14 Ups & 0 Downs From Last Night's WWE NXT (Oct 16)

No viewers? No problem.

Finn Balor
WWE

What a time to be wrestling fan. Still.

Chasing their tails and the highs of the first TakeOver-style offering from the first full week on USA Network, NXT have been forced to try and make an awesome product even better to compete with an All Elite Wrestling juggernaut fuelled on novelty as much as nailed-on quality. AEW, with partial justification, also remain the babyfaces in this weekly feud, even though it's the wrestling audience that are served a heroes bounty every Wednesday night.

Actively damaging the credibility of the brand, the wrestling media at large has become so blindly effusive in its praise of the opposition of late that it’s been easy to assume that the “War” is already lost and NXT may as well just cease to exist.

Make no mistake here, WWE are being forced to swallow the consequences of their own actions. AEW’s creative successes and failures would be subject to far more cogent analysis if it wasn’t for the NXT USA move Vince McMahon pushed for. Instead, an expected weekly ratings hammering enhances the exhaustingly cliched criticisms of a very good Full Sail product.

This week in particular, those criticisms would caustically unfounded. This show ruled...


Ups...

14. Daddy's Home

Tommaso Ciampa Angel Garza
WWE.com

Much like the quality of the segment between them to set this match up, Tommaso Ciampa’s clash with Angel Garza surprisingly employed a bit of comedy before the cool and calculated former NXT Champion put his lesser for away with Willow's Bell.

A Fairytale Ending tease on Garza’s flag pants was an absurd spin on the jingoism of old, but married up more with his wry corridor attack last week than it did Hulk Hogan’s distaste for foreigners in the 1980s. Kayfabe distaste.

Harking back to another bald hairy-faced legend, this was all actually closer to Stone Cold Steve Austin's Survivor Series 1997 neck injury return. Kept short, kept cool and kept relevant, Ciampa's aura was restored immediately by the battle. Daddy really is home.


13. Dream Over

Velveteen Dream
WWE

Heating up an already red hot start to the show, The Undisputed Era didn't even let Tommaso Ciampa leave the ring before rounding on him in a moment ultimately set up for Kyle O'Reilly to chuck a USB drive at Maura Ranallo before the first commercial. Fortunately it wasn't a link to f*cking thesaurus.com.

A great angle with a unique delivery, the device turned out to be full of footage of a beatdown on Velveteen Dream that had apparently taken place during Ciampa's return.

Led by Roderick Strong after his half-cocked humiliation last week, The Era were in vile form. Cole closed the piece with shots at both Ciampa and Finn Bálor, leaving open the possibility that the four may be willing to go to War(games) with this unlikely babyface alliance.


12. Death Or Glory

Oney Lorcan
WWE.com

A ripper of a brawl between four men only too happy to kick the f*ck out of each other for the good of the cause, this was a typical ripper from Danny Burch and Oney Lorcan and a far superior exhibition of Imperium's gifts than their six-man effort against Kushida and Breezango several weeks ago.

NXT has the roster of wrestlers and staff to assemble television matches as good as this every week - and should aim to make it the show's modus operandi. Accusations of the in-ring style being too polished for its own good were kicked clean into the back bogs of Full Sail by this exhilarating deathblow-trading session eventually won by Walter's warriors.

On a show with Dominik Dijakovic and Keith Lee still to come, this was brave booking too.


11. Doing It Himself

Johnny Gargano
WWE

Johnny Gargano was again kept curiously quiet on this week's NXT, but in saying little he actually said enough.

After another video package trying to sum up an extremely complex history in all of a minute, Gargano has a quick word with Cathy Kelley on the subject everybody wanted his thoughts on - Tommaso Ciampa's return.

He was coy, but kept the eventual payoff succinct and simple - he'll know when he sees his former partner/blood rival face-to-face. It's a meeting NXT would do well to save for ratings-bait too.


10. Pysch-G.O.A.T Killer

Io Shirai
WWE.com

Io Shirai's quick victory over Kayden Carter only looked in doubt for a few seconds - until a wicked german suplex nearly separated the newcomer's head from her shoulders.

This was another tremendous match in a first hour full of them, despite following a fairly obvious formula.

Carter has looked good in defeat before, but the quality of this was assured from the second Shirai's music hit. Her excellence has long crossed gender lines - she's one of the best wrestlers in the world, and a weekly gift to this brand.

And speaking of weekly gifts...


9. Division Of Labour

Io Shirai Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

The NXT Women's division continues to embarrass the opposition with its embarrassment of riches, with Shirai using her post-match promo time to add herself to the list of contenders for Shayna Baszler's crown.

Bantering off last week's challengers Rhea Ripley and Bianca Belair, the 'Joshi Judas' tried to put herself back at the front of the queue before the former NXT UK Champion made her way out to reminder of the potential pecking order.

This is All. So. Good. In just two weeks, NXT have established a minimum of four credible challengers and about three different ways to cut down the field. Baszler's time on top has triggered a host of top-level TakeOver matches, but this might be the strongest the underneath offering have been during her entire tenure.


8. Regal Rules

William Regal
WWE.com

Adding drama to the already-dramatic, William Regal confirmed that the upcoming Keith Lee/Dominik Dijakovic superclash would be for a North American Title Number One Contender spot after Undisputed Era's attack on Velveteen Dream.

Simplistically elegant stuff, this - having to potentially face one of these beasts acted as cruel and unusual punishment from the General Manager for their crime.

It was also just nice to see an authority figure acting quickly and with pro wrestling parity. It's always been a strength of Regal's character since he took over several years ago, but this was the first major example of it in the USA Network era.

It also lit another fire under a match that was already ablaze...


7. The NeverEnding Story

Keith Lee Dominik Dijakovic
WWE.com

Your writer would welcome Dominik Dijakovic and Keith Lee fighting every single week if the former's name wasn't so f*cking hard to type every time, but the stress headache from the spellchecker has nothing on the punishment these two seem to enjoy enduring against one another.

Lacking an explosiveness of their last encounter, this was actually slightly smarter - perhaps in response to the off-kilter Twitter digs by The Revival and Buddy Murphy. In truth, they needn't have worried about those dissenting voices - the two know each other, know how to nearly kill each other, and know how to leave crowds breathless by the end.

An end deprived by Roderick Strong, the absolute piece of sh*t, who decked them both to trigger a disqualification and avoid a title defence. The triple threat solution from Regal was predictable, but kudos to the booking for still keeping Lee/Dijakovic all tied up.


6. Bro'nt Call It A Comeback

Matt Riddle Bronson Reed
WWE.com

Matt Riddle hurriedly silenced echoes of the Killian Dain programme in an emphatic television victory despite Bronson Reed's similar size.

Having little interest in Reed's best attacks or the potential size discrepancy between the two, Riddle smashed his opponent with the Bro2Sleep and a powerbomb to remind audiences of his freakish strength before chopping down the tree once and for all with a magnificent-looking Bro Derek for the win.

More all the bits than merely the best ones, this was a much-needed restart for Riddle after a slightly drab summer.


5. Do Call It A Comeback

Tegan Nox

Taynara hasn't really captivated from underneath in her role as over-confident jobber thus far, but she was at least bland enough to ensure that returning hero Tegan Nox took all of the shine in a hugely cathartic return clash.

Like Shawn Michaels clinging to his back at SummerSlam 2002, the knee braces on both of Tegan Nox's legs will serve as both target and tacit weakness during what will hopefully be a permanent return, with a sense of panic in her sell here doing much for Taynara's middling moveset.

Nox came through of course, taking the very important first step back with several almighty leaps forward. A senton in the corner and diving crossbody tested the wheels before the 'Girl With The Shiniest Wizard' proved as much with a face-kicking finale.

This was mint. As was what came next...


4. Queen Of Shade

Tegan Nox Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

A post-match interview with a tearful Nox and friend Dakota Kai was cruelly broken up by Shayna Baszler and the MMA Horsewomen, all of smug grins and sh*thouse intent.

A common criticism of modern wrestling, there was absolutely no doubting who were the babyfaces and heels here as the 'Queen Of Spades' rained on her return parade. Because this is NXT and not WWE, the babyfaces didn't back down from the Champion's bullsh*t, teasing a possible tag match as well as yet another Challenger for Baszler's belt.

If only Vince McMahon hadn't bastardised this phrase via Jon Moxley's Chris Jericho podcast. Because this was such good sh*t.


3. Demons

Finn Balor
WWE

Building on the promise of big Finn Bálor news earlier in the night, a pre-taped promo with him stayed incredibly loyal to his success and failures since leaving NXT for the main roster.

Bleeding black-and-gold as much as Johnny Gargano earlier in the night, Bálor spoke with such reverence for the brand (and such regret for how The Undisputed Era had taken over it) that it was impossible not to want to see the cooler older brother come back and clean all the sh*t up.

And he's doing so next week.


2. Dain Unto Others

Killiain Dain Boa

Perhaps Killian Dain and Matt Riddle were each other's kryptonites after all - the 'Northern Ireland Nightmare' had as good a night as the 'Original Bro' in his crushing win over Boa.

More good booking here - Boa was livid with being brutalised by Dain last week, and showed guts and guile even getting in there with the former Sanity member in the first place. More guts than brains, sadly - killer Killian flattened him with a trio of Vader Bombs like the nasty pr*ck he is.

A sideways camel clutch/abdominal stretch submission victory was academic. Unsurprising, considering how much thought was clearly given to this instant rehabilitation - especially when he stuck around to earn a finger-snap from Pete Dunne before the main event.


1. Ballseye

Damien Priest Pete Dunne
WWE.com

This gets said every week because the guy is on the show every week, but Pete Dunne's so awesome, and he put in a great shift here to help elevate exciting prospect Damien Priest.

Holding back on the 'Archer Of Infamy' for the first few weeks appeared to be a statement of intent from NXT gaffers - this match and its result was the latest tell. The packaging is already spot on, so reps such as this will only advance him up the black-and-gold brand faster. Even Mauro Ranallo was forced to fight with the word "toxophilite" just add to the presentation, but his bullsh*t wasn't required by the fervent finish.

Though Dunne couldn't score with the Bitter End or a moonsault, he did at least make it to Priest's fingers before getting hoofed with a low blow to set up The Reckoning and a huge upset win. The 'Bruiserweight' needs to relocate his killer instinct - those coming up underneath him have it to spare.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.