15 WWE Returns That IMMEDIATELY Backfired
It was mere MINUTES before WWE realised they'd made a terrible mistake.
EVERY comeback is supposed to hit.
Live crowds are supposed to pop or boo someone mercilessly, fans at home are supposed to get up out of their chairs because they can't believe what's happening, and everyone backstage is supposed to get some pics for social media as Triple H maybe even does a little finger pointing action. In other words, literally everybody involved is supposed to react like the biggest thing in the world just occurred on WWE TV.
Sadly, sometimes it's a matter of weeks, days, hours or even minutes before the company realises they've made a terrible, terrible mistake. Some returns backfire almost immediately, and it's a painful experience. Awkward silences in arenas full of people who don't care one bit, ridiculously embarrassing in-ring performances that fall flat as a pancake and depressing dawning realisations that a former favourite just doesn't have it anymore - all of that is here.
A few creative decisions sure didn't help matters for several included. Force feeding unconvincing wrestlers into one of the most iconic tag-team gimmicks of all time springs to mind there, and so does an unfortunate decision to re-debut someone from the past under a cartoonish name in front of rowdy (likely drunk) fans post-WrestleMania weekend.
Listen closely and you could almost hear the air escaping from rapidly deflating balloons. Wrestlers aren't daft. They'll have surely known that things weren't working out. Nobody thought these return bids would flop as quick as they did though.
Like social awkwardness and when WWE gets a bit rubbish? You've come to the right place.
15. Bob Backlund (2000)
Would be President of the United States (remember that?!) Bob Backlund became a perennial Royal Rumble surprise throughout the 1990s. He showed up in the match between 1993-1996, then returned at the start of the new millennium in 2000. That one off wasn't what it seemed. The WWF planned to bring Bobby back as a manager for Kurt Angle, which actually didn't seem like a bad idea.
It flopped. Hard.
Kurt has told a story via his podcast about Backlund forgetting they were live on Raw when shooting a backstage skit. This happened shortly after they'd been shunted together as a mentor and protege double act. According to Angle, Bob was a little too "over the top" and erratic during skits, but it was his character breaking moment on the flagship that tipped producers over the edge.
Bob was supposed to put somebody in a submission, but they were sitting down. So, he turned to Kurt and asked if the dude was supposed to be standing or not. This real life bewilderment caused Angle to turn and stare at a WWF writer who was standing off screen. He was a rookie, so he didn't know what to do, and he couldn't believe that a true veteran like Backlund could be so clumsy.
It was a mistake, but a costly one. The promotion decided to go in a different direction with Kurt and take Bob off TV. Oops. So much for high hopes that the celebrated former World Champ would help take Angle to the next level. He got there himself anyway.
14. Sunny (2009)
Time to play a game of 'Spot The Sunny'.
Her life has taken several miserable turns over the years, but Sunny did seem to be getting things back on track when WWE brought her back for Raw's 15th anniversary celebrations in 2007. Eventually, the company inducted her into the Hall Of Fame in 2011. Sandwiched in between was a WrestleMania appearance most simply won't remember. You've got a good excuse for that.
WWE barely promoted that Sunny was part of the 'Miss. WrestleMania' Battle Royal at 'Mania XXV. In fact, she was hardly on camera at all before being dumped out of the match by Beth Phoenix. The women involved didn't get individual entrances; they were played down to the ring by Kid Rock instead, then Santino Marella won the bout dressed as his "twin sister" Santina.
At one point mid-match, it became obvious that even announcers Michael Cole and Jerry Lawler had forgotten all about Sunny's only official WWE match. So, the backfire here was on WWE itself. Why bother bringing “the original Diva” in at all if you weren’t going to shout about it and make some noise about her sole in-ring appearance as an active talent?
It didn't make a lick of sense. Some fans in attendance for 'Mania might not even have known that they were watching someone from yesteryear battle it out with the current crop of Divas. Even finding a workable screenshot of Sunny in the match is tough! Her comeback really was that low key.
A real head scratcher for sure.
13. Eva Marie (2021)
Not many shed a tear when WWE cut ties with Eva Marie and gave up on their 'All Red Everything' experiment in 2017 after years of bashing heads against brick walls. It was clear to anybody with two working eyes that she didn't have an aptitude for the industry and was never going to become an accepted member of the women's division. That was especially true once Divas gave way to revolution in 2015.
Then, they tried again. Following several weeks of hype vignettes, Eva appeared on the 14 June 2021 Raw and had Doudrop (Piper Niven's crappy original name on the main roster) wrestle on her behalf. This was more of the same stuff fans had seen from Marie during an unsatisfying first run in the company, and there was zero demand for it. No-one was fooled. It became clear instantly that she wasn’t going to work second time around either.
Like, it was obvious literally seconds after she strutted on screen with Doudrop behind her. Credit to Piper for doing everything she could to facially sell how awful Eva was being, but therein lies the problem: Marie was playing a one note dated caricature during an era where the likes of Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair, Bianca Belair and Bayley were working bangers between the ropes.
She felt out of place...again. WWE gave up later the same year after a roundly unwanted SummerSlam clash with Alexa Bliss that included too much Lily the doll nonsense. Eva was a throwback to the pre-revolution days, and not a good one. That's probably that for her links to pro wrestling.
12. The British Bulldog (1999)
Keep in mind before reading this entry that the WWF wanted Davey Boy Smith to be a key part of World Title storylines heading into 2000. He feuded with The Rock, and was part of a 'Six Pack Challenge' for the vacant WWF Title at Unforgiven 1999. That took place on 26 September. Earlier in the month, on the 9 September SmackDown, Smith returned to action and...
...beat Big Boss Man in 90 seconds for the Hardcore Title, then handed the belt off to Al Snow. The British Bulldog did all this wearing jeans and a hoody, so he barely looked like the chiselled man mountain federation fans had last seen back in 1997. Truthfully, Davey's comeback was snake-bit from the off. He was having personal issues and had various addiction woes away from the ring.
Regardless, this was a less than stellar piece of booking for such a major comeback. The company even changed Bulldogs music up, which meant fans in attendance initially had no clue who was answering Boss Man's open challenge. Worse was to come the longer Smith wrestled. It was painfully obvious that he was a shadow of his former self as a worker.
The whole thing was pretty sad to see, actually. Bulldog had been such a well-received star in his prime, and now here he was looking like someone's dad decided to win the Hardcore Title before picking the kids up from school. Way to make someone big time look less than, guys. This was a poor decision.
If anything, Bulldog should've been kept back for Unforgiven and eased back in rather than poking his nose into the Boss Man vs. Snow stuff just because that story had dogs in it and he had dog in his name.
11. Road Warrior Animal (2005)
What comes to mind when you hear the name Legion Of Doom? Big spiked shoulder pads, NWA/WCW squash matches and Hawk yelling, "What a rush" right? One name that doesn't (or shouldn't) leap to the forefront of brains is Jon Heidenreich. Unfortunately, someone in WWE creative thought he'd be the ideal replacement for the sadly deceased Hawk in 2005, and that ruined Animal's comeback immediately.
On the 14 July '05 SmackDown, then-champs MNM challenged the famous Road Warrior to find a tag-team partner and face them for the belts at the upcoming Great American Bash pay-per-view. Somebody must've cracked Animal on the bonce with a steel chair backstage, because he stumbled around before settling on Heidenreich as the right man for the job.
The worst era of LOD commenced.
Literally nobody asked for this. Had WWE fans been polled, they probably would've plumped for Animal riding solo against Joey Mercury and Johnny Nitro rather than teaming with 'Hei-den Hei-den-reich'. Worse, Heidenreich became an official member of The Road Warriors when he added his own face paints and spiky shoulder pads to the equation.
This was even worse than the Droz offshoot had been years earlier in 1998-1999. Bringing Animal back could've worked out had he not harpooned his own credibility within minutes by recruiting Heidenreich. Fans didn't want to see anybody replace Hawk, they really didn't. Animal and Jon might've been palatable without the forced 'LOD 2K5' stuff, but this was never going to get over.
LOD 2000 was one thing. LOD 2005? Nah, that was never going to float anybody's boat or pan out.
10. Scott Hall (2002)
Some readers might consider this slightly unfair, because there was a bit of excitement for the nWo's arrival on WWF screens in February 2002. In storyline, Vince McMahon decided to "inject [his] creation with a lethal dose of poison". Little did the then-boss know that he was inflicting a poisonous atmosphere on his otherwise harmonious locker room by bringing in Scott Hall.
Hall returned at No Way Out alongside Order buddies Hulk Hogan and Kevin Nash. Fans popped, but Scott became a backstage nuisance almost overnight. The man was battling a lot of demons at the time, so it's safe to say he probably shouldn't have been out on the road at all. WWF fans also wanted to see his old Razor Ramon character more than his nWo one, but that wasn't the pitch.
'The Bad Guy' offered next to nothing before getting released in May after the infamous 'Plane Ride From Hell' back from Europe. On top of all that, Hall's hiring and behaviour had a negative knock on effect for top acts like Steve Austin. Working with Scott was a rotten experience for 'Stone Cold' - he wasn't happy about being mired in the midcard for WrestleMania X8, and he found that Hall wasn't too interested in putting on a show anyway.
The single positive to come out of Hall's WWF reprise was his quick, "Hey yo!" at No Way Out. That earned a sizeable pop and Scott flashed a genuine smile. Everything after that exposed the fragility of his personal life at the time. He contributed little beyond annoying people behind the curtain or civilians on the aforementioned journey back from a European tour.
9. Kevin Nash (2011)
In the immediate aftermath of CM Punk's iconic "pipe bomb" promo in June 2011, nobody sat down and said: 'Y'know what'd really kick this into high gear? A confusing sub-story starring Kevin Nash'. WWE thought that was a fab idea, so they brought 'Big Sexy' back at SummerSlam to attack Punk and open the door for Alberto Del Rio to cash in his Money In The Bank briefcase.
This cut the 'Summer Of Punk' off at the knees, and wasn't a surface level "dumb" return that turned out to be genius. That was true at SummerSlam even before Nash got to his weird claims about receiving a text from Triple H even thought it turned out it wasn't actually Triple H texting from Triple H's phone. Yeah. That explanation sucked bad. This was the age of scripted promos, and it seemed even Kev was mystified by the plot he was asked to spew.
Punk's "pipe bomb" on John Cena, Vince McMahon and WWE in general broke the fourth wall, referenced New Japan, mentioned ROH and came across as something completely refreshing in an otherwise sanitised corporate world. Rather than capitalising on that and Punk's disappearance with the WWE Title post-MITB, the promotion crowned an interim champ then had Diesel launch into a mini-feud with CM after that.
Fans there live were always going to react to Nash, but his comeback didn't make sense unless he literally was there to help out Hunter. Apparently, that was far too simple a concept for the weary creative team to fathom. They went with Kevin and Trips at loggerheads as Punk's hot summertime shoot became less and less of a concern.
Backfired is putting it mildly.
8. Scott Steiner (2002)
The Steiner Brothers hated WWF life so much between 1992-1994 that they couldn't wait to leave, layover in ECW as a quick excursion then return home to WCW. Between then and 2002, Scott Steiner has blossomed into a main event level talent who looks drastically different to the mullet-rocking tag-team wrestler he'd been during the 'New Generation'. 'Big Poppa Pump' was walking muscle and had one of the most ridiculously pumped up physiques ever.
He'd also been a highlight of latter day WCW before the wheels fell off and Vince McMahon bought the group's skeleton for a paltry sum. Once his AOL/Time Warner contract expired, Scotty was ready to land in WWE and continue his good work. At Survivor Series '02, he interrupted a going nowhere Matt Hardy and Christopher Nowinski segment, and the live crowd in Madison Square Garden for the pay-per-view went nuts.
WWE would've been all smiles upon hearing that response, but then Steiner opened his mouth. High fives would've turned to sighs when Scott loudly shouted, "Gimme a f*ckin mic" on air. Oops! His debut was definitely eye-catching all round, but that little line was a sneak peek into the unruly mind of the 'Genetic Freak'. He was so used to throwing his weight around that he didn't know how to do anything else.
The returning star's resultant series of matches vs. Triple H also floundered. Somehow, despite stinking up the joint at the 2003 Royal Rumble, Scott and Hunter arguably went on to work an even worse match at No Way Out. WWE didn't get the best of Steiner from day one. They got the worst.
7. Shawn Michaels (2018)
Plot twist (sort of): Shawn's 2002 return was everything a blistering comeback should be. That immediately paid dividends at SummerSlam. It looked like Michaels hadn't lost a step. He'd go on to enjoy approx eight years of stunning work that maybe even topped what he'd achieved pre-back injury in the 1990s. Lightning didn't strike twice for HBK though.
He signed on for a marquee tag bout with Triple H vs. Kane and The Undertaker at Crown Jewel 2018, and fans were hyped by the thought of seeing Shawn wrestle for the first time since his 2010 retirement. He'd always been steadfast about never returning, so this felt like a huge deal. Surely such a legend wouldn't agree to work again unless he was about to blow everyone's minds?
Hmm. It was obvious within minutes that Shawn wasn’t the HBK of old. Fans knew he'd be slower and have some ring rust, but they also had every right to expect a better match than they got. The Crown Jewel tag was embarrassing from start to finish. Trips tore a pec, Kane’s wig fell off, all four botched multiple spots - it was just terrible. Michaels and ‘Taker later admitted their regret over this whole sorry affair.
They were mortified, and rightly so. Even the biggest Shawn Michaels fan could've done without this sorry excuse for a send off. DX vs. The Brothers Of Destruction unpicked some of the exhilarating work HBK had done before retiring the first time. It was a blatant cash grab. Nobody's throwing stones at wrestlers for getting paid, but the match was atrocious.
It began poorly, then got even worse.
6. Goldberg (2019)
This writer was in the house live for WrestleMania 33, and he'll never forget how electrifying Brock Lesnar vs. Goldberg was on that show. They only worked for a few minutes, but both hurled one another around the ring with devastating power moves before getting to the finish. It was one of the better matches on the card, so WWE can't be blamed for wanting a little more when Bill was ready.
Almost two years later, Goldberg was back for a fantasy clash with The Undertaker at Super ShowDown 2019. WWE hyped this like 'Taker's gong had hit on Nitro or Bill had speared him on Raw Is War in the 90s. The first two mins (or therein thereabouts) were actually fun until Goldberg suffered a concussion and the bout turned into a train wreck that could've realistically resulted in further serious injury or worse.
Goldberg and Undertaker were visibly humiliated afterwards, especially the latter. He ironically started to question his own mortality, because some of his recent matches had been pretty darn crap. This, along with the aforementioned Crown Jewel 2018 disaster, was the nadir of "dream matches" on Saudi Arabian supercards. WWE had to face it: Some legends just couldn't go anymore. Fans weren't dead wrong about them being finished.
The bell had to ring and they had to deliver, but they couldn't. Goldberg going after 'Taker was one match too many for the ex-WCW squash match machine. You probably know what happened next. Big Bill's next foray was even less enticing, and it blew up in WWE's faces instantly.
Sorry in advance, but it's time to take a good long look at...
5. Goldberg (2020)
...the misery of Super ShowDown 2020.
Yes, it's Goldberg again, and it hurts bad for an old WCW mark to slap Bill twice. Facts are facts though. Anybody who remembered the nightmare 'Taker botchfest that nearly brained both legends could've told you that Goldberg returning on the 7 February 2020 SmackDown and challenging Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' gimmick to a Universal Title match in Saudi Arabia was a terrible idea.
WWE ploughed ahead with it anyway. They failed to learn any lessons from the prior year's card, and they wanted Goldberg to beat Wyatt for the belt like he was in there with James Ellsworth. As soon as the bell sounded and Bill raised that belt above his head, the match became known for being one of the least wanted title changes in history. All in a night's work, eh?
In truth, the backfiring started on TV earlier in the month. Fans could smell a horror show coming as soon as Goldberg told the 'Fiend' he was next on SmackDown. Bray's wacky Undertaker-meets-Mankind character had been one of wrestling's most intoxicating guises since 2019, but everything was about to fall apart thanks to WWE's weird obsession with giving Saudi Arabia more lame Goldberg matches.
COVID ensured they didn't even get to the payoff of Goldberg vs. Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 36 either. Instead of that, WWE was forced to cram Braun Strowman in as a last-minute challenger. His Universal Title reign was barely better than Bill's. This was an awful time for the old Universal strap, but it started with sacrificing Wyatt's 'Fiend' at the feet of Goldberg.
4. Brian Christopher (2011)
Revisit the 14 March 2011 Raw now (if it's even one of the out of sequence episodes Netflix has uploaded to date) and you'll cringe the night away. On paper, a heel Michael Cole bringing back Jerry Lawler's son to browbeat him for being a rotten father worked. In execution, it was one of the most awkward segments in WWE history. It's also distressing for those who love them some Grandmaster Sexay.
The former Too Cool favourite showed up on the flagship at the behest of Cole, but nobody in attendance seemed to have a clue who he was. Brian Christopher's entrance played before deathly silence, and the crowd sat on their hands during tense dialogue between Bri and Jerry. Honestly, the silence was deafening. You could almost hear vendors selling popcorn in the foyer.
It became clear all too quickly that WWE's audience had changed since Christopher was last tearing it up as Sexay. Without the Grandmaster get up or Rikishi and Scotty Too Hotty by his side, Brian meant nothing to the modern fanbase. Crickets, people. Crickets. It was downright painful to watch somebody who had once been part of a seriously hot tag title change on Raw in 2000 suffer this undignified humiliation.
Back then, Christopher was one of the hottest acts in the entire company. By 2011, his star had faded to the point he might as well have been a fast food worker Lawler was rude to in the 1970s. That's the kind of gusto he was welcomed back with by fans.
People were clearly asking friends next to them: 'Who he?'.
3. Lord Tensai (2012)
Matt Bloom was known amongst wrestling fans for three things by 2012. One, playing walking penis gimmick (?!) Prince Albert during the 'Attitude Era'. Two, having a hairy body. Three, going off to Japan after leaving WWE in 2004 and becoming a much, much, much better worker. He deserves credit for that last one, so it's no wonder the promotion wanted to bring him back years later for another whirl.
Could they have picked a worse time to debut his new Lord Tensai gimmick than the night after WrestleMania though?! Tensai re-debuted in the E under his new name on the 2 April 2012 Raw. He beat Alex Riley in a quick squash that was designed to ready him for top star John Cena, but the rowdy post-'Mania crowd weren't interested in any of that. No, they were far too busy living it large and trolling Bloom with chants of, "Albert! Albert! Albert!".
The new character was doomed to fail after that.
Things might not have been so bad had the guy been returning as his old A-Train persona, or even under the Giant Bernard name he'd used out in New Japan. Hell, calling him Albert and cutting their losses would've been smarter than introducing an elaborate gimmick that was too over the top to be taken seriously by revellers in Florida for 'Mania XXVIII.
They'd just watched Cena and The Rock go "Once In A Lifetime" (which remains WrestleMania's biggest lie!) 24 hours earlier. Now, those same folks couldn't resist wrecking Matt's return to WWE. It was too good an opportunity to turn down, new Tensai gimmick or not.
2. Hulk Hogan (2025)
Read the room!
WWE failed to do that during Raw's debut episode on Netflix. Hulk Hogan came out with Jimmy Hart to prattle on about his new beer, run through some catchphrases and soak up acclaim from the audience. Apparently, some backstage thought that last one was a real possibility in 2025. Those people haven't been paying attention to anything surrounding Hulk for a long time, it seems.
The live crowd booed Hogan out of the building, which is something WWE should’ve seen coming a mile off. Poor Jimmy Hart stood behind Hulk waving his flag and looking like he'd rather be anywhere else. This was way worse than wrestling Mancow on pay-per-view multiple times for WCW. Way worse. It even tops having his precious hair snipped by Brutus 'The Barber' Beefcake, for crying out loud.
That's when you know things are rough. OK, enough (poor) jokes.
The real joke was on WWE for thinking Hulkamania would be embraced. This segment reeked of latter day Vince McMahon delusion, but...Vince was long gone. This happened under Triple H and TKO's watch. Let's assume they won't be doing anything of the sort again any time soon. Reportedly, Hulk's planned appearance on the next Saturday Night's Main event was scrapped because of this calamity of a promo.
Hogan was a game changer for the WWF in the 1980s and even revived his fortunes for further runs in the early 2000s, but times have changed and the people have spoken. They don't want to see Hulk on WWE TV anymore for various reasons.
1. Shane McMahon (2023)
What is it with the McMahons and torn quads on pay-per-views they're not even advertised for? Vince shredded his legs when trying to sort out the messy finish between John Cena and Batista at Royal Rumble 2005. Years later, his son Shane collapsed to the mat in agony after shockingly returning for an impromptu match vs. The Miz at WrestleMania 39 in 2023. Like his dad, Shane-O had suffered an embarrassing injury.
He ripped his quad during the very first leapfrog spot and had to be replaced by Snoop Dogg. This is the kind of story an older lapsed fan who hasn't watched in years wouldn't believe. 'So, let me get this straight: Shane McMahon returned for a match in 2023, got injured and SNOOP DOGG just happened to be on hand as a substitute vs. The Miz?'. Yes, yes this happened in real life.
It wasn't a fever dream.
Shane's familiar, "Here comes the money" entrance music refrain will always get a pop. It's so memorable and catchy, but the pop fizzled by the time he was jousting with Miz and fans settled back into their seats. Those punters then watched as McMahon went for a leapfrog, his body gave out on him, and everyone had to call something else on the fly as Shane was helped to the back by medics.
This was undoubtedly one of the most bizarre segments in 'Mania history. Returning to action also backfired spectacularly on Shane. He went from feeling on top of the world to spending the night in hospital. Sorry, a local medical facility.
What other WWE returns immediately backfired? For more wrestling, check out 10 Untouchable WWE Stars Who Got Special Treatment and 10 WWE Wrestlers In Danger Of Missing Out On WrestleMania 41!