15 Best WWE Royal Rumbles Ever

Which one is your favourite?

The Royal Rumble...for over twenty-five years, the revolutionary force in sports entertainment. It does not get much bigger. Only WrestleMania compares on the level of fan anticipation and expectation. So, indeed, WWE has hit a home run with the gimmick match that they created in 1988 to swat the pesky fly that was the Jim Crockett Promotions-led NWA and its Bunkhouse Stampede PPV. Vince McMahon was on a roll back then, was he not? It seemed like everything that he tried worked not just to a degree, but substantially. There is not a more popular gimmick match in the modern era. For over a decade, it has helped the PPV bearing its name to financial success nearly unrivaled in the business. Perhaps that is, in part, because of its direct tie to WrestleMania. For some fans, however, the match that marks the beginning of the Road to Mania is actually more exciting than what lies at the end of the Road. Even without any hype, Rumble matches provide a caliber of excitement that no other match throughout the rest of the year can offer. It is, in a single word: special. So, let us celebrate the forthcoming spectacular by looking back at the 15 greatest Rumble matches.

15. Royal Rumble 1991

On any given viewing, Rumble '91 can seem like one of the best of the rest or one of the matches in the middle of the pack. The climax that saw Hulk Hogan win his second consecutive Rumble match by last eliminating Earthquake could just as easily be construed as an example of the dwindling momentum for Hulkamania as it could be the apparent end of a marginally enjoyable Hogan feud dating back to the previous year. The field of wrestlers might well be considered "stacked" by some fans, yet full of "nobodies" to others. All in all, it earns its place by virtue of its simplicity. Back then, the Rumble had no need to reinvent itself because it was still inventing itself. In only its fourth year, the concept's bread and butter was the unpredictability of the entrant order, the countdown from the live audience, and the anticipation of the next man in. The strength of the match was allowing talented workers like Bret Hart, British Bulldog, and Tito Santana to shine and MVPs, Greg Valentine and Rick Martel, to spend 40+ minutes each building the baseline for the outing. Little else was needed for this match to be a success.

14. Royal Rumble 2009

For several consecutive years, there was a pattern to the booking of Rumble matches. 2009 seemed to be the year that threw out the established playbook. Perhaps Pat Patterson stopped helping? He had been brought into the fold to help piece together Rumble matches since their inception. '09 did not have the feel of a Patterson Rumble. The biggest difference was the sheer number of superstars who filled the ring without a mass elimination spree. Arguably, eliminations are what keep the match interesting, so not employing it as frequently was a risk. To some, it paid off. To others, it was a step down from previous years. To nearly everyone, though, it was another highly entertaining version of the gimmick. It was surely fascinating to see so many people piled into the ring. Randy Orton and his Legacy (Cody Rhodes and Ted Dibiase) had very notable performances, with Orton winning the match with their help by last eliminating Triple H. Orton and Trips were in for nearly 50-minutes apiece. Along with Rey Mysterio, they were the MVPs of the match. Mysterio's work with John Morrison in the early stages set a great tone, the story between Trips and Orton carried much of the Rumble, and the rest of the bout was sprinkled with enough top stars to keep things fresh despite the lack of eliminations to break up the monotony.

13. Royal Rumble 2012

In many ways, 2012 was an example of some of the best and worst things about modern Rumble match trends, depending on your point of view. If you like the comedy thrown into the matches in recent years, then 2012 well exemplified how to execute it in as entertaining a fashion as you could expect. Mick Foley came back to join the fray, combining with Santino Marella for an amusing bit that saw the two fashion their hands/arms with their classic puppets - Mr. Socko and the Cobra, respectively - for a sock puppet showdown of sorts. If that is not your cup of tea, then 2012 may not have fully connected for you. One newspaper's review spoke to that opinion, calling the Rumble "fun..but without much substance." The Miz and Cody Rhodes provided the foundation for the match with a pair of 45-minute outings that elevated them both. If you did find 2012 to be amongst the best, it would likely be due to its climax. The Rumble is booked to its finest when WWE identifies the favorites and makes sure that they are around at the end. Chris Jericho was the odds-on favorite. Sheamus was considered not quite a dark horse. When they were the final two, it seemed that it could go either way. The two pros played to that fact and kept everyone guessing for several minutes, having a "match within the match" similar to the Undertaker-HBK ending in 2007 that drew considerable praise. To the critics of the 2012 Rumble, it might also speak to them to state that the finish was the only redeeming quality. A mixed bag to be sure, but it left an impression.

12. Royal Rumble 1994

Fairly pedestrian in many ways, the '94 Rumble match was, in other ways, incredibly entertaining. Of course, there was the finish. Much credit must be given where it is due for the finish that saw Lex Luger and Bret Hart eliminated at the same time, leading to mass confusion and the excitement that accompanied it. It was an innovative climax that required impeccable timing from all parties involved, including the cameramen. All these years later after repeated viewings, it is safe to say that everyone succeeded. What an ending! Several years into the concept, it was the right time to pull such a stunt. Plus, it was an integral part in returning the Hit Man to the peak of the WWE mountain, giving this Rumble match an added boost of historical credibility. This was an interesting blend of initial boom period stars and new generation stars, with Diesel having a coming out party of sorts that earned him the crowd€™s respect and began the slow push toward his title win later that year. HBK also shone bright, bumping all over the place and creating for exciting near eliminations in a manner that became more of a staple as the roster got smaller in stature. Diesel was arguably the match MVP. He displayed an intensity and desire to steal the show that exuded his passion for the business.

11. Royal Rumble 1989

If Royal Rumble matches were defined only by the majority of their overall story and not the totality, then Rumble '89 might well have been considered amongst the very best. The first three-quarters of the match were excellent, with standout performances from Mr. Perfect, Andre the Giant, Ax, and Hulk Hogan. Perfect, in particular, was the star of the first half of the match, bumping all over the place and creating drama during the dozen times he was nearly eliminated. He was the man responsible for teaching the fans the fullest extent of what a Rumble match could be. The 1988 version was the dry-run; 1989 was when the match started to become what we know it to be today - the match that made possible all of the superlatives used in the introduction. Perfect's '89 outing was one of the greatest in Rumble lore. You can trace the lineage of Ziggler in 2013, Mysterio in 2009, Benoit in 2004, Jericho in 2003, HBK in 1995, and Flair in 1992 back to Curt Hennig's "perfect" performance in 1989. After Hogan was ousted, the match slowed down considerably. In the end, Big John Studd got the win in the midst of a failed babyface push. Also of note was that it took the crowd a few entrants to start the countdown chant leading to the next wrestler. A crowd hasn€™t failed to do it since.

10. Royal Rumble 2003

The early part of this Rumble was some of the most entertaining stuff ever seen from the gimmick. Thanks in large part to Chris Jericho, Rey Mysterio, and Edge, the first 10-15 minutes were absolutely awesome to watch. Jericho carried the majority of the match with his ill-fated quest to win from #2. His story with Shawn Michaels kicked off the match with a bang, reinvigorating the audience as it naturally came down from the Angle-Benoit induced high from minutes prior. A quest of the Y2J variety proved to be the ideal compliment to the climax. Jericho was clearly never going to win, but his attempts to make people think that he would added an element to the match that very few other Rumbles have executed quite so well. There were several good changes of pace, too. Edge and Mysterio added a high octane element, Matt Hardy and Shannon Moore provided comedy in a less obvious manner to what 2012 so prominently displayed, and the bigger talents like Lesnar, Batista, Taker, and Kane switched to a heavier-hitting gear later on. The final four was not overly spectacular, as it just was not that exciting when you saw Lesnar in there against three guys so highly unlikely to win. It weakened the unpredictability that so often carries Rumble matches, but never replaced it with anything to help sell the bigger picture of Brock's earning a title shot, as was the case with Triple H and Randy Orton, for instance, in 2009. Still a thoroughly enjoyable Rumble overall, though; a match that you should certainly not skip over if chronicling all of the Rumble matches.

9. Royal Rumble 2001

One of the greatest things about the Royal Rumble "best" debate is that, unlike with classic singles matches, the 30-man gimmick has taken on many forms and has adapted its formula numerous times. Thus, fans may agree on the top two or three in history, but there are a wide variety of opinions on the "others." 2001 is a Rumble that often finds itself right in the thick of things at the top of the heap. Though it features many notable performances that arguably outweigh its negatives, the overall result was a Rumble that better fits the middle of the pack, interchangeable perhaps with the best of the rest but not the best of the best. The Rock, Kane, and Steve Austin were all marvelous. They were the primary highlights. Up until last year, Kane earned from this match the record for most eliminations in a single Rumble. It was one of the biggest nights of his entire career and a feather in his cap that was noted on commentary for a decade plus. The Rock and Austin seemed the obvious top choices for the winner, but Kane did a good job of making it seem like there might well be a third candidate. At the end of the day, Rock and Austin were the heavy favorites for a reason and, when Rock was eliminated, it made it clear that the Rattlesnake's journey to regain the title was going to be the Mania focal point. Drew Carey made the '01 Rumble similar to 2012, in that it had outstanding work in the climax, particularly, but had a giant moment of comedy that was hit or miss to some sects of the audience. In a comparative analysis, such things stand out.

8. Royal Rumble 2006

One of the simplest formulas for creating a successful Royal Rumble match is to have a consistent story throughout featuring an early entrant going on to win or come up just a little bit short. Rey Mysterio, in 2006, had the added bonus of carrying Eddie Guerrero's spirit with him into the New Year. Some have argued over the years that Latino Heat's untimely passing was the only reason for Mysterio's rise, but such arguments fail to take into account all of 2005 - when Mysterio was routinely defeating Guerrero en route to advancing definitively beyond his mid-card roots and onto the cusp of the main-event scene. Entering at #2, Mysterio had to overcome the other overwhelming favorite to win that year in Triple H, who everyone had pretty much assumed since the previous summer would be wrestling John Cena for the WWE Championship. There was also Randy Orton to contend with later in the night, which would foreshadow a large chunk of the World Heavyweight Championship situation at WrestleMania 22. So, Mysterio winning was by no means a given. In fact, it was never a given for any 1st-3rd entrant who won it all. The odds so heavily stack the deck against that logically happening that, when it does, it is difficult for it not to come across as a miracle. Unpredictability was a helpful tool in elevating the overall impression left by this Rumble. Mysterio, Orton, and Trips were all there for the climax. Mysterio put in one of his all-time great performances that night.

7. Royal Rumble 2002

For anyone who adores the 1992 Rumble because it is like taking a walk down Memory Lane for fans from the Rock and Wrestling Era, the 2002 Rumble was similar to fans of the Monday Night Wars. You had Rikishi, who rode the late Attitude Era to heights few ever thought possible for the Phat Man, entering first. The Hardy Boyz reunited early on in the match. The Undertaker was the dominant force of the first half and provided a shockingly memorable moment when he was eliminated by Maven, winner of a competition that came about solely because of the success of the Attitude Era. You also had the APA, Billy Gunn, Christian, and Big Bossman as highly relevant stars from that period. It was like a "Who's Who of Attitude" the entire match, with spotlight returns afforded to Goldust, Val Venis, and The Godfather after each had less successful stints in other roles. Mr. Perfect came back, too, and excelled as one of the focal points of the climax. Not to mention that a number of WCW stalwarts, such as Booker T and Diamond Dallas Page, made their first Rumble appearances. And don't forget the incomparable Rob Van Dam doing the same. Your opinion of the match likely hinges on the performances by three particular individuals; Kurt Angle, Steve Austin, and Triple H. The story of the match during the weeks leading up to the Rumble was that of a four man race for the main-event slot afforded the winner. Taker had already been written out long before the final four, so it was up to Angle, Trips, and Austin. Stone Cold was on his last legs as a character, eking out a few months of nostalgia with the horrific "What?" chant inching him toward retirement. In the end, it came down to HHH and Angle, with The Game using the Rumble win to further his comeback story.

6. Royal Rumble 2005

Has a botched finish ever worked out so well for a match? Think back to the conclusion of 2005's Royal Rumble. If Batista had merely tossed John Cena out of the ring, as was originally planned, then this would not be remembered in as high a regard or, arguably, even be memorable at all (as compared to its peers, anyway). Yet, because Batista and Cena mistimed a powerbomb and, in perfect unison that only fate could have intended, tumbled together over the top rope and to the floor at the same time, '05 is a borderline classic. Vince McMahon blew out quadriceps muscles in both legs in an angry tirade that is quite amusing to watch, in retrospect. He came storming to the ring, throwing his jacket off, huffing and puffing with steam coming out of his ears, half seriously and half in attempt to corral control of the match back onto the original plan. Smackdown referees, who moments prior were declaring Batista the winner despite his Raw status and the clear cut and obvious fact that both men touched the floor in unison, went back to toting the blue brand's flag once Vince relayed his instructions, but it wasn't before the Chairman dove under the bottom rope and slammed his knee into the corner of the apron. That blew out quad #1. Then, he tried to stand up, perhaps not yet realizing his injury and proceeded to tear quad #2. It was incredibly exciting to watch just the other day, much less live on PPV on the night of a decade ago. Earlier in the match, Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit had been showmen, carrying the first half of the match with help from Edge and Rey Mysterio. Raw and Smackdown collided in a preview of the year's on-going feud. Pride for brand took a backseat to pride for country as stars from both rosters united to make quick work of a foreign threat. Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle provided what would have otherwise been the most memorable moment, laying the groundwork for their classic WrestleMania clash. Collectively, these moments paled in comparison to the crazy melee that characterized the climax. However, the move gone wrong at the finish actually made these other things seem a little more right. That's what an exciting finale can often do, correct? It can make the rest of a performance better by comparison...and it doesn't necessarily have to be on-purpose.

5. Royal Rumble 1990

What do you want from a Royal Rumble match? What are the essential elements for this gimmick to be successful? Preferably, you want the finish to tell a story within a bigger story. The Royal Rumble is, after all, a means to a very large end: WrestleMania. You also want the other top talents that do not win the Rumble to go out in style. They are top guys for a reason, so their failure to win arguably the second most important match of the year (outside of the WM main-event) should be made to seem important. Then, there is the role of the Ironman, usually going to a relevant headliner tasked with giving the match a solid foundation. Then, there are the spotlight eliminations of the wrestlers that you can almost guarantee are not going to win the match, but who are largely responsible for providing the action unassociated with the ten minutes or so given to the climax and to the eliminations of the headliners. If you can add a hot crowd and a decent amount of hype for the match during the lead-in shows on TV, then you have a Rumble with just about everything. 1990 benefits from having one of the intangible qualities that, outside of the above, help shape the perception of a Royal Rumble match: a moment that lives through the ages. Hulk Hogan vs. Ultimate Warrior has stood the test of time for a reason - their WrestleMania VI clash of the titans was the original babyface match on the grand scale that we have come to expect. Yet, it was their Rumble moment that basically took care of the hype. Warrior and Hogan; Hogan and Warrior. Two iconic heroes staring a hole through each other with the people standing in awe. Sure, the finish was just fine. Hogan last eliminated Mr. Perfect, undefeated at the time in singles competition and with as high a profile as he would ever have. Sure, performances like that from the Million Dollar Man helped define the Ironman role for the gimmick. Indeed, there were spotlight eliminations that are as enjoyable today as they were then. The crowd was involved, too. It was that one moment in combination with all of the above, though, that separates Rumble '90 from the majority of its peers.

4. Royal Rumble 2007

If Rumble '90 separates itself from the pack because of an awesome "moment," then Rumble '07 does so via the greatest climax in Royal Rumble match history. Let us face the facts: Rumble 2007 was billed as the most star-studded Rumble of all-time because stars from the ECW brand were included; it was anything but. Overall, it was a decent Rumble with a few notable happenings throughout, just as we typically see on a year-to-year basis. Yet, when it came down to the Final Four, the complexity of the match changed and, with it, the historical perception. Edge, Randy Orton, Shawn Michaels, and Undertaker. One had already won the Rumble before. All four eventually would by the time all had been said and done in their careers. Who would emerge victorious that night? Conventional wisdom discarded Edge and Orton as possibilities, despite their respective statures at the time. Nevertheless, they maximized their minutes as the antagonists to an otherwise protagonist story of monumental proportions. Hyberbole? Absolutely not. Starting with Rated-RKO attempting to heel their way into the WrestleMania main-event, the final minutes of the '07 Rumble were absolutely fantastic; as good a 10 minutes as you will ever see in pro wrestling. Though still a shame that their issue did not lead to a match at Mania, Orton and Edge played their roles beautifully. Then, it came down to HBK and Taker. It was the first of two Rumble previews of their iconic, all-time classic Mania series. In a piece of Rumble history that has already been (and will continue to be) copied, the two legends tore the house down. It was in HBK's hometown, but Taker's unquestionable status kept it from seeming like the odds were definitively in the Showstopper's favor. When the Deadman finally did manage to dump Michaels over the top, wrestling fans had just witnessed something special. That climax has no peers in Rumble lore.

3. Royal Rumble 2008

Another intangible Rumble "moment" that has often been utilized over the years is the surprise return, but never in the gimmick's history was it handled as well than when John Cena shocked the world in 2008. At Madison Square Garden in New York City, Rumble '08 was chock full of memorable performances, but they were all to be trumped by an unforgettable #30 entrant. Months prior, Cena had been written off TV, presumably for several months that would go beyond WrestleMania XXIV. Triple H was, then, pegged as the most likely Rumble winner, set to take Cena's place in the main-event. WWE played up to this common thought process, having Trips enter at #29 after all other, lesser favorites had been eliminated. 5...4...3....2....1.... Cue familiar music. "My Time is Now"?!?! Everyone gasped. The people in attendance, already on their feet, rose a little higher to their tip toes, desperately trying to catch a glimpse of what was happening in that tiny MSG tunnel. A man walked out wearing Cena's clothes and Cena's hat, but he had his head down, so surely it was just a joke being played by a dastardly heel trying to earn cheap heat....right? Wrong! It was, in fact, John Cena! The rest is history. Cena proved to be a machine for the rest of his career. He is like a cyborg that needs to have his mechanical parts lubricated instead of a true human-being with breakable bones and tearable ligaments. His return embodied the ideal that "anything can happen in WWE" and the 2008 Royal Rumble shined because of it. Of course, it also shined because HBK and Undertaker spent the first thirty minutes recreating, in spurts, the magic on display at the previous year's climax and for a handful of other reasons, too, but the intangible quality of Cena's rapid comeback from injury is one of the greatest in Rumble lore.

2. Royal Rumble 1992

If there is one iconic Royal Rumble match that, to most fans, stands alone amongst its peers, it would be 1992. And for good reason. Ric Flair's victory told us the original story of achieving victory despite near-impossible odds. When he entered at #3, he was justifiably written off as a potential winner by 99% of the audience. To that point in Rumble history, there was no precedent established that would make thinking otherwise logical. Bobby "The Brain" Heenan's words on commentary reflected that notion. He was so dejected that his client and friend had been dealt such a presumably lousy blow from Lady Luck. Of course, Heenan would provide a soundtrack to the match that has never been duplicated, as subjective as it may have been. He was superlatively outstanding, giving the '92 Rumble an intangible quality similar but not equal in scope to the previously mentioned "moments" of early entries. Flair finding a way to win was an outstanding way to stamp him with a seal of WWE approval. "The Dirtiest Player in the Game" had used any means necessary to gain underhanded victories galore in his NWA career, but WWE's audience was different. Flair was being pushed to the WrestleMania main-event in his first five months with the company. They needed to make him credible. Mission accomplished. WWE had never seen a heel quite like him in the early WrestleMania Era. Flair's performance is still amongst the greatest in Rumble match history, watching like a microcosm of his career as he worked with so many different styles of wrestlers during his hour long march to glory. "Star-studded" this match has often been named. Indeed, it was dotted from the outset with incredibly relevant talents. Shawn Michaels had one of his first great outings as a singles wrestler, perhaps inspired by sharing the ring with Flair. Jake Roberts and Randy Savage had a memorable encounter, with the enduring clip of Macho Man bursting through the curtain like he had been shot out of a canon as readily cued up in the mind as any in Rumble lore. Savage's gaffe of eliminating himself and then having to be reinstated by a technicality explained by Heenan and Monsoon aside, the Macho vs. Snake portion of the match was one of those feuds within the greater context of the match that separates '92 from the pack. Hulk Hogan and Sid Justice were favorites for a reason and they played their roles well in creating tension between them to open the door for Flair to squeak out the win. All in all, 1992 is considered the original standard for Rumble matches for a reason.

1. Royal Rumble 2004

Your Royal Rumble narrator can certainly appreciate the idea that 1992 is the best, but after watching all the top matches in question, it was made apparent that a new standard was set in 2004. It has been wiped off the face of the earth in WWE's mind, for the obvious reason of its winner. Yet, unlike the list of greatest non-Rumble matches released a few days ago - which saw Kurt Angle vs. Chris Benoit dropped to #2, in part, because of its "out of sight, out of mind" quality in WWE lore - the depth of the '04 Rumble match was too great to ignore. Benoit's journey to win the World Heavyweight Championship was a phenomenal story. He was the backbone that made the match the classic that it was. However, if you go back to entry #5 on this countdown and read over the essential elements described for Rumble match success, there is not a single element missing in 2004. So, that means that Benoit's tale may have been the highlight, but every conceivable quality that you could ask for in a Rumble was present before his climactic moment capped it off. Perhaps the thing about the '04 Rumble that stands out most is how connected it was to the WrestleMania that followed it. The Royal Rumble and WrestleMania are intricately connected. The success of one is often linked to the success of the other. Never was that more the case than it was in 2004. The '04 Rumble match was essentially a preview of the WrestleMania XX card. Take, for instance, the teased return of the Deadman, which sparked the rekindling of the feud between Undertaker and Kane for WrestleMania. Then, add Mick Foley stealing a spot in the match to take out Randy Orton, leading to another WrestleMania match. Goldberg vs. Brock Lesnar was furthered, too. Forget that their match ended up stinking out Madison Square Garden. Their Rumble moment was spine-tingling. John Cena vs. Big Show, which was the Mania XX opener, also earned a splash of added hype through the Rumble match. And, though it was not explicitly stated on-air, one could even infer that Kurt Angle's disappointment in failing to win, after dedicating his victory to the American Armed Forces, might have been the catalyst for his character to snap and become so hateful toward eventual WWE Champion, Eddie Guerrero. Oh, and Christian and Chris Jericho hinted at their deteriorating friendship, as well. It was the perfect Rumble match, more well-rounded than any of its peers and the characterization of the modern association between WWE's two most profitable events.

Contributor
Contributor

"The Doc" Chad Matthews has written wrestling columns for over a decade. A physician by trade, Matthews began writing about wrestling as a hobby, but it became a passion. After 30 years as a wrestling fan, "The Doc" gives an unmatched analytical perspective on pro wrestling in the modern era. He is a long-time columnist for Lordsofpain.net and hosts a weekly podcast on the LOP Radio Network called "The Doc Says." His first book - The WrestleMania Era: The Book of Sports Entertainment - ranks the Top 90 wrestlers from 1983 to present day, was originally published in December 2013, and is now in its third edition. Matthews lives in North Carolina with his wife, two kids, and two dogs.