15 Ups & 6 Downs For WWE NXT In 2019

12. Halftime Heat

Halftime Heat
WWE

A cocaine spectacle before AEW dolled the style up and made it an entire Tag Division out of it, five of NXT's six biggest stars brought their no-selling indie selves out of retirement for one wild night in the Performance Center, with PC pet project Velveteen Dream coming along for the wildest of rides.

A Halftime Heat entirely divorced from the famous Mankind/Rock empty arena brawl 20 years earlier, this was kept to the right side of the railings but used just about every other inch of the smaller stage available as the six raced through a 60-minute epic in just over 16.

It was f*cking mental - a match that's "must-watch" simply because it has to be seen to be believed, the babyface and heel trios just about observe character traits in between head drops and mammoth pops. On commentary, Shawn Michaels surrenders his entire legacy to the excitement of it all - not since his post-Crown Jewel interview had he sounded so happy to be retired.


11. The Prophecy Fulfilled

Undisputed Era
WWE.com

As arguably the best act on arguably the best show, The Undisputed Era are arguably the best thing in all of wrestling. But enough of things up for debate when one thing was categorically proven un-dis-puted in 2019 - the group's quest for golden domination was a stroke of booking genius.

All started to appear lost for the quartet following Adam Cole's TakeOver: New York loss, not least with his loyal stablemates also short on gold. Tempers and tensions flared between Roderick Strong and Cole in particular as his leadership looked in doubt for one of the first times - until he snared the NXT Championship all by himself at TakeOver: XXV.

At the exact point when his goon squad could have finally seen the light, he showed them a different one to reassert his authority and finally execute his grand "prophecy" as the black-and-gold brand's talisman. Bobby Fish and Kyle O'Reilly's capture of the tag team titles was necessary considering the state of the doubles division, whilst Strong's victory over Velveteen Dream highlighted one of the early USA Network editions of NXT.

For once, they had objective metrics with which to believe their own bullsh*t. The queue of battling babyfaces wanting to rub their noses in it remains long to this day.


10. TakeOver: Phoenix

WWE.com

Another TakeOver month, another awesome TakeOver.

Phoenix was a somewhat-forgotten but nonetheless noble addition to the TakeOver collection with four exceptional Championship matches and one explosive offering between a white hot new babyface and his perfect first heel.

Matt Riddle and Kassius Ohno left the often verbose-to-a-fault Mauro Ranallo speechless with their inventiveness, Bianca Belair almost pulled off the upset of the year in January with her achingly close run at Shayna Baszler, The War Raiders took up their rightful place as Tag Team Champions in a hard-fought decimation of the cagey Undisputed Era, whilst Tommaso Ciampa entered the God Tier of NXT Champions in a gritty defence of 'Goldie' against Aleister Black.

The show was stolen by a tweener Johnny Gargano somehow subverting his gutsy babyface persona as a heel against a Ricochet at his eye-popping jaw-dropping best. The two assembled a match that was an amalgamation of everything 'The One & Only' had achieved with Will Ospreay and Gargano's irrepressible TakeOver formula.

This special outing transitioned the North American title to 'Johnny Wrestling' to facilitate his loss to Velveteen Dream, but felt more like a grand main event payoff than just a functional midcard treat.


9. Ciampa & Gargano Escape The Main Roster

Tommaso Ciampa Aleister Black Ricochet Johnny Gargano
WWE

This doesn't get an "Up" just because it was really funny for WWE kingmaker Triple H not to have any power for a change when he was made to announce that he was losing his four top guys, though that was magic on its own terms. It gets one because Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano are exactly where they should be to this day, despite being pulled away at the worst possible time.

The two weren't going to be a credit to the main roster but were likely to plug gaps in boring matches on Raw or SmackDown until they were handed an ill-fitting angle or storyline that didn't make use of their talents or one of them was made to dress like a basketball player action figure. Ciampa's injury resulted in both being pulled from that hellscape, back to the heavenly surrounds of Full Sail.

It's there they've remained as the heart and soul of NXT - pillars of the superworker era as friends and enemies with a backstory to revisit and bangers yet to have with any and everybody lucky enough to share the sacred black canvas with.


8. The Return Of Finn Bálor

Finn Balor
WWE.com

Finn Bálor's return to NXT was all things to all viewers, even critics.

Used in a transparent attempt to capture buzz and numbers as the show was roundly trounced by AEW in the first week of the wednesday night wars, the feeling of the prodigal son returning home was brilliantly subverted when he turned heel on Johnny Gargano with a brutal attack just weeks later.

Exhilarating stuff, but the best and most controversial was yet to come. In the bilious worked shoot promo that followed, Finn raged on the roster that had reshaped the black-and-gold brand in his absence. Like a contemporary Undertaker, self-appointed conscience of the company Bálor was cloaked not in the flesh of his victim but in the darkness that mirrored his stifled self-loathing.

It was the instant propulsion back to relevance that could be felt on the night he returned, but yet again WWE's best brand serviced his story in a way far more captivating than anybody could have crafted.


7. TakeOver: XXV

Roderick Strong Matt Riddle NXT TakeOver XXV
WWE

Johnny Gargano and Adam Cole had a near-impossible task in their June sequel to an April classic - follow it.

The fact that the pair came within touching distance of their era-defining original was as admirable as the match was awesome. Kept relatively lean at 32 minutes, Adam Cole's big night came not a moment too soon, and the Undisputed Era crucially conquered the Champion all on his own for once. A victory for the programme before it fell off a cliff later that year, this went underrated all year just as it did on the night.

The main eventers had stolen all the headlines over WrestleMania weekend, but TakeOver: XXV belonged to NXT's tantalising midcard - Matt Riddle and Roderick Strong's spine-shattering opener was a tour-de-force of pro wrestling brutality, whilst Shayna Baszler's heartbreaking win over Io Shirai set off the 'Joshi Judas' lurking within the 'Genius Of The Sky'.

The rest of the plaudits belonged to the Street Profits, who kickstarted their short but perfectly formed run as NXT Tag Team Champions after a captivating ladder match victory over the last remnants of a once-great doubles division.


6. NXT On USA

Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

The panic was real.

When NXT was cynically used as the vehicle with which to counter the rise of AEW from its very birth, most felt as though the damage had already been done. It was moving to USA Network, where Vince McMahon would assume control as he does everything else and it'll never be the show it once was. Instead, and long may this continue, the move has been an unmitigated triumph.

The extra hour has allowed NXT to be all things to all fans - it remains the breeding ground for new stars to a point, but offers at least one match worthy of main event billing every week whilst addressing most major concerns with regularity rather than the detached taped cycle of old. The stars shine brighter on TV, with Full Sail electrified for every second instead of taking for granted what they'd normally get in bulk.

It's expedited certain matches as part of NXT's attempt to defeat Cody's company in the ratings war, but WarGames was early proof that this wouldn't be at the expense of TakeOver cards if at all possible. Angles have since been set up and paid off within the 12 weeks the two sides have been positioned against each other, highlighting how logically and strategically the show can still be booked in spite of this new era. Having now won several of the head-to-head battles in the chase for viewers, the brand has carved out its own revitalised identity, perhaps even more so than its nascent opposition.


5. This F*cking Spot

Adam Cole Keith Lee
WWE.com

Despite how Reddit or Twitter may look during and immediately following the broadcast of a show, it's still technically not the job of wrestlers to create gifs and memes that'll go viral within seconds - but it's an awful lot of fun when one fits the bill. And has there been a more satisfying one than the loop above?

Chris Jericho burst the dam with a little bit of the bubbly, Batista got given what he wanted and there was money in Brock Lesnar's beastbox, but Keith Lee sending Adam Cole into space just days after captivating the WWE Universe over Survivor Series weekend was the sort of spot that'll still be celebrated years from now.

Recency bias makes it easy to overstate, but it equally shouldn't be undersold. With exactly the right levels of physicality, production and pro wrestling chaos, this was one of the greatest spots of all time.


4. Dakota Kai's Turn

Dakota Kai
WWE.com

This was the best heel turn of 2019.

In NJPW, WWE escapee KENTA turned on friend and mentor Katsuyori Shibata to join Bullet Club as his shocking G1 Climax came to an even more shocking conclusion, but the payoff between those two hasn't come in time for Wrestle Kingdom, so will it come at all? Meanwhile, AEW delivered the predictable (in the best way) MJF switch at Cody's expense, but many posited that it actually came too soon - a feeling confirmed somewhat by how they've faltered on the immediate follow-through.

Kai's brutal assault of tag team partner, best friend and WarGames comrade Tegan Nox was perhaps the biggest booking victory of NXT's entire year. Both the New Zealander and Welsh star had lost time to injury before post-Summer returns, and had tagged together in a spirited loss to The Kabuki Warriors to establish that they at least had each other as support through testing returns to the ring. It all changed in plain sight whilst everybody else looked another way.

Kai wasn't selected for Rhea Ripley's WarGames squad despite her best efforts, whilst Nox looked on, acceptant of the decision in spite of her friend's bitter disappointment. She really, really wanted it, didn't get it, and completely snapped. Getting in via an attack on Mia Yim away from view, Kai revealed the extent of her planned rage in a brutal assault on her friend's surgically repaired knee.

Amidst thunderous boos, only the piercing wails of Nox's screams could be heard - and they've replayed as part of her callous new entrance ever since.


3. The Women's Division

WWE.com

Dakota Kai's November heel turn was just one glorious chapter from the most satisfying story in wrestling all year - that of the NXT Women's division.

Far from just a one-shot-per-month league or a collection of aimless wrestlers masquerading as a division, this collection of ultra-talented and diverse performers helped craft something so layered, detailed and dedicated that it may have surpassed the Four Horsewomen golden era of NXT women's wrestling.

With Shayna Baszler as a seemingly unstoppable champion, an upper-midcard formed underneath her that offered such a rich range of stars that it's a wonder more weren't poached for the main roster ahead of the show's move to USA Network. Kairi Sane got every last bit out of her series with the Champion before departing, but it only left space for Bianca Belair, Io Shirai, Candice LeRae, Tegan Nox, Dakota Kai, Mia Yim and most notably Rhea Ripley to all shine in the revitalised spotlight. The matches constantly stole TakeOvers and weekly broadcasts, while the characters themselves became fleshed out enough to proffer one of the best ever iterations of WarGames at the very first attempt.

The division needed Baszler as its loathed leader during this time of exponential growth, and it really can't be mis-sold how important that malevolent leadership really was. 'The Queen Of Spades' owned her throne...


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.