13 Ups And 23 Downs For WWE In 2020
14. Rowan’s Pet
One of the stupidest storylines in recent memory did not start in 2020, but a good chunk of it played out during the year, so we’ve got to call it out here.
Shortly after being drafted to Raw in late 2019, Erick Rowan could have been booked as a monster heel. And indeed, he would pick up a bunch of squash wins. But it would be completely overshadowed by the fact Rowan carried a covered cage to the ring, presumably carrying a pet. Worse, Rowan would be shown backstage talking to the pet, sometimes from the viewpoint of the animal inside the cage.
The stupidity would continue with Rowan getting bitten several times by the creature, and it finally reached its peak (of stupidity) in March when Erick revealed that it was just a very fake-looking giant spider. Yep, four-plus months of TV time was dedicated to an ongoing angle that involved a Halloween novelty spider.
And finally, Drew McIntyre put the gimmick out of its misery by smashing the cage with the steel steps, squashing the stuffed arachnid. One month later, Rowan was released from WWE. But the stupidity remains in our memories.
13. Lana’s Heroic Storyline
If you thought Erick Rowan’s spider was bad, then you’ve got to believe that what we just lived through on Raw in recent months was equally bad, if not worse.
Lana has never been a sympathetic character in WWE. She’s almost always been a despised heel – and she’s been pretty decent at it. So when Natalya disbanded their team and Nia Jax subsequently put Lana through a table earlier this fall, you felt like it was putting the Ravishing Russian out of her misery for a while.
But then a funny thing happened: Nia kept putting Lana through the announce table, every week for two months. Lana was shown to be utterly incompetent and inept, but somehow, we were supposed to feel sympathy for her because Jax was bullying her.
It didn’t work and it was idiotic storytelling, but at least it seemed to be consistently building toward an obvious climax: the TLC PPV was coming up, so naturally, the perfect poetic justice would be Lana putting Nia through a table to win a match. When the Women’s Tag Team Championship got caught up in the storyline (with Asuka), it felt like a reasonable conclusion.
Only, none of that happened.
Lana somehow rolled Jax up the week before TLC, and Nia and Shayna Baszler injured Lana, forcing Asuka to recruit Charlotte Flair to be her tag partner, and they captured the tag titles at TLC. Lana was nowhere to be found, and got no revenge on Jax. And this stupid months-long storyline built to absolutely nothing.
12. Ricochet’s Wasted Year
In a similar vein to Aleister Black, Ricochet was another NXT callup in 2019 who felt like he gave WWE a license to print money. But Vince McMahon apparently doesn’t like money unless it’s generated by big, hulking dopes, so he frittered away another talented wrestler in 2020.
Ricochet’s 2020 started out like he was going to go somewhere. He assisted in eliminating Brock Lesnar from the Royal Rumble (via a low blow, which has been whitewashed from the records – it was all Drew McIntyre’s Claymore), and then earned a WWE Championship shot against Brock at Super Showdown (there’s that show again). But what could have put Ricochet on the radar turned out to be nothing more than a squash, as Lesnar annihilated Ricochet in less than 2 minutes.
After WrestleMania 36, Ricochet started tagging with Cedric Alexander, as it looked like WWE was going to use the two high-flyers as an exciting tag team to bolster the division. But the duo would lose a bunch of matches, including to the no-name team of Brendan Vink (who?) & Shane Thorne. They would then join Apollo Crews in a never-ending feud with the Hurt Business.
Just when that ended, Ricochet found himself mired in a new never-ending, go-nowhere feud with Mustafa Ali and RETRIBUTION, which is still going on as 2020 closes. Ricochet is little more than a super-talented warm body filling space on the roster and time on Raw.
11. Keith Lee’s Flame-Out
For a further example of WWE blowing a can’t-miss wrestler, witness Keith Lee’s 2020 on the main roster. The man held both the NXT and North American Championships at the same time before departing the brand for Raw after SummerSlam.
Upon debuting, Lee defeated Randy Orton in his first PPV match just a week after showing up. It seemed like WWE was going to do the unthinkable and strap a rocket to the Limitless One. But there were warning signs almost immediately. Lee’s entrance music and ring gear were changed from NXT, taking something defining away from him before he even got started.
And then the 50/50 booking started. After defeating Orton at Payback, Lee lost a triple threat #1 contender’s match to the Viper. He lost matches to Orton and Drew McIntyre via DQ, then got stuck in a feud with Braun Strowman where Lee jobbed to a low blow. Then there was the Survivor Series debacle, as we had to endure Lee and others on Team Raw having “tension” heading into the PPV. Finally, Lee lost a handicap match to Miz & John Morrison for no discernible reason.
Of course, we can’t forget the report of Lee and others being sent to the Performance Center to work on “how to work” as big men in WWE. Maybe being able to fly around the ring like a cruiserweight isn’t appealing to Vince McMahon. Or maybe there’s something more…
10. Braun’s Abysmal Year
You would think a year in which Braun Strowman won his first world championship – at WrestleMania, no less – and held it for five months would be a banner year for the superstar.
But 2020 was a horrible year for the Monster Among Men. After winning and losing the Intercontinental Championship to open the year, Strowman found himself in a weird spot: he didn’t have a scheduled WrestleMania 36 match, but was called upon when Roman Reigns couldn’t face Goldberg for the WWE Universal Championship. Braun won an underwhelming match with no build to capture the title.
Winning the title in that manner was far from ideal, but if he was smartly booked as champ, he could have overcome that unusual start. However, Strowman was thrown into two ridiculous feuds with Bray Wyatt and the Miz (and John Morrison). Braun’s battles with Bray were especially bad, including a cinematic Swamp Fight that ended with the champion being drowned in the swamp.
Braun returned, but was a “changed” man. He would lost the Universal Championship to The Fiend, then lost a triple threat rematch involving Roman Reigns. Strowman would compete on Raw Underground (remember that debacle?) for a bit before being drafted to Raw, where he feuded aimlessly with Keith Lee, competed on Team Raw at Survivor Series, and then got suspended for grabbing a WWE official.
It was just an awful, awful year for Braun, as his aura has completely vanished and his big singles title run was a total dud.
9. Orton Torches Fiend
OK, so fair warning, this might be getting ranked a little high because it’s still fresh in our minds.
But Randy Orton’s feud with Bray Wyatt was another horrific rivalry involving the Viper in 2020. Sure, the two have a history with each other, but that feud ended in the god-awful WrestleMania 33 match, so why on Earth would you want to revisit it?
Nonetheless, that’s exactly what WWE did this fall, pitting Wyatt against Orton, this time without clearly delineated face/heel lines (though it was safe to assume Randy hadn’t had a face turn). This climaxed at TLC with a match between Orton and Fiend that was suddenly turned into a Firefly Inferno match, which gave us one of the worst moments of 2020.
After surviving a gas-soaked rocking chair, Orton managed to light Fiend on fire, then hit an RKO for good measure. With Fiend laid out, Orton doused him in gasoline, then lit him (or an obvious dummy) on fire. Even in the confines of professional wrestling, lighting another living person on fire like this is just beyond the pale.
And everyone is the worse for having witnessed this.
8. Black Wednesday
There’s no denying that the global pandemic has wreaked havoc on individuals and businesses around the world. The impacts vary from industry to industry – some have maintained their standing, while others have suffered greatly.
In the weeks after a shutdown that forced WWE to retreat to its Performance Center and tape programs without an audience, it was unclear if or how the company could proceed with its operations. Shortly after WrestleMania 36, we got our first answer from WWE about how the year could shape up: a slew of releases.
Just 10 days after Mania aired, WWE released an unprecedented amount of talent, including: Kurt Angle, Rusev, Zack Ryder, Curt Hawkins, Karl Anderson, Luke Gallows, Heath Slater, Eric Young, Erick Rowan, Sarah Logan, No Way Jose, Mike and Maria Kanellis, EC3, Lio Rush, and a ton of backstage production workers and other employees.
So why does “Black Wednesday” rate so high on this list, especially during such uncertain economic times? Quite simply, WWE is on track to have its most profitable year in company history. Dozens of workers, including several talented wrestlers, found themselves unemployed as a presumed cost-cutting move, and instead of scraping by, Vince McMahon can do his best Scrooge McDuck dive into the money bin impersonation yet.
The lack of depth on both rosters was on full display through much of the year, as we saw feuds drone on for months, with wrestlers competing against each other repeatedly because of a lack of other opponents. It all makes this decision look worse in hindsight.
7. Vega’s Impotent Stable
We could wax about the firing of Zelina Vega as its own item, but we’ll just roll that into the complete mismanagement of her stable of jokers.
In the beginning of the empty arena era, it looked like Vega and her charges, Andrade, Angel Garza and Austin Theory, were poised to be major players. They were featured prominent on every episode of Raw, wrestling long matches and being positioned as challengers for the tag titles and United States Championship.
But the trio fell short repeatedly and spent much of the year bickering with each other over and over. They continued to tread water for months, losing matches constantly and being little more than cannon fodder instead of a powerful force. They were quickly eclipsed by the Hurt Business as a top heel stable, and then disbanded.
Theory was booted out early and sent back to NXT. Andrade has been absent from TV for months. Garza resurfaced recently leaning into his “lothario” persona, albeit in a strange manner. And Vega tried her hand as a full-time competitor before being axed because of her desire to retain her revenue stream from her Twitch account.
Yet another ball dropped by WWE in 2020.
6. Rollins/Mysterio Groundhog Day Feud
If you felt like you saw every angle of the Seth Rollins/Rey Mysterio feud multiple times in 2020, you aren’t alone.
The rivalry between the Monday Night Messiah and the legendary masked luchador started off with a ton of promise: Rollins needed a good feud with a quality opponent, and Rey could have used an opportunity to continue his renaissance. Instead, the wheels quickly fell off as Rollins targeted Mysterio’s eye in a bizarre angle that grossly underperformed.
That feud, which began in May, continued through July, when they had the aforementioned “eye-for-an-eye” match. With Rey out of action, son Dominik stepped in and continued the feud with Rollins and Murphy, as things grinded on through the summer and fall carrying over from Raw to SmackDown as all parties were drafted to the blue brand.
Along the way, Rey’s 19-year-old daughter Aalyah was incorporated into the storyline and started a semi-romantic angle with Murphy (who’s in his early 30s). The feud finally was buried in November when Rollins left for the birth of his and Becky Lynch’s first child.
If it hadn’t been for paternal duties, this six-month feud could still be going on today, with the same four wrestlers squabbling. Consider that, and then recoil.
5. Who Writes This Crap?
We’ve detailed many horrible moments and ongoing angles throughout 2020 (with a few more to come), but we really need to point the finger at the overall problem.
No, it isn’t the wrestlers themselves. They can only do what they can with what they’re given, and that means the fault has to lie with the writers and bookers who put this product on television every week. With dozens of writers and agents involved in the production of Raw, SmackDown and the monthly PPVs, you’d think they’d be able to filter out the bad and put on a good show, but that just hasn’t been the case in 2020.
We’ve seen never-ending angles between the same small group of wrestlers for months on end with little to no progression. We’ve seen uninspired in-ring action – and while you can forgive the wrestlers a bit because of the lack of fan reaction, it’s tough to excuse the most talented roster in professional wrestling. Simply put, the talent is all there, but the execution is not.
Randy Orton’s feuds with Drew McIntyre and Bray Wyatt have been among the worst written stuff of the year. The entire booking of RETRIBUTION has been a joke. The Rey Mysterio/Seth Rollins and Apollo Crews/Hurt Business rivalries that droned on for months were horribly uneventful. And the misuse of wrestlers like Ricochet, Kevin Owens, Keith Lee, Aleister Black, Andrade and several others was criminal.
The writers should be embarrassed, and several probably should be fired for their collective incompetence. The ratings and fan assessments don’t lie: something drastically needs to change in 2021, and no, we’re not talking about bringing back Raw Underground.