude Era-style brawls backstage. It's as if you're playing every game mode at the same time: the greatest fan service vehicle in the age of the nonexistent attention span.

Claudio Castagnoli was a monster here. Everything you thought he could be in WWE, Matt Jackson sold for that vision. Kenny Omega and Jon Moxley furthered their rivalry in the top star show-down thread, which bettered Mox and Jericho's effort from last year. If you watched a Nick Jackson dive, you missed Omega smashing Mox with a barricade.

This is a feature and not a bug of the genre: the impossible to track action creates the idea that the hatred between the teams is such that they don't even care if you see them fight. When you do see it, though, it is beyond exhilarating. It at once doesn't feel like a "performance" and is the most entertaining spectacle in wrestling, all at the same time. This just ruled so hard.

Rick Knox being the first to blade was an hilarious sight gag. Matt Jackson took the swing on a concrete floor, and then returned to the ring with a secret explosive attached to his f*cking shoe, which he aimed at Jon Moxley's face. What a spot. A secret explosion spot! How good do you have to be to come up with that?

Excruciating bumps, like when Matt lost his sneaker and was slammed sole-first into tacks.

Incredible near-fall exchanges, in which some of the best wrestlers of all time, having protected their finishes to unprecedented degrees, generated heart-stopping reactions for what felt like every 5 seconds during a particularly furious sequence towards the finish.

Kenny Omega and Hangman Page teaming together again in a life-affirming moment before the opposite emotional side of that extreme was achieved through the Konosuke Takeshita heel turn.

This match lacked absolutely f*cking nothing: emotion, violence, comedy, exhilaration, shock, awe.

It was wonderful. A maelstrom of genius.

Star Rating: ★★★★★


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!