17 Wrestlers You Didn't Know Worked In WWE

Some of the biggest stars in the history of the business who just passed through...

One of the big stories of 2014 has been Sting doing business with WWE. It seems inevitable that this is leading to him wrestling at WrestleMania 31, possibly in his retirement match, ending a near 30 year career with his first WWE match. There are very few, if any stars of his magnitude left that didn't have a single match under the WWE banner. Most of the other obvious cases are dead, nominally retired, or too old/injured for WWE to do anything with them. In spite of that, a lot of the biggest stars in modern wrestling history DID pass through WWE at one point or another, but had short stays, came in for a one-shot deal, didn't appear on TV, or otherwise aren't really remembered as ever being WWE talent even though they were. So let's count down some of the biggest stars in wrestling history that you may not have known were in WWE.

17. Samoa Joe

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fG5ONc6aWac In 2005, it was clear that CM Punk and Samoa Joe were both going to make the move from Ring of Honor to a bigger promotion. Punk was clearly going to WWE since he was very public about hating TNA, but Joe was a question mark. When he heard rumors that WWE was signing him just to bury him, he opted for TNA and has been a mainstay ever since. He did wrestle on WWE television once, though: In 2001, when he was just a southern California indie guy without much of a name, a young, slim Joe took on Essa Rios. This was during a period where a lot of indie guys got showcase matches against cruiserweights like Rios, and it's a pretty fun match, though Joe doesn't look like the world beater he became later.

16. Bruiser Brody

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qLYXf3x-evw Arguably biggest American star of the '80s not to have a run with a national promotion during that time, Bruiser Brody was a wild brawler who made his primary living in Japan. An outlaw who wasn't afraid to stand up to promoters, he took dates in indie promotions and the remaining territories in between his overseas tours. Before that, he was a green rookie wrestling under his real name, Frank Goodish. In Florida, met Killer Kowalski, who recommended him to Vince McMahon Sr. as a potential opponent for WWWF Champion Bruno Sammartino. It was there that he got the Bruiser Brody name, as well as his behind the scenes reputation, as he was fired after a confrontation with part-owner Gorilla Monsoon.

15. El Hijo Del Santo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xa80Z1ZeNWQ Recently retired due to a back injury, the son of the biggest legend in lucha libre history became a huge star on his own, thanks in part to being a better in-ring wrestler than his father. A savvy businessman, he would only make season appearances on television to avoid overexposure, as he made his living touring the country and didn't want to be too familiar to the audience. In 1998, the WWF made a deal with Univision for a Spanish-language lucha libre show with a mix of WWF and Mexican talent (Santo's far from the only one, but he's by far the most recognizable to English-speaking fans). Santo was brought in as the star, and he had a number of fun matches, though they were short because it was a half hour show. The relationship was doomed from the beginning, though, as WWE wanted the talent to unmask. They were so magnanimous that they even offered Santo a $5,000 bonus! Thankfully, someone (likely Jim Cornette) intervened and he didn't walk out right there.

14. The Fabulous Freebirds

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JfSCVfGH1As Yes, Michael Hayes has been with the company as a non-wrestler since 1995, but he had a cup of coffee with the WWF in 1984 as they were expanding nationally. On the heels of Cyndi Lauper getting them a ton of publicity, the WWF wanted €œrock and roll€ wrestlers to be associated with her. With Hayes trying to kickstart a singing career, who better than Hayes and his partners, Buddy Roberts and Terry Gordy? It lasted a few weeks, with a handful of matches on weekly TV and televised house shows. Hayes lasted a few weeks longer. They just didn't fit with the WWF, either stylistically or backstage.

13. Konnan

One of the biggest stars of the '90s in Mexico and a WCW mainstay in the second half of the decade, Cuban-American Konnan was trying to break into the American scene long before he actually did. At the same time, the WWF was trying to make a new Spanish-speaking star, and they started collaborating. The result? An elaborate robot costume that cost well into five figures. Konnan wrestled on and off in dark matches at TV tapings in 1991 and 1992, using various names like Latin Fury and El Relampago (€œThe Flyer€). Usually, he was paired with Americans from Mexican border towns who could do lucha libre, like Louis Spicolli, or Mexican luchador Rambo, who had a lot of international experience. He never made TV, and eventually had a falling out with the company over a number of issues. Left with a big investment and nothing to show for it, Paul Diamond saw an opportunity. He said he could fit into the outfit (the expensive robot exoskeleton never made TV, though) and do all of the same moves (which he couldn't), leading to his debut on TV as Comet Kid before a quick name change to Max Moon.

12. Christopher Daniels

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vs2oYmSTf1Y See Samoa Joe, just a few years earlier. Daniels was a veteran independent wrestler, but the post-ECW indie boom was years away. He got a pair of TV matches against Taka Michinoku on Shotgun Saturday Night, and impressed the hardcore fans watching the WWF's most throwaway show. He started to be more in demand among promoters all over the country, and compilations of his best matches were heavily traded. He became a hot commodity and was signed to WCW, but it didn't go anywhere. He became one of the most induring stars on the independent scene via runs with ROH and TNA.

11. Tiger Mask

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tXy3Eus0p6g From the mid-'70s through the mid-'80s, the WWF had a working agreement with New Japan Pro Wrestling. The company got a big booking fee while NJPW got big name American stars and would occasionally tape television at the WWF's Madison Square Garden shows, where a few Japanese stars would appear. Another part of the deal was that NJPW could bill a new belt, their junior heavyweight belt, as the WWF Junior Heavyweight Championship. Initially conceieved to elevate Tatsumi Fujinami on the way to becoming a main eventer, it became a full-fledged division. When Fujinami moved up, he was replaced by Satoru Sayama in the guise of Tiger Mask, a legendary anime character. With a blend of kickboxing techniques, high flying inspired by Lizmark in Mexico, and British-style matwork, he became a giant star. He made numerous WWF appearances on the weekly TV shows and at Madison Square Garden, leading to the northeast fans declaring him the greatest high flyer they'd ever seen. His prime was just two years, but he made such an impression that €œBest of Tiger Mask€ sets are the best-selling pro wrestling VHS and DVD releases every in Japan.

10. Kevin Von Erich

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8AEhaCeMVNM The oldest and last surviving of the wrestling Von Erich brothers (the oldest died in an accident as a child), he was one of the biggest stars in the wrestling business in the first half of the '80s. Famous for wrestling barefoot, he was one of the better high flyers in the United States at that time as well as part of a number of great brawls like his family's feud with the Fabulous Freebirds. He spent most of his career at home in Texas with ocassional stops elsewhere, but never he never went anywhere else full-time. It was always quick shots or tours for a few weeks like in Japan. One of those quick shots was at Madison Square Garden in 1980, where he got a showcase match beating area mainstay Johnny Rodz. He returned for a dark match in Texas in 1991, when his younger brother Kerry was on the roster as the Texas Tornado.

9. A.J. Styles

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y1h3JCirtuU One of the faces of TNA for much of its existence (he was in their first pay-per-view match), the popular high flyer was actually under WCW contract when the company was bought by WWE. His contract and that of his tag team partner Air Paris were not picked up, though, so both went back to the independent scene, including their home promotion, NWA Wildside. With the deaths of WCW and ECW, new promotions tried to fill the void, with TNA stepping up to try to replace WCW and Ring of Honor trying to replace ECW. Styles quickly became one of the top stars in both companies, and caught the eye of WWE to a degree. He appeared on the B-shows like others before him and even got a few try-out dark matches. While impressive, he wasn't what WWE was looking for at the time. Styles left TNA this year, claiming they attempted to cut his contracted money 40%, and WWE didn't show much interest this time, either.

8. Kevin Sullivan

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSPR4rKq7U8 Best known nationally as a WCW mainstay (and their head booker) during the nWo boom, Sullivan had decades of wrestling experience. He learned from some of wrestling's most creative minds, like Mark Lewin and Bob Roop, and carved out a niche for himself booking promotions where he'd work on top playing some variation of a Satanic character leading a stable of crazy characters. A Boston native, he grew up on the WWWF, and that's where he spent the mid-'70s, working the mid-card as a babyface. With the McMahons' love of ethnic babyfaces, including their fellow Irish-Americans, it's likely that the only reason he didn't get a bigger push was being short (billed at 5'9€ and actually a few inches shorter) in a promotion that's always been the land of the giants.

7. The Public Enemy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dFLuGQrC48M The signature tag team of ECW in its early years, they left for WCW early in 1996, where they had minimal success: They won the tag titles once, but largely did jobs for bigger names and filled out B-level TV shows. The WCW stint exposed them as limited talents who Paul Heyman did an expert job protecting with booking, production, etc. In 1999, at the recommendation of Terry Taylor (who was working there as an announcer), the WWF hired them. They fizzled out in short order due to a number of issues including Rocco Rock appearing on camera during a segment where he was supposed to have disappeared. Most famously, they were booked to be squashed brutally by the Acolytes as €œpunishment€ in a match filled with weapons shots and table bumps...only to have no idea that was the plan and thank their opponents for an awesome ECW-style match.

6. Kaz Hayashi

Best known to westerners as one third of the Jung Dragons in WCW, Kaz Hayashi was one of the best cruiserweight wrestlers in the world from the late '90s-on. He didn't always get to show it in WCW, but there was some light at the end of the tunnel when the cruiserweight division got a new push...right before Vince McMahon bought the company. Hayashi's contract was among those picked up, and he was sent to the Heartland Wrestling Association, which had been brought on as a developmental territory. He was quickly lost in the shuffle, especialy once the late Brian Adams was sent down to work as the booker. Under a mask as €œTiger Hung Lo€ and doing a horrendously racist accent, Adams gave Hayashi and partner Jimmy Yang a series of ridiculous gimmicks to €œbecome stars.€ Eventually, Hayashi was released with most of the other developmental WCW talent, never making the main roster.

5. Brad Armstrong

A WCW mainstay for almost its entire existence, Armstrong was known for being one of the smoothest in-ring wrestlers in the business. Known for being vibrant and quick witted backstage but lacking the ability to translate it to his promos, WCW was a much better fit for him than the WWF, as their fan base was much more willing to get into matches absent any other context. He didn't work in the WWF until 2006, five years after WCW closed. When the new ECW launched, WWE wanted €œplayer coaches€ on the road to teach the younger developmental talent how to work. Of the veterans working the independent scene at the time, they picked Armstrong, Rodney Mack, and 2 Cold Scorpio/Flash Funk. With ECW-only house shows bombing, the experiment ended quickly. He got a tryout as an announcer after that, but it didn't go well, and that was the end of his run.

4. The Great Sasuke

In 1997, WCW had overtaken the WWF for a number of reasons, one of which was the fast-paced action provided by their cruiserweight division. With an eclectic mix of talent, including top names from Mexico and Japan, it was the type of wrestling you knew you couldn't see on WWF programming. Unfortunately for the WWF, WCW had agreements with many of the top promotions for smaller wrestlers. This led to the WWF looking elsewhere. Enter The Great Sasuke. A Japanese independent wrestler, he had caught the eye of bigger promotions and even become a champion in New Japan Pro Wrestling, but becoming an international star meant a lot to him, and when the WWF came calling, he jumped at the opportunity to become their star "light heavyweight," as the division was called. He brought Taka Michinoku, one of his favorite opponents, with him to Canada, and they had back to back matches on a pay-per-view event and a live Raw broadcast. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c09FimmhRr4 While both looked impressive, the WWF ended up passing on Sasuke, as Taka, the heel, played to the crowd much more, while Sasuke wrestled in a vacuum. Sasuke never returned to the WWF, while Taka got his spot and stuck around for several years.

3. Buzz Sawyer

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xa52bv_s-d-jones-vs-buzz-sawyer_sport One of the biggest stars made by the rise of cable television in the early '80s, "Mad Dog" Buzz Sawyer transformed from a clean-cut amateur wrestler who happened to be nicknamed "Buzzsaw" to the wildest, craziest wrestler in the United States. As the long-term rival of Tommy Rich, the top star on the Georgia Championship Wrestling show that became a nationwide smash on cable, he became famous for his powerhouse style that melded amateur wrestling with vicious brawling and the nastiest-looking powerslam in the business. In 1984, with the WWF expanding, he was one of the wrestlers they picked up to head into the Summer, which was when they started invading new cities. Whether he'd have had an impact is unknown, as he lasted just a few weeks as "Bulldog" Buzz Sawyer. It's safe to say that he probably just didn't fit in with the style of wrestling the WWF was transitioning into at the time.

2. Eddie Gilbert

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvPJiQggLXU Best known nationally for his run as a babyface in WCW's first year as part of Turner Broadcasting, the Memphis star found much of his early fame in the WWF. His father, Tommy Gilbert, had befriended Bob Backlund when they worked in the same territory, so Backlund brought Eddie into the WWF as his protege, both in reality and on TV. Gilbert's WWF run was as what's often referred to as a €œjobber to the stars€ nowadays. His job was to give competitive matches to heels on TV en route to them beating him to set up matches with Backlund. In 1983, he was in a car accident, suffering a broken neck. It was worked into storylines, with Backlund training him for his comeback. Just when everything was going well, the Masked Superstar, Backlund's next opponent, €œre-broke Eddie's neck€ with a neckbreaker on the floor. Eddie eventually returned, teaming with Tony Garea, but left for Memphis when the WWF's national expansion ramped up.

1. Mr. Wrestling II

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xa3drt_mr-wrestling-ii-vs-terry-funk-pt-1_sport As part of the national expansion, the WWF bought promotions and took over their TV slots. Most infamously, Vince McMahon secretly bought majority ownership of Georgia Championship Wrestling to get their TV deal with TBS. While he offered jobs to everyone in the territory, only a handful took him up, and the only one that made a lasting impact was Nikolai Volkoff. One of them was the area's biggest legends, Mr. Wrestling II, also came in. It could be argued it was a risky move, as he was a terrible fit for the WWF, but he was at the end of his career. He made some appearances on the TBS show and televised house shows, even having good matches in the process. While the mask hid his age to a degree, he wasn't in the shape most of the WWF wrestlers were. He left in 1985 and finished out his active career in Georgia independent promotions.

In this post: 
Samoa Joe
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Formerly the site manager of Cageside Seats and the WWE Team Leader at Bleacher Report, David Bixenspan has been writing professionally about WWE, UFC, and other pop culture since 2009. He's currently WhatCulture's U.S. Editor and also serves as the lead writer of Figure Four Weekly and a monthly contributor to Fighting Spirit Magazine.