15 Ups & 6 Downs For WWE NXT In 2019

"The stars don't even matter, I wanna be next to you. Black & Gold, Black & Gold"

If you're a fan of NXT already, you'll not need yet another piece telling you how the black-and-gold brand is the most fantastic thing going today. But here's one anyway.

It's a show so fantastic that there simply wasn't enough time to pontificate on everything ace about 2019's output.

If you're short on ideas of what to watch but long on time, treat yourself to the WWE Network archives for any of the following; The rise of Damian Priest from bizarre Ring Of Honor signee to future TakeOver pop generator in under six months. Kassius Ohno's return from England as the UK's greatest export and future Performance Center coach that knows he's a future Performance Center coach. Adam Cole using a TakeOver: Prime Target camera crew to shoot his humbling of Johnny Gargano's family and friends ahead of their final fight in Toronto. The Prime Target series in general, in fact, for how it effortlessly blended work and shoot for the good of a product fans remain willing to play along for. The mind-melting show-opening/Io Shirai entrance from semi-regular collaborator Poppy that can be found above and below this introduction.

And so on, and on, and on.

The Wednesday Night War welcomed scrutiny on arguably the most consistent brand of pro wrestling in the whole world, and it remained near-perfect to its followers and begrudgingly excellent even to those fundamentally opposed to the ethos the parent company controlling it.

Near-perfect...


Downs...

6. The Tag Division

Forgotten Sons
WWE.com

There's no getting away from NXT's primary failing since they were forced into advertising it every week on USA Network - the doubles division hasn't ever been repopulated from the last main roster raid.

The Undisputed Era had already cycled through big match bangers with every pair anyway, but the loss of The Viking Raiders and Street Profits in particular exposed a gaping hole a returning Breezango couldn't fill.

The Forgotten Sons still have the most self-effacing gimmick in wrestling, whilst underdogs Oney Lorcan and Danny Burch can't just be kept in stasis as plucky losers if the brand wants to run another Dusty Rhodes Classic without looking totally stupid.


5. KUSHIDA's Cr*p Year

Kushida NXT
WWE

KUSHIDA is yet to appear on a TakeOver event since being present in the crowd for the New York event in April, and it speaks to the lack of focus his character has received since the NJPW Junior Heavyweight icon made the jump.

A banger factory if he can still be a*sed, the 'Time Splitter' has instead been confined to clumsy and relatively meaningless contests against Drew Gulak, Walter and Cameron Grimes. As a character, we know he's moved to America to chase a better life for his family (as if he wasn't already a massively monied star back home), and that he's into nicking symbolic hats just for the patter.

Underwhelming would be an understatement, but at least the latter silliness proffered a decent match. Hopefully there'll be more of that in 2020.


4. Pete Dunne - A Man Without A Country

Pete Dunne Danny Burch
WWE.com

When Pete Dunne's fantastic 685-day reign as United Kingdom Champion came to an end in April, most assumed him broadly better off.

Cruelly (to the talent, if not WWE) NXT UK had become wrestling shorthand for the most boring kind of Good Wrestling™, and Dunne had always seemed beyond its limitations right up until he lost his precious prize to Walter. It appears, in hindsight, it was saving him from the hinterland.

A series of half-baked mini-feuds kept him on television but with issues even 'The Bruiserweight' himself admitted to not really caring about. A Survivor Series NXT Championship match against Adam Cole was a pyrrhic victory for the character - it gave him something to do on the night but nothing to chase in the aftermath of a predictable defeat.


3. What To Do About Killian Dain

Matt Riddle Killain Dain
WWE.com

Killian Dain has been a rule-proving exception for NXT being the saving grace for the lost main roster causes in 2019 - his return after Sanity did less than nothing on SmackDown was greeted with affection from a loyal Full Sail crowd, but his angles have thus far proven more underwhelming for his opponents than anything else.

Matt Riddle, Pete Dunne and Damian Priest didn't leap from their programmes alongside the Belfast star into high profile spots, but into the fresh air of something - anything - brand new. Release from his clutches was a relief rather than a retooling, with Dain left in stasis.

Just about every f*cker gets over on this brilliant brand, and Dain's proven able to do exactly that before. But until the key-eating chaos-merchant of WarGames 2017 finds himself again, all still looks a little lost.


2. The Price Of Excess

Mia Yim
WWE

On the two final pre-TakeOver: WarGames editions of NXT, the combatants of both the male and female double cage spectacles went to war in ladder matches for the vaunted on-the-night advantage.

For male heel captain Adam Cole, this was another bruising night in the million or so he worked through as a way to prove himself bulletproof in WWE's archaic system. Mia Yim donated her head to the women's equivalent, but would have just as much damage to her body with the bumps regardless of what went wrong with the giant metal weapon.

This sort of escalation has become the unsettling norm of late, made worse by revelations that NXT stars aren't being nearly as well-compensated as they should be for their role in the ultra-competitive Wednesday Night War era for the brand. The ultra-talented and ultra-competitive performers are on an unsustainable path - they need to make it look like they're killing each other, not actually killing themselves.


1. TakeOver: Toronto

Adam Cole Johnny Gargano
WWE

TakeOver events are significantly special without needing to rely heavily on main events (as several Ups will highlight later), but the dismal and overwrought to Johnny Gargano and Adam Cole's scintillating series underscored a card that should probably be objectively considered the worst of its kind.

Aside from the Ambrose Asylum reboot that went on last, Shayna Baszler had perhaps her worst ever title match in a lumbering effort against Mia Yim, Pete Dunne, Velveteen Dream and Roderick Strong simply didn't click, and Street Profits' win over The Undisputed Era was one victory too far for the departing duo.

But this is NXT. Even as comfortably the weakest presentation from the black-and-gold brand's 2019, it still had one f*cking sensational diamond in the rough...


Ups...

15. Io Shirai's Turn

WWE.com

Io Shirai wasn't exactly floundering as a babyface following the dismantling of her Sky Pirates tandem with Kairi Sane, but the originators somehow felt second rate when WWE condescendingly chucked Sane with fellow Japanese star Asuka to create The Kabuki Warriors on the main roster.

NXT follows the old wrestling rules more than the WCW-obsessed Cody could ever dream of, and just like it always used to be, a transformative heel turn was the answer.

Turning on best friend Candice LeRae after one loss too many to Shayna Baszler (in one of the best matches of the year, by the f*cking way), Shirai allowed her psychopathic side to come out in the most glorious and grizzly fashion. A sensational match at TakeOver: Toronto followed, and Shirai's been revitalised as a crazed killer ever since. All the goals she failed to achieve as a babyface last year will surely come to fruition for her in the next 12 months. She's too good at everything to permanently deny.


14. The Reborn Cruiserweight Division

WWE.com

"Give it NXT 'til the end of the season" was the strategy for the cursed purple strap once keeping 205 Live from having absolutely no purpose at all. The latter may now be true but who gives a single sh*t when the matches on the black-and-gold brand have been so uniformly fantastic?

Under the stewardship of Drew Gulak, Lio Rush and Angel Garza, the matches have ranged from great to amazing and generated the first buzz for the strap since the celebrated Cruiserweight Classic.

That took place in Full Sail too - perhaps that generous, molten crowd were what WWE were missing all along.


13. TakeOver: WarGames

Kevin Owens NXT
WWE.com

A glorious victory for a gimmick that's had mixed results since NXT relaunched it in 2017, the last TakeOver of the year had the challenge of presenting two distinct variations of the stipulation without dragging down the remainder of the card. It was an unqualified success.

In front of a blisteringly hot Chicago crowd, the first ever all-female WarGames encounter stole the show in the opener with a f*cking fantastic angle (more on that later) augmenting an all killer no filler spectacle. Victories for Pete Dunne and Finn Bálor were understated but far from underwhelming in the heated efforts that followed, before the Allstate Arena roof rattled at the surprise return of Kevin Owens to make up the numbers for Tommaso Ciampa's babyface team against the seemingly unassailable Undisputed Era.

A glorious finale saw all four fiends put through tables, with Ciampa's Air Raid Crash from the top of the cage through the wood serving as a grisly and glorious finale.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.