13 Triple H WWE Projects That Failed Miserably
Not everyone turns out like Seth Rollins when backed by Triple H.

Triple H is the kind of guy who likes to start a project, then runs away and hides when it goes badly wrong. He's done a shady job over the years, attempting to start and take credit for something, only to see it fail miserably. At the minute, his reputation for pet projects is actually quite positive. He's the brains behind NXT, which he hasn't been shy boasting about. Just look at his Twitter, where he posts regular photos of himself with Seth Rollins, Kevin Owens, Charlotte and other wrestlers he mentored to success. But you won't find photos on there of the wrestlers on this list, talent that Hunter backed and then abandoned. It should also be said that even his successes still have question marks. Raw television ratings have slumped to seventeen year lows with Rollins as Champion. As for NXT, it doesn't make money and has struggled to fill 2,000 seat buildings when touring in Philadelphia and Albany. Critically NXT is fantastic and Seth Rollins is the best worker alive, but the bottom line numbers are all that matters to Vince McMahon. When it comes to Triple H projects that failed miserably, he's got quite the history to look upon.
13. Shelton Benjamin

Shelton Benjamin was one of the best in-ring workers of the WWE new millennium, but unfortunately he couldn't cut a promo to save his life. Nevertheless, Hunter thought he could make the talented athlete a star. He was rightly impressed by Benjamin's performances over on Smackdown in 2003, so he lobbied for him to be drafted to Raw in March of 2004. Right away, he wanted to work with him, so Benjamin versus Triple H was made for the March 29th 2004 Raw. It was the show closing main event no less! Amazingly, Hunter put him over clean, with the youngster executing a roll up on the veteran after a splash in the corner. Even more amazingly, Benjamin then won further matches via count out and a DQ. But that was that. Benjamin went nowhere in the weeks after the Triple H feud, it ultimately didn't help him one little bit. Fans just couldn't bring themselves to care about a dull personality. He became a lower card jobber and novelty act, before being let go in 2010. Hunter had quickly moved on in 2004 and dropped all interest in the rookie.
12. Damien Sandow

Triple H's reason for getting behind Damien Sandow was personal, as both men had been trained by the legendary Killer Kowalski. The in-ring game of Sandow is also very good, as is his mic work and overall look. So Hunter went down to FCW in 2011 and took a look at him. He came out impressed, telling everybody at WWE that he was high on Sandow's potential. Not long after that, Sandow was called up to WWE's main roster, working a routine very similar to Triple H's original Hunter Hearst Helmsley gimmick. Some speculated that Triple H had specifically gave Sandow his old act, as he was that high on him and wanted to help make him a star. But the fact is that gimmick barely worked in 1995, and it definitely wasn't going to work in 2012. Sandow has had his moments these last few years, but right now he's a barely featured comedy jobber act. Triple H has abandoned all interest in him and moved on to younger blood from NXT.
11. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre worked for WWE from 2007 to 2014, mostly as a lower card jobber. But if you remember correctly, he was actually Vince McMahon's "chosen one" in the storylines at one point. The truth was actually that he was Triple H's chosen one. Behind the scenes, it was Hunter pushing for him to be featured. What attracted him to the Scottish star was apparently their similar in-ring style and bodybuilding work ethic. The Wrestling Observer Newsletter reported just a few years ago that Hunter was still very high on McIntyre. The report said that he was in line to be repackaged with a new gimmick, and Triple H thought there was serious long term potential. But that gimmick ended up being a joke jobber role in 3MB, which went nowhere other than the "future endeavours" door in 2014.
10. Sheamus
The story about Sheamus and Triple H is now infamous. The veteran was training in the gym one day, when the plucky Irishman went over and asked if he could work out with him. The two end up becoming gym buddies, then a few months later Sheamus was WWE Champion. A few more months after that, they worked against each other in a high profile match at WrestleMania. Everyone figured it was a case of sucking up to the boss and getting preferential treatment. But to be fair to Sheamus, maybe WWE always planned on using him in a major role. Also to be fair to him, there's no rule against wanting to lift weights with your boss. It is good to get on with people. The Sheamus push has never really stopped, he's on a cool million dollars a year and is pushed as a top guy. But he's got to be considered a failure, given that he's been pushed and paid as a top guy but never really generated top guy business. Fans are on the whole loathing of him, with the kind of "X-Pac Heat" that no performer wants. Triple H remains a major supporter.