12 Ups & 0 Downs From AEW X NJPW Forbidden Door
Claudio Castagnoli debuts, Jon Moxley becomes interim World Champion, AEW & NJPW kill it.
The build for All Elite Wrestling and New Japan Pro Wrestling's first collaborative pay-per-view was suboptimal, for reasons outwith and within the promoters' control.
Injuries robbing the companies of CM Punk, Bryan Danielson, Hiromu Takahashi, Tomohiro Ishii, and more (including one of the architects of the Forbidden Door movement, Kenny Omega) can't be helped - and AEW has pivoted before. Lest we forget Jon Moxley's bout of MRSA prior to All Out 2019. Zack Sabre Jr.'s mystery opponent aside, that the substitutes weren't going to be Ishii and Punk sucked, but what was the promotion to do?
Nonetheless, fast-forwarded half-angles masquerading as storylines meant even the card's more established pairings fell flat. Kazuchika Okada, one of the greatest wrestlers of all time with a once-in-a-generation megastar aura, debuted in a t-shirt and track pants. Debates on whether or not AEW needed another men's singles title diluted the stacked All-Atlantic Championship four-way discourse. Hangman Page and Okada ended up in a multi-man when a singles bout (and an alternative IWGP Title fight for Jay White) looked the more interesting choice.
The list of avoidable issues continues.
But in the end, Forbidden Door didn't need a great build to stand as the best wrestling pay-per-view of 2022 so far. This show was fantastic in spite of the weeks leading up to it.
Let's light the fuse...
12. Swerve & Lee Highlight The Buy In
If the Buy In pre-show is to serve as a last-minute way of convincing would-be customers to part coin for the pay-per-view, Swerve In Our Glory's victory over Suzuki-gun provided the bulk of the argument.
Built primarily around El Desperado and Yoshinobu Kanemaru attempting to neutralise Keith Lee by targeting his legs, it saw the former NXT Champion and Swerve Strickland overcome their recent issues and their opponents when Kanemaru ate a Big Bang Catastrophe while his partner was out of the picture. Afterwards, Ricky Starks and Powerhouse Hobbs spat fire on the microphone, challenging their rivals to another match.
Hirooki Goto and YOSHI-HASHI looked good in their win over The Factory's QT Marshall and Aaron Solo to kick things off. Elsewhere, Lance Archer vs. Nick Comoroto was occasionally awkward and comprised primarily of two gigantic men bashing into each other, while Gunn Club's streak as the undercard's most gleefully obnoxious bell-end group continued in a TV-calibre bout pitting them and Max Caster against an LA Dojo crew.
Though lacking in anything that would rival the main card, the Buy In was a gentle net positive, thanks, primarily, to Swerve and Lee. Their AEW pairing has proven an inspired choice thus far.
11. Holy Shibata
While Forbidden Door's other surprise appearance could have been seen a mile away by a blind man, Katsuyori Shibata's arrival was totally unforeseen, blowing the roof off the United Center as a result.
Last seen working LA Dojo student Ren Narita in his first true wrestling match in close to five years at Wrestle Kingdom 16, Shibata came to fight. United Empire had set upon Orange Cassidy following his defeat to Will Ospreay. Rocky Romero and Trent Beretta failed in their attempted save, setting the stage for New Japan's ultimate head-kicker, who came out in fight shorts, ready to maim.
Aussie Open were downed before Ospreay found himself trapped in a rear naked choke. Fortunately for the Englishman, Kyle Fletcher and Mark Davis saved further damage by getting him out of the ring, with Ospreay vs. Shibata now very much on the table.
An unexpected, delightful surprise here. Shibata getting physical remains one of the most cathartic things in modern wrestling given his near-death experience (and miraculous comeback from) wrestling Kazuchika Okada in April 2017. That Chicago received him with such reverence proves, once again, that those spitting outdated "casual fan" rhetoric around these events are out of touch with reality.
10. Thunder Rosa & Toni Storm Keep It Tight & Technical
Thunder Rosa has had an eventful few weeks amid reports of backstage discontent and allegations of sandbagging. The latter has since been squashed with literal bread breaking, though concerns over her screentime appear to have been alleviated in recent weeks, with the Women's World Champion's focus improving in the face of a difficult month or so surrounding Double Or Nothing 2022.
She felled Toni Storm in one of the better matches of her reign at Forbidden Door. Crisp, tight, and tidy, the duo immediately demonstrated a high calibre of work in their initially respectful opening exchanges, before Storm starched Rosa with a slap to the face, bringing out a more competitive, fiery spirit in both women. Thunder Rosa continued to embrace Dustin Rhodes as her mentor by once again employing some of the former Goldust's signature offense, including his Final Reckoning finisher for the win.
Though the finish came abruptly and could have benefitted from coming after a more dramatic closing stretch, this was nonetheless a very good match between two very good wrestlers. Really, this is the kind of bout AEW should be doing more of in the women's division: an all-star showdown between two established veterans.
9. FTR Takes All
FTR's glittering, gold-paved 2022 continued with their IWGP World Tag Team Title win over Roppongi Vice and United Empire's Jeff Cobb and Great-O-Khan, with this latest triumph meaning Cash Wilder and Dax Harwood now simultaneously hold ROH, AAA, and NJPW's top straps. Presumably, the perennial contenders will now look to cement their near-complete industry dominance by challenging for familiar foes The Young Bucks' AEW World Tag Team Championships in the not-too-distant future.
Dax and Cash deserve it. Now operating at a level above even their NXT vintage, in tag and singles matches, they have comfortably been the world's best tag team in 2022. These title runs are just rewards for two master craftsmen hell-bent on going down as all-time greats in their chosen field.
Harwood was tremendous here, working a fake shoulder injury into the bout without disrupting its flow, leaving Wheeler to fend for himself for extended stretches. Re-emerging to a great reception late one, Dax's absence allowed Great-O-Khan, in particular, to shine while he was away, though the Big Rig on Romero ended up scoring FTR the victory.
8. Dudes With Attitudes Prevail In Different Kind Of Banger
The irritating thing about Dudes With Attitudes' win over Bullet Club is that the match would have been even more fun if not for Hiromu Takahashi's pull-out, which prompted AEW and NJPW to pull Hikuleo from the bout and make it a trios clash. One of the most arresting, dynamic wrestlers on the planet, Hiromu would have added insanity to an insanely fun, expertly laid-out clash that effectively served as a great palate cleanser ahead of the meatier action to come at Forbidden Door.
This was a riot. A hoot. A blast. Pick your favourite word for "a really good time" and apply it here, because it was almost certainly that.
Sting began the bout by DIVING OFF THE ENTRANCE TUNNEL and onto the Bullet Club team, who were total pricks throughout. The Young Bucks and El Phantasmo were in full-on troll mode for delayed, over-acted back-rake spots on Darby Allin in the corner, bringing the pantomime. Shingo Takagi kept things stiff and straight-faced, ensuring the bout stayed grounded in competitiveness, and what else can be said about Sting in AEW that hasn't already been covered a thousand times before? The man is a marvel. His signature no-sell spots are given extra weight now that we know how banged up he has been over the past few years - and saying "nope!" to the Jackson brothers' tandem superkicks drew one of his loudest AEW pops yet.
Takagi's Made in Japan finished El Phantasmo off not long after Allin had downed Hikuleo with a Coffin Drop to the outside.
7. Injury Sullies (But Doesn't Ruin) IWGP World Title Match
AEW's injury crisis deepened in the IWGP World Heavyweight Title match, as Adam Cole went down during his four-way clash with 'Switchblade' Jay White, Kazuchika Okada, and 'Hangman' Adam Page.
It happened during the finish. Cole looked like he was ducking away from Okada's Rainmaker attempt. Initially, he appeared to be selling a move that didn't connect as he hit the canvas, which made for awkward viewing as White pinned him after putting Okada out of the conversation. The Undisputed Elite member had essentially fallen over and lost, though news of his injury makes this both understandable and forgivable. All the best to Cole in his recovery.
The match was a ton of fun prior to this. Starting off at a moderate pace before exploding into an exciting big move buffet late on, it preserved Page, who appeared to have victory within his grasp on several occasions and wasn't directly involved in the finish. Circumstances aside, White benefits as a sneaky heel stealing a pinfall from a tough situation too, having played up his status as the least trustworthy person on the planet by tugging at his complicated relationship with Cole throughout.
6. Finally, PAC
One of Forbidden Door's most pleasing moments came from PAC, who finally scored his first championship in the company by becoming its first All-Atlantic Champion, felling Miro, Malakai Black, and Clark Connors for the honour.
Whether or not AEW needed another men's singles championship is a worthy debate. Nonetheless, PAC deserves this moment in the sun. An incredibly talented wrestler whose precision and timing are unmatched in modern wrestling, he has, over the past few years, appeared only in fits and starts. That he frequently travels between the United Kingdom and United States makes him a hard guy to push despite his obvious skull. Something may have now changed in this regard.
PAC's win came following a great four-way. Miro, the pre-match favourite, was neutralised by Malakai Black's mist, putting him out of contention. Black then looked to submit Connors, which let 'The Bastard' soar down with the 450 splash, nailing both men before tapping Clark out with the Brutalizer.
Connors deserves a nod here. Him replacing the injured Tomohiro Ishii attracted groans from many, though he showed out big time at Forbidden Door. Seemingly driven by a desire to prove his doubters wrong, Connors was on fire, demonstrating pure 'Wild Rhino' spirit in his pulse-pounding moments on top.
5. A Fireworks Show With An Emphasis On FIRE
Give Shota Umino his flowers today.
Once tipped as a future New Japan Pro Wrestling megastar, the young protege suffered greatly in the pandemic. Stranded in the United Kingdom, where he was on excursion pre-COVID, Jon Moxley's young violent son lost his conditioning and charisma in return appearances for RevPro, looking a husk of the bright-eyed prospect he looked before the break. It took a long, long time for him to relight the fire, too, with even his 16 April Windy City Riot showing opposite Jay White suggesting Umino had much work to do to regain ground lost to fellow NJPW prodigies Yuya Uemura, Ren Narita, and more.
At Forbidden Door, Umino was the standard performer in a match featuring Minoru Suzuki, Chris Jericho, and Eddie Kingston. The 25-year-old was incredible here. Riding the lighting from start to finish, he was an intense, pulse-pounding, Hiroshi Tanahashi-like presence, with his late-match flurries and defiant last stand enough to put arm hairs on end.
Umino was ultimately felled, giving the Jericho Appreciation Society Blood and Guys advantage for Wednesday. Overall, it was a bruising, attritional twist on the show-opening bomb-fest format, sacrificing nothing in intensity while delivering on all the huge, poppable moments AEW likes to pull out in this spot.
4. Will Ospreay Justifies His Reputation
Forbidden Door saw Will Ospreay enter the kind of performance that makes it easy to see why he is generally considered amongst the best in the world.
Opposite Orange Cassidy, Ospreay was at his repugnant best, successfully imparting hyper-athleticism, psychology, and his fantastic "obnoxious British person in a foreign land" character in one of the night's most impressive matches. Where once the United Empire's heel persona represented a tired Conor McGregor knockoff, this is no longer the case. Ospreay has made this role his own. You see it when he mockingly stuffs his own hands into Cassidy's pockets, lets himself fall for OC's tricks by reacting scornfully to those deliberately soft kicks, and walks the ring like a chihuahua with a ten-inch member.
Cassidy was tremendous here too. His schtick never gets tiring because he is continually evolving, always thinking of fresh spots and new ways to keep things interesting. Yes, he puts his hands in his pockets and uses insultingly weak strikes in every match, though his Eddie Guerrero tribute spot was genuinely inspired here. Luring Ospreay in by pretending to be injured when his back was turned, the moment was made even more electric when Will looked like he had countered it, flipping around OC several times, then ultimately ate a Beach Break.
Ospreay won, successfully defending the IWGP United States Championship. Juice Robinson and Katsuyori Shibata both took aim at him on this show, giving him a fresh set of matches to enhance his already strong Wrestler of the Year case.
3. A Technical Wrestling Masterclass
Continuing to emphasise Zack Sabre Jr.'s Forbidden Door match as a quest to find the best technical wrestler in the world after Bryan Danielson's pull-out telegraphed Claudio Castagnoli's insertion into the pay-per-view. Nonetheless, this did nothing to hamper the moment. Sometimes in wrestling, the predictable option is the best option, and the response Claudio received in Chicago shows this was the case in his AEW debut.
The match was as great as you'd expect. Castagnoli kicked it off by posing with AEW's mystery masked cameraman, addressing rumours that he was behind the veil, then ignited the crowd by smashing ZSJ with a forearm and the Neutralizer as soon as the bell rang. From there, an A-grade technical wrestling bout unfolded between the ropes, with Claudio's early dominance prompting Sabre Jr. to target his arm, theoretically taking some of the powerhouse's biggest weapons away from him.
This appeared to be working when Castagnoli was forced to abandon an attempted giant swing later on. Chicago was baying for the move at points, but Claudio stayed true to the story, not employing its full power until much later in the night, when he'd had reasonable time to recover.
A Swiss Death uppercut and powerbomb ended Sabre's night. Ultimately, Castagnoli's power game proved too much, even with one of his limbs in pieces, which made the Swiss star look like a million dollars.
More on him later.
2. A Crowd Control Masterclass
The indomitable babyface power of Hiroshi Tanahashi will never die.
Even now, with his body breaking down and his main event schedule lessening, New Japan's Ace is one of the best in the world at generating sympathy and drama in a big spot. Here, he helped turn an AEW crowd against Jon Moxley, who has been one of the easiest wrestlers in the world to root for since returning from rehab, embarking on a second-to-none Wrestler of the Year crusade as a modern-day folk hero.
Moxley leaned into this fluid dynamic. He was genuinely nasty against Tanahashi, whom he has been trying to get a piece of for a long, long time. When a King Kong Lariat yielded only a one-count, Mox responded by furiously bashing his elbow into Tana's skull over and over and over, generating jeers for him and chants for his venerable opponent. Prior to this, he beat the Ace up on the outside and sent him through a table, with Tanahashi only beating the ten-count by the skin of his teeth.
Respect was almost restored when Moxley and Tanahashi came within a hair of shaking hands following Mox's win, though the Jericho Appreciation Society put an end to that.
The right outcome and one many would have predicted prior to the show, but the match was of a strong enough calibre to generate doubt nonetheless. That's a kind of pro wrestling magic few, if any, are able to conjure like Tanahashi. His mind for what does and doesn't work will never dull.
1. Claudio The Centrepiece
Claudio Castagnoli was the absolute centrepiece on his first night in All Elite Wrestling, giving the impression that the hyper-talented Swiss star is set to be rocket-strapped and sent to the moon after years of chasing such a push in WWE.
Forbidden Door's closing angle cemented this. Already glittering after his great match with Zack Sabre Jr., Claudio was at the heart of Blackpool Combat Club, Eddie Kingston, Santana, and Ortiz gaining ground on the Jericho Appreciation Society. His signature uppercut cloudburst cleared enough space for the crowd-popping giant swing on Angelo Parker, who must have rotated over two-dozen times before eventually going down, gratifying the crowd after being denied of the move in the ZSJ bout.
Following this angle, viewers were left in no doubt as to who the MVP of Forbidden Door was.
Castagnoli, by all accounts, didn't want to leave WWE. He appeared happy there despite the consistent push many argued his prodigious in-ring talents warranted. Though he always shone when given a big spotlight, Claudio was content, it seemed, to exist on the midcard, stepping up only for the occasional main event. The brass ring is a mythical Stamfordian concept tied to outdated perceptions of what it takes to be a modern wrestling star. It was never to be his, but Castagnoli was cool with that.
At Forbidden Door, this changed. Wrestling vs. Sports Entertainment is a tired argument but the differences in AEW and WWE's approaches are clear. Claudio was The Man on a major pay-per-view here. There's a good chance he will now be The Man in this week's Blood and Guts match, too - and it's nothing less than what he deserves.