12 Greatest Ever Fictional Wrestlers

Just because they never existed doesn't mean they weren't great.

the wrestler mickey rourke
Fox Searchlight Pictures

Professional wrestling is already half-fictional. You can debate what the fraction is, I guess, but you get the idea; a significant portion of our favorite pseudosport is a fiction, and the same can be said of its performers. That's why the idea of a fictional pro wrestler is so fascinating: it's an actor, usually a wrestler himself, playing the part of a second performer playing a different role. It has the potential to be endlessly recursive, but it's always fun to watch.

The following grapplers may not be real, but maybe they should be.

13. The Shrieking Sheik - The Simpsons

Bret hart simpsons
20th Century Fox.com

This one is really just a throwaway gag, but it's really a sublime one. It's prime-era Simpsons, first of all, and it's also related to a strange Bret Hart cameo. They never revealed where Springfield is, but I guess it's relatively close to Calgary, Alberta, Canada, because the Hitman has come to town looking to buy Mr. Burns' mansion. At first, he's put off by the house's "old man stink", and my inner Heenan wants to point out that's he'd surely be used to that growing up with Stu.

What sells Bret on the house is that fact that another wrestler, the Shrieking Sheik, lives in the neighborhood, and this revelation is punctuated by the sound of the Sheik ululating in the distance. You have no idea how much improved my life would be if the Shrieking Sheik actually showed up at some point. The show's been on the air for 45 years and they've had spotlight episodes for goddamn Duffman, why can't they give me twenty-two minutes of some shrill Sabu pastiche teaching Homer to value his marriage?


12. The Russian Mummy - Starsky & Hutch

russian mummy
ABC

When I first heard that Richard Kiel of "Jaws" fame played a wrestler on an episode of Starsky and Hutch, I had many questions. When I found out that that wrestler was the Russian Mummy, I had even more. At first, I thought he was a Russian mummy in the Soviet, creepily-preserved-corpse-of-Lenin sense, but nope. He's a straight-up Old Kingdom Egyptian, with linen wrappings and canopic jars to store his organs, the whole nine. He's a Boris Karloff-style mummy that came to life and defected to the USSR for some reason.

I mean, I think. The episode actually deals with the predetermined nature of the sport (gasp!), and the fearsome Commie Corpse is actually a shy dude named Iggy. But that's not to say Iggy doesn't take his role seriously; there's a wonderful scene of him getting in a full workout in full mummy wrappings, despite the apparent risk of heat exhaustion. Maybe that's why he's only pressing like 35 pounds, but whatever. Iggy lives the gimmick, man. He probably thinks Undertaker's killing the business for showing up on his wife's Instagram.


11. El Toro Fuerte - Jackie Chan Adventures

el toro fuerte
Sony Pictures Television

Hey, remember Jackie Chan Adventures? It was a cartoon that cast sixty-something martial arts stuntman Jackie Chan as an anxious archaeologist that habitually fought demons. It was kind of like a Chinatown version of Jonny Quest, but better, because each episode ended with the real Jackie Chan personally answering questions from children by rambling incoherently. Then they'd send his garbled, half-English response to the world's most harried intern, who would edit his twelve minute tangent into a ten second clip. There shouldn't be twenty-five jump cuts if you're just trying to tell us what your favorite ice cream flavor is, Jackie.

Anyway, one of Jackie's friendly rivals on the show was a luchador called El Toro Fuerte, and he was totally cast from the classic Santo mold. He wore a three piece suit with his mask when he wasn't wrestling, and spent his spare time throwing topés at organized crime. Also, he owned a magic ox medallion that gave him superhuman strength. Rumors that he'll appear on season two of Lucha Underground are so far unconfirmed.


10. The Foreigner - Futurama

foreigner futurama
20th Century Fox Television

Okay, fine. The Foreigner isn't technically a wrestler, per se. He competed in Futurama's Ultimate Robot Fighting League, which is halfway between pro wrestling and BattleBots; Mick Foley would love it. But all the Ultimate Robot Fighters have gimmicks, the matches are rigged, and it's my article, so here we are.

All of the villainous robots are straight out of the 1980's heel handbook, including Billionairebot and the Chainsmoker ("I love smokin', and after the show I'm headin' right for YOUR FAVORITE RRSTAURANT"). But the best of these is the aptly-named Foreigner, an all-purpose hateful immigrant parodying everyone from the Iron Sheik to Ludvig Borga. He's got a handlebar mustache, a bolero jacket, he's not even trying to maintain an accent, and he carries a threatening passport. This is going to sound like I'm a worryingly big fan of early 80's AOR (which is true albeit unrelated), but Foreigner 4 life.


9. Nacho - Nacho Libre

Nacho Libre Final Fight
Paramount Pictures

It's been nine years since the release of Nacho Libre, and coincidentally, the ninth anniversary of my talking point about how Nacho Libre is an underrated gem. Despite being a Napoleon Dynamite-esque farce, it's based upon the life of Fray Tormenta, a genuine catholic priest who moonlighted as a luchador enmascarado to fund his orphanage. The other stuff, such as our hero having an emaciated homeless man as a tag partner, or climbing the Cliffs of Insanity to gain EAGLE POWER NUTRIENTS, not so much.

As any real wrestling fan knows, there is no route to self-actualization more effective than grappling excellence. Nacho's story is farcical, but his emotional journey from glory-obsessed fanboy to altruistic champion is genuine and heartfelt. Plus, it turns out he really can harness mystical eagle powers, complete with literal flight and a raptorian screech. 


8. Mike Haggar - Final Fight

Mike Haggar
Capcom

Years before Jesse Ventura, uh, ventured into politics, Final Fight's Mike Haggar was a pioneer for wrestlers in politics. After a championship career in the Capcom Wrestling Association, Haggar retired to run for the mayorship of Metro City. When gang violence proved indefatigable, he set out to make a difference with only his wrestling ability, a pair of olive green chinos and the kind of anger a public servant can muster.

Mayor Mike would be the sole constant throughout the Final Fight franchise (aside from mysteriously-occurring turkey dinners on the trash), appearing in every game in the series. There's just something magical about a character who, when faced with a literal army of street thugs, chooses to eschew firearms and simply murder all of them personally with pavement pile drivers. Haggar also got his own prequel series of games, which explored a simpler time in his life when his piledrivers came from a place of friendly competition, rather than ridiculously personal counterterrorism.


7. Bone Saw McGraw - Spider-Man

Randy Savage Bonesaw
Sony Pictures

If you know your comic book lore, the wrestler Peter Parker faced way back in Amazing Fantasy #15 was known as Crusher Hogan. However, by the time Spider-Man became a feature film, Hulk Hogan was a thing, far more famous than the comic book footnote that predated his ring name by at least a decade. Even if the folks at Columbia thought keeping the name was a wise move, they would never have been able to sell Randy Savage on the idea (he was smack in the middle of one of his legendary Hogan hate binges at the time).

Bone Saw owes every single drop of his vitality to the performance of the Macho Man. He's basically the Macho Man a non-wrestling fan would imagine, based solely upon Slim Jim commercial and, uh, Spider-Man cameos. The real Savage had twelve or fourteen layers of fascinating strangeness buried beneath the surface-level formula of "gravelly voice + catchphrase", but if we'd gotten to see that he never would have worked as a heel, and they would've had to turn Spidey. The movie would have ended with the Green Goblin taking an Atomic Elbow off the Brooklyn Bridge.


6. President Camacho - Idiocracy

president camacho
20th Century Fox

In Mike Judge's superlative dystopian comedy Idiocracy, Dwayne Elizondo Mountain Dew Herbert Camacho is president of the United States, the second-smartest man on Earth, a critically-acclaimed pornstar, and a former "Ultimate Smackdown champion." Played by the delightful Terry Crews, he looks like a perfect fusion of Apollo Creed and the 2005 Lemmyface version of Triple H, and I kind of want him to run for president for real.

We don't actually see any of Camacho's in-ring exploits, although his various presidential speeches and proclamations have the all the crowd-swaying gravitas of a good Rock promo. Also, he's able to to dispatch a flamethrower dude called "Beef Supreme" with a single shoulderblock. Terry Crews has some wrestling experience, kind-of, as T-Money from the bizarro late 90's series, "Battle Dome." Can we start a campaign to have Terry Crews guest host Raw and work a faces of Foley gimmick?


5. The Crusher - Looney Tunes

crusher looney tunes
Warner Bros.

The Crusher was a legitimate two-sport athlete: not only did he trade holds with Bugs Bunny in 1951, but the two also boxed each other in 1948's Rabbit Punch. Watching the earlier short, though, it's clear that Crusher was always destined to be a legendary wrestling heel. When his brute strength wasn't enough to knock Bugs out, he shed his gloves and started fighting dirty, most notably hijacking an actual train to try to kill his opponent.

Crusher's only real undoing was choosing to wrestle Bugs Bunny, who may look like a non-threatening New York-area cartoon rabbit but is secretly a primordial chaos god. Like, Crusher may as well have been in there trying to work a wrist lock on Gozer the Gozerian. Bugs kind of has that whole Tatanka, "get beat up the whole match, then just decide to win" thing going, except instead of throwing bad chops he just laughingly rewrites the laws of reality.


4. The Lout Brothers - The Ren & Stimpy Show

ren stimpy lump
Paramount

These two monsters hail from perhaps the only pro wrestling cartoon that's better than Bunny Hugged: Mad Dog Höek, a 1992 episode of the Ren and Stimpy Show. The title characters are matched against the undefeated Lump and Loaf, the Lout Brothers. They're hulking, Legion of Doom-esque brutes, and they absolutely demolish their opponents. It's like they rotoscoped a particularly nasty Steiner Brothers squash.

Unlike the Crusher, they are able to withstand attacks based on cartoon logic; Ren applies a sleeper hold to Loaf, and he produces a tray of hot coffee from his tights, for example. Later, Lump maims Stimpy with the most fearsome fictional wrestling hold of all time, the dreaded Flying Butt Pliers. The image of a cartoon cat clenched between the airborne cheeks of a giant dude has haunted me for twenty years, and now, dear reader, I pass it on to you.


3. Randy "The Ram" Robinson - The Wrestler

914543

I wasn't a huge fan of The Wrestler, but when I've crafted a list that counts a twenty year old sound effect from The Simpsons as a wrestler, I can't really justify not including Randy "the Ram" Robinson. He's surely the only wrestler that netted an Academy Award nomination for the actor portraying him (although personally I've always felt Big Show was snubbed for his harrowing portrayal of The Waterboy's Captain Insano).

Randy is a sadly accurate portrait of the ultimate fate of many wrestling stars of the 80's: his body is broken down, his life is in a shambles, and all he has left is his in-ring legacy. He's reduced to diminishing even that by continuing to perform long after doing so is a grotesque embarrassment. Personally, I would have preferred a lighter revolving around the used car-selling misadventures of Ernest Miller's Ayatollah, but, uh, there might be a reason I'm not an Oscar-nominated filmmaker.


2. Thunderlips - Rocky III

Thunderlips hogan
United Artists

Those who know their (currently forbidden) WWE know that Hulk Hogan wasn't some unknown quantity when he showed up defeat the Iron Sheik and something something runnin' wild. He'd had an extremely successful run as a heel in the late 1970's, including a sold-out Shea Stadium bout where Hogan definitely didn't slam André the Giant, no sir. Despite his rising star, Hogan left the company to film a role he strongly believed would make his career, but that Vince McMahon Sr. didn't approve of.

Hulk Hogan's star-making performance -- sorry, No Holds Barred fans, all two of you -- was as Rocky III's Ultimate Male. He's like the final form of Superstar Billy Graham, a ridiculous giant in a cape-and-bowler-hat ensemble swathed in adoring hype girls. He looks like he's about 23 feet tall next to Stallone. It's honestly a much better character than "Orange vitamin taker", "self-styled celebrity nihilist" or "national embarrassment, so maybe Hogan should just quietly morph back into Thunderlips full time.


1. Rasslor - Dial 'M' For Monkey

dexter rasslor
Cartoon Network

Okay, so maybe this random Dexter's Lab b-segment is the best wrestling cartoon ever. When a super-powerful, super-competitive alien comes to Earth, he demands that our champions meet him in single combat to prove that our planet deserves to exist. Earth’s greatest champions fall, one after another, until only one scrappy survivor is left, refusing to quit. Eventually, the alien is moved by his conviction, and decides to spare our planet in honor of our champion’s intestinal fortitude. Oh, and the alien is a seafoam green space luchador played by Randy Savage.

Just like Bone Saw, this character succeeds primarily on the strength of Savage’s brassy baritone. In fact, as fun as it is to watch pastiches of everyone’s favorite Superfriends get pummeled with folding chairs, I can only imagine how much fun the guys at the recording studio had watching Randy scream his lines into an innocent microphone, which probably collapsed into dust the moment they stopped recording. Incidentally, I have always believed that when and if aliens invade Earth, it is not our technology but our dropkicks and atomic drops that will save us; James T. Kirk and Ultraman, among others, would seem to agree. 


Contributor

Long-time fan (scholar?) of professional wrestling, kaiju films and comparative mythology. Aspiring two-fisted adventurer.