13 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dark (Nov 3)

A welcome two-hour distraction from the rest of the world.

Franke Kazarian
AEW

With the outside world hollowing out into a giant cauldron of bubbling tensions and anxieties, political or otherwise, AEW Dark took on a different tone last night. For once, the colossal two-hour runtime was a welcome break and distraction from everything else. Escapism is important.

It helps that this represented the second straight week AEW has used the bumper to better effect than usual. These shows are usually stuffed with identikit pseudo squashes, which makes watching them from start to finish a chore when it should be a breeze, but not at the moment. Having delivered one of the best Darks of the year thus far on 27 October, AEW came through with another well laid-out episode yesterday.

Sammy Guevara vs. Lee Johnson was the obvious highlight coming into the show, given Guevara's dynamism and his opponent's new Nightmare Family status, though Chaos Project vs. Private Party looked interesting as well. Elsewhere, the newly-signed Max Caster/Anthony Bowens tandem, former TNA wrestler Lei'D Tapa's debut, and regular weekly highlights like Will Hobbs, The Butcher and The Blade, and Ricky Starks provided additional intrigue.

Let's light the fuse on AEW's latest YouTube marathon...


Downs...

4. Chaos Project vs. Private Party

Luther Isiah Kassidy
AEW

This was a relatively mundane match that did little of note with its extended runtime. A basic layout and lack of heat, particularly during Chaos Project's control segment, made it totally skippable, though Serpentico using his streamers as a weapon by blasting them in Isiah Kassidy's face made for a cool spot.

Private Party took the victory via Gin and Juice, with Kassidy spending much of the bout on the backfoot.


3. Frankie Kazarian vs. RYZIN

Franke Kazarian
AEW

Taz is always fun on Dark, as the former ECW World Champion cuts loose in the announce booth, popping his fellow broadcasters (and the audience) throughout the night. Here, he highlighted a straightforward Dark clash by dropping a Terra Ryzin joke while the enhancement talent was in control. Pour one out for Paul Levesque.

Otherwise, this was typical Dark fodder: well-worked, but basic and uneventful. Kazarian won with his Inverted DDT.

The Hybrid 2 jumped Kaz after the bell, with Christopher Daniels making the save. A tag match looks likely as this Dark storyline progresses.


2. Alan Angels vs. VSK

VSK Alan Angels
AEW

Again, like the two Downs before it, Alan Angels vs. VSK was a typical Dark pseudo squash and hard to recommend to anyone but Dark Order diehards.

Angels' sick-looking hook kick was the highlight as he scored a relatively straightforward victory. Fine, but not necessarily worth your time.


1. Peter Avalon Gets Weird

Peter Avalon is reborn! No longer a Librarian, he is bringing his old 'Pretty' Peter gimmick to AEW, having lost to Brandon Cutler last week. A change was needed after Leva Bates walked out on him and while this could theoretically take the talented enhancement wrestler down an interesting path, this was a deeply weird promo.

Avalon spent it seducing whoever was on the other side of the camera before earning himself a slap across the face after pulling their glove off. "PPA all day", is the new catchphrase, and Avalon dropped it before kicking his guest out of his lavish hotel room, his advances rejected.

PPA isn't short of charisma, though there wasn't a whole lot to sink your teeth into here. It was kinda creepy, really, and not in an effective way.


Downs...

13. Griff Garrison & Brian Pillman Jr. vs Sean Maluta & Alex Chamberlain

Brian Pillman Jr Sean Maluta
AEW

AEW rarely books regular jobbers against each other without one party being signed, so it looks like Griff Garrison and Brian Pillman Jr. have earned themselves deals here. Good for them, and here's hoping they take off.

Though straightforward, the bout with Sean Maluta and Alex Chamberlain brought enough to the table for it to finish on the positive side of the ledger. Griff and Brian took control of Malulta after having some trouble with his larger tag partner, putting him down for a nice victory.

Garrison and Pillman must develop a more distinct style from here, inside the ring and out, though they looked decent last night.


12. Max Caster & Anthony Bowens vs. Aaron Solow & Angel Fashion

Anthony Bowens
AEW

Prior to Dark, AEW President Tony Khan confirmed (via PWInsider) that Anthony Bowens and Max Caster had been signed by the promotion. A considerable coup, given that Bowens was once targeted by WWE, and the tandem got their first win together last night.

Caster cut a rapped pre-match promo putting Solow and Fashion down, which had the announcers in stitches. His and Bowens' characters are developing already which is a very encouraging sign, and they showcase some sick double-team moves in the ring, suggesting they're already capable of playing a role in the tag division's middle tier.

Solow enjoyed a nice offensive spell, though his team still fell in a nice warm-up for Bowens and Caster.


11. KiLynn King vs. Lei'D Tapa

KiLynn King Lei'D Tapa
AEW

Lei'D Tapa is a former Impact and GFW wrestler who hasn't worked a match since 2017. Matches like this one vs. KiLynn King are a good idea, particularly when they feature people like Tapa, as the pseudo tryouts give AEW an impression of how they might fit into their product.

It's hard to get too much of a read on Tapa as this bout only ran for about three minutes. Still, this was solid enough. Tapa's work is basic but everything she did felt nasty and the bout's biggest moves were all impactful, with King picking up a first AEW victory via Frog Splash.


10. Jurassic Express (Luchasaurus & Jungle Boy) vs. Danny Limelight & KC Navarro

Danny Limelight Jungle Boy
AEW

Danny Limelight has been a standout d*ckhead on Dark lately. He and Jungle Boy started things out, keeping things relatively even, before Luchasaurus entered the fray and wrecked everything and everybody.

A basic story, but the right one. While Jungle Boy was never in real danger, he had more trouble with the opponents than his prehistoric father, who looked positive beastly on the road to victory.


9. Brandi Rhodes & Red Velvet vs. Elayna Black & Leyla Hirsch

Leyla Hirsch
AEW

An interesting bout, this, as Hirsch wrestled for the NWA Women's Championship on last week's episode of Dark and looks like a future AEW signing. She has stood out in each of her appearances thus far and this was no different.

Excalibur spoke of Black and Hirsch effectively fighting for a job while they shared a ring with the Chief Brand Officer. Both entered good performances, with Hirsch particularly commanding during a control segment on Red Velvet, contributing towards a neat, tidy, and well-worked contest.

A Shot of Brandi on Black was enough for Rhodes to take the pin.


8. The Dark Order (Evil Uno & Stu Grayson) vs. Baron Black & Nick Comoroto

Stu Grayson Nick Comoroto
AEW

Another good workout for Nick Comoroto, here. Though he struggled in his first bout, the former WWE trainee looks increasingly confident. He is growing into his role and it is starting to look like he may bring value as a full-time AEW performer, so let's see what his future holds.

Evil Uno and Stu Grayson are always fun to watch. Their work had its usual levels of pop and snap and they meshed well with Comoroto, who nailed some big slams. Comoroto and Black lost, because of course they did, but this is worth checking out.


7. Ricky Starks vs. Dave Dutra

Ricky Starks
AEW

Details-first wrestlers like Ricky Starks should be on Dark every single week. Whether it's a simple facial expression or lacing his punches with extra starch and contempt, the effort he goes to to enhance the watchability of these simplistic bouts is always appreciated.

Peppered with Ricky's usual array of hooks, this was another fun squash in which Dutra was dispatched efficiently, leaving Starks to join the commentary team afterwards.


6. Darby Allin vs. BSHP King

Darby Allin BSHP King
AEW

King and Allin went back and forth early on here, taking it in turns to force each other out of the ring before controlling the space, refusing to let their opposite number back in. The difference in characters was highlighted when Darby broke this by diving through the ropes and onto his opponent, bringing the put to life.

King used his superior size to craft a handful of openings while Taz helped elevate the bout on commentary, openly rooting for King after his team's recent issues with Allin. Darby, however, was too much for BSHP, taking the W after rolling through a leg-trap submission.


5. Will Hobbs vs. D3

Will Hobbs
AEW

Nothing more than complete domination would have sufficed here - and that's exactly what we got.

Will Hobbs completely blanked D3's pitiful strikes before smashing him with a Uranage followed by the Oklahoma Slam, and the pin. Simple, ruthless, and exactly what it needed to be.

Jumped by Ricky Starks and Brian Cage after the bell, Hobbs was saved by Darby Allin, who returned the big man's favour from last week. A tag team match appears to be inbound.


4. The Dark Order (John Silver, Colt Cabana & 10) vs. Shawn Dean, Fuego Del Sol & Cezar Bononi

Cezar Bononi John Silver
AEW

You should watch this match for John Silver's performance alone.

The Dark Order's pint-sized muscle man was a total popper here, making a mockery of Cezar Bononi's huge size advantage by challenging the Brazilian to pick him up, then flexing like a total goof after turning the spot around. His energetic, personality-packed efforts continue to make him one of the most watchable performers in the entire promotion.

This was a fun, all-action six-man that absolutely flew by, and concluded with the increasingly overconfident Silver getting the pin via airplane spin. The Dark Order face Gunn Club and Cody on Dynamite tonight.


3. The Butcher & The Blade vs. Jersey Muscle

The Blade
AEW

This was a largely one-sided shellacking of an overmatched enhancement team - and it ruled for it.

Through Jersey Muscle fought back towards the end, The Butcher and The Blade pretty much ran through them. A bout that began with one Jersey Muscle member being yeeted almost the whole way across the ring stayed one-sided for the bulk of its runtime, with Butcher and Blade beating the poor sods up inside the ring and out, leaving enough of an opening for a short comeback before Butcher righted the course.

A Powerbomb/Neckbreaker combo ended Jersey Muscle's night, with Butcher and Blade brawling with the Natural Nightmares after the bell. That story continues.


2. Everybody Dies

Griff Garrison, Brian Pillman Jr., Sean Maluta, and Alex Chamberlain all died by Lance Archer's hand after their tag match, with the beatdown totally effective in making the 'Murderhawk Monster' look like a force of nature.

Jake Roberts then took the microphone and told Eddie Kingston he'd made a mistake crossing into their path. Archer took things up a notch after that, cutting a cold, convincing promo in which he set his sights on Kingston (or whoever leaves Full Gear with the AEW World Title), calling himself a horror movie that fans can't bear to watch but keep peeking through their fingers to see.

Though short, this was a Dynamite-quality angle that enhanced Archer as a force in the World Title picture. Speaking of Dynamite-quality...


1. Sammy Guevara vs. Lee Johnson

Lee Johnson Sammy Guevara
AEW

Yeah, this ruled, and should probably have gone down on TNT.

Johnson's recent match with Ben Carter wasn't too far off the Englishman's acclaimed Scorpio Sky bout in terms of quality, and his new Nightmare Family affiliation means we can probably expect to see more matches like this going forward. He's great - and it's heartening to see his efforts have earned a bigger role.

Parity grappling gave way early on, with Sammy Guevara preening and posing when in control. Johnson answered this, mocking the Inner Circle man, and the matches unfolded thereafter, with Johnson getting a fair share of the shine all the way to the end.

Guevara took the victory and sent a message to PPV opponent Matt Hardy at the same time, finishing Lee off with a Twist of Fate.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.