12 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Full Gear
Moxley & Omega erupts into a bloody storm as Cody goes for the heartstrings.
Numbers can be deceiving when it comes to the Ups and Downs format.
While a quick glance at this article's title may suggest All Elite Wrestling's Full Gear was a great-to-excellent pay-per-view, this isn't quite the case. Yes, the show had a handful of staggering highs, but most of what the night offered wasn't anything close to blow-away, with the flaws fewer in number, but weightier individually. This was a good pay-per-view, subjectively, rather than a great one.
Cody challenged for Chris Jericho's AEW World Championship in a dramatic "main event" that concluded in the most gut-wrenching fashion, yielding a game-changing post-match angle in the process. They were followed by a grisly Kenny Omega vs. Jon Moxley Lights Out clash sure to divide the internet, though its biggest spots will never leave the memory of anyone who witnessed want went down, no matter what they thought of the bout as a whole.
Elsewhere, pupil met teacher as AEW Women's Champion Riho defended against Emi Sakura, The Young Bucks battled Pride and Powerful in the opener, Hangman Page and PAC looked to settle their long-running beef, and a lot more.
Let's light the fuse...
Downs...
5. Brandi & Kong Take A Scalp
The ongoing Brandi Rhodes Is A Mad Goth Now saga rumbled on after Britt Baker vs. Bea Priestley, with AEW's Chief Brand Officer leading her charge, Awesome Kong, to the ring decked out in a big goth dress to big goth music and big goth lightning, with Kong destroying the defeated Priestley with a spinning backfist and Implant Buster, then slicing off a lock of her hair to add to a belt full of similar samples.
Rhodes is a fine valet and her managing Kong makes sense, but this change of direction isn't resonating so far. The warm, affable businesswoman who presents a cooking show from her home kitchen has become an obsessive wackjob overnight. She's charismatic enough to make it work long-term, but for now, it's not having the desired effect.
Brandi's new character needed more time. The switch needed to be a gradual one to get over early, and AEW now face an uphill battle to right the course.
4. Jim Ross Takes The Night Off
This drum has been beaten many times in this column throughout AEW's lifespan so we'll spare you a lengthy word count here, but Jim Ross wasn't good at Full Gear. At all.
This might have been the legendary announcer's worst performance for the promotion. Sat alongside Excalibur in a two-man booth, he was curmudgeonous, unengaged, and largely detrimental to the product. There were only a handful of moments throughout the entire pay-per-view where he sounded genuinely locked in. For most of it, he was doing a poor job of masking his distaste for modern wrestling styles, highlighting errors rather than hiding them, mispronouncing names ("Amy Sakura"), failing to recognise moves he's been calling forever (the Alabama Slam), and arguing with Ex. It was, unfortunately, a mess.
Ross is doing more to harm than help the product at the moment. It's a serious problem, and must be addressed if AEW is to push forward with the current announcing personnel.
3. Styles Clash Falls Flat
Shawn Spears vs. Joey Janela was a solid little wrestling that tried to present itself as a styles clash, though this ultimately worked against it. Spears and Janela were working from different playbooks. 'The Chairman' is a grinding WWE-style Sports Entertainer, while 'The Bad Boy' is a hard-bumping daredevil. This could've created a compelling dynamic if their styles had meshed, but they didn't, and there wasn't enough crowd heat to take it to the next level either.
Janela flung his body around with the same reckless abandon present in most of his matches, creating most of the bout's excitement in the process, though Tully Blanchard deserves props for assisting the Spike Piledriver on the floor that preceded Spears' victory with the C4. His client was solid but unspectacular, though tying Joey's hair to the back of the turnbuckle at least created a cool visual, particularly as 'The Bad Boy' ripped his own hair out to escape.
AEW are committed to this Spears heel character, even if it doesn't seem to be working at the moment. Let's see if his "No More Garbage Wrestling" campaign starts taking him to better places.
2. Stodgy Pacing
AEW Dynamite has largely favoured fast-paced, spot-heavy action matches since its inception, drawing widespread critical acclaim from those into that style of wrestling, and complaints from those who aren't. Which is fine. Wrestling is subjective and people are always going to disagree, but it felt like AEW tried to move away from this at Full Gear.
There was little in the way of cocaine wrestling on this show. Instead, the bulk of these matches were slower, more considered, and more methodical. None of them were boring, they just didn't get the adrenaline pumping like Dynamite often does, leading to a show that felt as though it was locked in the same gear for much of the evening.
Baker vs. Priestley was the shortest bout at roughly 11:30 and while it's great to see so many wrestlers getting so much time, at least one shorter bout and a couple of pace changes would have done this show the world of good. Full Gear really felt like it was dragging as we approached the final two matches. That's a problem; one that first arose at Fight For The Fallen, and one AEW will do well to learn from going forward.
1. A Most Divisive Deathmatch
Kenny Omega vs. Jon Moxley will likely prove one of the year's most divisive matches, and while there was certainly plenty of good amongst what the duo brought to the table (more on that later), it felt like they gave us the least interesting version of what this bout could have been.
They delivered a deathmatch, but not even a particularly interesting deathmatch. More an escalating series of brutal, stomach-churning weapon spots than anything else, it provided plenty in the way of grisly visuals, but little else, and it didn't always connect in the building either, with some of the most violent moments seemingly playing out to hushed crowd responses.
The bout's tone didn't feel right for Omega's character either. While 'The Cleaner' has shown an increased willingness to get his hands dirty in recent angles and promos, to go from 'Best Bout Machine' to deathmatch lunatic in just a few weeks felt like a stretch. It felt unnatural. Creative thinking and head-canoning can fill in the blanks where AEW's storytelling failed, but Kenny's sudden transformation didn't hit the mark.
Ups...
12. The Buy In Is Good Now
Full Gear's Buy In pre-show saw AEW flip the format's criticism by turning the 60 minutes into a massive advertisement for the pay-per-view to come, providing enough room for Britt Baker vs. Bea Priestley in the process.
The broadcast started by screening (almost) the entire Countdown: Full Gear show that aired shortly after this week's Dynamite. A smart move, as this was an excellent production that more people needed to see heading into the event, and it did a particularly great job of enhancing the Pride & Powerful vs. Young Bucks programme through sharp, expertly-produced promos. After that, we got Baker's top-notch Dark promo in which she effectively promised to rip Priestley's jaw off in the ring.
Recycled content? Sure, but the right content. That's what matters here. AEW have fixed the broken Buy In format.
11. Look At That Stage!
Different aesthetics are important. Not only do they prevent the onset of staleness, but they help shows feel distinct and more important, giving fans a nice little pop in the process, so kudos to AEW for flipping their usual set design for Full Gear.
Doing away with the TNA-style entrance tunnels, the promotion brought in an elevated WCW ramp, three towering video screens, and a whole bunch of gears to decorate the stage with. It looked great, and we can only hope that this leads to more unique PPV set designs as the promotion progresses.
Take note, WWE.
10. Britt Baker's Revenge
Any mistimed moments found within Bea Priestley vs. Britt Baker get a pass from this writer. There were a few of them throughout, but Baker worked the bout with a flu. Props to her for battling through and delivering a performance that peaked in all the right places.
The bout began with Priestley throwing her entrance jacket at her opponent as the opening bell rang. It was a stiff, attritional battle that felt every bit like a feud-ender, with Baker fired up, and Bea out to injure Britt by going for another concussion. She bludgeoned the babyface with stiff blows and wrapped her torso around the ring post, going for physicality above all else, and the duo looked like two people who were legitimately out to beat the tar out of each other. This transcends any flaws, and that the big moments got big crowd reactions marks it an objective success.
Britt's victory via Lockjaw should see her move onto bigger and better things. For Priestley, it's back to the drawing board after Awesome Kong's post-match beatdown and hair-snipping.
9. "Cheerio, Dweeb!"
Kip Sabian has started coming out of his AEW shell in recent weeks and it continued with a backstage promo alongside Goldenboy, whom the English initially mistook for an intern, before deciding to play ball as the commentator asked what was behind Kip's recent change in attitude.
Sabian said that when he came into AEW, he planned to play it straight. He soon realised that he needed to carve his own path, leading to his alignment with The Hybrid 2, but when this didn't work out between the ropes, he went looking for someone who he has genuine chemistry with. In walked his real-life partner Penelope Ford. "Why be bad, when you can be Superbad?", she said, closing this neat, tidy little segment, and kickstarting an alliance that makes all the sense in the world.
"Cheerio, dweeb!" Kip said as he and Ford walked away from Goldenboy. A great line, and while it's hard to focus how far Sabian can go in this promotion, this is an exciting new direction for the former World of Sport star.
8. Rey Fenix Soars... Again
Fans who'd spent Full Gear waiting for adrenaline-pumping high spots must have been rubbing their hands together when SCU, the Lucha Brothers, and Private Party hit the ring. Said spots came, but not with the frequency or volume many would have expected. This bout was a lot slower than advertised, particularly in the opening stages, and while the action did come thick and fast towards the end, the net was a more measured bout than anyone could've predicted.
Though it took a while to come alive, the match was electric once Rey Fenix decided to remind the audience that he's one of the best wrestlers in the world. His creative rope work and effortless agility stood out over everything else here. His partner, Pentagon, was as brutal as ever, but Fenix was the star, and AEW wisely kept him and his brother out of the finish.
A great near-fall came on a 2.99-count kickout following a Marq Quen Shooting Star Press. SCU countered Private Party's Gin and Juice attempt soon after, proving they'd done their homework, with Frankie Kazarian hooking his legs to prevent the top-rope 'Rana, before him and Scorpio Sky hit the SCU Later for the 1-2-3.
Christopher Daniels returned in the aftermath, disguising himself as Penta to initiate a beatdown of the Lucha Brothers, vowing revenge for the duo putting him on the show a few weeks prior. This storyline continues.
7. Rip & Tear
"It's time for some f*ckin' garbage wrestling!" Jon Moxley announced early in his Lights Out match with Kenny Omega. Two minutes later, 'The Cleaner' was stomping a bin onto the 'Purveyor Of Violence' in a wonderfully poetic moment.
Moxley and Omega deserve immense credit for putting their bodies on their line here. Their efforts were immense, with Jon harking back to his CZW days, and 'The Best Bout Machine' coming out of his usual comfort zone to engage in literal deathmatch spots. Barbed wire weapons ripped and tore at flesh, opening wounds all over the competitors' bodies. Both were slammed onto shards of broken glass. Kenny at a suplex onto a barbed wire trampoline off the stage and things somehow escalated from there, with Mox pulling the ring apart, leading to all kinds of career-shortening bumps on the exposed boards. It was nuts.
Like this match type or not (and your writer, most certainly, does not), these guys risked a lot for your entertainment here. That deserves props. They literally tore each other apart to tell what they felt was the best story on the night.
6. Selling 101
The Young Bucks vs. Pride and Powerful was an incredibly well-executed tag bout built largely around Nick Jackson's impeccable limb selling, further proving that anyone who still clings onto the false idea that the Bucks can't sell is either full it, playing contrarian, or simply not paying attention to the product.
Nick was excellent here. He destroyed his shin early on, whacking it straight into the ring post as Ortiz ducked a kick. He was limping and hobbling around thereafter, with his leg totally collapsing on a Meltzer Driver attempt. The younger Jackson would battle through the pain later on, coursing on adrenaline to battle Ortiz and Santana one-on-two, though each offensive move dealt further damage to the ruined limb, leading, ultimately to his defeat.
While the bout-ending Street Sweeper on Nick could've been built to a tad better, the rest of the match ruled. The Rock 'N' Roll express were shown at ringside early on and Pride and Powerful eventually threw Matt over the barricade and on top of them, providing the impetus for the post-match angle. The victors were as scrappy and nasty as you'd expect, too, proving their versatility in a slower, more story-driven bout than many would have expected, and propelling themselves towards the top of the pile in victory.
5. Page Finally Conquers PAC
Simple brutality defined PAC vs. Hangman Page: a straightforward bout that showed great wrestling need not be complicated, and likely settled the recent beef between the two warring stars.
PAC and Page worked like they hated each other. Their offense was sharp, snug, and stiff. When Hangman threw PAC into the barricades, he did so to cripple, and when PAC booted his opponent in the face, it was like he was trying to concuss him. They beat the absolute p*ss out of each other without a single plunder spot. Page was hossy, PAC was nasty, and in the end, they crafted one of Full Gear's most effective matches.
'The Bastard' got cocky during his control sequences, going after Page with a series of covers so arrogant in their execution that they were designed to humiliate rather than pin. Once this unfolded, it was back to popping and snapping, and the match succeeded on the back of effective stiffness, impact, and selling.
A nice piece of storytelling saw Page block the low blow that felled him the last time they met, hitting his Deadeye finisher at the second attempt (PAC brilliantly countered the first into a Brutaliser). Redemption for the rising star, who feels more like his old self with every passing appearance.
4. Ricky Morton Is 63 Years Old...
... and he's doing sh*t like this on a major wrestling pay-per-view.
2019 is weird as hell.
3. Student Defeats Teacher
What Riho vs. Emi Sakura lacked in build (and, to be fair, crown connection) it more than made up for in execution and storytelling, with student and teacher collided in an explosive, intense, and emotional clash that began with Sakura so consumed by the moment, she couldn't help but shed genuine tears during the introductions. That's pro-wrestling.
As Excalibur pointed out on commentary, these two hard shared a ring a whopping 286 times. They played into this throughout, with Riho harking back to her dojo days by executing a half-crab on her mentor (a staple hold in any young lion's arsenal), then bumping around like a maniac. That's the thing about her: she's such a great bumper and so, so small that literally every single move she absorbs looks like death. It's a great quality for any professional wrestler, and one of the main reasons why she has caught on so well in AEW.
An outstanding series of counter-pins brought the crowd to their feet late on. Finally, after a compelling chess battle, Riho put her former teacher away with another cradle. Smart and opportunistic rather than lucky, she had her arm raised by Sakura afterwards, making for the evening's most resonant feel-good moment.
2. Cody Falls To Jericho
In terms of audience reactions, Cody vs. Chris Jericho started hot, cooled off after just a few minutes, and finished molten. This makes it an absolute triumph of crowd control. The duo got everything they wanted from every stage of his match, building towards a loud-as-hell conclusion thanks to one of the smartest bout layouts you'll see all year, though nobody should be surprised, given the quality of the build.
A slow-burning 30-minute epic, this subverted several expectations. When Jericho fannied around on the outside early on, mouthing off at judge Dean Malenko instead of engaging with Cody, AEW told you "this thing is going the full hour." When Cody announced his stipulation on Dynamite, AEW told you "Cody is winning." Neither of these came to pass. Instead, Jericho triumphed in a perfect finish that saw MJF throw in the towel after the AEW World Champion's own second, Jake Hager, had been sent to the back for one interjection too many.
This was an extremely economical match that saw these two pros make great use of the space between moves, and it didn't drag for a second. Full of spotlight moments like Cody's face-first ramp bump (and ensuing blood) and his mother straight-up slapping 'The Alpha' in the face, it succeeded by squeezing as much juice from each beat as possible, and the Liontamer that effectively ended Cody's night was nothing short of brutal.
It's hard to imagine a better scenario here. Everything was on-point, from the pacing to the character work.
1. MJF Turns On Cody
MJF provided what will go down as Full Gear's biggest talking point by booting Cody in the nuts after his loss to Chris Jericho, finally executing a long-expected heel turn that many probably assumed was still a month or two away. Instead, AEW got right to the point with this storyline, and while time will tell whether or not they jumped the gun, that the arena was such a cauldron of noise after MJF had turned on his "best friend" says everything.
This resonated. Hard.
Though clearly frustrated with his pal, Cody had the good grace to pull the grieving, disconsolate MJF from the mat after the devastating decision. When he turned around, he walked right into the low blow. "It's my turn!", MJF yelled over the corpse, and with big "!*$%!" chants filling the arena, young Maxwell had trash thrown at him when he neared the stage. An open bottle of water doused him as he stood smug at the top of the ramp. Was he rocked? Was he hell.
What better way to turn a guy heel than by ensuring the babyface he's turning on can never challenge for the World Championship again? It's hard to think of one, and this writer can't wait for MJF's Dynamite follow-up.