11 WWE Wrestlers With Multiple 5 Star Matches

These guys knew what Uncle Dave's sweet spot was.

Dave Meltzer
http://betwrestling.com/

Hey guys, we're talking about Dave Meltzer and his star ratings system again! Cue the chorus of "Why does anyone care about what Dave Meltzer says?" as well as "Dave Meltzer didn't give Shawn and Undertaker five stars, his opinion is invalid!"

Seriously though, yes, it is a bit old hat to discuss star ratings, especially when it comes to Uncle Dave, but in the case of WWE, it's actually quite special. As of the recent NXT TakeOver: New Orleans, the company now has an extra two 5 star matches to boast about, when historically, they only had six. This also means that WWE now have an additional three wrestlers who have multiple 5 star matches from Dave Meltzer.

It can be tricky to determine who are the "best" wrestlers to ever step foot in WWE, but when you consider that Meltzer awards matches 5 stars based on how they get over with the crowd based on the work in the ring, you're certainly in the conversation if you have that honor multiple times. These gentlemen got many of their 5 star ratings outside of WWE, but that doesn't change the fact that while in WWE, they were (or are) some of he very best at what they do.

11. Johnny Gargano

Johnny Gargano Candice LeRae
WWE.com

2018 has been a whirlwind for Johnny Wrestling.

In 2016 and 2017, the former NXT tag team champion had established himself, along with Tommaso Ciampa, as the best act in NXT, putting on classics with the Revival and the Authors of Pain. His career was changed forever last year when, in a failed effort to regain the titles, Ciampa turned on Johnny, forcing him into a singles run.

That run paid off huge in January of this year, when Dave Meltzer awarded his NXT title match against Andrade "Cien" Almas five stars, the first honor for WWE since 2011. Last week, his run of greatness continued, as he had a five star match in a grudge match against Ciampa, now considered to be the greatest match in NXT history.

With two five star classics in just the developmental league, Johnny Gargano is now more-or-less WWE's best-kept secret. Given his size and the moniker of "Johnny Wrestling," he doesn't seem like the kind of guy Vince McMahon would be all that invested in upon reaching the main roster. Still, the more power Triple H gains backstage, the more interesting it'll be to see how future call-ups perform.


10. Bret Hart

bret hart stone cold steve austin
WWE.com

Not sure if you were aware of this, but Bret Hart had these little monikers such as "the excellence of execution," as well as "the best there is, the best there was, and the best there ever will be." You shouldn't blame yourself if you didn't know, since he was kind of low key about both, but needless to say, he had sort of a reputation as being a pretty good wrestler.

Heavy sarcastic understatements aside, at a time when WWE's average talent wasn't the 20th in-ring as they are now, Bret was still by today's standards an outstanding performer. Such ability showed when in the '90s, he produced two 5 star matches for the company which were of incredibly different styles. The first, in 1994 against brother Owen, was a steel cage match that featured no bloodshed. Then, in 1997, he and Steve Austin produced a vicious brawl that featured one of the best uses of blood ever when a crimson mask donned Austin's face.

Bret could have gotten a third five star match even earlier with his brother Owen at WrestleMania X, but alas, Uncle Dave only gave that match 4.75 stars. However, there was another performer on that show who earned the perfect mark...


9. Shawn Michaels

Undertaker Shawn Michaels Hell In A Cell
WWE.com

Now obviously, Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels patched up their personal issues many years ago, and are now on good terms with each other. However, if Shawn did want to reignite any animosity between himself and the Hitman, a good place to start would be to remind Bret who it was that got the first ever 5 star match in WWE history.

At WrestleMania X, the same night Bret and Owen had a 4.75 star classic in the opener, HBK and Razor Ramon had their iconic ladder match for the Intercontinental Championship. The first match of its kind seen by a worldwide audience, it was instrumental in the evolution of match styles that are seen in WWE to this day. Three years later, Michaels did it all over again when he and The Undertaker competed in the first ever Hell in a Cell match. This brutal, storyline-heavy match was seen as a masterclass of Shawn Michaels as a worker, and it's hard to disagree with that.

While many argue that the original ladder and HIAC matches have been surpassed, it will never be disputed who has to be thanked for elevating both of them.


8. CM Punk

John Cena Cm Punk
WWE.com

Was CM Punk truly "the Best in the World?" It's hard to say, since the standard for ring-work has increased dramatically since his prime. However, it can't be denied that during said prime, nobody knew how to work a crowd quite like Charles Montgomery. He's of course known for his iconic match with John Cena at Money in the Bank 2011, where he won the WWE Championship in front of a rapturous Chicago crowd. That bout was the first WWE match since the original Hell in a Cell to earn 5 stars from Big Dave.

However, it was only the first 5 star match in seven years for CM Punk, as during his feud with Samoa Joe in Ring of Honor, he and the Samoan Submission Machine went to a one-hour draw in front of an equally rapturous Chicago crowd. It seems that Uncle Dave's criteria isn't just "if it happens in Japan, it's five stars." You also have a good chance of getting that honor if you wrestle CM Punk in Chicago.

With that said, you can bet Cody Rhodes is waiting with bated breath for Punk to return his calls about All In.


7. Samoa Joe

samoa joe cm punk
ROH

There was a time when Samoa Joe was probably the best wrestler in North America, and arguably, the world. In the early-to-mid 2000s, he went on an absolute tear in both ROH and TNA, having lengthy title reigns and dream matches that are still being talked about to this day.

He had the first 5 star match in America in seven years with CM Punk, which went to a time limit draw after an hour of intense physical storytelling. In 2005, he, AJ Styles, and Christopher Daniels main-evented TNA's Unbreakable PPV, where they put on the only 5-star match in the company's entire history: a wild, fast-paced spotfest that was the peak of TNA's golden age. Finally, just a month after the TNA show, Joe faced off against Japanese legend Kenta Kobashi in a dream match for ROH, and the two peltered the absolute bejesus out of each other for the enjoyment of a molten New York City crowd. That last match earned the Wrestling Observer's "Match of the Year" award for 2005.

It's absolutely bonkers to think it took a whole decade afterward for Joe to finally show up in WWE. We can only imagine what he could have (or wouldn't have) accomplished if his best years were spent there.


6. Steve Austin

Stone Cold Steve Austin Bret Hart
WWE

It's tricky to say who deserves credit when a 5 star match features so many competitors, as is the case with the ladder match at this last NXT TakeOver. While all six men absolutely put on fantastic performances, you can't really say that any one of the competitors were the most important in the match's success. Still, it's shocking to think that guys like Velveteen Dream, Lars Sullivan, and EC3 now have a 5 star match under their belts, especially Dream, when you consider his youth.

It's similar to how "Stunning" Steve Austin, despite being relatively new in the wrestling business, earned a 5 star rating when participating in a War Games match at WrestleWar 1992, when the Dangerous Alliance took on a team led by Sting. However, the Alliance's manager, Paul Heyman, probably wasn't that shocked that Austin set the bar high for himself early on. Heyman says he was convinced early on that Austin was the future of the business, and eventually, "Stone Cold" proved him right. In 1997, a little over a year into his WWE run, he and Bret Hart put on arguably the greatest match in company history: a bloody, brutal brawl which saw the most famous double turn of all time.

So the question is: can guys like Velveteen Dream and Sullivan follow suit? Time will tell.


5. Shinsuke Nakamura

Shinsuke Nakamura AJ Styles
WWE.com

It's safe to say that many people see Shinsuke Nakamura's WWE run as disappointing. Aside from cool entrances and the occasional flashes of in-ring brilliance, there hasn't been a lot to the King of Strong Style's body of work to suggest he's the all-conquering master of his craft his hardcore fans tout him as. Some who have never seen his work in Japan even go as far as saying he's overrated, lazy, or downright bad.

However, looking at his pre-WWE career, that's patently not the case. The reason Nakamura was so hyped upon signing with WWE was because he had established himself as one of the best wrestlers in the world in New Japan. His match with Kota Ibushi at Wrestle Kingdom 9 stole the show and earned him a 5 star rating, and his G1 Climax final with Hiroshi Tanahashi earned the Wrestling Observer's "Match of the Year" award. Both of those matches were in 2015, the year before Nakamura signed.

Maybe it's age, maybe it's the quirks of WWE's style, but whatever the reason, people are hoping we get to see the old Shinsuke Nakamura again, and soon.


4. Ricochet

ricochet ladder
WWE.com

Ricochet: a human GIF machine, and a man who has possibly had his knees surgically replaced with jelly.

With his freakish athleticism and in-ring ability, Ricochet is arguably the best high-flyer in the world right, and now that he's in WWE, he has a better chance than most of being pushed as the next Rey Mysterio. Just like Rey before him, Ricochet was on an absolute tear before signing with WWE, changing how people saw high-flying contests.

Obviously, Ricochet was really put on the map with his viral match against Will Ospreay in 2016, but his first 5 star rating came when he and Ospreay teamed up with Matt Sydal against the "Super-Kliq" at PWG later that year. This chaotic, unrelenting spotfest was seen as one of the greatest six-man tags of all time, and it cemented in peoples' minds that Ricochet was on a level above even the best of his contemporaries.

Finally, Ricochet earned another 5 stars this month at TakeOver: New Orleans in the opening six-man ladder match. Obviously, it was a star-making performance for all the competitors involved, but Ricochet especially made his presence known in front of a WWE audience.

Will we see more similarly stellar performances from Ricochet? It's hard to see why not.


3. Ricky Steamboat

ricky steamboat ric flair
WWE.com

It's easy to rattle off a list of truly great heels, but truly great babyface workers are harder to come by. It cannot be disputed, however, that Ricky Steamboat should absolutely be on everyone's Mt. Rushmore of babyfaces.

Obviously, WWE fans are aware of the classic Steamboat and Randy Savage put on at WrestleMania III. However, that did not earn the illustrious 5 star rating. To break that threshold, Ricky had to leave the company and feud with none other than Ric Flair.

The Flair-Steamboat series of the late '80s is seen by many as the greatest in-ring rivalry of all time. These two put on technical and storytelling classics on PPV, television, and even once at a house show in Maryland. Yes, a house show match got 5 stars from Meltzer. That's how good this rivalry was.

So while it's unfortunate that Ricky had his best matches outside of WWE, it's only right that the company still celebrates him today for his achievements. The Dragon most certainly deserves it.


2. Adam Cole

Adam Cole NXT Takeover Philadelphia
www.wwe.com

It's always fun to speculate on who has the potential to be huge stars in WWE. There are obviously several factors that determine a superstar's success, and you just never know who the company randomly decide to push (lookin' at you, Jinder Mahal). However, in this author's opinion, the smart money for who's going to be a major star on the main roster in the years to come is on none other than Adam Cole (bay-bay). With his own stable, NXT tag title, and inaugural North American Championship, Cole has already amassed a great WWE resume by the age of 28. Then there's his work on the independents, where he won world titles in both PWG and Ring of Honor.

Of course, he's on this list because not only was he in that fantastic ladder match, but in 2016, he participated in a wild six-man tag on the second night of PWG's Battle of Los Angeles that earned the coveted 5 stars. And wouldn't you know it, that match also included Ricochet. It would seem these two are just destined to put on classics together.


1. Ric Flair

Ric Flair Royal Rumble 1992
WWE.com

Stop me if you've heard this one: Ric Flair is arguably the greatest of all time.

Now that's nothing new, since it's a narrative pushed by WWE time and time again because Triple H is his biggest fanboy. However, it needs to be appreciated that, in his prime, Ric Flair was a 5 star match machine. From technical masterpieces with Ricky Steamboat and huge War Games matches, to wild brawls with Terry Funk, Ric Flair earned the 5 star honor up and down the food chain. Whether it was on PPV, TBS, or even at a house show once, Big Daddy Dave just couldn't help but give the Nature Boy 5 stars.

What's especially impressive about Ric's accomplishments are the series of 5 star matches he had with certain guys. Obviously, most people know about his legendary run of matches with Ricky Steamboat, which is compared to the modern-day equivalent of Okada and Omega, but how many of you knew Ric had multiple 5 star matches with Barry Windham? Seriously. When was the last time you thought about Barry Windham?

Quite simply: you may not think Ric Flair is the absolute greatest, but it's a good guess Meltzer does.


In this post: 
Dave Meltzer
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A mystery wrapped in an enigma wrapped in bacon wrapped in wrestling listicles wrapped in tin foil wrapped in seaweed wrapped in gak.