13 Ups & 9 Downs For WWE In 2022
Ups…
13. Vince McMahon Resigns In Disgrace
...WWE got an unexpected and quite remarkable creative restart.
Articles like this and others similar to it will use the success and failure of various wrestlers, angles and matches to determine exactly how well or poorly Triple H has done since taking over from Vince McMahon in July, but while there are cogent arguments on both sides for 'The Game's dealings so far, one thing is so apparent that it splits the entire year in two with a BC/AD-like chasm - WWE is a wrestling show again.
It might not be a particularly good one if it's not to your tastes, or in comparison to a far more established wrestling company in the form of AEW. But even the most boring changes made by Triple H ensured that the Sports Entertainment brand could at least go back to making a modicum of sense instead of zero at all. The positives now are far more earned than the usual cycle of "X talent got over in spite of the WWE system" or "X managed to fool Vince McMahon into doing something good" and the like, with several of the below entries seemingly a direct result of Hunter either providing performers with something to focus on, and/or allowing them more freedom to flourish away from crippling and fatalistic micromanagement.
The extremely high levels of positivity now do raise questions about those that were just as high on WWE when Vince McMahon was in charge, but that says more about those people and anybody else that parrots their sycophantic co-opted drivel.
12. Seth Rollins Gets It
Seth Rollins has had an absolutely fabulous year.
The 'Visionary' gimmick never really got any more fleshed out than it was at inception, but it started working for people in a big way nonetheless. Meanwhile, his scenery-chewing cackle at long last became endearing, especially paired with the ostentatious outfit and infectious singalong theme. Starting the year working critically acclaimed tag team matches alongside "best friend" Kevin Owens before moving into Feud-Of-The-Year territory opposite Cody Rhodes and Matt Riddle didn't hurt his cause either.
WWE have strangely pulled back on what felt like an organic babyface turn, but perhaps that's Rollins himself figuring out how much is too much when it comes to being a fan favourite. His turns have killed him before, but this one feels like a can't-miss. Kudos to man and management for trying to make this so.
It's been a year of memorable moments for the former WWE Champion, and it's hard to argue he hasn't deserved the lot of them. Especially one that was more about the man across the ring from him...
11. Cody Rhodes Returns
This whole thing would bring a tear to Cody's eye upon reflecting on his year, but then a lot of things do, so perhaps that's not the best gauge.
What is, however, is the reaction 'The American Nightmare' received at WrestleMania, the Raw two nights later, just about every house show appearance shared on Twitter and especially in the gutsy and dramatic Hell In A Cell bruised t*tty classic.
Cody Rhodes has already had a vintage second WWE run and he only got three months in before suffering an injury. His comeback was an earthquake within the industry - wrestlers choosing to leave former utopian landscape AEW for the opposition still is, let alone EVPs and company founders considering the jump - but WWE uncharacteristically capitalised on it by bringing him in exactly as he was just weeks earlier on TNT and TBS. This felt like a wholesale show switch indicative of the new wrestling landscape Vince McMahon was desperately eager to suppress.
The chaos of 2022 in general underwrote the historic significance of his return, but his legacy was assured forever in the moment, and the general vibe around the soon-to-be-returning star is that within his new home he's only just getting started.
10. Gunther
Gunther's main roster run was admittedly going quite well even before Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace, but rumours had circulated that the old s*d was tiring of one of his new toys and looked set to doom with the Intercontinental Champion with rank anti-America sh*t before Triple H took charge and kept the train on the tracks.
Imperium are a stable reborn under 'The Game's steady hand, and Gunther is a nailed-on banger factory when he puts his title on the line in a major setting. His Clash At The Castle war with Sheamus was WWE's match of the year, and the rematch was just a notch below. Shinsuke Nakamura and Rey Mysterio made for outstanding TV opponents, and the quality contest in which he secured the belt against Ricochet may well be topped by an impending rematch set to air after this went to press.
And just briefly on the belt - Gunther's elevated the status of the secondary strap beyond anything it's been in forever. With Imperium as his muscle out front and 'The Game' clearly supporting his run behind the scenes, Gunther's pulled off a show-not-tell trick that just about Intercontinental Champion since 2003 has failed to do before him. The man has made the title, just as it should be.
9. SummerSlam
Caught in the hinterland between Vince McMahon's departure and Triple H taking his chair, this was a show orchestrated by one and promoted by the other. And for mostly better, it showed.
Triple H has yet to prove that he can polish a turd quite as well as his Father-In-Law, and he's got some way to go if the incredible Last Man Standing main event between Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar is anything to go by. Reflecting on that with any happiness at all seemed impossible when the graphic dropped - no paring in wrestling was as tired as this one - but a tractor tipping the ring half into the f*cking sky was as absurd a visual as has ever been crafted in wrestling, and WWE presented itself wisely as the only place insane enough where such a thing could occur.
Elsewhere, the hope of a new dawn under 'The Game' was realised in a thrilling post-match angle following Becky Lynch and Bianca Belair's superb WrestleMania sequel. Lynch returned to the babyface side in defence of her now-former Rival, Bayley returned from injury, Dakota Kai returned from the unemployment line and Io Shirai was called up from NXT and dropped directly into what looked like a main event angle. It wasn't to be, but we didn't know that then.
Beyond the huge bookending scenes, Logan Paul and Pat McAfee both shone in midcard matches that would have cancelled lesser stars out by virtue of their proximity to one another, and The Usos and Street Profits brought some finality to their longstanding feud in a choice outing since forgotten due to the great match churn wrestling gleefully provides.
8. The White Rabbit Project
It's not looking good for the Uncle Howdy chapter of Bray Wyatt's latest WWE story, but the comeback can't be faulted even if the return itself ends up in as many flames as the ones that engulfed The Fiend at TLC 2020.
"The White Rabbit Project" (everything has to have a brand), the viral marketing device was a multifarious success for WWE and a great example of Triple H following a code re-popularised by the man that smashed his throne. 'The Game' did the work.
WWE fans spotted early that a series of QR codes and videos sprinkled across the show in the summer were related to a returning Bray Wyatt, and the White Rabbit motif worked magnificently as the thing to keep following regardless of the quality of the eventual Wonderland. It didn't matter if the outcome was obvious - those that cared had a blast decoding clues that were less about who it was but more about how it could be related to prior Wyatt lore. WWE were a company giving fans fun things to do - this was the sort of simple sh*t they'd neglected forever.
They were rewarded for it too - the initial tease of September 23rd generated an insane rating for the SmackDown on that date (peaking, brilliantly, at 9:23 pm as just-in-case viewers warily looked on) and live reactions for Wyatt's Extreme Rules return in the flesh were some of the loudest of the year. It'd be a shame if it all can't live up to the hype (again), because the hype itself was a success story for the ages.
7. NXT
The ever-reliable Brandon Thurston recently brought something to the timeline's attention that was more required viewing than the last days of Triple H's black-and-gold brand.
NXT - in direct contrast with AEW Rampage, interestingly - is trending upwards.
NXT improved this year while Rampage declined https://t.co/1MeFEprMSD pic.twitter.com/FtNCqnvaNc
— Brandon Thurston (@BrandonThurston) December 6, 2022
Striking for sure, but for those that have dared to tune in over the past 12 months, this doesn't actually come as much of a shock.
There are other excellent articles and discussions on the weekly foibles of AEW Rampage but the same doesn't exist for NXT success stories because there isn't a market for it. The show almost never penetrates the discourse bubble, and when it does it's more because the developmental roots of the roster are far too much on show for a broadcast that airs on national television once a week. Or because of the rampant and horrifically dated sexual content on show marketed as PG but watched predominantly by people who offer Grandparental Guidance to any kids in the room.
What it does do better than Rampage even when it's doing it poorly, is front-load everybody with backstory and gimmick out the *ss to the point where you know the characters inside out even if and when the matches or stories suck. When the work is good - and there are enough wrestlers on the brand to just about guarantee one ripper a week - it feels like added value instead of reasonable expectation.
NXT hasn't cheated the system to get these gains. It's simply operated with one clear (if chaotic) direction and yielded modest but deserved rewards. The 2021 2.0 rebrand was the right call all along, and 2022 was the year an almost entirely brand new roster found themselves as performers within it.
6. The Ballad Of Bianca Belair & Becky Lynch
It began as a lie started in 2021, but WWE made the Becky Lynch/Bianca Belair saga real in 2022, and paid it off masterfully at SummerSlam before indulging in the fruits of the labour at Survivor Series WarGames.
Handshake bookends were an excellent touch, featuring heavily in the SummerSlam squash that kicked it off, a bona fide WrestleMania classic and a SummerSlam finale one year on from the original crime committed against 'The EST'. The latter two matches were proper worldies, and one legitimate wrestling megastar genuinely helped make another. It became perfect pro wrestling distilled.
Them finally coming together as babyfaces having earned mutual respect even dovetailed into Bayley's return - 'The Man' had another reason to stand alongside Belair. Bayley’s turn all the way back in 2019 was at her expense, and she never forgot. Suddenly, there was an ideal time to remind her of that, as was the case when Lynch returned to action properly alongside the Raw Women's Champion against Damage CTRL at Survivor Series WarGames.
5. Logan Paul
The picture of Logan Paul flying through the air during his incredible Crown Jewel main event against Roman Reigns speaks a thousand words about his first year in WWE, and if it didn't he'd presumably happily do it instead.
The influencer came in as a natural heel, but was attacked by his mate The Miz after stealing a sizeable part of a glorious WrestleMania: Night One in their tag match together. It was no fluke or case of beginner's luck though - Paul held his own against Miz in their SummerSlam singles bout, and then raised both the roof and everybody's expectations of what he can offer in a main event that could well stand as the 'Tribal Chief's best match of the year.
At present, Paul Logan Paul is the wrestler Shane McMahon constantly wished he could be, and is ten times better than that too. He does a lot, but does so from his position of immense privilege and the opportunity to pick his spots in situations designed around highlighting his positives. But he's also shown a keen grasp of the intangibles and radiates more star quality than literally hundreds of wrestlers that have passed through WWE's Performance Center.
Will he tire of it all, or is he just getting started? 2023 will give us those answers, but 2022 changed the questions.
4. The Judgment Day
For the longest time set to be one of the most appalling entries in Edge's historic career, his former makeshift goth group has somehow evolved into one of the industry's most entertaining heel stables in years.
It'd be too simple to blame/thank 'The Rated-R Superstar's exit from the group too. That felt just as stupid as the formation when it first happened - Edge was booted out a night after they picked up their biggest win to date, and for new leader Finn Bálor, who'd been on the losing end. It turned out to be a saving grace for both sides, with (and not a soul had this on their bingo cards) a turned Dominik Mysterio was the missing piece of the puzzle.
Unashamed in their sh*thousery, the quartet are a joyously devious pack of bastards on Raw that have found their place in singles, tags and stables wars thanks to clearly-defined roles and characters that don't feel remotely forced. This is most obvious when they're legitimately very funny - WWE has never done consistent and knowing comedy that well, but this lot just loving their evil deeds is irresistible stuff.
There's a reason Rhea Ripley is one of the first faces you saw opening this article too - the former NXT Champion has at long last found success on the main roster that should have arrived instantly, and is becoming a one-woman dream match factory based on recent simple stare-downs with Bianca Belair and Becky Lynch. She feels a certainty for the WrestleMania slot against the former, and is now a runaway favourite Royal Rumble winner in order to get there too.