13 Ups And 23 Downs For WWE In 2020
4. Men’s MITB Becomes A Joke
Remember when the winner of the Money in the Bank ladder match was basically a made-man-in-waiting for WWE? The winner of the briefcase in the early days was an up-and-coming superstar who was just one step shy of the main event, and that guaranteed title shot was seen as an elevation.
Edge, Rob Van Dam, CM Punk, Daniel Bryan and Seth Rollins all had memorable moments with the briefcase and upped their game and standing as a result.
Lately, the men’s MITB briefcase has become something of an albatross. Three of the last four winners have failed in their cash-in attempts, including Baron Corbin and Braun Strowman. (Brock Lesnar’s MITB win in 2019 also was damning, as he entered the match at the last minute to capture the briefcase.)
But what happened this year has to be a dagger to the heart of the gimmick. Otis, a career tag team midcarder, won the MITB match unceremoniously when the briefcase literally fell into his hands. Still, the potential was there to elevate the hulking superstar as a serious player. Instead, the carried on as a midcard semi-comedy act, then lost the briefcase to Miz.
It seemed like WWE was trying to redeem the MITB briefcase by transitioning to a former world champion, but Miz was portrayed equally as a joke, looking incompetent on Raw, and finally failing at his cash-in during a TLC match at the PPV.
At this point, WWE either needs to consider scrapping the concept or getting back to basics with it, because it’s become a complete joke.
3. Raw Underground Fizzles
Earlier this year, Raw ratings were in the toilet (though they would sink even further before the year was out), so the company brass decided it would take drastic action.
Suddenly and without warning, there was Shane McMahon on Raw welcoming us to a new concept: a Fight Club-esque segment called Raw Underground, where NXT wrestlers and under-utilized superstars gathered to compete in shoot-style fights in a rope-less ring. Shane jumped around like a child off his ADD meds, yelling into the mic about the “matches,” randomly declaring them to be over.
Rules were never explained, and wrestlers would randomly jump from inside the squared circle to taking their feuds to Raw Underground, where apparently things were more “real.” Sure, there was potential there for some superstars to jumpstart their flagging careers (guys like Riddick Moss actually got some exposure there), but as with most poorly thought-out ideas, WWE brass quickly lost interest, and two months after it debuted, Raw Underground quietly disappeared.
Raw Underground wasn’t patently offensive, but it came about at a time when the company felt it needed to do something drastic to improve the product. If anything, it exemplifies the company’s inability to have a coherent strategy or long-term planning about anything. It’s among the most “2020” things of the year.
2. RETRIBUTION A Complete Disaster
Now on the other hand, RETRIBUTION was not only one of the most “2020” things of the year, it also is patently offensive.
Another desperate creative creation born out of a desire to arrest the ratings freefall, RETRIBUTION started out as a Molotov cocktail-wielding, cinderblock-throwing bunch of black-clad thugs. It’s widely speculated that the group was Vince McMahon’s response to the racial injustice protests of the summer that saw some groups damage property and clash with law enforcement.
Regardless, this faceless band of miscreants were doomed from the get-go, as their acts of violence were laughable, their demands unintelligible, and their promos nonsensical. They were supposed to be trying to bring down the WWE system that had failed so many, yet they signed contracts with the company, had entrance music and graphics created, and competed in structured matches.
Worse, the group finally revealed its members, with several talented NXT superstars donning partial masks and assuming new identities (despite it being obvious who each of them are). They got a leader in Mustafa Ali (which was viewed optimistically as a step up for him), and then they lost. They lost a lot.
RETRIBUTION went from trying to tear down the WWE system to battling Raw’s top stars, to battling their midcarders, to closing out the year trying to convert just one lower-card wrestler, Ricochet (it’s painful to say that, but it’s true).
This group is an utter joke of a faction that should be put out of its misery as quickly as possible.
1. The Buck Stops Here
At the end of the day, all the failings of 2020 (the ones not directly tied to the global pandemic) have to be laid at one man’s feet: Vincent Kennedy McMahon.
You can blame poor booking, poor writing, a lack of enthusiasm or poor execution by some of the wrestlers, but it really all starts and ends with Vince. We’ve all heard the stories of Raw and SmackDown being rewritten at the last minute, sometimes with rewrites happening as the show goes on the air. This is not how a major company should operate, but when everything comes down to the whims of a 75-year-old man who doesn’t sleep, that’s what can happen.
Just look back at this past year: the go-nowhere feuds that last forever, the gimmick matches like the eye-for-an-eye match or Firefly Inferno match, the numerous wrestlers whose pushes vanished, the haphazard booking, the abrupt changes that don’t make any sense, the idiotic segments that seemed like they were written to entertain only one person… everything has to be laid at Vince’s doorstep. And the ratings and countless critics’ reviews bear that out.
2020 was a hugely profitable year for WWE in a year in which the company was forced to rethink a lot of things. And we shouldn’t hold stuff beyond their control against them. But many of the items listed here were well within Vince’s ability to correct, adjust or avoid altogether. Simply put, Vince McMahon is the biggest negative about WWE in 2020.
Ups...
13. A Genuinely Hilarious Moment
Typically, when WWE tries to do humor, it comes off horrific at worst, mildly funny at best. But on rare occasions, the company strikes gold.
We got that magic in January when Brock Lesnar and Paul Heyman were out to talk about the Beast entering the Royal Rumble at #1 and plowing through the field. Enter R-Truth, who came down to declare that he was entering the Rumble himself. Truth then pledged to throw the big, big, big man in the ring out – Paul Heyman.
What ensued was a back-and-forth between Heyman and Truth that had Brock legit laughing throughout the entire segment, and the crowd right along with him. Truth had the audience going as he un-declared for the Rumble and attempted to avoid Lesnar taking him to Sioux Falls (Suplex) City.
Unfortunately for Truth, it didn’t work out for him, but we all had a truly hilarious moment that should stand out at year’s end.
12. The Street Profits Are Up
It’s tough to rate the Street Profits’ 2020. Much of their gimmick relies on fan interaction and reaction, so the moment the empty arena era began, things derailed a bit.
The Profits won the Raw Tag Team Championship in fine fashion before WrestleMania and would go on to hold the titles until October, when they swapped championships with the New Day as the two brands’ tag champs switched shows. (That in itself should be a negative noted here.)
And while the Profits had some bad moments – the rivalry with the Viking Raiders that went on too long with the extracurricular competitions, not defending their titles very often – the fact is that they were a steady presence during an unsteady year. They have firmly established themselves as a solid tag team and more than competent wrestlers. They’ve shown that they can be entertaining both in and out of the ring as well.
Hopefully, we can see the Street Profits in action in front of fans again sometime in 2021, because they deserve the opportunity to shine.
11. No One Is Ready For Asuka
There are a handful of MVPs to come out of this uneven year. One of them has to be Asuka, who spent half the year as Raw Women’s Champion and dominated much of the red brand’s television.
The year didn’t start out great for Asuka, as she lost a title match at Royal Rumble to Becky Lynch, and then the Kabuki Warriors lost the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship at WrestleMania 36. But afterward, Asuka became a focal point of the women’s division. She excelled in the empty arena era, as her shouting in Japanese on commentary filled the silent arena with noise while allowing her to get some screentime.
Whether it was purposeful or not, the yelling actually softened her heel persona somewhat, as she transitioned to being more of a tweener and less of the green mist-spewing villain she had been. This helped greatly at Money in the Bank, where Asuka captured the briefcase, which she learned held the Raw Women’s Championship Lynch was vacating.
The Empress went on to defend the title successfully for much of the year, save for a short reign by Sasha Banks. Asuka had solid matches and an entertaining feud with Banks and Bayley throughout the summer. She closed out 2020 winning back the women’s tag titles with Charlotte Flair, becoming a double champion.
Not bad work for a woman who had the division thrust upon her.
10. ThunderDome Creates Unique Experience
Credit where credit is due: The WWE ThunderDome was a much-needed upgrade for WWE programming.
Once live shows with audiences were shut down, WWE reverted to holding empty arena shows at their Performance Center. The novelty quickly wore off and it became very uncomfortable. WWE tried to compensate by adding “fans” to the mix – NXT developmental wrestlers who weren’t yet on TV regularly cheering and booing at the action. It was a decent attempt, but it too wore thin after a while.
Enter the ThunderDome. Similar to other national sports, it employed numerous video screens ringing the arena with fans video conferencing in to “watch” the action and cheer. It’s far from perfect – the crowd noise is actually piped in, and not the reactions of the fans watching – but the visual is much more appealing and looks much closer to a typical WWE program experience. Throw in the return of pyro and flames and you’ve got a pretty good appearance to the show.
It will be great to get back to seeing real people in a WWE arena again hopefully in 2021, but the digital faces we’ve been looking at in the ThunderDome have been an acceptable substitute.
9. The Man Becomes The Mom
How can you not cheer for Becky Lynch getting to bow out gracefully to do something that means so much to her personally?
Lynch spent more than a year as the face of the entire women’s division, winning both Raw and SmackDown Women’s Championships at WrestleMania 35, then holding the Raw title for 13 months before bowing out in May. Lynch relinquished the title before Money in the Bank, having the championship put into the briefcase, so the winner – Asuka – wasn’t winning a shot at the champ, she was winning the championship itself.
The next night, The Man announced what she had done, and revealed she was leaving because she was going to become a mother. And within the past month, Lynch and Seth Rollins announced the birth of their daughter.
Thankfully for Lynch, she also avoided a creatively barren 2020 that might have taken the wind out of her sails had she been around all year. Here’s hoping The Man comes back at some point next year and takes the women’s division by storm once again.
8. Taker Bows Out
There is probably no character more synonymous with WWE through the years than the Undertaker. While you can easily argue that wrestlers such as The Rock, Steve Austin or Hulk Hogan were bigger stars, Taker has been a consistent force in the company for the past three decades.
And that’s what made 2020 so significant for the Deadman. UT’s career clearly has been winding down – he’s had 12 matches during the past five years – but he’s never made it clear that he’s ready to hang it. That changed this year.
Taker tipped his hand with a series of out-of-character appearances – few wrestlers have been more protective of their character than Undertaker – on Stone Cold’s podcast, and with his own WWE Network special series. And then there was the Boneyard match at WrestleMania 36 against AJ Styles, a cinematic match that was widely praised, but also felt like a nice coda on UT’s career.
It turned out that that was exactly the case. At Survivor Series, 30 years after he debuted at the same PPV, Undertaker came out and retired his character, effectively ending his in-ring career and going out on a high note.
While the “ceremony” itself was lacking, the entire process in 2020 – the Boneyard match, the specials and interviews – made for a memorable ride into the sunset for Taker.