13 Ups And 23 Downs For WWE In 2020
Creatively bankrupt year has many failings. Tribal Chief, McIntyre rise above.
As we say goodbye to an awful year that needs to be thrown onto the ash-heap of history, we need to take stock of where things stand in the world of WWE.
Yes, 2020 was a dumpster fire for a year, but the global pandemic doesn’t excuse what was a creatively bankrupt year for the largest wrestling company in the world. This might have been the most profitable year in the company’s history, but 2020 also was a horrible year for WWE. That’s not some purely editorial comment. Look at the record-low ratings and universal criticisms lodged against the product. It’s not just one person’s viewpoint.
In this year’s wrap-up column, we tried to keep the negatives geared toward items that were solely within WWE’s control. You won’t see criticisms about the empty arena shows or changing WrestleMania card due to the virus. (However, you might see some praise for how the company successfully navigated aspects of the pandemic.)
When you get down to it, 2020 was a really bad year for WWE: wrestlers’ pushes were wasted or abandoned, storylines stalled for months or were completely nonsensical, gimmick matches were undermined, concepts were poorly thought-out (if at all), and WWE did nothing of significance to arrest the falling ratings.
It makes you wonder how this is the global leader of professional wrestling. Regardless, let’s take a look at the good and the bad in WWE in 2020.
Let’s get to it…
Downs...
23. Morrison’s Wasted Return
You would think the return of an athletic, good-looking wrestler who has improved his mic skills and won several world championships in other promotions would provide a shot in the arm for WWE, that the company would position this superstar in the upper card to become an impact player for the promotion.
But John Morrison’s return to WWE did not lead to a main event run. It didn’t even lead to a midcard run. The Friday Night Delight instead turned back the clock to 2008 and teamed back up with The Miz as a tag team. While that was a pretty big step down from what some thought possible, a run as SmackDown Tag Team Champions could then be parlayed into something bigger.
Yes, Miz & Morrison won the tag titles, but it was an uneventful run, and the year wound down with Morrison serving as Miz’s echo and flunky while he tried unsuccessfully to cash in the Money in the Bank briefcase (more on that fiasco much later). Morrison was nothing more than a more talented Alex Riley or Miztourage.
Sorry JoMo fans, but that’s the truth: Morrison is just an athletic Bo Dallas these days.
22. Bow Out, Not Bow Down
WWE’s King of the Ring is far from wrestling royalty, both in terms of in the ring and in booking.
King Corbin’s 2020 started with him battling Roman Reigns using dog food as a weapon, and it ended with him getting Wesley Blake & Steve Cutler as lackeys to bail him out, because that was what was lacking for him.
In between, Corbin lost his feud with Roman Reigns, lost to Elias at WrestleMania 36, lost the Money in the Bank ladder match, lost to Matt Riddle, lost to Otis, lost to Jeff Hardy, and lost at Survivor Series. He’s just a big goof with a crown and scepter at this point. If anyone needs to come off TV for a while and rebuild, it’s Corbin.
But he’s a heat machine!... said no one. If anyone is clamoring for a Baron Corbin match in 2020, they’ve got bigger problems in life.
21. Owens’ Listless Year
When you talk about wrestlers who are under-utilized in terms of talent and ability, you have to start with Kevin Owens.
KO’s 2020 was a nearly wasted year itself, save for a memorable WrestleMania 36 victory over Seth Rollins after a lengthy feud with the Monday Night Messiah. However, it was Rollins who emerged from Mania with the renewed push, while Owens fell into the background. He had some sporadic appearances before feuding with Aleister Black in a strange rivalry that could have been interesting but ultimately went nowhere.
Owens was all but a forgotten man when he was drafted to SmackDown, where he saved face with his feud with Roman Reigns to close out the year. But if you saw Mania and then saw TLC last week, you’d think KO had a banger of a 2020. You’d be shocked to learn that everything in between was just directionless fluff.
20. This Is The Feud That Never Ends
It’s understandable that WWE would want to get multiple PPV matches out of a marquee feud between top stars, especially in a year like this.
But the Randy Orton/Drew McIntyre feud was easily one of the worst ongoing feuds of the year, the kind where you were just wishing someone would pull the ripcord and eject it into oblivion. McIntyre won the first match at SummerSlam clean as a sheet with a backslide – a wrestling move against the guy who was running around calling himself the greatest wrestler alive.
However, that wasn’t the end of this rivalry. Oh no, we were just getting warmed up. We would have to endure weeks of McIntyre buddying up with and sticking up for a bunch of legends who Randy Orton had previously assaulted. Then those legends bailed the WWE Champion out in what should have been their definitive match, an ambulance match. Instead, Orton stalked the legends to goad a third PPV match, which Randy won. And then that set up one last bout for McIntyre to recapture the gold.
It was brutal, bad television. Four words: Randy Orton, night-vision goggles. Somehow, this wasn’t Orton’s worst performance of the year.
19. Not Seeing Eye-To-Eye With This
2020 brought us the advent of cinematic wrestling match, some of which was gold, some of which was so abysmal that they should be burned with fire and never seen again.
And then there’s the Eye-for-an-Eye Match between Seth Rollins and Rey Mysterio. The bout was exactly as described: Seth had punctured Rey’s eye on the steel steps, so it set up this PPV match where the winner needed to extract his opponent’s eye from its socket. That’s not a misprint or typo. If you just woke up from hibernation, this really happened.
Well, sort of. The match happened, and Rollins did win after shoving Mysterio’s face into the corner of the steel steps again. But we never really saw anything (despite rumors that WWE had brought in professional effects personnel for this stunt), and the match fell completely flat and was widely panned.
There’s an old adage about being careful to deliver what you promise, and WWE certainly didn’t do that here.
18. Throwing Dirt On The Title
This writer has had a love/hate relationship with the 24/7 Championship. Initially, the title was panned for being joke… until the joke actually became hilarious. All credit to guys like R-Truth, Drake Maverick and Jinder Mahal for making it work.
But in 2020, we saw the 24/7 title become nothing more than a running joke that just wasn’t funny. Maybe it was the global health crisis locking operations down in Florida that limited creativity with the title, but “defenses” became formulaic, as Truth would somehow get duped out of the title, only to win it back later that night. He would battle Akira Tozawa and his ninjas (yes, ninjas), Lucha House Party and Drew Gulak constantly, sometimes backstage, and sometimes in actual “matches” that lasted about 30 seconds in the ring.
Through it all, the ratio of humorous moments for the 24/7 Championship has dwindled to next-to-none. Sure, one week might get a couple chuckles, but by and large, the title is well past its sell-by date. Time to bury it and move on.
17. Throwing Down The Gauntlet
Back in the days when fans were allowed at wrestling events, tens of thousands of Saudi Arabians (and many more wrestling fans around the world) got to witness an embarrassment of a match, all for a “prestigious” trophy: the Tuwaiq Mountain Trophy Gauntlet Match.
The idea of a crappy gimmick match during these Saudi shows was not a new one, but this gauntlet match was probably worse than the Greatest Royal Rumble or the Best in the World Tournament. Put it this way: R-Truth “won” three bouts in a row, rolling up Bobby Lashley, falling on Andrade after they headbutted each other, and winning via DQ against Erick Rowan. This allowed AJ Styles to pick the bones and beat Truth, setting up a Styles/Rey Mysterio final.
But the OC beat up Mysterio, leading to a presumed forfeit for Rey. However, the Undertaker took his place and spiked Styles in minutes to win the “prestigious” tournament. All of that really happened. It was awful and insulting to fans.
It also was a funny way to give new meaning to the word “prestigious.”
16. Goldberg Buries Fiend
As a longtime WCW fan, this writer can’t hate on Goldberg. However, it’s still fair game to hate on how Goldberg was booked this year, and how that booking nearly ruined a character.
Bray Wyatt’s Fiend had been portrayed since his debut as all but indestructible, defeating Seth Rollins for the Universal Championship (as Wyatt) and then running through Daniel Bryan and tormenting The Miz before running into Goldberg at Super Showdown (the same show as the Tuwaiq Mountain Trophy Gauntlet Match).
The WCW legend proceeded to demolish Fiend in 3 minutes, winning the Universal Championship to set up a spear-versus-spear match at WrestleMania against Roman Reigns… only that match never happened. Instead, we got Braun Strowman winning the title.
Regardless, 53-year-old Goldberg running through the top heel in the company to set up a match to presumably once again try to get Reigns over at Mania might be just the perfect example of Vince McMahon being Vince. Goldberg buried Fiend for what ended up being no benefit whatsoever, and Wyatt had to dig himself out from that hole.
15. Where’s Aleister?
If you follow NXT, you know one of the best superstars to come through that brand was Aleister Black. He had “can’t miss” written all over him.
So naturally, WWE didn’t just miss, they screwed him up so royally that he closed out 2020 having just five televised matches in the past six months – four of which were losses, and none since being drafted to SmackDown two months ago. (Oh, and the company fired his wife, Zelina Vega.)
Black actually started out 2020 strong, picking up several squash wins and even defeating Bobby Lashley at WrestleMania 36. But once Paul Heyman was deposed from Raw, it all went downhill. Aleister lost his cool entrance and theme, got “injured” by Seth Rollins and started wearing an eye bandage, and then lost a few matches to Kevin Owens before disappearing.
It’s yet another example of WWE being so incompetent that they have a unique, talented superstar and almost deliberately botch his booking before cutting him loose, saying, “he just didn’t have it” or “he wasn’t a good fit.”
Maddening.