15 Ups & 6 Downs For WWE NXT In 2019
2. Shayna Baszler
It took the guts and guile of Rhea Ripley to finally terminate Shayna Baszler's incredible second reign as NXT Women's Champion in a glorious payoff to a truly magnificent feud, but 'The Queen Of Spades' contributions up to and including that cathartic switch were possibly more important than anybody else's on a show.
Wrestling companies are often (rightfully) defined by their Champions, and the unflappable, unstoppable Baszler was simply sensational in her role as such. Her TakeOver title defences were wrestled at a different pace to every other bout on the card - fought like the monster/monster slayer battles they were, Baszler's ability to flit between dominance and panic extracted every last burst of hope from the crowd before she put another pretender away.
It informed every one of her defences up to and including the last, and if November was any indication of Vince McMahon's thoughts on her, Raw and SmackDown will be substantially better for having her.
1. TakeOver: New York
The best NXT TakeOver of all time? The WWE pay-per-view of all time? The best company match of all time?
That all three questions could be answered with an emphatic "Yes" even without consulting Dave Meltzer's star ratings for (arguably) objective confirmation of the last speaks to the unfathomably high standard of another TakeOver for the ages. Wrestling often relies on perfect storms rather than pre-planned sunny spells, but the hurricane that blew through NXT shortly before this show should have blown the whole house down, rather than simply the roof off.
Tommaso Ciampa's injury shelved not just the Champion but the payoff to a three-year angle that would ultimately crown Johnny Gargano NXT Champion. Adam Cole stepping in as a late replacement reframed the narrative entirely, but the two did what the two do and went on to have what many (your writer included) considered the match of the year, and some the greatest ever.
And it was far from a one-match card. Though none of them knew it at the time, the pulsating and artful opener between The War Raiders and Aleister Black/Ricochet was the NXT swansong for all four on a brand they clearly adored. Matt Riddle and Velveteen Dream rose to the challenge of turning an easy-going hero into a heel and making underdog babyface out of the coolest f*cker on earth before rectifying everything at the end, all for the good of the North American title. Shayna Baszler asserted her authority over the entire Women's Division yet again in a multi-person high spot war, whilst Pete Dunne's surrender of his UK Championship to Walter was the best moment of his 685-day reign since the first.
This was, by any standard, a complete masterclass.