14 Greatest Rubber Matches In Wrestling History
As the saying goes, third time's a charm.
Be it a rivalry born out of mutual hatred, desire to win a title, or mere competitive spirit, many of wrestling's best feuds have ended with a rubber match. A final, definitive contest to decide who is the better competitor once and for all. As the saying goes, third time's a charm. The trope has been around for decades in wrestling, and given that two of 2015's most high profile matches were, at their core, rubbers, proves that they remain popular to this day. There were plenty others - some memorable, some less so - but last year's booking alone tells us that the concept has stood the test of time. A few ground rules for this one. Strictly speaking, a rubber match would be the third match in a trilogy of matches, acting as a tiebreaker to prove who the best competitor is. For the sake of making this an interesting list, the term 'rubber match' extends to something that settled an even feud, even if the number of victories each wrestler/team had were not exactly even. The 'third match in a trilogy' rule is there, where possible, but there are one or two exceptions it would have been remiss to exclude on a technicality.
14. Rey Mysterio Jr Vs. Ultimo Dragon - WCW Spring Stampede 1997

13. Bret Hart Vs. Diesel - WWF In Your House 6

12. John Cena Vs. Randy Orton - WWE Bragging Rights 2009

11. John Cena Vs. Kevin Owens - WWE Battleground 2015
NXT Champion Kevin Owens made his main roster debut on Raw on May 18 2015, interrupting John Cena's United States Championship open challenge. An embittered Owens resented Cena for being fast-tracked to the top of WWE, while he had worked the independent circuit for 15 years and had only just made it to the big time. He attacked Cena with the pop-up powerbomb and put a disrespectful boot on Cena's championship belt, setting up a match for Elimination Chamber. In one of WWE's biggest ever upsets, Owens beat Cena with a clean pinfall in his main roster debut. Cena won the rematch at Money in the Bank and an increasingly aggressive feud led to a US Championship bout at Battleground. The champion went into the bout under the greater pressure, aiming to preserve the integrity of his beloved championship. Cena is not renowned for a large move-set but the three matches against Owens brought the best out of WWE's poster boy. He used a wider range of holds and manoeuvres against KO than in many of his bouts. Owens used these three matches and the spotlight it brought to show off his technical prowess and prove what an amazing heel he is. He was brash and defiant, the perfect rival to Cena's clean-cut babyface. In the end, Cena made Owens tap out to the STF. Many would argue Cena's victory - and the manner of it - killed Owens' momentum and damned him to a disappointing midcard run for the rest of 2015. That's probably true, but the match still made Owens look relatively strong, particularly after he kicked out of an Attitude Adjustment from the second rope. Their match at Elimination Chamber was probably the best fight they had, but their Battleground bout ran it fairly close.10. Chris Jericho Vs. Rey Mysterio - Title Vs. Mask Match - WWE The Bash 2009

9. Diamond Dallas Page Vs. Macho Man Randy Savage - WCW Halloween Havoc 1997

8. Kurt Angle Vs. Shawn Michaels - 30 Minute Iron Man Match, WWE Raw (October 3 2005)
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xs5x9f_30-minute-iron-man-match-shawn-michaels-vs-kurt-angle_sport Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle are two of the best technical wrestlers to ever grace a WWE ring. With that said, it should come as no surprise that a dream rivalry between the two men produced three classic matches for the ages. Their feud started at the Royal Rumble, after HBK eliminated Kurt Angle with a superkick. Angle took quick revenge by getting back into the ring to dump Michaels over the top rope, then locked him in an ankle lock over a set of steel steps. Over the coming weeks, Angle revealed the scorn he felt for Michaels as he hogged the wrestling spotlight in 1996 while Angle was winning Olympic gold in Atlanta. The feud had everything - great promo work, a logical beginning point that uncovered a deep lying resentment, post-match attacks and two wrestlers that seem the polar opposite of one another. It led to a match at Wrestlemania 21, now touted as one of Mania's best ever contests. Angle got Michaels to submit to an ankle lock in a technically brilliant match that lasted nearly half an hour. Some consider the follow up even better, with HBK picking up the win at Vengeance after hitting Sweet Chin Music on Angle as he dived from the top rope. WWE never scheduled a rubber match for pay-per-view. Instead they set up a match between the two on a special 'Homecoming' edition of Raw as the show moved back onto the USA Network. The pair were pitted against each other in a 30 minute iron man match, and once again the duo put on an excellent technical bout. Angle picked up the first fall with an Angle Slam from the top rope, and Michaels levelled the scores by countering an ankle lock with a roll-up pin. HBK tapped to the ankle lock to put Angle back in the lead, but the Heartbreak Kid again tied the scores with Sweet Chin Music. As the last few seconds ticked away, Michaels hit Angle with Sweet Chin Music again. It proved too little too late as time ran out and the match ended level at 2-2. HBK demanded sudden death, but Angle slithered away to the locker room, happy to escape with a draw. Angle left WWE in 2006 and with Michaels now retired, there will never be a definitive answer as to who the better man was in this feud. Considering their three classic encounters, that feels entirely appropriate in this case.7. Brock Lesnar Vs. The Undertaker - WWE Hell In A Cell 2015
The Undertaker's 21-0 winning streak at Wrestlemania was the Holy Grail of wrestling. When Brock Lesnar broke it at Wrestlemania 30, it seems only logical that it would kick off one of the greatest feuds in the Deadman's career. Lesnar's streak-breaking victory over the Undertaker is undoubtedly one of the most shocking in the history of WWE. No-one really expected a part-time superstar being the one chosen to beat Undertaker at Wrestlemania. It would be over a year later before the two crossed paths again, with Undertaker's surprise return at Battleground 2015 to cost Lesnar a match for the WWE Championship against Seth Rollins. Their rematch at Summerslam ended in controversy. The timekeeper wrongly rang the bell as Lesnar had Undertaker in a kimura lock, so the match was restarted and after a low blow, 'Taker put Lesnar in the Hell's Gate submission hold until he passed out. The rubber match was set in WWE's most intimidating environment, Hell in a Cell. Both men had previous in the cell, and both are known for going to any length necessary to win. The match lived up to the billing - it was savage. The two duked it out in the opening stages, and it wasn't long before the cage became a dangerous weapon. The pair brought out a steel chair and the ring steps to liven up the bout though things got really tasty when Lesnar exposed the wooden ring boards by tearing up the ring mat. A chokeslam and tombstone later, Lesnar looked like toast. The Beast doesn't give up that easily, fighting back with a low blow of his own to set up an F5 on those exposed boards. Both Lesnar and Undertaker are known for their physicality, but even they went above and beyond all expectations with this meeting.6. Edge And Christian Vs. The New Brood - Ladder Match, WWF No Mercy 1999

5. Eddie Guerrero Vs. Dean Malenko - ECW (August 26 1995)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sAndeYqHya0 This match breaks the most rules on this list, particularly as it was not part of a trilogy - the bout is such a classic and served as a symbolic end to both a feud and both wrestlers' time with ECW, it had to be included. In an effort to differentiate itself from WWE and WCW, ECW and its creator Paul Heyman looked abroad for inspiration on how to make their product stand out. They signed a number of acclaimed wrestlers who were working in Japan and Mexico. Among the two biggest stars they signed were Eddie Guerrero and Dean Malenko. Both men were hugely proficient mat wrestlers. The combination of Malenko's ruthless style and 'Shooter' gimmick with Guerrero's agility and charisma led to a series of brilliant matches as they feuded over the ECW Television Title. On July 21 1995, Malenko beat Guerrero for the title only to lose it back to him a week later. As their feud progressed, they both got noticed by WCW and were signed to lucrative contracts. They fought their final ECW contest against one another on August 26, 1995 in a two-out-of-three falls match. Malenko and Guerrero showed just how they had earned their WCW contracts with an amazing display of chain wrestling through a tense, close battle. As both men's shoulders were down for the last fall, the match was declared a draw. After the contest was over, both Guerrero and Malenko gave impassioned promos about their time in ECW to chants of 'Please don't go' from the Philadelphia crowd. Members of the locker room filled the ring to carry Guerrero and Malenko on their shoulders, leaving ECW with a triumphant moment and one final classic match to remember.4. Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs. The Rock - WWE Wrestlemania 19

3. Ric Flair Vs. Ricky 'The Dragon' Steamboat - WCW Wrestlewar 1989
2. Kurt Angle Vs. Brock Lesnar - Iron Man Match - WWE Smackdown (September 18, 2003)

1. Edge And Christian Vs. Dudley Boyz Vs. Hardy Boyz - TLC II, WWF WrestleMania 17
