18 Ups & 12 Downs From The WWE SmackDown Live Era

For when the B-Show blew your mind, or just left you feeling blue...

Maryse Nikki Bella
WWE

There's quite the symmetry between the first edition of SmackDown Live in July 2016 and this historic week that will see off the live Tuesday Night edition in favour of a billion dollar Friday showcase for Fox.

After surviving its wilderness years following the demise of the first brand extension, the July 19th 2016 edition of SmackDown the most commercially successful and critically acclaimed era of the blue brand with a bang.

On that night, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose were cast as the stars of Raw and SmackDown respectively, in much the same way 'The Architect' leads the charge for all of WWE today across from his former partner's wild reinvention in AEW. Mauro Ranallo was the fresh voice of Tuesday Nights alongside a rejuvenated Jerry Lawler of all people. Both men are again key to the company's success on NXT and Raw respectively following a huge shake-up at the desks. Shane McMahon began life as the SmackDown Live Commissioner - a role he may well be booted from on the SmackDown Fox "Premiere".

Few could have foresaw the blue brand doing this well out of the deal, but the show's offered much to celebrate in the past three years that almost justifies the prominence it'll now receive. Alright the WWE Championship had maybe the worst 12 months in it's 50+ year history and two particularly bad promos killed the careers of those entrusted with them, but like a rainbow without rain, we'd not have some amazing ups without some damaging downs...


Downs...

12. "Good Lucha Things"

One of several men Vince McMahon likely assumed eventually capable of replacing Rey Mysterio as a contemporary lucha icon, Kalisto chose the Sin Cara method of botching the living sh*t out of his big moment rather than the Andrade method of knocking out bangers.

The former NXT Champion has doled out "good lucha things" against Mysterio in countless bangers (more on that later), but the Lucha Dragon failed to breathe fire when offered a short opportunity to scorch the earth on 2016's draft night.

It marked his cards forever - the company even named a new theme "Good Lucha Things" in honour of his atrocious offering. It'd take about a year for somebody to get close to it...


11. "Charlotte...CHARLOTTE"

An "everybody in the ring" setup is rarely the best way to ensure combatants in a multi-person all look good, but Tamina took just 12 words to lower the bar enough for everybody else to look better in comparison.

The idea that six potential opponents can magically avoid scrapping because it's talking time is an inherently silly trope that has stuck around long enough to shore itself, but the turn-taking at least gives each performer a chance to steal the show.

Tamina simply stole Charlotte's material.

Inadvertently (or not, who the f*ck even knows?) cribbing 'The Queen's craic, the fellow second generation star's put-down left her target and the crowd in a state of hilarious confusion. Tragically (and tellingly), they remain the most iconic words she's ever said on television.


10. The Lunatic Flop

Dean Ambrose WWE Title
WWE.com

He was the choice of the people and SmackDown Live's Number One Draft Pick in 2016, but his usefulness on top had already been outlived before the blue brand made it to Survivor Series season thanks to one too many indifferent displays.

Between the ropes, his contests with Seth Rollins and Dolph Ziggler simply didn't sparkle as they could and should have done, thanks in part to an aura-destroying encounter with Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 32 and cripplingly awkward podcast interview with Stone Cold Steve Austin that was more goof than aloof.

Worse was to come upon losing the title, too. Rather than regaining some sort of fire and aggression in the wake a tough defeat, he instead found himself tied too tightly to some pretty poor comedy...


9. The Importance Of Being Ellsworth

James Elsworth Dean Ambrose AJ Styles
WWE.com

James Ellsworth the Braun Strowman victim was the "chinless insect" operating at his peak, but SmackDown Live galvanised the best bits of that act in its early days thanks to his broadly enjoyable interplay with AJ Styles and Dean Ambrose during their Championship programme.

In a very WWE move, the company waited until the joke wasn't funny anymore then doubled the f*ck down on it.

There was suddenly so much Ellsworth that his underdog charm had dissolved entirely, enforcing a heel turn that made little narrative sense beyond reflecting the crowd's disinterest. His union with Carmella showed promise and courted controversy, but his return after their original split brought about the unforgivable collapse of Asuka.


8. Social Commentary

Tom Phillips JBL Mauro Ranallo David Otunga
WWE

Mauro Ranallo: WWE Announcer felt destined to fail if only for the memories of others entirely unable to cope with Vince McMahon screaming in their ears, but the combat sports commentator instead had to deal with his colleague b*llocking him the flesh too.

Amidst the awkwardness of Tom Phillips being added as a "host" to help shunt him out, Ranallo's mix of style and substance was relentlessly shouted down by JBL doing his best impression of himself as a total a*sehole.

Bradshaw was subsequently booted from the both whilst Mauro found a finer fit with a role as NXT's play-by-play man.


7. Burning Down The House

Randy Orton Bray Wyatt Fire Utter !*$%
WWE.com

A surprisingly superb WrestleMania programme was set ablaze by one of the worst examples of WWE's impatient silliness, even though the worst was somehow yet to come.

Randy Orton burning down the Wyatt Compound (before they found a dirtier "House Of Horrors" to fight in a month later) was an overreach in the extreme from an 'Apex Predator' that had, up to that point, saw through a masterful scheme to take his leader's title.

The symbolism was on the nose enough for a Wyatt story, but the whole thing coming just weeks before their intriguing WrestleMania tangle made Orton look like a raging malevolent !*$% rather than an evil genius completing his destruction derby.

The big visual was spaffed out here too. Spooky bullsh*t for the rest of the way couldn't touch Orton's inferno, whilst their 'Show Of Shows' projection-filled title switch absolutely stunk.


6. No Survivors

Survivor Series 2018 Raw Men's
WWE

It's been hard enough over the years to accept "Raw Vs SmackDown" as a viable storyline that envelopes the entire f*cking company every November, but 2018 pushed the idea to its limit yet again when the red brand flattened SmackDown live with a 7-0 shutout.

As if we just weren't supposed to care about any of that, SmackDown had actually won the Survivor Series elimination contest on the Kickoff, but that didn't fit the evening's narrative.

As if we just weren't supposed to care about any of that (2), Shane McMahon promised consequences for his gang of losers, but hardly anybody even seemed to give a sh*t 48 hours later, least of all the 'Best In The World'.


5. "Kami"

AJ Styles Kami
WWE

More than just a bad nickname and lame portmanteau, AJ Styles' self-popping "Kami" reflected a writing team absolutely drunk on the instruction to bury Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens during a rotten run for the two between 2017 and 2018.

Sent home from tours and frozen out of major pay-per-views, the unfocused quasi-push of the pair as heels did far more damage to the friends that designed.

The "Kami" nickname didn't help, but it spoke volumes of how funny Styles was scripted to find it (or simply just did, he seems the type) - revealing an insecure undercurrent below a knackered writers room, the stupid moniker was the evil that emerged.


4. Barren Corbin

Baron Corbin
WWE.com

Allegedly dropped from a height thanks to a simple "this ain't it, chief" from John Cena to Vince McMahon after one of their blue brand interactions, the murdering of Baron Corbin's character over the summer of 2017 left the 'Lone Wolf' with a ludicrous uphill struggle.

That year's Money In The Bank winner had it all going on heading into SummerSlam, with a match against 'The Champ' likely to be his biggest test to date as a potential new headliner with a near-guaranteed title win locked in the eponymous briefcase, until a go-home show catastrophe saw him lose the lot before being bantered off at the pay-per-view itself.

Losing to Jinder Mahal in seconds thanks to a Cena destruction, Corbin was further eviscerated just days later at the 'Biggest Party Of The Summer'. It took more than just three good tournament matches to make him a King two years later.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.