11 Ups & 4 Downs From ALL IN 2018

A landmark event in independent wrestling history.

All In
Twitter

Though ALL IN didn't go off without a hitch, it was the pro-wrestling party of the year, and a roaring success that matched all realistic expectations.

It was an excellent representation of what the global scene has to offer in 2018. Multiple Being the Elite angles were paid off throughout the night, from Joey Ryan's death, to Flip Gordon's long-running exclusion angle. Cody vs. Nick Aldis came packed emotion and catharsis. In Kenny Omega vs. Pentagon, the event delivered a first-time singles clash to satiate the Match Of The Year crowd. Women's wrestling was well represented by four of the brightest talents on the planet, Hangman Page vs. Joey Janela brought the insanity, and though curtailed, the six-man main event was a beautiful, blood-pumping spotfest.

Cody and The Young Bucks pulled it off. After selling the 10,000-capacity Sears Center out in 30 minutes, they were under immense pressure to deliver, but they did. The trio deserve all the credit in the word for betting against Dave Meltzer last May, because it just paid off in spectacular fashion.

There'll almost certainly be an ALL IN 2 (after tonight, how could there not be?), but for now, let's bask in this game-changing event's glory...


Downs...

4. A Curious Opener

ALL IN opened with an unadvertised MJF vs. Matt Cross match, which, itself, was fine. The duo worked hard for the spot they were given, as Cross countered his opponent's rampant heeling with the smooth-as-silk high-flying he has built his reputation on, eventually taking the 1-2-3 with a Cutter and a Shooting Star Press. Still, going with this as the appetiser for an evening of wild action was a curious choice.

They had a building full of fired-up, rabid wrestling fans, dying for a hot opener, yet kicked things off with the coldest match on the show. None of that makes sense, and what's most confusing is that the rest of the night was extremely well-paced.

This was the kind of bout that'd be best placed between two bigger contests later in thenight. Give the crowd 6-8 minutes to cool themselves down before getting right back into the show's closing stretch, with Cross and MJF effectively buffering the billboard matches. Instead, ALL IN jammed a **½ bout into a spot tailor-made for a barnburner.


3. Muting The Crowd

All In Stage
Twitter, @pwponderings

If Chicago sounded a little off tonight, it wasn't down to a lack of crowd investment.

Search the ALL IN Twitter hashtag and you'll find a number of beaming reports on the night's tremendous atmosphere. Unfortunately, this wasn't reflected on the live broadcast, on which the crowd noise was under-emphasised in the audio mix.

This is a shame. If the building was as loud as those in attendance claim, you ideally want that to be reflected on the feed, as crowd heat enhances everything. There's no better example of this than CM Punk's WWE Championship triumph at Money In The Bank - an excellent piece of sports entertainment scripting taken to the next level by Chicago's molten atmosphere. Sadly, this just didn't come through on FITE.tv, which gives the producers a big point for improvement if and when ALL IN 2 happens.

It wasn't terrible, and this is a borderline nitpick, but it was noticeable. On a show that pretty much lived up to all expectations across the board, we could have done without this minor technical issue.


2. A Botched Finish

Tessa Blanchard ALL IN
ALL IN

ALL IN's most unfortunate moment came at the conclusion of the women's four-way, when what looked like a timing issue caught the victorious Tessa Blanchard by surprise, spawning a brief moment of confusion while the audience tried to figure out whether or not they'd just witnessed a botch.

The Impact Wrestling star had nailed her Hammerlock DDT finisher for the pin. Britt Baker charged over as if she were trying to break it up, and Blanchard reacted as if things were about to continue... but the bell rang.

It took the gloss off a bout that the fans were 100% into throughout, creating an odd segue between the conclusion and the women's united celebration. Wrestling isn't always fair. The slightest misstep can create a complete immersion-breaker in a split second, and that's what happened here.


1. Timing Issues Lead To A Rushed Main Event

The main event was a 20-minute bout condensed into just over half that, with the six competitors forced to rush to an abrupt finish ahead of the FITE.tv feed cutting off before the moment could truly sink in. This meant that Cody and The Young Buck's event-closing speeches were dark segments, so if you were watching at home, you were deprived of the chance to watch their victory lap and heavy ALL IN 2 teases.

Major timing issues put them in this position. They had no scope to go over the four-hour timeslot by a single second, so it's safe to assume at least a handful of matches went over their allotted minutes, forcing them to make major sacrifices later on.

Though fans were still treated to an excellent main event, the competitors should never have been put in that position. Okada vs. Scurll, Lethal vs. Gordon, Rhodes vs. Aldis, the Joey Ryan segment: each ran a shade too long, and could've been snipped by at least a minute or two. This would have allowed the main all the time it needed to unfold and conclude naturally, but alas.

That a logistical issue was this show's biggest problem speaks volumes of its quality. Let's hope they keep a tighter schedule next time.


Ups...

11. Who Knew Green Arrow Could Wrestle?

Pairing Stephen Amell with Christopher Daniels was a masterstroke, as the 25-year veteran guided the Arrow star through an extremely smart bout that nobody could have asked for more from.

Daniels, a consummate pro, was excellent. He's one of the best hand-holders in the business, and proved it by guiding a near complete rookie through his first singles match on one of the biggest wrestling shows of the year to craft an end product far better than it had any right to be. Were there a couple of sloppy moments? Sure, but they can be forgiven under these circumstances.

As for Amell? He looked better than some of the full-time wrestlers on this show, and worked his arse off to more than hold up his end of the bargain. The effort he put into training for this bout paid off. As well as consenting to a big table bump, he was always in the right place at the right time, and rarely seemed like an actor playing a wrestler. There were times when it looked like he belong in that ring with Daniels, and he should be delighted with how the match came out.


10. Leaving Nothing In The Tank

Though not without its flubs and miscommunications, the women's four-way between Tessa Blanchard, Madison Rayne, Chelsea Green, and Britt Baker was a triumph, with Chicago rising to their feet for an arena-wide standing ovation midway through.

All four were fired-up, hungry, and ready to impress, and they used their 13-minute runtime well, racing from spot to spot at a breathless pace. They were rewarded with tremendous noise from the capacity crowd. Everything they did had the building buzzing, and while the finish didn't quite come off as planned, their collective work ethic, pacing, and layout all hit the mark.

Each participant deserves immense credit. Rayne, the most experienced of the group, was vital in holding things together. The explosive Baker showed great promise. Chelsea Green, meanwhile, impressed with strong character work and sharp offence, but it was the victorious Blanchard who came off as the biggest star.

Oozing confidence from the moment she walked out with her father, Tully, and Magnum TA, Tessa looked like a million dollars, and had the crowd popping with her imposing power game. She's a gem of a performer, and someone well-positioned to become one of her generation's most important women's wrestlers.


9. D*cks Ahoy

A phalanx of phalluses.

A procession of penises.

A cortege of cocks.

This silly bullsh*t went on for entirely too long, but how could it be anything other than an Up?

Incredible.


8. Pantomime Perfection

Good grief, this Cody vs. Nick Aldis match. What an incredible display of pro-wrestling cheese.

The entrances alone were enough to give the lactose intolerant nightmares. Cody gave his wife, Brandi a totally unnecessary introduction. The cameras then cut backstage as he made his own arrival, surrounded by the Nightmare Family, whose ranks included Diamond Dallas Page, Tommy Dreamer, and fellow wrestling LEGEND Glacier. Cody's dog Pharaoh was there too, and more over than half the wrestlers on the show. What a time to be alive.

As if that wasn't enough, the boys wheeled out the hilariously out-of-his-depth OVW announcer who called Rhodes' first ever match, and had Earl Hebner cut an atrocious pre-bout promo to boot. It was pure, corny pantomime, and this writer lapped it up.

The bout itself felt like a straight up '80s throwback, which, given the story (Cody chasing one of the most storied championships of his planet - one his father fought for 30 years ago) made perfect sense. The DDP/Daivari interferences weren't necessary, but the rest delivered, and Cody was the most over man in the building when he won.


7. Black Machismo Rides Again

Flip Gordon earned a Ring Of Honor Title shot by winning the Zero Hour battle royal, having disguised himself as Being The Elite banter boy Chico El Luchador, before removing his mask and eliminating a stunned Bully Ray. BTE storylines meant this was always likely, but it still hit the mark.

He then delivered a perfectly solid clash with Jay Lethal, who was in full on showman mode himself. Accompanied by Lanny Poffo, he channeled his old Black Machismo character, busting out his pitch perfect Randy Savage tribute act for the first time in years. Brandi Rhodes tapped him out of it midway through. From there, the bout was significantly less interesting, but both men worked hard regardless.

Hopes of a Gordon upset were dashed when Lethal nailed his opponent with a top rope Cutter, then the Lethal Injection for the victory. Still, getting on the main card was enough for Flip. BTE had been building to this for months, and while he never looked like stealing the show, Gordon likely had boatloads of fun in what was comfortably the biggest match of his career to date.


6. What This Means

Cody Rhodes NWA Heavyweight
ALL IN

Winning the NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship was a huge moment for Cody. This is, of course, the very same belt his father fought many legendary battles for decades ago. Its history is almost unfathomably deep, but while the entire NWA organisation has faded into the abyss since the territories collapsed, the group has just fallen into a goldmine.

Cody is the perfect NWA Champion. The man's a star, and his title win was executed perfectly. His highlight reel victory was emotional and exciting: not only for himself, but for the brand he now represents.

With all due respect to Nick Aldis, he was never going to be the guy to help the NWA claw out of the murk. Cody is. He's a major international star who'll give the brand huge exposure whenever he appears for ROH or NJPW, and the belt gains boatloads of prestige from him holding it alone. This should create a groundswell of support for the group, and if handled correctly, there's no reason that Cody can't help Billy Corgan and Dave Lagana reach their goals.

The NWA will never be the name in professional wrestling again, but with a Rhodes as their lynchpin, there's no reason they can't be a name once more.


5. Scurll Proves Himself In Defeat

Though Marty Scurll vs. Kazuchika Okada ran a little too long, and suffered from several slowdowns throughout the first 10-15 minutes, it ultimately succeeded by telling the story it needed to tell, with 'The Villain' proving his worth against the consensus best wrestler on the planet.

This was a simple tale told well. Scurll, the Junior Heavyweight, was considered no match for Okada, who's coming off the greatest IWGP Heavyweight Title reign of all time. 'The Rainmaker' had disrespected his p*ssed-off opponent, taunting him with "205 Live" suggestions in the build-up. This manifested in the match too, but Scurll showed great fire, and refused to go down to his celebrated opponent without the fight of his life.

The duo built towards an exciting closing stretch that had Scurll on the edge of victory several times. He snapped Okada's fingers, pulled him into the Crossface Chickenwing, filling the building with the anticipation of an upset. Marty even blasted Okada with his own Rainmaker for a two-count, resulting in the bout's best near-fall.

It wasn't enough, though. Three Rainmakers later, Scurll was felled. It was the right outcome, and while the bout would have benefited from better pacing, 'The Villain' lost nothing in defeat.


4. A Breathtaking Conclusion

It's disappointing that the six-man main event was cut short, because these ridiculously talented performers were well on their way to concocting a classic spotfest before the curtain came down. Regardless, we still got an excellent lucha tag, and a myriad of gif-worthy moments to boot.

Everyone dazzled. Bandido walked in as the least well-known performer in the bout, but will leave Chicago with thousands of new fans. His offence is slick, his swagger palpable, and his athleticism off the charts. The 23-year-old is now all set to become a huge global superstar, and he didn't look out of place among some of the best wrestlers in the world, starring in a number of the bout's biggest set pieces, including an awesome corkscrew dive.

The Young Bucks brought their working boots, performing to ALL IN's massive stage with a typically cohesive showing. Kota Ibushi, fresh off an MVP G1 Climax run, walked out with a crazed look in his eyes and proceeded to rule the ring whenever he was tagged in. Rey Fenix took the breath away with one of the most outrageous rope-run spots you'll ever see, and as for Rey Mysterio? He was Rey f*cking Mysterio, all 619's, Frog Splashes, and big dives, holding nothing back despite rumours of an imminent WWE return.

Bandido ate More Bank For Young Buck and a Meltzer Driver for the finish. A predictable outcome, but the action preceding it was breathtaking.


3. Omega Vs. Pentagon Delivers

Kenny Omega and Pentagon beat the absolute sh*t out of each other, and it was glorious.

This always looked like an intriguing match. Penta has never worked the format Omega typically excels in (that long, dramatic, New Japan main event style), and on the flipside, Kenny rarely produces the kind of wild, violent brawls his opponent typically favours. There was a slight chance their bout could have fallen short of expectations as a result, but it didn't. It definitely didn't.

The stiffness was off the charts, with both men taking all manner of brutal strikes and head bumps. Kenny's V-Triggers were as skull-shattering as ever. Penta's chops? As stinging as they were theatric. At one point, Pentagon hit his opponent with a Package Piledriver on the apron, and as if that wasn't bat enough, his foe followed up by damn near killing the luchador with the same move (albeit in the ring).

Omega is the IWGP Heavyweight Champion, so the outcome was a dead lock. It speaks volumes to Penta's performance, then, that he had us all genuinely buying into the idea he could win by the closing stretch. His final Package Piledriver created a heat-stopping near-fall. He lost in the end, but deserves immense credit for planting doubt in what looked like a sure thing.


2. Pure Insanity

Chaos was guaranteed from the moment Hangman Page vs. Joey Janela was transformed from vanilla singles clash to a Chicago Street Fight. These two were always going to go nuts, and damn near murder each other with the kind of risky spots that helped build their reputations in the first place, so while this clash offered few surprises, it was pure exhilaration from bell to bell

Joey Janela is a lunatic. The mad c*nt works like he has a deathwish, consenting to bumps that are likely shaving months of his wrestling career at a time. By the end, his entire torso was a battered, swollen, bulbous mess. This style could well ruin him, but the visceral thrill his riskiest matches bring is undeniable.

Hangman Page is a lunatic. He actually had the balls to hit his Rite of Passage finisher (a risky back-to-belly piledriver) from the top of a ladder through a table for the conclusion, and pulled it off to perfection. His fearlessness is one of his greatest traits, and in a year of incredible improvement, Page may have just delivered the strongest singles match of his career.

Nobody could possibly have asked for more from this glorious trainwreck of a bout. Though traditionalists may well be appalled by the risks taken, it delivered everything it promised - and even found room for a couple of fun comedy spots.


1. Holy Sh*t

Chris Jericho ALL IN
ALL IN

So much for appeasing Vince McMahon by not appearing for any other wrestling show in the United States, eh Chris?

Jericho's appearance gave ALL IN the big taking point it needed. The lights dimmed after Kenny Omega vs. Pentagon, and the felled skeleton ninja rose from the dead. He jumped Omega, battering him with strikes, before pulling off a Codebreaker. Then, he stopped, soaked in the atmosphere, and pulled off his mask, hitting 'The Cleaner' with another finisher, blowing the roof off once more.

It was an incredible spot. Visually, 'Y2J' is taller and heavier than Penta. This established the first strains of doubt, and the initial Codebreaker blew them away, provoking a thunderous response from the Chicago crowd.

Having fallen to Omega at Wrestle Kingdom 12, the IWGP Intercontinental Champion gained a measure of revenge, pimping his upcoming cruise, and immediately put his name back in the headlines, all within a single angle. He's playing the free agent game to perfection. God bless him and everything he brings to the table.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.