12 Reasons WWE’s Ruthless Aggression Documentary Is An Absolute Mess
Garbage wrestling.
First, the good things.
It shouldn't be understated how welcome it is that WWE have finally started mining another period from their history beyond Steve Austin's beer truck and that D-Generation X "tank" invasion of WCW. Regardless of anybody's personal take on this supposed "era" (and there were plenty of those upon announcement of this series), the prospect of the company using its infinite resources for something beyond splicing together more Val Venis clips was fantastic.
And on fantastic splicing, that's exactly what Episodes 1 and 2 of this were. Despite evidence to the contrary every Monday and Friday, there are fields within wrestling WWE are still the runaway leaders in. Production on projects like this is one such example. The company dove deep into the archives for new backstage footage as well as on-screen moments that helped shape a narrative, even if that particular one was further away from the truth than Vince McMahon was from adhering to an agreement with the World Wildlife Fund in the late 1990s.
But more on that later.
Enough of the stuff to enjoy though. This was, at all other points, an absolute mess. This was not, by a wide f*cking margin, a journalistic endeavour. And that's an important distinction to understand, because this list isn't either.
12. What About The Attitude Era?
"RUTHLESS AGGRESSION!" "RUTHLESS AGGRESSION!" "RUTHLESS AGGRESSION!" "RUTHLESS AGGRESSION!" was effectively how WWE trailed this new show, every talking head more excited than the last to finally be allowed to offer an opinion on something that wasn't tangentially linked to the Ministry Of Darkness.
The grand unveiling then spent the first 15 minutes talking about the f*cking Attitude Era again.
There was absolutely space for context here - a transitional time for the company doesn't come without prosperous periods to slide out and in of - but the show didn't need a third of its runtime dedicated to yet more self-fellating on the Monday Night War win. Not least when it was peppered with how quickly they dropped the ball in the aftermath.
But more on that later, we've got the f*cking ATTITUDE ERA to talk about...
11. The Turning Point
For those keeping track of such things, WWE won the Monday Night Wars not when DX drove that not-a-tank over to where Nitro was being taped or when Vince McMahon screwed Bret Hart or when Hulk Hogan poked Kevin Nash in the chest or when The Radicalz signed or when Stone Cold Steve Austin won the WWE Championship at WrestleMania XIV or when Kane debuted but actually when 'The Rattlesnake' confronted Mike Tyson the night after his Royal Rumble 1998 victory.
'The Rattlesnake' confronting 'The Baddest Man On The Planet' was absolutely electric and well worth the many hours that have already been spent celebrating it, but if t's almost as if a bust-to-boom period for a multi-million dollar enterprise can't be boiled down to one solitary moment no matter how much the company telling the story try to frame it.
Heads were still up a*ses at this point in the premiere - perhaps they were removed when it came to discussing the purchase of WCW some three years later?
10. World Championship Wasting
If anything about the Atlanta outfit ever meant anything to you as a fan, try not to have something in your hand or a small child in your care when mention of WWE's use of the brand post-buyout ramps up. The poor cat might be getting kicked - it was here.
WWE from Vince McMahon and unreliable narrator Bruce Prichard (more on him momentarily) at the top table all the way down to former WCW Hardcore Champion Haku in a "Get It?!" t-shirt should still be hanging their heads in shame over the sh*t show that was the Invasion storyline. Instead, that was left to latter era Nitro standout and failed WWE prospect Mark Jindrak - who spoke as if he was being held at gunpoint.
Noting how his lot weren't used to "the culture" before calling his new boss "Mr Vince" in a mis-speak they cynically left in the edit, he was there to vindicate the narrative bullsh*t spewing forth about why the angle failed. Almost as if it's the job of the wrestling company with the monopoly they fought for to push the wrestlers, not least the ones that have only just arrived and don't know whether to sh*t or wind their watch in a locker room full of enemies.
Let's drill into that a bit more. The docuseries didn't...
9. Monday Sh*te Raw
Ask Bruce Prichard (and they had to with Vince McMahon apparently unavailable or not remotely a*sed about contributing to this pantomime spectacle masquerading as a documentary) and the WCW experiment failed because the talent weren't over, the fans weren't bothered and those two things simply couldn't be addressed.
To the crumb of truth in that sentiment - yes, WWE hadn't procured the full complement of Atlanta headliners and were left to make do with the bulk of the midcard alongside former World Champions Booker T and Diamond Dallas Page.
But how not bothered were the fans again? Well listen to all the boos for that Booker T/Buff Bagwell catastrophe, they were obviously not bothered. Just as they weren't bothered when the mere sight of a logo and a Hugh Morrus moonsault generated the pop of the show a week earlier. Or how the Invasion pay-per-view - 20 days removed from the Booker/Buff Raw stinker - was the most-bought "B" show in company history.
People really, really wanted it to work and we're so not not bothered by how much of a f*ck up that first swing was that they were still emotionally and financially invested in something proper.
Invested in something proper. Like the past...
8. HHHard Yards
There's probably going to be a lot of Triple H glorification in the bowels of this docuseries, but the first instance of it was one of the most egregious.
Across footage of Hulk Hogan's 2002 return and his historic WrestleMania X8 confrontation with The Rock, the documentary seemed to suggest that it was mere short-termism compared to the evocative and emotional end to the show as if 'The Game's win over Chris Jericho didn't play out to library silence in an era where the 'Grandaddy Of Em All' still only went four hours.
It was f*cking criminal, in truth. WWE were guilty of leaning in to nostalgia over something more secure and futureproof, and with Hogan, but half of that came explicitly during the era they were profiling for this series. No need to tie up loose ends if you don't create them in the first place, eh? Especially when there's an opportunity to put Hunter over again.
On that...
7. HHHarder Yards
Resembling the 2001 clip of William Regal planting a smacker on Vince McMahon's a*secheek, John Bradshaw Layfield was in vapid shill mode for most of this particular feature, and why not? Few benefited more from an era so bereft of talent that the bar was forever lowered than pub-brawler turned cod-Ted Dibiase JBL.
Amongst the dry babble was a note about how much pressure fell on the broad shoulders of The Undertaker and Triple H to carry the company in the absence of departing top stars Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock.
It's weird; there was half an insight in here about what it means to really be the top guy when the industry isn't making money hand over fist, but it was lost to saccharine sucking up. Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart weren't celebrated for labouring through the fiscally barren 1990s - they were vilified as internal introspection was done in an effort to find what Stone Cold Steve Austin eventually forced people to look for.
6. Fantasy Vs Reality
In Michael Rapaport, WWE has a literal unreliable narrator for the Ruthless Aggression docuseries, but he's at least just reading the script he's been paid to overenunciate. He leaves the meat of the story to both Bruce Prichard and Brian Gewirtz.
The difference in their tone and timbre is stark. Gewirtz is a man so gleefully and comfortably separated from the world he inhabited for so long that he can speak with a certain freedom on the realities of the situations without burying the company outright. Prichard, conversely, steers so hard in the other direction that it's hard not to imagine his entire memory not being tinted by his recent reintroduction to the fold.
Everything good he offers to his podcast is absent here - the convivial and cordial relationship with Conrad lost to a caricature of mouthpiece treading too carefully to say anything worthy of note. He was actually f*cking there - why does it feel like he's talking about the company he left in 2008?
5. Shooting For The Stars
There's some brutal honesty buried within the bullsh*t in at least one aspect of the show - WWE were definitely going to be in bother without Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock.
Twice, apparently.
Forgetting when and where they'd asked the audience for sympathy, the production team wildly assumed so little of the viewing public that they used occurrences in both 2002 and 2004 to big up the idea of a world without 'The Rattlesnake' and 'The Great One'.
This was sloppy, but also increasingly irrelevant. On the off chance this wasn't spotted by those that weren't watching at the time, the megastar revolving door is a concept the company has exploited for years now. It was a big deal the first time it happened, but more is always more and WWE simply couldn't help itself trying to heap even more praise for John Cena in his personal profile.
Cena, incidentally, was the best bit about his own show in Episode 2. He was the first to note that "Ruthless Aggression" meant sh*t all to his career in the grand scheme of things. He didn't need the closing qualifier.
4. TRuthless Aggression
Not to undermine the entire point of the project, but "Ruthless Aggression" was a naked attempt at marketing a phrase as effectively as "Attitude" (and to a lesser extent, "The New Generation") that didn't even actually take outside of the odd Vince McMahon ra-ra speech and John Cena's launch promo.
The docuseries inadvertently highlights this! A clip is used of Cena entering the 2003 Royal Rumble in his relatively new rapper persona, mocking the term as a way to disassociate himself from his original incarnation. The era's biggest star doesn't even want anything to do with it!
It's also woefully out of time - in the clip from a 2002 Raw that's used over and over again McMahon hoots and hollers like a f*cking pillock for one of his browbeaten wrestlers to grab brass rings and show Ruthless Aggression but he's actually asking them to grab him a coffee and kiss his *ss. He bought his competition and made them job scared - how exactly can one subscribe to a philosophy when billionaire operating the controls has set them up to fail it?
3. Gratitude Era
It was quite refreshing hearing Brian Gewirtz note that much of the post-2001 output was Attitude Era-lite - the sort of sh*te that happened because the creative team were looking for excuses to be puerile rather than letting the purility occur organically.
It was an honest appraisal off the best and worst bits of the era, basically. And there was far, far too much of the latter in the Ruthless Aggression era...which this series' confusing timeline appeared to position as being bottlenecked between November 2001 and April 2002. Using clips going as far forward as 2004.
B*llocks on top of bullsh*t - half of the so-called better days the docuseries spoke (lied) about were from the exact period they were criticising. The Ruthless Aggression era, they were arguing, was somehow the fix for itself.
2. Shut The F Up
Thank you, World Wrestling Entertainment, for teaching us the very important and accurate history lesson that is about the time in 2002 when, entirely on his own, with no outside pressure, Vince McMahon changed the name of the WWF to WWE.
— David Bixenspan (@davidbix) February 17, 2020
Just breathtaking.#RuthlessAggression pic.twitter.com/4FBUrGqmvs
The most egregious of fabrications - so much so that the above clip went viral within seconds of the show launching on the WWE Network - came as Vince McMahon's so-called creative genius was responsible for the WWE's 2002 name change. Not a lawsuit they lost handily thanks to the relentless breaking of an agreement made years earlier.
The World Wrestling Federation shared initials with the World Wildlife Fund for many years as per a deal in which McMahon wouldn't hammer the "WWF" brand too hard. Until he did, almost immediately after settling the dispute.
2002 was the culmination of a legal battle the company were never going to win (nor did they deserve to) that spoke to the Chairman's stubbornness more than some sort of magic power or foresight.
It's thought that if you tell a lie long enough and loud enough it will eventually become true. This overreach appears to be the most recent case of the winners writing their own history but (and doesn't this sound familiar) over-scripting to a fault. Nobody believed this, and those that even questioned it immediately discovered the truth.
1. Was F For Federation, Or Fix...
...because despite Gary from Friends' best efforts on narration, business didn't magically pick up immediately after splitting the brands and getting Vince McMahon to scream in Booker T's face or whatever f*ck the first episode was daring to suggest.
Plenty of things worked to a point, some worked very well, but enough didn't to the point where ratings were never recovered to Attitude Era highs and buyrates were solely dependent on temporary spikes from the likes of Cena, Batista et al or the type of gimmick match that eventually became the overblown theme of the show. Even the established ones faced the axe - Survivor Series' numbers almost convinced McMahon to bin off the fan favourite event after years of under-performance during this supposedly fruitful period.
Fantasist bullsh*t, the lot of it. Watchable, fascinating fantastic bullsh*t. An absolute mess.
Here's to next week's episode!