14 Ups & 3 Downs From NJPW/ROH G1 Supercard
Kazuchika Okada retakes the throne on a stunning night in Madison Square Garden.
The Ring Of Honor/New Japan Pro Wrestling G1 Supercard was a success long before the first bell rang at last night's show.
A complete sellout within an hour of tickets going on sale in August 2018, it was an immediate triumph from a business standpoint. The sport's second-biggest promotion and their American partners had sold out 'The World's Most Famous Arena,' Madison Square Garden, bloodying WWE's nose in the process. Not only had they stepped into Vince McMahon's backyard and accomplished a feat the market leader hadn't done in years, but slow NXT TakeOver ticket sales forced WWE to switch from their traditional Saturday night to Friday. Talk about a home run.
This business success would've meant little had the show not delivered, however. We're pleased to report it did. Your writer was in the house for a special night at MSG, and while the ROH portion of the show couldn't match the stellar NJPW parts, the G1 Supercard was the smash hit it needed to be.
An earlier-than-advertised start meant we missed the opening STARDOM six-woman tag. Other than that, here's everything that went down inside that beautiful, beautiful venue on a historic night for NJPW and ROH...
Downs...
3. Why Did This Exist?
Wrestling-friendly rapper Mega Ran, who composed the G1 Supercard's "Going To The Garden" theme, walked out to perform the track after the Beautiful People's ill-received debut. It was an interlude that precisely nobody asked for or wanted, and it went down as such.
Ran's a talented, likable guy, but this didn't work. He walked down the ramp, claimed that his arrival meant the show had "really started," got himself booed, and kicked into the song. This prompted hometown boy Bully Ray's arrival to a monster reception. Minutes later, after much pleading from Ran, the former Dudley Boy struck the rapper, chased him off, and got ready for his advertised New York Street Fight.
A pointless segment to cap the G1 Supercard's least enjoyable run of content, this could've been trimmed to save valuable minutes on this marathon show.
2. Kelly Klein's Big Moment Falls Flat
Mayu Iwantani and Kelly Klein's Women Of Honor Title match failed for two reasons:-
1. Bret Hart was assaulted at the WWE Hall Of Fame seconds after it had kicked off. This caught the whole arena's attention, with hordes of fans attached to their phone screens, desperate to get the scoop on an absurd situation across the East River in Brooklyn. Klein and Iwantani could've wrestled a modern classic and nobody would've given them a lick of notice, those poor, poor souls. A real shame for them.
2. Kelly Klein doesn't wrestle to what should be the modern working standard for women's wrestling. At a time when the likes of Io Shirai, Becky Lynch, and Charlotte Flair can genuinely be considered among the best in the world regardless of gender, her clunky, slow, mistimed movements don't cut it.
The match was a misfire. It didn't land, and the performers didn't seem to be on the same page, either. It made a phenomenal talent in Iwantani look normal and boring. this division needs to get its sh*t together, because having a subpar women's scene in 2019 isn't good enough.
1. The Beautiful People's Ugly Debut
The Klein/Iwatani post-match saw a surprise appearance from Velvet Sky and Angelina Love, AKA TNA's Beautiful People, who battered the new Women Of Honor Champion, joining forces with WOH stalwart Mandy Leon in the process.
Imagine how you'd feel if someone took a dump on your mother's chest. That's how this angle went down in MSG.
A complete misread of what the fans wanted from this show, it was a grim angle that prompted hundreds upon hundreds to bury themselves further in their phones or head for the toilet. Nobody cared - nobody - and given that ROH turning down a Beautiful People reunion in the promotion was reportedly part of why Madison Rayne left the company, it's hard to understand why they went ahead with it.
The three segments we've listed as Downs came one after the other, albeit not in the specific order listed here. At this point, it looked like ROH were on the verge of dragging down an awesome NJPW show. They didn't, thank God, but they came close.
Ups...
14. Lifeblood Get Hardcore
Bully Ray's New York City Street Fight was originally advertised as an open challenge. This changed when Juice Robinson, the affable IWGP United States Champion, answered the call prior to the event, but the former CJ Parker was ambushed backstage early in the night.
The challenge was reopened, and thus emerged the returning Flip Gordon to a big MSHG pop. He was swarmed by Silas Young and Shane Taylor within minutes of arriving, and out came Lifeblood's Mark Haskins and Robinson to even the odds, resulting in a wild, fun plunder brawl completely different to anything else on the show.
Though far from star ratings fodder, this wacky '90s WWE-style hardcore scrap served as a nice palette cleanser following the bullsh*t before it. We could have done without Taylor taking an unprotected chairshot straight to his big bald dome, though.
13. A Star-Making Squash
Rush vs. Dalton Castle f*cking ruled.
It was a three move squash, and ROH played it perfectly. Castle, the former Ring Of Honor Champion, was granted a long, elaborate ring entrance, with confetti, a raised platform, and an army of his Boys accompanying to the ring. Rush was given similar treatment in his horned mask and white suit, and dedicating so much time to these arrivals gave the impression a long, epic match was coming up.
We got the opposite. A lightning-fast shotgun dropkick sent Castle into the buckles. Rush's stiff, nasty Bull's Horns (a running basement dropkick straight to the face) followed, then again, and 'The Party Peacock' was put away in just 19 seconds.
This short, sharp shock hit like a slap in the face. Rush destroyed one of ROH's most popular stars, minting himself as a big, big deal in the process, and it sparked a memorable post-match angle.
12. Dalton Castle Turns
Castle's quick death left him as shocked as anyone else in Madison Square Garden, and the fans knew something was up as focus lingered on him in the arena, disbelief etched across his defeated face.
Dejected and enraged, Castle took it on the Boys. He turned heel on his little lads, driving one into the mat hard, prompting the other to lay across his broken body for protection. Big mistake. A Bangarang followed, and with the Boys slain, Dalton concluded his most memorable angle since returning from the debilitating back injury that has ravaged his physique and hampered his in-ring ability.
A new direction is precisely what Castle needs at this point, so let's hope it pays off.
11. Realest Guys In The Room?
Enzo Amore and Big Cass "invaded" the G1 Supercard last night. You've probably heard the details now, but check out the video above for Michael Sidgwick and Simon Miller's live, in-the-moment coverage last night.
This was almost certainly a work. It was absolutely insane. Yes, it starred a controversial couple of wrestlers, and yes, there are valid concerns to how their run will play out, but this absolutely got over inside MSG.
The heat was nuts as soon as people figured out who'd jumped the barricade to assault the Briscoes, and that the wrestlers were instructed to legitimately beat the sh*t out of Enzo made it feel real. It looked like Mark Briscoe and Bully Ray were legitimately taking lumps out of him. It's hard to put into words just how hot the building got as a result of this, and that's why it can't be anything than an Up.
ROH will present this as a shoot. They apparently didn't stream or acknowledge it on the broadcast at all. Whether or not this is the right approach remains to be seen, but it got over in the building.
10. Rumbles Are Great
Ostensibly a big bad Banter match, last night's Honour Rumble was tonnes of fun.
Entrants came thick and fast. The supposed 60-second intervals kept things moving, and there were all kinds of fun moments peppered throughout. Tomohiro Ishii and Minoru Suzuki reprised last year's hard-hitting rivalry. Rocky Romero ran wild with Forever Clotheslines as Ryusuke Taguchi directed traffic. The soon-to-retire Jushin Liger got an incredible pop. Haku showed up. THE GREAT MUTA entered at number 30, for God's sake!
A busy, crowded match boiled down to Muta vs. Liger an in an epic battle of the puroresu dads - or so we thought. Kenny King, who'd entered at number one but spent most of the match hiding on the outside, snuck back in, eliminated both, scored the win, and basked in the ensuing troll heat.
King paid for it with a face full of Muta's mist after the bout, the prick. Much deserved.
9. In Which PCO Almost Dies
The ROH vs. IWGP Tag Team Title four-way scramble over-delivered.
To what extent? Well, PCO did this, the mad c*nt:-
Jesus CHRIST. That man is 51 years old.
The former Quebecer and partner Brody King faced Guerrillas Of Destiny, The Briscoes, and SANADA and EVIL. They performed as if the preceding Junior Heavyweight title match had lit a fire beneath them and they were trying to outdo Bandido, Dragon Lee, and Taiji Ishimori because they worked at a breakneck pace, layering spots on top of spots on top of spots to craft a chaotic, out-of-control spectacle.
With the PCO bump and Enzo Amore/Big Cass invasion angle, Tama Tonga and Tanga Loa becoming double champions is somehow one of the match's smallest stories. That's a shame, because they, like their cohorts, worked their backsides off throughout. They killed it.
8. The Garden
Madison Square Garden is a stunning sports venue that must be experienced in person to be truly appreciated, and it was absolutely the right place for NJPW and ROH to hold this landmark event.
This will sound like hyperbole to anyone who wasn't there, but it was like watching a great wrestling show inside a sporting museum. 'The World's Most Famous Arena' is a monument. It's an immaculate, evocative, and atmospheric building that doesn't just look great, but feels incredible too, and taking in the G1 Supercard in such surroundings was a delight.
The crowd were on fire throughout, the presentation was sublime, the views were great, and the seating comfortable. Really, the experience can't be faulted.
7. The Junior Heavyweights Go NUTS
Coming in at a shade under nine minutes, the Taiji Ishimori vs. Dragon Lee vs. Bandido IWGP Junior Heavyweight Triple Threat was much shorter than most expected. It didn't matter. This, like last year's ALL IN main event, was a berzerk blitzkrieg that actually benefitted from its shorter runtime, with three of the world's foremost high-flyers cramming all kinds of madness into the curtailed runtime.
If you like sprints, you need to check this out. It was one of the most gif-worthy matches of the year, and with moments like Bandido nailing his top rope Moonsault slam on both men and Lee hitting one of the best Canadian Destroyers your writer has ever seen, it is crammed with beautiful set pieces. Jim Cornette types will likely be appalled, but that's their loss.
Dragon Lee scored the win with a pin on Bandido, so the prospect of a singles match between him and Ishimori remains. This is his first IWGP Junior Heavyweight Title reign. He's a stellar performer, he deserves it, and earned it on the back of another breakneck NJPW performance.
6. Taven Triumphs In Tremendous LLadder War
The ROH World Championship three-way ladder match wasn't the kind of bout that appeals to everyone.
An atypical bout for the stipulation, it wasn't the wild, fast-paced maelstrom many might have anticipated. Matt Taven, Jay Lethal, and Marty Scurll slowed down on several occasions. This may have fatigued some as the show headed towards its fifth grueling hour, but in this writer's eyes, those moments of quiet only enhanced the crazy, destructive spots - of which there were many.
Notable highlights saw Lethal powerbombed onto a ladder bridge, Jay paying tribute to Jeff Hardy by diving onto Taven from a ridiculous oversized ladder, and Scurll trapping Lethal upside down by jamming his head in a ladder and draping his legs over the top turnbuckle. Throw some outstanding Scurll knee-selling and great heel work from Taven into the mix and were left with one of the night's craziest matches.
Taven eventually clambered up a custom purple ladder, knocked Lethal down, and seized the ROH Championship. Nobody was happy about this, but that's the point: he's the bad guy. MSG got worked.
5. Check The Technique
It speaks to Hiroshi Tanahashi and Zack Sabre Jr.'s skill as performers that they were able to pull the MSG crowd into their careful, methodical technical batter after the insanity of Enzo and Big Cass' arrival.
Lesser wrestlers would've been lost. This chess battle would have gone down like a fart in an elevator, and the G1 Supercard may have fallen off a cliff. It didn't, though. ZSJ and Tana delivered a smart continuation of their awesome New Japan Cup clash in a 15-minute battle punctuated by an undercurrent of nastiness, concluding in one of the biggest victories of Sabre's career.
His Orienteering With Napalm Death submission had The Ace knotted like a pretzel, forcing the icon to verbally submit on this special night. Tanahashi had no choice. He failed in his quest to become RevPro British Heavyweight Champion, and Sabre celebrated his victory like a last-minute winner in a football match,
4. Cobb & Ospreay Mesh Beautifully
ROH TV Champion Jeff Cobb vs. NEVER Openweight Champion Will Ospreay opened the G1 Supercard proper, and it came exactly as advertised. That is to say it was absolutely astounding.
This was pure video game material, with Ospreay using his prodigious agility and athleticism to flip and fly his way out of Cobb's vast array of suplexes and slams, landing on his feet when he should have eaten dirt on several occasions. Their styles complimented each other perfectly. Cobb, one of the world's strongest wrestlers, was out to throw Ospreay across the ring like an empty tracksuit. He succeeded on several occasions, and this ultimately led to his victory, but watching Ospreay evade him and get hossy himself on occasion made for spectacular viewing, and one of the best matches of 2019 thus far.
... and it was only the third best bout on this show, for crying out loud.
A top rope Tour Of The Islands brought Cobb the victory and made him a double champions. Him and Ospreay killed it out there. Seek this match out immediately.
3. The Authentic NJPW Main Event Experience
It took serious, serious balls to do what Kazuchika Okada and Jay White did last night, and they pulled it off.
After the absurd Junior Heavyweight and Tag Team Title spotfests, the fluid technical mastery of Sabre vs. Tanahashi, the career-shortening Naito vs. Ibushi neck destruction fest, and the hard-bumping ladder match, Okada and White worked the classic New Japan main event format. That long, drawn out, slow-burning style should have bombed, but guess what? It didn't.
They took the show from sixth gear back down to first, then worked through them once move, building towards an electric conclusion that had everyone in the Garden enraptured. They could (and should) have lost the audience; instead, they crafted the G1 Supercard's most memorable climax.
A riveting closing stretch concluded with 'Switchblade' falling to two consecutive Rainmakers. We'll talk about Okada's victory later, but credit to White. His IWGP Title win drew much criticism, but he keeps knocking it out of the park between the ropes in 2019, and he did it again last night.
2. Match Of The Year
Recency bias is real, and great matches always come across better live and in-person, but Tetsuya Naito vs. Kota Ibushi was 2019's best wrestling match.
Better than Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Kenny Omega.
Better than Tomohiro Ishii vs. Kazuchika Okada.
And yes, better than Adam Cole vs. Johnny Gargano.
These guys continued where they left off in their grisly New Japan Cup scrap by destroying each other's spinal columns with all manner of brutal offence. Hatred permeated every single second, their chemistry was palpable, and the atmosphere was so hot that people were chanting "this is awesome!" before they'd even locked up. Such was the power of Naito vs. Ibushi.
We'll avoid minor details so as to not detract from the experience, because this match needs to be seen. It was two of the best wrestlers in the world whipping a white-hot arena into a frenzy with a beautifully barbaric in-ring story, resulting in the night's most cathartic finish, and it set an impossibly high bar for the rest of WrestleMania weekend to follow.
1. Make It Rain
Kazuchika Okada overcame Jay White to claim his fifth IWGP Heavyweight Championship in last night's G1 Supercard main event. It was the perfect moment to continue a perfect wrestling storyline at the conclusion of a near-perfect event.
White had Okada's number heading into the show. He'd defeated 'The Rainmaker' while in his broken state in last year's G1 Climax, then repeated the feat with a shocking triumph over the seemingly recovered former champion at Wrestle Kingdom 13. Both victories were vital in building towards his IWGP Title win, and after winning the New Japan Cup, Okada was out for revenge in New York.
He did so by learning from past mistakes. This was a smarter, sharper Okada: one who understood how to counter his former manager Gedo's interferences and distractions, and approached the bout with a far greater understanding of White's arsenal. That's what led him to victory, and he looked great in doing so.
White loses nothing in defeat, either. First IWGP Title reigns are never long, and he fell to the best wrestler on the planet. He'll be fine. He's a world-class heel, an ever-improving wrestler, and a guy whose day will come again.
For now, though, NJPW belongs to the 'Rainmaker' once more.