16 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Double Or Nothing 2019
All Elite Wrestling hits HUGE home run on maiden PPV voyage.
Spread the word: mainstream American wrestling is great again.
Double Or Nothing was an absolute triumph of a pay-per-view from start to finish, with only a handful of minor hitches detracting from the overall experience. It was, in short, everything it needed to be, and while not every match swung for five stars, the night's lows were so trivial that pointing them out almost seems petty.
There were surprises aplenty, as Jon Moxley debuted, Hangman Page took the Casino Battle Royale, Awesome Kong returned from the wilderness, and Bret Hart showed up to unveil the AEW World Title. Only CM Punk's impossible appearance could've raised the stakes in this department. The bell-to-bell delivered, with one particularly bloody bout exceeding expectations to an unthinkable degree, and MJF's mid-show promo will go down as one of 2019's finest.
The Elite did it. While Brandi Rhodes' claims that this would be the "best wrestling pay-per-view ever" weren't met (of course they weren't), they delivered five hours of rich, varied entertainment, and it flew by. Double Or Nothing was a long show, but it didn't feel like one. That might be its greatest triumph on the night.
Fans should be very, very excited if this is the quality we can expect from AEW going forward...
Downs...
4. A Laboured Librarian Segment
A Buy In backstage segment saw Alicia Atout attempt to interview Kylie Rae ahead of her bout with Nyla Rose and Dr. Britt Baker.
She didn't get far. Peter Avalon showed up before Rae could say anything of note, trying to "shhhh" the exuberant babyface, before his fellow 'Librarian,' Leva 'Blue Pants' Bates showed up, hitting her male counterpart with a "shhhh" of his own medicine.
Though Rae's enthusiasm came across well, this awkwardly acted skit didn't hit the mark. The participants didn't look comfortable in such a Sports Entertainmenty environment. Yes, AEW had to get the Librarians onscreen after building the angle on Being The Elite, but Bates and Avalon needed something more than this. It was the corniest thing on the show.
3. Dodgy Camera Cuts

Double Or Nothing's production was strong for the most part. It lacked WWE's glossy sheen, but that isn't necessarily a bad thing, and there weren't any grand derailments. That the show looked and felt different to the average Kevin Dunn-helmed show is a good thing, though there were a number of rough camera cuts throughout.
That the crew was having trouble keeping up with the action first became apparent in the Casino Battle Royale, during which they missed several important spots (like Jimmy Havoc stapling a cigarette to Joey Janela's godd*mn face). This continued throughout the night. Even Kenny Omega vs. Chris Jericho was afflicted, and that can't be happening going forward.
We shan't go in on the crew too hard, as this was their first proper show together and they'll have likely learned boatloads from the experience. Regardless, the mistakes were notable. Cuts were choppy and sloppy, and while they became less frequent as the evening progressed, a promotion with mainstream aspirations must stamp them out.
2. Tag Team Angle Underwhelms

The Best Friends vs. Jack Evans & Angelico clash yielded an unexpected post-match angle, with the lights cutting as Trent Beretta and Chuck Taylor were trying to hug it out with the losers. Indie veterans the Super Smash Bros were stood in the ring when they returned. Then, another cut, and an army of nameless grapplers in black and green masks.
They laid waste to the guys who'd just wrestled in a move designed to provoke shock and promote the tag division's newfound depth. Sadly, though, it didn't get over.
Rather than getting into the angle, the crowd chanted "who are you?!" at Evil Uno and Player Dos. Watching at home, the commentary team had no answers either. Marvez, Ross, and Excalibur didn't even mention their names, which was ridiculous, and a confused aura spread through the building as Uno and Dos posed with their army of Craters to close the scene.
A decent angle framework that would've worked had it starred a better-known tandem.
1. The Botched World Title Reveal

Bret Hart's surprise appearance was awesome. Consider it a supplemental Up. Nobody could have expected 'The Hitman' to show up at Double Or Nothing, particularly after the way WWE had rolled the red carpet out for him following the Hall Of Fame incident, and watching him come out to a Jimmy Hart version of his classic entrance theme was a joy.
His reveal of the AEW World Championship? Not so good.
In fairness, it probably wasn't the legend's fault. It was poorly directed. Unleashing the strap came too soon after the MJF/Jungle Boy/Jimmy Havoc brawl had dispersed. The cameras cut from their scrap to the ring, and suddenly, 'Hitman' had it hoisted up.
What really sucked was that we didn't even get a good look at it, as Hart barely spent a second facing the hard cam. A shame, as it's a beautiful beautiful belt, and this sloppiness left its unveiling feeling underwhelming.
Ups...
16. Welcome To The Party
The Buy In's brief closing segment saw The Young Bucks, Kenny Omega, and Cody and Brandi Rhodes gathered on the stage for their obligatory ra-ra "welcome to the show" segment.
That this took place on the pre-show rather than the main card is an Up in itself. If this was WWE, it would have been Triple H, Stephanie, and Vince McMahon putting themselves over for 20-30 minutes, sending everyone to sleep in the process. Here, it was The Elite soaking in the applause, showing gratitude, bantering off each other, and claiming they were out to make history. The best part? It only lasted a couple of minutes.
This segment had to happen, and The Elite delivered it in the best possible format. Well done to those guys for not seizing a needlessly huge spotlight here.
15. Commentary: Better Than Expected

The commentary situation was a worry heading into Double Or Nothing. PWG's Excalibur is excellent at all aspects of the game, but there was no telling how he'd mesh with two brand new partners, given that he usually calls his home promotion's matches alone. Common opinion was that the game had passed Jim Ross by - an argument with merit. Alex Marvez, meanwhile, had no pro-wrestling announcing experience at all.
Fortunately, we can safely say that this new team over-delivered. Marvez was the least impressive of the trio. That's to be expected, though. He's an experienced sportscaster, but he has never had a gig like this before. He'll improve as he goes along.
Ross and Excalibur struggled for chemistry early on, with JR audibly noting that he'd "lost his place" at one point. By the end, they were starting to sound like a well-oiiled partnership, and Ross was in vintage form throughout the Jon Moxley angle, screaming "MOXLEY AND OMEGA! MOXLEY AND OMEGA!" like the legendary play-by-play guy of old.
It's hard to read too much from their first night together, but this trio might just work.
14. LOL @ Paul

On the nose? Sure, but this is what wrestling wars are all about, baby. Hook that intense pettiness straight to this writer's bloodstream.
13. Guevara & Sabian Seize Their Moment
Kip Sabian vs. Sammy Guevara wasn't calibrated to steal the show. The goal here was to showcase two bright up-and-comers who'll hopefully play big roles in AEW going forward, and to that end, their Buy In clash was a success.
Coming in at just under 10 minutes, this was a fast-moving, exciting scrap between two similar personalities eager to prove themselves. Both of these guys are cocky as hell. Guevara was almost a different person to his Being The Elite persona, with the Panda enthusiast shedding his YouTube niceness for an oblivious cockiness that almost flipped the face/heel alignments halfway through. Fortunately, Sabian is highly detestable. The guy has 'SUPERBAD' printed across his *ss, for God's sake, and it helps that he has one of the most punchable faces in the promotion.
Sabian scored the victory after getting his knees up for Sammy's attempted 630 Splash, then nailed the Deathly Hallows for the pinfall. A surprising outcome, given Guevara's BTE focus, but one that'll feed into his character work.
12. Baker & Rae Emerge As Future Stars

Double Or Nothing's women's four-way match wasn't the blow-away spectacle many hoped it would be.
Dr. Britt Baker was positioned as the division's star at the Jacksonville press conference, Kylie Rae is one of the most promising babyfaces in wrestling, Nyla Rose has boatloads of monster heel potential, and Awesome Kong's unexpected entrance into the bout was an awesome surprise. Even without the former TNA Knockout, many expected a show-stealing scramble. What we got was a good, solid battle between four wrestlers with a firm grasp of what they're doing, smartly laid out to highlight Rae and Baker over everyone else, but nothing more.
'Smiley' Kylie looked particularly awesome as she tried to steal the win away from Baker, but it was Britt's night. With Rose and Kong neutralized by Nyla's own spear into the ring steps, Baker took the victory by blasting Rae with a Superkick and her partner Adam Cole's Last Shot, proving Brandi Rhodes' pre-match Being The Elite prediction was a smart one, capping a fun bout that's well worth watching.