12 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite: Bash At The Beach (Jan 15)

In which Jon Moxley inexplicably becomes a pirate.

Last's week's Dynamite may have been the worst of the show's three-month run by a wide margin, but AEW still cruised to ratings success with an impressive 947,000 viewers tuning in.

That this misfiring show drew such a solid number was a product of strong promotion and momentum. Not only was the episode well advertised and marketed, but it came on the back of a lauded New Year's Day show and retained much of that excellent night's audience. It'll therefore be interesting to see how last night's Bash at the Beach special does; this was a vastly superior show, but how many of those 947,000 will have been driven away by the previous week's shortcomings?

Regardless, Bash at the Beach was loads of fun. Boasting a different lock, a stacked lineup of matches (PAC vs. Darby Allin, Sammy Guevara vs. Jon Moxley, and more) as well as Cody finally responding to MJF's ridiculous demands, Dynamite promised a lot and generally delivered - though it wasn't without a few major problems.

A roster buoyed by yesterday's good news (largely) delivered when it mattered. Let's run through its successes, failures, and everything in between...


Downs...

4. Recruitment Drive

Dark Order Man
AEW

This week's Dark Order segment saw their motivational speaker/spin doctor stood on a darkened room, presenting an update on the group's ongoing recruitment drive to their apparent "Exalted One." Michael Nakazawa, Brandon Cutler, Kenny Omega, and Hangman Page were amongst their targets, with the Order taking additional steps to acquire them, but while the first two make sense (the group are all about taking advantage of down-on-their-luck losers), Omega and Page? Really? These guys just earned a Tag Team Title shot. They don't fit the group's remit.

A well-produced segment here, but the act is done. Stick a fork in it. "The Exalted One' speaking on a goofy B-movie EVIL VILLAIN PERSON voice didn't help matters either and while last year's indoctrination vignettes were decent, the damage done to The Dark Order in recent angles has now rendered their position untenable.


3. Forgotten Feuds

PAC IS A SCARY MAN
AEW

A big flaw in AEW's storytelling mechanism is the promotion's tendency to start a feud one week, then randomly forget about it soon after. They do this all the time. It's frustrating, and something WWE are lambasted for all the time, so the same criticisms need to be applied here.

Remember when Dustin Rhodes was "out for blood" in his war with Jake Hager, who broke his arm? We've had a brawl or two since then and nothing else. Is this even still an ongoing storyline? If so, why has Dustin moved on without resolving it?

PAC stretched Michael Nakazawa to the point of unconsciousness to try and goad Kenny Omega into a rubber match last week. Sure, both men have other targets to aim for at the moment, but how about a little follow-up?

It's a similar story with Joey Janela, who appeared to brush Kip Sabian and Penelope Ford off before challenging Rey Fenix last night.

The Elite's issues with The Inner Circle have never been explored to a satisfactory degree. The same goes for their beef with The Dark Order.

If these stories are still ongoing then the bookers haven't done the best job of keeping them bubbling away in the background. Rather than delivering incremental escalations before resuming them full-time, it feels like they've been forgotten about.


2. Production Problems... Again

Jon Moxley car
AEW

We keep bringing this up every single week so yes, it probably isn't the most exciting thing to read about anymore, but the production issues blighting AEW's televised product keep rearing their head. When they do, it's only fair that they're pointed out.

Jon Moxley's entrance music not playing through the TV mixing desk after driving his car into the arena was odd, and Justin Roberts' microphone came in mid-sentence as 'The Death Rider' was on his way to the ring. When Chris Jericho cut his promo on Mox, the microphone cut in and out, resulting in a choppy feed. Maddeningly, the producers went screen-in-screen for MJF's match-winning pin on QT Marshall. Backstage segments still feel low-rent.

Producing live television sounds like a tough, tough job, but NXT isn't making these mistakes - and that's the show Dynamite should be compared to every week. On a production level, the comparison isn't flattering AEW at times.


1. A Nightmare

Mel Brandi Rhodes
AEW

Is the nightmare over?

Mel and Brandi Rhodes lost to Kris Statlander and Hikaru Shida last night, suggesting a demotion. It's unlikely that they'll remove The Nightmare Collective from TV entirely, of course, but perhaps this shows that AEW is about to ease off on the group after recent criticisms.

Or maybe that's just wishful thinking on the critics' behalf. We'll find out soon.

Either way, the match didn't work. Statlander and Shida tried really, really hard to lull the crowd from their slumber but were only moderately successful. It was like the atmosphere was sucked out of the building from the moment this thing started and while Mel may have promise as a heel powerhouse in this (largely) undersized division, her work was clunky. Brandi, meanwhile, looked very much like an underseasoned wrestler working only her third match in 12 months - which is exactly what she is.

Rhodes admonishing Mel (who ate the pin) after the bell is an interesting hook and Shida smashing Dr. Luther out of the way on her ring entrance was fun. The babyfaces' efforts have to be appreciated as well, but this didn't hit.


Ups...

12. What A Beauty

AEW Bash at the Beach
AEW

Jim Ross tweeted a video of Miami's Watsco Center looking very bare and very ordinary on Tuesday evening, giving the impression that Dynamite's Bash at the Beach special would go down without a cool set design. Fortunately, those concerns were premature, as while AEW didn't quite go all-in on the concept, they at least put significant effort into playing to the theme and making the episode look and feel distinct.

Wrestling is an aesthetic business as much as a lot of other things, and Bash at the Beach looked lovely. The neon colour palette, Miami Vice-style logo, prop-laden stage, and Justin Roberts decked out in a cream shirt and trousers like a dad on holiday provided the window dressing. The entrance tunnels were flanked by sand, too. It was class.

Perhaps the show itself could've played to the aesthetic a little more, though this may have provoked criticism for being too gimmicky. A gentle Up here regardless.


11. New Year, New 'Bad Boy'

Joey Janela
AEW

Joey Janela looked a lot more comfortable in this week's promo than he has in previous segments. Though 'The Bad Boy' has plenty of physical charisma, he's still finding his feet as a weekly TV wrestler - and this was a sign of progress.

Solid stuff from Janela here. He said 2020 was a new year, a clean slate, and a fresh decade for him, then spoke on his ex-girlfriend, Penelope Ford, low-blowing him the other week. The only way Ford could get over was on his name, Janela claimed, then ripped Kip Sabian, before saying his record wasn't should have been in 2019. 2020 is when everything changes, however, and that's why he challenged Rey Fenix.

Janela's work will never be for everyone and his mere presence is always going to irritate viewers of certain preferences, which is fine. Taste is subjective. Still, there was enough here to warrant an Up. A tidy promo from Joey, and that Fenix match should rip.


10. FINALLY

Cody Wardlow
AEW

Wardlow has been on AEW's books since his first vignette aired at All Out. That was the best part of five months ago and now, finally, we're getting his first singles match, with Cody confirmed as his opponent for 19 February.

It's overdue. While well-cast as MJF's suit-clad Rick Rude expy, we've been yearning to see what this big beefy boy can do for a while - particularly as the current AEW roster is as meaty as a vegan buffet. The prospect of seeing him tangle with AEW's best in-ring storyteller in a goddamn cage match is very exciting indeed, so here's hoping he gets a few dominant squashes to warm up for it.

Time to see what this beefer can do.


9. Liquid Courage

Hangman Page SCU
AEW

Hangman Page drunkenly stumbling into SoCal Uncensored's backstage promo may seem like a minor segment, but AEW accomplished plenty here.

Christopher Daniels, Frankie Kazarian, and Scorpio Sky were obviously p*ssed off at the interruption. This gives the bout a nice slice to heat to jazz it up a little. On top of this, it furthers the slow-burning Page heel turn by having him behave like a booze-addled *sshole, and Kenny Omega coming in to play peacekeeper, talk Hangman out of trouble, and insist the two teams have a "gentlemen's contest" gives him another legitimate reason to be peeved with Page's recent behaviour.

When a segment this short can further so many plot points at once, it's an easy Up. This thing was economical as hell


8. Dads Fall In Valiant Effort

MJF AEW
AEW

A supplemental Up for MJF's wonderfully crude and immature "I banged Dallas' daughter" t-shirt. Man's a piece of trash.

'The Salt of the Earth' teamed with The Butcher and The Blade to face QT Marshall, Diamond Dallas Page, and Dustin Rhodes in a well-played, well-paced clash of bastards vs. overmatched sentimental favourites. Sympathy was key here. QT Marshall isn't all that good but works really hard, DDP is 63 years old, and Dustin Rhodes is the most sympathetic man on the roster. Realistically, the didn't stand a chance against the younger, stronger, more athletic heel trio, but they tried - and that's what it's all about.

Dustin carried most of the water here. A wise move, as he's the best worker on that side, and the build to DDP's hot tag was nicely done. Page ran wild for about a minute and it worked a lot better than it did in last week's segment. In the context of a match, with fatigue and chaos both in-play, it's a lot easier to believe the old fella getting his spots in. He did well.

That MJF scored the pin while a replay was happening was a pain in the *ss, but the bout worked. It was fun, well laid-out, and just the right length, with the heels emerging as rightful winners.


7. 'Le Champion' Being 'Le Champion'

Chris Jericho
AEW

It'd take a disaster of intergalactic proportions for a Chris Jericho promo to not finish on the Ups side and 'Le Champion' was in good form last night, throwing all kinds of poppable lines out as his Inner Circle met with Jenn Decker.

Regarding stabbing Moxley in the eye, Jericho said that after last week, all of this was on Mox. The former Dean Ambrose signed his own death warrant when he screwed with the Inner Circle, his own reckless abandon put him in that position, adding that he's going to keep an eye out for Moxley... because Jon's only got one left.

Next week, 'The Alpha' promised to do the same thing to Jungle Boy and Jurassic Express. "See you there, Moxley, even if you can't see us," was his sign-off, before Jake Hager arrrrrr'd like a bloody pirate and Sammy Guevara left Decker with a "hit me up," the scuzzbucket.

Not exactly the most substantial Jericho promo, but entertaining nonetheless.


6. Relighting The Fuse

Jon Moxley
AEW

Jon Moxley is the perfect guy to book immediately after an atmosphere-destroying match like The Nightmare Collective vs. Statlander and Shida because the man's so goddamn electric. He's a kinetic bad*ss so brimming with bellicose energy that he can turn almost any building around, and that's pretty much what he did opposite Sammy Guevara.

Enhanced by the wrinkle of last week's Inner Circle betrayal, the match was a hoot. Moxley showed up in his shiny new car (a moment that could've only been better if the thing was a rolling wreck, though it's hard to see Shahid Khan, the owner, consenting) before coming through the crowd. Guevara, meanwhile, flirted with Vanessa Hudgens via cue cards while Dynamite ran commercials. Both entrances are becoming important parts of their respective characters.

A nice moment saw Guevara eat crow for that spot that sees him climb the top rope, only to come down and slap his opponent's face. Moxley popped up on him, surprising the 'Spanish God,' who later nailed Mox with a Meteora on the apron and brained a box of popcorn off his head.

Guevara looked great in defeat. Allowed to showcase his skills and character, his recent winning streak came to an end when Moxley trapped him in a rear-naked choke, rather than hitting his usual Paradigm Shift. A smart move, and another avenue to victory in future matches, provided Moxley established the choke as his thing.


5. No Surrender

Tony Schiavone PAC
AEW

Jon Moxley's display of pure bad*ssery in Dynamite's closing stages ruled, with the busted-up 'Purveyor Of Violence' powering out of an ambulance, bandaged and bloodied, saying that he didn't care if he was blind: he'd be there to fight PAC next week, because the AEW World Championship shot has his name on it.

It came from a typically gruff PAC promo that saw 'The Bastard' growl that there was no way Moxley could compete against him next week after the Inner Circle's brawl. He insisted on a forfeiture, then promised Jericho he was coming for him, all in his harsh Geordie brogue.

Over-relying on staredowns to build matches and storylines is a product of laziness, but it felt right here. AEW don't run angles like this every single week, after all, and PAC and Moxley have pre-existing beef from their TV time limit draw on Dynamite's 23 October episode to lean on as well.


4. Eye For An Eye

Chris Jericho
AEW

Chris Jericho and The Inner Circle were always going to clap back at Jon Moxley after the previous week's betrayal - and they did so in suitably brutish style last night.

Moxley was in the ring after defeating Sammy Guevara. "Judas" hit, the lights dimmed, and the entire heel faction were in the ring when they came back on. Moxley threw himself into the fire but was picked apart almost immediately. Ground down by Jake Hager then Jericho, Moxley was kicked in the d*ck, whipped by 'Le Champion's' belt, then stabbed in the f*ckin' eye by a spike from Jericho's ridiculous jacket. A weighty, impactful moment, and the announcers did a great job of putting it over.

The Inner Circle relented as a group of referees and a medic descended to take care of Moxley. They'd done their damage, though Mox's retribution will be swift and brutal. This feud just got a whole lot more personal and while Jon still has to get through PAC, one can only imagine the kind of violent delights him and Jericho are going to inflict on one another over the next few weeks.


3. Cody Calls MJF's Bluff

Cody AEW
AEW

Shout-outs to Cody dressing like a member of the Miami Vice cast for his in-ring promo. Don Johnson, eat your heart out.

'The American Nightmare' drew a great response as he came out to respond to MJF's stipulations. He said that when he asked for his rival's rather expensive price, it was an act of indignance and self-righteousness, then ran through the stipulations one by one. The Wardlow match was, he noted, an attempt at softening up, but twisted it by claiming MJF was worried the audience would realise he was the one who should be carrying Wardlow's bags when they see the beefcake in the action - not the other way around.

As for those 10 lashings? No problem, apparently, because MJF is doolally if he thinks that's the worst thing that'll happen during their feud, and Cody has no problem with the "no contact" clause either - because he knows Friedman is stalling.

Tremendous delivery, great lines ("you go for less because you're incapable of more"), and logical, this was a home run. Deep down, MJF doesn't really want to wrestle Cody. He threw these absurd stipulations down in the belief that 'The American Nightmare' would never accept them, but Cody called his bluff by doing just that, putting himself back in the driving seat in the process. MJF must now react to that. Having Wardlow Chokeslam Cody off the side of Chris Jericho's big silly boat would be a great start...

Obviously don't do that, Cody might die. But still.


2. Screwball Scramble

Nothing on last night's show will spark more debate than the opener, which showcased everything tag team traditionalists hate about AEW's duos scene in 16 blurry minutes.

In that regard, it was the most lucha libre thing AEW has booked in weeks, with fluid, fast-moving action, little sense of order, and pops prioritised over psychology - though there were still a couple of neat story points. Fortunately, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. If you hate the chaotic house style, that's fair, but this columnist got a huge kick out of the pure sugar rush.

The bout played out as if all eight participants had scoffed a massive bag of candy prior to hitting the ring, with high spots and double-team moves aplenty. Santana and Ortiz stepped in to spoil the fun at various points, drawing heat in the process, and the crowd lapped everything up. They were into it from Trent and Nick Jackson's opening exchanges all the way to Hangman Page and Kenny Omega's V-Trigger/Buckshot combo finisher, showing that the wrestlers did their jobs.

Most of the intrigue comes from the Page/Omega pairing, once again, with Page stealing the pinfall from his partner, and The Young Bucks not best pleased either, having done the heavy lifting only for Hangman and Kenny to sneak in for the victory. More seeds of dissent within The Elite, but how much longer can Omega keep playing peacemaker?


1. Come Grind With Me

PAC Darby Allin
AEW

While some fans may have preferred the opener's cocaine hit, Darby Allin vs. PAC was an excellent slice of TV wrestling and, as you are reading, the night's biggest Up.

This was exactly what it should have been. Darby is the perfect guy for PAC to just torture for 12 minutes because of their contrasting spirits and styles. 'The Bastard' is a nasty, grinding menace who doesn't always get the credit he deserves for making his slow, methodical control segments genuinely interesting to watch, peppering his bouts with only flurries of his prodigious athleticism to avoid too many pops. Allin, meanwhile, is a great ragdoll bumper, a sympathetic seller, and has believable avenues back into the match through his propulsive offense. Much of this bout was him hurling his little body around to combat PAC's stifling onslaught, including a top rope Crucifix Bomb and Coffin Drop to the outside.

Where those bursts of life enough? No. They weren't.

PAC's ring generalship was greater than Allin's hard-to-kill survivability that night, and 'The Bastard' punched his number one contender's ticket with the Black Arrow. A ruthless, meticulous villain, the Brit is purist's delight.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.