15 Most Surreal WWE Moments

Betrayals, shocking debuts, and real life tragedies make for some surreal wrestling moments.

WWE storytelling has been filled with countless twists and turns over the years. Its television product is built off of engaging audiences to the degree that they€™ll become hooked and keep returning. To move their storylines forward, the company tries to keep their fans constantly guessing what they€™ll do next. Most of the time, though, it€™s pretty easy to predict what wrestler is going to win, and where a particular angle is headed. But now and then WWE pulls a fast one on us. Besides many heart-stopping and shocking moves and stories in the company€™s history, there have been some downright surreal moments that just didn€™t feel real. Surrealness is a hard feeling to explain, in part because it so rarely happens. It€™s almost dreamlike. It's seeing moment you didn€™t ever think was possible. In part, it's the rare instances like these that keep the fans tuned in, so they don't miss out. To rank the most surreal WWE moments, we have to go with shockers that a mass audience has seen, which means no non-televised events, or things that happened in companies Vince McMahon now owns like WCW and ECW. From talent we€™d never thought we€™d see in a WWE ring to real-life tragedies, here are the 15 most surreal moments in WWE history.

15. Pillman's Got A Gun!

The vast majority of professional wrestling storylines happen inside of a ring, or in the arena that the show airs from. From time-to-time, we go inside the homes of wrestlers, but it's usually just so they can update us on their injury via satellite. It's very rare that we see a home invasion. As the WWF was getting badly beaten by WCW, they began to think outside the box. One night they went a bit too far outside of it. In 1996, Brian Pillman and Steve Austin were involved in an extremely personal feud. Austin broke his former tag partner's ankle, and then later threatened to show up at his house while he was recovering. The WWF had a camera crew there ready for the showdown. Kevin Kelly was on assignment to give us updates, and interviewed The Loose Cannon who suddenly pulled out a gun, claiming the was going to blast Austin's "Sorry ass straight to hell." This sure was a long cry from Doink vs. Crush just a couple years earlier. Austin eventually arrived, and was greeted by two of Pillman's friends who were quickly disposed of. Inside of the home, a frantic Kelly tried to give us the play-by-play, while a terrified Melanie Pillman watched on, and her husband Brian remained silent and holding his gun. Austin broke in, and as we saw a close-up of PIllman's deranged face, the feed was cut. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pmsdz29_dv8 Of course, no one was killed, but the WWF kept us hanging for a few minutes until the feed was restored. That level of implied violence was one of the strangest moments to watch in the company's history.

14. Brock Lesnar Returns

On March 18, 2002 Brock Lesnar debuted on Raw the night after WrestleMania. A couple days shy of two years later, he was gone. He'd simply had enough of the travel and the wear and tear. It was a huge blow to WWE, as Lesnar was one of the fastest rising stars in the company's history. WWE obviously didn't want him to go, and took him to court to prevent him from competing anywhere else. Brock wasn't too interested in wrestling though. His first big career move was trying to make the Minnesota Vikings. After that, he was onto UFC where he became one of the biggest draws ever in MMA. Unfortunately, a case of diverticulitis sapped away some of his superhuman strength, and he seemed to be a shell of his former self in his final match. Still, a return to WWE seemed incredibly unlikely. By all accounts, Lesnar doesn't need the money, and he doesn't like the fame. He's a recluse who just enjoys hunting in Minnesota. But one night after WrestleMania (just like his debut) in 2012, he did come back. It was eight long years, but his theme song immediately popped the crowd (a good portion had actually been chanting his name moments earlier due to the news leaking), and he stood on the entryway getting ready to face down John Cena. Here was one of the biggest star athletes on the planet destroying the face of the company in his abscense. It was shocking, but absolutely thrilling television.

13. Austin Joins The Devil - WrestleMania 17

Perhaps the biggest, most profitable feud in feud in WWE history was Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. Vince McMahon. When Bret Hart left the company after the Montreal Screwjob, McMahon realized that he could be an effective, money-making television character. However, with Hart gone he needed a new nemesis. He found the perfect one in the Texas Rattlesnake. The two battled for years in and out of the ring in a variety of scenarios. Blood was spilled, zambonis were involved, and personal property was destroyed. It was fantastic. While all good feuds must eventually end, some of them end really badly. Due to a mixture of The Rock€™s rise to challenge Austin as the top babyface, backstage politics, and Austin wanting to try something new, he was turned heel in the main event of WrestleMania 17. After Rock and Austin battled for over 25 minutes, McMahon slid a steel chair inside of the ring. The Austin of old would have kicked it right back, or nailed Vince with it, but that night he blasted Rocky. Fans were stunned. McMahon entered the ring and then shook hands with his arch-enemy. An exasperated and stunned Jim Ross wonderfully called out €œStone Cold is shaking hands with Satan himself! For the love of God, someone tell me this isn€™t happening!€ That pretty much summed up the feelings of the audience.

12. CM Punk Breaks The Fourth Wall

By now, CM Punk's Pipebomb Promo is the stuff of legend. And at the time, it was one of the most talked about moments in years. In June of 2011, internet fans knew that Punk was getting to step away from wrestling. He was upset that he'd been overlooked for so long, and felt he was deserving of main-event status in the company. WWE never gave him that chance, and he'd had enough. On his way out, he was going to feud with John Cena, and presumably put him over before taking time off to do non-wrestling activities. To set up his feud with the face of the company, he beatdown Cena and then sat at the top of the entrance way to vent his feelings. What he unleashed was a brilliant and bizarre promo, one that resonated with countless fed-up and disgruntled fans. Punk insulted Vince McMahon, HHH and Stephanie as well as "Glad handed, nonsensical, douchebag, yes men" like John Laurinaits. Ouch. He even turned toward the camera and waved to his good friend Colt Cabana. For the hardcore fans, it seemed like a middle finger right to the WWE. News outlets like ESPN even picked up on the story in the following days, as anyone who witnessed it knew they'd seen something that appeared to break all the rules.

11. Paul Heyman On Commentary

Jerry Lawler has been with the WWF since 1992, mainly known for his work as the color commentator of Raw. But in 2001, he had a falling out with the WWF, and quit in protest when his girlfriend Stacy €œThe Cat€ Carter was released from her contract. As Raw began, it was bizarre to see Jim Ross without The King by his side as they had been the voices of a great product for years. Moments later, the situation became downright unbelievable when Paul Heyman was announced as the new color commentator. Just two months earlier, ECW ran its final show, but not many people (including the wrestlers themselves) knew where the company stood. Heyman was the leader of the brand, and had built the company's popularity in part by mocking the WWF and WCW. He finally sold out. The rebellion was now dead. Heyman pulled no punches, as he immediately let fans know that Lawler quit, and he was taking over. It was a one-two punch of shock as a beloved announcer was suddenly gone, and was replaced by one of the most unlikely candidates possible.

10. Eric Bischoff Hugs McMahon

The war between the WWF and WCW was personal. Very personal. From 1995 to 2001, we saw McMahon mock his former top stars Randy Savage and Hulk Hogan on air. Eric Bischoff returned fire by giving away the results to the WWF€™s pre-recorded Raw. McMahon lamented behind the scenes about Ted Turner stealing all of his talent, and Bischoff told his crew that he was going to put the WWF out of business. He was wrong. The war came to an end in March of 2001. After declining ratings and millions of dollars lost, WCW lost its TV timeslots and McMahon bought them out. While many WCW talents jumped over to WWF for The Invasion angle, most of the big guns stayed home. Perhaps Bischoff, more than anyone, could have given the Alliance an identity, but he missed out. And who could blame him? How could one driven, proud, egotistical individual ever work for the man who beat him? In July of 2002, Bischoff did the unthinkable and joined the enemy. During a segment on Raw, McMahon announced that the show needed to be shaken up, and a new general manager would be revealed that night. In a random backstage segment with Booker T, the camera suddenly zoomed in on his face as he looked horrified. As the camera moved out, Bischoff stepped into frame and shook his hand. Seeing him without any sort of announcement beforehand was unbelievable. At the time, it seemed he wouldn€™t be welcomed in the same state as a WWF show due to how poorly he treated some of the talent when they worked for him. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlqZLPsFgNc Shortly after, McMahon announced Bischoff as the new GM. Instead of coming to blows, they hugged. Shocking! Even more shocking was that the company probably threw away boatloads of cash right then and there by having the two former enemies play nice.

9. NWO In WWE

It was one thing to expect Hulk Hogan, Scott Hall and Kevin Nash to eventually end back up in WWE after the demise of WCW. But arriving altogether? As the NWO? Absolutely surreal. The New World Order, after all, was a WCW creation and a genius idea that brought Vince McMahon and his company to its knees. The WCW Invasion of WWE in 2001 was a pretty big letdown. This was in part due to most of the bigger names deciding to sit it out, and collect money off of their Time Warner contracts at home instead. When those deals ran out for Hogan, Hall and Nash, WWE was wise to bring them in as a unit. At the time, Vince McMahon was battling Ric Flair over control of the WWF. Since he couldn€™t defeat his nemesis, he decided to kill the entire company with a €œlethal dose of poison.€ On the January 14, 2002 episode of SmackDown, he cut a bizarre and brilliant promo announcing the New World Order was coming. One month later, they arrived. At No Way Out, the three original members opened the show. Their familiar theme from WCW played, with the added addition of black and white footage. Jim Ross and Jerry Lawler were just as amazed as fans. The three stood in the ring to enormous cheers, with plenty of skepticism too. They were a few years older, but they still had it. Unfortunately, WWE dropped the ball on the angle, but those first few weeks of WCW€™s greatest stable aligned inside of a WWF ring was truly something special that seemed insanely unlikely to ever happen.

8. Twin Refs

Judging by pure numbers, this entry may be the most overall shocking WWE moment. A record 33 million fans tuned in to watch Andre the Giant battle Hulk Hogan in a WrestleMania 3 rematch on Saturday Night€™s Main Event on February 5, 1988. This was before the days of monthly pay-per-views and big matches given away on weekly television, so just seeing the two superstars in the same ring on free TV was surreal enough. While fans are now familiar with referee Earl Hebner (most infamously due to his involvement in the Montreal Screwjob), we hadn€™t seen him on TV until that event. It was his twin brother Dave who was one of the WWF€™s most noticeable referees, and he was assigned to ref the Hogan/Andre match. For the majority of the match, it sure seemed that way. The end of the contest saw Dave make a quick three count, and ignore Hogan€™s shoulders being raised off the mat. He declared Andre the winner. Just like that, a four year title reign appeared to be over! Suddenly, the real Dave Hebner came down to the ring. No one could figure out what was going on. Here were two men dressed in the same outfit, with identical facial features, yet only one of them being the true official. They started fighting, and Hogan eventually threw Earl over the top rope. He later claimed that The Million Dollar Man must have paid for some guy to have plastic surgery to look exactly like Dave. While that€™s a pretty far-fetched claim (wouldn€™t Hogan just assume twins were more obvious?), seeing Hogan lose the title because of a pair of twins was one of the most creative and memorable moments in the company's history.

7. Bret Hart Enters The Hall

With Bret Hart, there's multiple surreal moments you could choose stemming from The Montreal Screwjob to add to this list. You could take the 1997 Survivor Series match itself, or his hug with Shawn Michaels in 2010. While you could make a case for both of those, let's go with Hart somehow reconciling with WWE and entering their Hall of Fame due to the sheer improbability of it all. After Montreal, the following years made Bret's story even more tragic. The documentary Wrestling With Shadows let viewers behind the scenes on what went down with him and McMahon that night. Besides Bret spitting on his face, he also knocked him out afterwards. No matter what side you fell on, it was hard to imagine the two parties ever working together again. Bret's book in 2008 was a scathing takedown on his former employer as well as HBK. In the time he was away, his former company made fun of him on air, he suffered a stroke, his little brother died in a WWF ring, and he stood by his sister-in-laws' side as she sued Vince for millions. It was a cold war between the two, but eventually the ice started to melt when the company was going to make a DVD on his career. He didn€™t want WWE to have the final word, so he agreed to participate. What was more amazing is that he showed up for the Hall of Fame in 2005 to be inducted by Steve Austin. No one would have blamed Hart for never showing up in any capacity in WWE, but the two sides somehow came to terms. Seeing an older Hart stand in front of thousands of wrestling fans in a company owned by Vince McMahon was something that seemed impossible just a couple years earlier.

6. Sting In WWE

When WCW went out of business in 2001, one giant name after the next eventually showed up in WWE. Scott Steiner, Goldberg, Ric Flair and the NWO all signed contracts with Vince McMahon. Heck, even mid-card guys like Johnny The Bull, Vito, and The Cat showed up in WWE too. But one big star always stayed away: The Man Called Sting. Over the years, there were plenty of rumors that Sting was about to sign with WWE. There was a planned feud with Steve Austin that fell through, and potential dream matches with The Undertaker that seemed to pop up ever year. Nothing ever came of it. Sting stayed in TNA where he was earning a healthy six-figure salary to work a limited number of dates. When TNA€™s seemingly endless funds started to dry up, perhaps he saw the writing on the wall and finally decided to go to WWE. Or so it seemed. For months, we kept reading reports that Sting had finally signed with the company, but there was no visual proof. There was licensing deals in place, but nothing that put him on air. Maybe he was getting cold feet. Maybe he just didn€™t want to wrestle anymore. Then at Survivor Series, he showed up in the main event. Thirteen years after WCW went under, Sting finally showed up in WWE. He was the last of the big names to enter the company. It was a surreal sight that we€™ll perhaps never witness again. The next mind boggling image in wrestling will probably be when he actually competes in a WWE ring.

5. The Real World Champion

In the 1980s, there was Hulk Hogan rocking the WWF and bringing it to new heights. In the NWA, there was Ric Flair, who was selling out arenas, and putting on the best main events in the industry. For purists, it was Flair who was the greatest wrestler in the world. The biggest dream match for years would be seeing those two clash, but they were always in seperate companies. Besides, Flair was too well respected, and too well paid to jump ship to the more cartoonish WWF. That is until 1991. When a former Pizza Hut regional manager got control of WCW, he didn€™t realize Flair€™s worth. He didn't get wrestling at all. He wanted Flair to cut his hair, take a paycut, and be known as Spartacus. When The Nature Boy rightfully refused, he was let go. Two months later he showed up in McMahon country. What made Flair€™s debut so shocking was that WWE had not been recognizing other wrestler€™s histories at that point. Guys like Roddy Piper, Sgt. Slaughter, Dusty Rhodes and Harley Race didn't have incredible resumes. They just appeared to be McMahon creations. And now here was Bobby Heenan holding the WCW World Title on WWF television claiming that it was the €œreal€ world championship. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j8ggDRV5Rj4 Sure enough, on Prime Time Wrestling, the familiar 2001: A Space Odyssey music hit and out emerged Flair. To help fully explain the surrealness of the situation, Flair was 41 when he first joined the WWF. That means decades of him as a top star in wrestling went by without ever setting foot in the WWF. It€™s hard to imagine something like that will ever happen again.

4. Jerry Lawler's Heart Attack

Jerry Lawler started out having a pretty good night on September 28, 2012. Even though he was in his early 60s, he still teamed up with Randy Orton to defeat CM Punk and Dolph Ziggler. After that, he went back to the announcers table to call the rest of the show with Michael Cole. Then during a match with The Prime Time Players and Team Hell No, he suddenly stopped talking. It sounded like someone was gasping for air. As the camera angles changed, we could see The King slouched over in his chair. Now both announcers were silent. The crowd began standing up, ignoring the match and looking over off camera. What was going on? Referee Charles Robinson looked distracted, as did Kane and Titus O'Neil. Cole tried his best to continue as the crowd began chanting "Jerry! Jerry!" After commercial break, a visibly shaken Cole informed us that his co-host passed out and collapsed. As the show went on, we were given updates about King, but the possibility of his death seemed very real. It became impossible to be entertained by Raw as fans feared for the worst. To add to the surrealness, Cole stopped announcing out of respect for his partner. It was silence, except for the wrestlers in the ring doing their best to work through the very real and scary situation.

3. The Streak Ends

Ever since WWE began heavily promoting Undertaker€™s undefeated WrestleMania streak, it became one of the most anticipated matches at the event. Every year fans wondered if it could be the year someone finally beat him (well, besides Mark Henry's go at it), but after Shawn Michaels and Triple H failed in back-to-back attempts, it seemed that Undertaker would ride off into the sunset with no losses to his name at WrestleMania. The perfect ending was going to be written. And why would anyone believe WWE would change that? The Steak was so popular with fans that any heel or babyface who ended it would run the risk of drawing the anger of fans. Or even worse they'd be mad at the company itself and not the wrestler. It was also a guaranteed money-maker, so anytime Taker wanted to come back, there was sure to be increased buys for the event. The idea of Brock Lesnar toppling Undertaker at Mania 30 seemed almost laughable. Sure, he€™s a former WWE and UFC Champion, but John Cena and Triple H had already beat him. He wasn't booked as unstoppable monster. Besides that, he€™s an extreme part-time act, so having Taker pin him seemed like the logical choice. Instead, WWE shocked the wrestling world by ending The Streak which started back in 1991. Fans around the arena had their mouths blasted open in shock. It seemed like it had to be a mistake, that Taker was meant to kick out. Conspiracy theories even floated around the web in the following days claiming that what we saw wasn€™t the intended finish. Of course it was, but it was such a bizarre call that it wasn€™t that hard to believe. Witnessing Taker sit up after his loss is truly one of the most surreal moments in WWE history. They say all good things must end, but this is something WWE should have made live forever.

2. Shane McMahon On Nitro

March 6, 2001 may be the most surreal, sad and exciting night in wrestling history. After years of mismanagement, World Championship Wrestling went out of business, and Vince McMahon picked them up for essentially the change found in his couch cushions. For one night, Vince had control of the WWF and his long time competitor WCW. Every segment on both shows was absolutely fascinating to watch. There was no telling what was going to happen. Vince was shown on a monitor watching WCW and was continually mocking them throughout the night. He was clearly relishing this victory, and later teased what he was going to do with his new brand. But before passing final judgment, his son Shane popped up on Nitro to the shock of the live crowd and millions of fans everywhere. The Nitro series finale was simulcast on TNT and USA Network at the same time, which means that WCW diehards and WWF faithful were watching the same exact segment for the first and only time ever. It's hard to explain just how weird it was seeing Shane McMahon on Nitro. This was a company that tried to put the WWF out of business. They got close just a few years earlier, but were now on their deathbed, and their chief rivals son gloating about his new purchase was going to be the last thing the fans of the product would ever see.

1. Over The Edge 1999

Far too many WWE wrestlers have died way too young, but only one died while millions were watching. Certain storylines have absolutely shocked audiences, but how can you compare any angle to a performer falling to his death during a wrestling show? Thousands of fans witnessed Owen Hart's final moments in the Kemper Arena in May of 1999, yet many of them didn€™t know that what they were seeing was real. After all, Road Warrior Hawk appeared to fall off the Titantron to his death just months earlier. It wasn't out of the question to think the WWF would book something like that again.This was also in the days before fans had the internet on their cellphones, so they couldn€™t just look it up and see what happened with Owen. WWE didn€™t tell them either. It wasn€™t until the show was over did they find out that they all watched a man die. For television viewers, they were made aware before the show was over by a visibly shocked Jim Ross. In a solemn tone, he regretfully informed viewers of Hart's death. Since the fans at the arena weren't informed, they continued to cheer wildly in the background, which made the situation even more bizarre. All of the wrestlers seemed to be going through the motions after that point, with some holding back tears. Vince McMahon is a firm believer in the show going on no matter what, but that doesn't mean the experience won't be a surreal and sad affair for everyone involved.

Contributor

As Rust Cohle from True Detective said "Life's barely long enough to get good at one thing. So be careful what you're good at." Sadly, I can't solve a murder like Rust...or change a tire, or even tie a tie. But I do know all the lyrics to Hulk Hogan's "Real American" theme song and can easily name every Natural Born Thriller from the dying days of WCW. I was once ranked 21st in the United States in Tetris...on the Playstation 3 version...for about a week. Follow along @AndrewSoucek and check out my podcast at wrestlingwithfriends.com