13 Ups & 9 Downs For WWE In 2022
A rollercoaster review of the most chaotic year in WWE history.
In judging WWE's 2022 as a whole, what would be too generous or harsh to include simply as a straight "Up" or "Down" per the restrictions of this review format?
Bray Wyatt, as usual, has divided the audience and he's only appeared in three months out of the twelve. Uncle Howdy feels increasingly like a Fiend by any other name, even if Wyatt himself feels closer to perfecting the act of playing himself at last. He's neither Up nor Down yet, though it's clear 2023 will decide that one way or another.
Johnny Gargano's had a rotten start to life on the WWE main roster, but has such a brilliant and relatively recent legacy under Triple H that it seems like sooner or later he'll kick out from the pinning predicament he's been placed in. 'The Game' himself has inspired patience in his processes too, and while WWE's not been perfect since he took the wheel, enough has improved to suggest that even more will.
Brock Lesnar lifted up the ring with a tractor at SummerSlam but lifted nobody with nuthin' in a rotten WrestleMania main event. Edge's unlikely second career looked legitimately doomed for half the year before a separation from his new stable saved him and it. Bobby Lashley was WWE Champion at the start of the year and a former United States one by the end. Current titleholder Austin Theory's trajectory is heading in the opposite direction but the burial he endured to get back on track was one for the ages.
It's actually quite tough to be either so awful or awesome for the bulk of the calendar year that it's memorable by the end. Kudos, then (or...the opposite of that...) to those that made the cut...
Downs…
9. The Royal Rumble Matches
Recent reports confirmed that morale within the WWE locker room had been at an all-time low following this year's devastatingly bleak Royal Rumble.
Think about that; regardless of WWE being a television company more than a pay-per-view one now, the entire year is still shaped around the undeniable magic of WrestleMania and, for the wrestlers, the promise of making it on the biggest stage in the industry. In kayfabe and reality, the Rumble represents a passport to that paradise, and even if you're not the one pointing at the sign, you're on the road and exposed to all possibilities.
That both matches could suck so much and play to that much indifference speaks to how much faith had clearly been lost in former head honcho Vince McMahon. The vibe was destroyed by actual ticket-buying punters revealing themselves to not watch Raw on the reg when theme songs dropping didn't lead to popping. The booking was stubborn and/or beige with little wiggle room for fun runs, nostalgic thrill rides or overly optimistic hope spots. When the opportunity for nice things - Melina, Molly Holly and The Riott Squad's one night returns being potent examples - they were senselessly crushed just to remind us all who was still - but not for long - boss.
Father fired son after Shane McMahon tried to bogart all the coolest spots in the closing stretch of the main event, but beyond that, McMahon was never been further apart from what his audience - or roster - wanted. And think of the vast, vast acres of ground that covers.
8. The (First) Lacey Evans Return
Lacey Evans has made three distinct comebacks this year, so the title's clarification isn't just for snark.
Her most recent, with a heavy leaning on her military background, is too new to analyse either way. Her second, a "getting serious this time, honest" reappearance on the SmackDown undercard for multi-woman action, was so indistinct that fans have almost been instructed to forget it ever happened anyway.
Her first, though, was the sort of sh*t that WWE hardcores had become so conditioned to that her maiden live appearance in the gimmick drove long-standing observers into an existential crisis about if the entire business was doomed forever.
That's not an exaggeration - the company cackhandedly forced her in front of a lens for several consecutive weeks to explore in great detail an upbringing that included multiple patterns of abusive behaviour, tragedy not-limited-to the death of immediate family members, and pain and poverty no child should have to endure. They could barely be threaded into the silliness of WWE's weekly show anyway, but this traumatic revisiting was made even more soulless when she was brought back to television as a heel.
And it got worse.
In some terrifying vision of how the world almost completely turned before Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace, ring announcer Samantha Irvine asked live fans to cheer for Evans as per her rather cynical request. But the traditional heel bit backfired when the conditioned and obliging fans simply did what they were told. She got cheered, she switched brands, and by the time she did her "each and every one of you" generic shtick, the fans had forgotten the backstory that made the whole thing so sickening to begin with.
It's always darkest before dawn but this was pitch f*cking black.
7. Ronda Rousey
Ronda Rousey has been struck with that most dreaded of modern WWE ailments - she's had too much WWE for her own good.
'The Baddest Woman On The Planet' was never more in keeping with her old nickname than when she was brand spanking new out there. The less she knew the better, or more specifically, the less she appeared to know, the more awesome things were.
Her debut was a peak few in wrestling ever reach, full stop, but her 2018-2019 run in totality drew comparisons to Kurt Angle for how quickly she picked up the vast and challenging array of skills needed to be a megastar within WWE. Equal parts controlled and reckless but never short of the charisma that had made her one of the biggest stars in the world before her debut, she gave the likes of Nia Jax, Alexa Bliss and Nikki Bella some of their most entertaining matches ever, looked like she belonged across from Charlotte Flair, Sasha Banks and Bayley, and portrayed her beast-mode variant against the likes of Ruby Riott and Liv Morgan with a terrifying quality befitting of somebody that survived the danger of the UFC cage.
The vibe felt wrong from the off in 2022, but that was initially put down to the Royal Rumble's overall rankness. A WrestleMania loss to Charlotte Flair was too humbling even if she beat her the following month, and her stint thus far has been more defined by Premium Live Event stinkers against Liv Morgan and Shotzi than the quality brawl with 'The Queen' back in May. The that-which-cannot-be-defined intangible has departed her too, which even good booking next year might not be able to restore.
An assumed match with Becky Lynch at WrestleMania 39 will answer a lot of tricky questions - if the pair can summon the magic of their 2018/19 series, Rousey might yet be able to re-ascend to something beyond the normalised presence she's become.
6. The Bad Triple H Comebacks
Tony Khan brings too many wrestlers into AEW, but the reason this is a bad thing is missed by countless online critics thinking with their bias before their brains.
Wrestling has always been a bigger industry than just within WWE's walls, and AEW's potential to be the destination for all of it to thrive was made real by multiple names from multiple locations making Dynamite or Rampage their sudden home. Fan reaction or a quick Excalibur explainer is enough - don't let grifters tell you otherwise - but the sheer quantity and turnover of these is the actual problem. There are too many; so many in fact that you are encouraged to approach any with caution now because your investment may not be rewarded. Are there other scripted television shows where so many new characters would be dropped in at random with this regularity? No, and that's why.
Triple H fell into the same trap but asked different things of his audience. He brought back/in a bunch of wrestlers as a way of making a statement about his stewardship of WWE, but the expectation of monster pops was foolish and the subsequent management of too many of them has resulted in already-quiet fans greeting every new returnee with polite recognition (at best) instead of an actual pop.
WWE had cut way, way too aggressively between 2020 and 2022, and talent was absolutely needed in areas Triple H has attempted to fill. But there's no current distinguishing feature between those returning as rank-and-file and the ones we're supposed to take seriously. Karrion Kross came in on top but went 50/50 with a top star so why should Roman Reigns be worried? What is the value of a Hit Row diss track if they can't fight a lick when the bell rings. The Viking Raiders and Valhalla destroyed jobbers but when they start grabbing holds will the matches last so long that we're left wondering why they bother with all that b*llocks?
There are good and bad ways to do everything (hence this very article and the praise soon to follow), but - like his opposite on the other channel - Triple H needs to pull right back on the hiring spree and actually see what he can do with his collection of talent rather than just papering over cracks in bad booking with tail-chasing and tepid reactions.
Especially when the evidence of its limitations is regularly on show...
5. Damage CTRL Has Failed...
...and it's the biggest indictment of Triple H thus far.
The picture above has been specifically chosen because WWE likes to stage moments like this that can be captured to help fans remember a time that never actually existed. That's not Bayley's belt, and she's failed to climb ladders both literal and metaphorical since returning at SummerSlam. Those Tag Titles do belong to Dakota Kai and Iyo Sky, but they preside over a division so neglected that the straps scarcely even need to exist at present.
The castle is still made of sand, and if 'The Game' wants to rebuild it brick by boring brick, he shouldn't have started off by keeping 'The Role Model' heel.
There's a decent narrative thread buried deep beneath the surface of Damage CTRL - Bayley was both privately and publicly somebody who constantly wanted to elevate others with her performances and any status she could attain, a diamond for any locker room that shouldn't still be getting spurned by management - but the heel unit slotted so listlessly into the weekly churn that Raw controlled them before they even had a chance to make it the other way around.
The story isn't a story, but a series of wins and losses against different collections of wrestlers in matches greeted by indifference or worse. It was good for management and the wrestlers themselves to commit to all of it, but it'd be even better now for them all to admit defeat.
4. Dexter Lumis Vs The Miz
Did you actually watch it?
If you did, there are probably no words henceforth that can do a better job of articulating why this sucked than the (in)action itself, but let's give it a go because based on the complete silence that greeted the various matches that took place within the body of this lame story, it's believable that nobody invested at any point.
As later revealed to us by a Johnny Gargano exposition dump so lame that it had to be framed as intentionally so, a Dexter Lumis summer return was bankrolled by a Miz character looking to build on his wealth and influencer status by getting decked by a contract killer once a week. He risked the health and wellbeing of his family to put it over, abused Lumis' financial state (itself caused by a shoot WWE release earlier in the year), and got deeper in the sh*t when Gargano found out and held it over his head for weeks on end.
During this time, Miz defeated Gargano in a rubbish match and tried in vain to avoid fighting Dexter in a similarly shoddy showing until the inevitable match was greeted by silence and the literal murderer earned a job and a big bag of cash by virtue of his victory.
It's since resulted in 'The A-Lister' playing a down-on-his-luck Skint Baron Corbin knockoff, but it's not as though that's a shining justification for a terrible tale that actually kicked off - to timestamp this - when CM Punk was still an active wrestler in AEW. Maybe all the power players in wrestling are obsessed with stepping on their own d*cks?
3. The Liv Morgan Push
WWE tried and failed to make a star out of Liv Morgan this year, and whilst we used to live in an era where points were awarded simply for trying at all, Triple H's stepping into Vince McMahon's shoes has allowed the bar to be raised. And Morgan's run fell damagingly below it.
A Money In The Bank cash-in victory has always been a less-than-ideal start for any babyface, but when Morgan failed to conclusively beat former Champion Ronda Rousey in the cleaner confines of a SummerSlam rematch, the booking of her time at the top seemed doomed from there.
She lost all credibility with an audience that had specifically propelled her into the spot in the first place because they believed in her. It was as if that specific finish - Morgan secured a pinfall right as Rousey secured a tap-out - was designed with the expressed purpose of burying what people loved, and crowd reactions flipping on television in the run-up to their final battle at Extreme Rules spoke to the mess that had been made.
She's in recovery mode at present and it's hard to imagine she won't rise back up once again when the timing is right, but Triple H had the opportunity to prove himself different to nnnnnnDadddd-uh by getting this one right from the start. That he failed and in such short order was a worrying reminder of how it was to temper optimism that any of this really was a brave new world after all.
2. WrestleMania 38, Night Two
Despite Vince McMahon's best efforts to tinker with his unique selling point from the day he bought the company off his own Father, WrestleMania is still the centrepiece of professional wrestling. Once a great promoter, he promoted the sh*t of that thing long enough and loud enough that he had to deliver action befitting of the entire industry's "Show Of Shows".
It's a high pedestal; when it goes badly, it's illuminative of the company's biggest and most egregious faults. It was particularly weird this year, when the very best of what he had to offer was on display just 24 hours earlier. But more on that later because this show needs an absolute kicking.
The two-night WrestleMania format was the right answer years before WWE was forced into it by a pandemic, but future structuring cannot be so lopsided. You were absolutely instructed not to care about Sasha Banks and Naomi's tag title win, nor The Brawling Brutes' victory over The New Day by virtue of match agenting and run-time respectively. Sami Zayn's loss to the Jackass lot was a smoke-and-mirrors triumph but it needed to be following a sluggish Omos/Bobby Lashley showdown and slotted before an interminably rubbish and over-thought AJ Styles/Edge snoozer.
The Roman Reigns character looked cooked in victory over Brock Lesnar. The Bloodline's development alongside Sami Zayn has saved this entire run, or at the very least protected it from what felt like torturous oblivion over WrestleMania weekend. There was a finger in the air to the fans but it didn't feel much like the index one.
Oh, and Vince McMahon completely and utterly humiliated himself in victory over Pat McAfee before selling fear at the wrong entrance music and botching his last and worst-ever Stone Cold Stunner.
But all that feels positively charming compared to what was to come just months later...
1. Vince McMahon Resigns In Disgrace
On July 22nd of this year, Vince McMahon made two mistakes in a tweet that instantly became an historic piece of pro wrestling documentation.
The first was that the stupid idiot got his own age wrong. But the second was to confirm that he was retiring from all duties within WWE. He meant to type "resign", but perhaps the years advancing even quicker in his mind than his body are at fault for that. Either way, he was gone and nothing would ever be quite the same.
The story behind the story is no less dramatic, but is substantially more troubling than his polite little swansong might suggest. The Wall Street Journal reported an ongoing internal investigation into alleged payments to former staff and talent regarding NDAs and "hush money" that ran into the millions. The investigation cost WWE a small fortune, and, eventually, their former leader. These costs don't compare to the lives forever altered and/or ruined by McMahon's behaviour, but the narrative is always a more complicated one when you're not a billionaire booking it yourself.
Nothing else could be the biggest down in WWE - or indeed wrestling - this year. It is, in reality, one of the darkest things to ever emerge from pro wrestling's already-blackened auspices.
And yet, because it did...