15 Worst PPV Main Events Ever
The worst of the worst pay-per-view main events ever.
A bad wrestling match isn't the end of the world, because once it's over you can put it out of your mind and move onto the next one. A bad pay-per-view main event, however, leaves a sour taste in the mouth because that's all you get, and you're left reflecting on the mess that you just saw.
Bad main events can ruin careers of perfectly good superstars, and cause fans to lose faith in a promotion entirely, so it's no small matter when one occurs that can be ranked as one of the worst of all time.
While some of the matches on this list are just bad examples of pro wrestling, it really focuses on matches that were bad examples of what we think a main event should be, and a lot of the time this is due to reasons beyond the performers' control.
Whether it's bad booking, technical glitches or poor scheduling, a main event can be ruined for a number of reasons and there's no saving a pay-per-view once the star attraction has proved to be a stinker. Here are fifteen of the worst main events in wrestling history.
15. John Cena Vs. R-Truth - Capitol Punishment 2011
Capitol Punishment stands as one of the oddest one-off pay-per-views in WWE's recent history, solely based around the fact that it emanated from Washington, D.C. with a White House set, a poster featuring Barack Obama and had a controversial commercial where Obama answered questions about the upcoming event.
Such an odd pay-per-view needed an odd main event, which it got in the form of R-Truth vs John Cena for the WWE Championship.
In his defence, R-Truth worked hard to earn a WWE Championship at pay-per-view, reinvigorating his character as a whacked-out conspiracy theorist who quite rightly pointed out that he had never received a singles main event before.
It would have worked better if it didn't feel so disingenuous, as Capitol Punishment was nothing but filler to give Cena something to do and someone to beat for that month, before he moved into his feud with CM Punk leading into Money in the Bank 2011.
14. The Undertaker Vs. The Dudley Boyz - The Great American Bash 2004
900016This match occurred when, under the instruction of Paul Heyman who told them to "make an impact", The Dudley Boyz abducted Paul Bearer. The Undertaker was told the only way he'd see Bearer alive again was to join their faction.
This led to a Concrete Crypt Handicap Match as the main event of the Great American Bash, where Bearer was sealed in a glass chamber and if The Undertaker lost, it would be filled with cement.
The Undertaker managed to beat both Dudleyz and then flipped the switch to fill the chamber with cement anyway, just because.
Like many matches on this list, there was a much more deserving main event place lower down the card. This time it was Eddie Guerrero vs JBL in a Texas Bullrope Match for the WWE Championship - a career highlight for both men and possibly one of the best bullrope/strap-style matched in wrestling history.
13. Diesel Vs. King Mabel - SummerSlam 1995
The majority of the matches on this list have some sort of extenuating circumstances as to why they were terrible events, but this one is just a straight-up stinker from start to finish.
Mabel was fresh off a King of the Ring win that no-one was interested in, and Diesel during this period has often been referred to as the lowest-drawing champion in WWE history, so matching the two up was a recipe for disaster.
It's a prime example of what's wrong with the old WWF style of booking, which has been used for Hogan and as well, in which Vince McMahon will pick a top guy, put the title on him and then build one off Big Threats for them to overcome, expecting that's enough to get fans invested or interested.
Mabel versus Diesel only proved that this style of booking was no longer feasible in the mid-nineties, and over the next year WWF would start the slow process of clawing their way back to relevance with the emergence of stars like Austin, Rock and Mankind.
12. The Undertaker Vs. The Undertaker - SummerSlam 1994
Folllowing The Undertaker's casket match with Yokozuna at Royal Rumble 1994, he took some time off to heal a back injury, but Ted DiBiase brought out a man he claimed was The Deadman. Thus was vehemently refuted by Paul Bearer.
This angle culminated at SummerSlam, as the real Undertaker returned to take on DiBiase's imposter in the main event. After he won, the imposter was never seen again.
The build-up to this epic encounter between two Undertakers was Leslie Nielsen as his Naked Gun character Frank Drebin investigating the mystery of the two Undertakers in backstage vignettes that seemed to exist just to get a celebrity on the show.
What's worse is that the forgettable Undertaker vs Undertaker clash took the main event spot from an excellent WWF Championship steel cage match between Owen Hart and his brother Bret, which totally stole the show and exposed the main event as the cartoony nonsense it was.
11. Extreme Elimination Chamber - December to Dismember 2006
ECW December To Dismember is remembered as one of the worst pay-per-views of all time with very good reason, but none better than the abysmal main event that was the Extreme Elimination Chamber.
The match featured only one ECW original in Rob Van Dam, newcomer CM Punk and then four of the most WWE guys you can think of in Big Show, Hardcore Holly, Test and The Big Show.
Aside from RVD, the one person the fans are really happy to see is CM Punk, so naturally he's the first one eliminated and Bobby Lashley ends up winning the match and the ECW Championship.
Reportedly Paul Heyman fought hard for CM Punk to win and become the future of ECW, and Big Show has said he wanted to tap to the Anaconda Vice to put Punk over which might have saved the main event, but it stands as one of the most embarrassing matches in WWE history.
10. John Cena Vs. John Laurinatis - Over The Limit 2012
John Laurinatis was never a main even wrestler in the USA, he was an undercard guy at best and it's arguable that he only achieved the success he did in AJPW was because Giant Baba's wife was fond of him.
The Dynamic Dude had no place in the main event of shows in the eighties, and he certainly had no place in the main event of a WWE show in 2012 against the biggest star of the decade.
Somehow, Johnny Ace won when the previously fired Big Show interfered on his behalf and knocked Cena unconscious, allowing Mr. Excitement to score the pinfall victory. What's even more bizarre as Over The Limit 2012 saw the dream match of CM Punk vs Daniel Bryan for the WWE Championship, and that wasn't the main event because this match was.
9. Hulk Hogan And Eric Bischoff Vs. DDP And Jay Leno - Road Wild 1998
There has always been a crossover between wrestling and the wider pop culture world.
From Andy Kaufman and Jerry Lawler, to Mr. T at WrestleMania to John Stewart & Stephen Amell at this year's SummerSlam, but the effectiveness of guest appearances relies on how interested the star is in being there, and how they're booked when toe-to-toe against wrestlers.
That's why Jay Leno sits way at the top as one of the worst guest appearances at a pay-per-view ever, as he teamed with DDP to take on Hogan and Bischoff. Jay Leno's involvement wouldn't have been so bad, but he was booked to actually stand in the ring against WCW's #1 bad guy Hulk Hogan and hold his own.
Leno even got the final pinfall wrong, by placing his arm under Bischoff's neck, he lifted both of his shoulders off the mat during the deciding fall, which was counted anyway and Leno & DDP were crowned the winners.
8. Hulk Hogan Vs. Sid Justice - WrestleMania VIII
The first mistake WWE made when it came to the main event of WrestleMania VIII was that it wasn't Randy Savage vs Ric Flair for the WWF Championship, and was instead Hulk Hogan vs Sid Justice that closed the show.
Neither man is known for their in ring prowess, and together they put on a plodding match that couldn't live up to the standards set elsewhere on the show.
The real disaster came towards the end when Papa Shango missed his cue to interrupt Hulk Hogan's Atomic Leg Drop on Sid, so Sid became one of the few men to kick out of Hogan's supposedly deadly finisher. Even if Shango had hit his queue and made it to the ring in time, the main event of WrestleMania VIII would have still ended in disqualification which is no way to finish up the biggest show of the year.
7. The Miz Vs. John Cena - WrestleMania XXVII
808852The Miz earned his way to the main event of WrestleMania XXVII after a solid two years of outstanding and entertaining work as WWE's best heel.
Unfortunately, WrestleMania XXVII wasn't about him, it was about the budding rivalry between his challenger John Cena and the host of WrestleMania, The Rock. Because WWE wanted to set up the next year's WrestleMania, this one paid the price.
The main event of WrestleMania XXVII ends with a double-count of all things, before The Rock restarts the match in order to crown a winner.
Then The Rock hit Cena with Rock Bottom, which enabled The Miz to get a very weak win and following a People's Elbow to Miz, WrestleMania went off the air with neither of the main event competitors standing tall as Rock celebrated to close the show.
6. Sting Vs. Hulk Hogan - Starrcade 1997
Sting's road to Starrcade 1997 isn't just one of the best stories in WCW's history, it's one of the best builds in all of wrestling that took eighteen months to reach its conclusion.
Sting left WCW as the nWo began to take off/over, directionless with no place following the huge paradigm shift, but returned in his Crow-style character to stalk and torment the heel group for month leading to his confrontation with Hollywood Hulk Hogan.
What was supposed to happen was Hogan pins Sting with a fast count by nWo referee Nick Patrick, Bret Hart restarts the match and Sting win the World Heavyweight Championship. When it came time to do the fast count, Patrick counted at a normal pace, which meant Hogan ended up looking like the one screwed by Sting and Bret Hart.
There's speculation that Patrick was bribed or influenced by Hogan to count normally to make his character look better, but whatever the case may be, it ended up making the whole angle worthless.
Eighteen months went down the drain as even the most ardent WCW fan saw Hogan as the rightful champion, and WCW had to jump through hoops to get back to where they should have been originally.
5. Randy Orton Vs. Daniel Bryan - Battleground 2013
Randy Orton v Daniel Bryan was a great feud from two years ago that reminded fans just how devious and hatable The Viper could be, and cemented Bryan as a main event player able to hang with the likes of Orton and carry PPVs based on his matches.
Unfortunately at the time, they weren't the only two involved in the feud, as Big Show was also inserted into the WWE World Heavyweight Championship picture and it was his presence that would ruin a great main event.
The actual Orton v Bryan match is a fun watch as all of their encounters were, but it's ruined when The Big Show enters, knocks both men out, and the show goes off the air with a no-contest. It's one of the most unfulfilling finishes to a pay-per-view in recent memory, and did nothing but leave fans confused and angry.
4. Bret Hart Vs. Shawn Michaels - Survivor Series 1997
712049Bret Hart versus Shawn Michaels is an all-time classic rivalry in the vein of Hogan and Piper, Rock and Austin or Cena and Punk, and every time they stepped foot in the ring against each other they absolutely stole the show.
Survivor Series 1997 was set to be their last match ever as WWF Champion Bret Hart was leaving for WCW, but no-one could have predicted how the main event would end. Michaels locked in Bret's own finisher, The Sharpshooter, and the referee immediately rang the bell awarding the Championship to Michaels.
Rather than risk Bret Hart heading to WCW with the WWF Championship, which he assured Vince he wouldn't do, McMahon set up a sequence of events to get the title off The Hitman any way he could, and the result was the Montreal Screwjob.
3. Hulk Hogan Vs. Yokozuna - WrestleMania IX
The supposed main event of WrestleMania IX, WWF Champion Yokozuna v Bret "Hitman" Hart, wasn't the greatest WrestleMania match but it was by no means the worst, and it would have been a fine main event to close out the show.
Unfortunately, after Bret Hart lost the match, Hulk Hogan made his way out to ringside and was challenged by Yokozuna and Mr. Fuji to a WWF Championship match right there and then.
It only took twenty-two seconds for Hulk Hogan to defeat Yokozuna for the WWF Championship in one of the worst WrestleMania moments in history.
Bret Hart looked like a complete chump telling Hogan to face the sumo in his honour, and there has never been a bigger example of Hogan's massive ego and the lengths Vince McMahon went to placate him.
2. Goldberg Vs. DDP - Halloween Havoc 1998
There was nothing wrong with the wrestling in Goldberg v DDP, it actually accomplished everything fans wanted from the match and is one of Goldberg's better matches in his career.
Unfortunately, Halloween Havoc 1998 overran to the point that for many households across America, the PPV feed cut out just as the main event was about to get underway.
What made things worse was the match before it was Hollywood Hulk Hogan v The Warrior in a rematch from eight years previous that was simply abysmal. WCW was forced to rerun the main event the next night on Monday Nitro as an apology to its viewers, but the damage was done and it just ended up being another nail in the coffin of the promotion.
1. Jeff Hardy Vs. Sting - Victory Road 2011
It was obvious that Jeff Hardy v Sting was going to be a shambles as soon as Hardy appeared on camera and shambled to the ring, obviously under the influence and in absolutely no state to compete in a wrestling match.
Sting is noticeably angry as the match starts and following a Scorpion Death Drop, Sting physically holds a struggling Jeff Hardy down for a three count, ending the match in under ninety seconds.
Following the decisions, the fans were audibly upset with chants of "This is bull****" and Sting can be heard saying "I agree".
Jeff was suspended for six months, but TNA faced severe criticism not only for its lack of standards in drug testing, but also for allowing a very visibly intoxicated Jeff Hardy head out to wrestle a main event match.