18 Ups & 12 Downs From The WWE SmackDown Live Era

3. Lawyer Up

Shane McMahon Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Kevin Owens' 2019 babyface turn seemed, at long last, to suggest a change in luck for the deeply unfortunate 'Prizefighter'.

Switched out of WrestleMania plans thanks to the KofiMania movement, he lost his shot at Daniel Bryan's WWE Championship and missed the 'Show Of Shows' entirely as a result, then turned heel on The New Day to get a revenge programme that also ended in defeat.

Expressing his frustrations via promos resembling the "pipe bombs" legendarily dropped by CM Punk, his path of rage went straight through heel General Manager Shane McMahon until 'The Money' used just that to turn him into a simpering, apologetic mug.

A Steve Austin clone in attitude and moveset, the rejuvenated Owens was brought back down to earth with an unpleasant thud by a company never more detached from what makes a great babyface.


2. A Couple Of D*cks

Shinsuke Nakamura AJ Styles
WWE.com

The "Dream Match" that became a nightmare programme, Shinsuke Nakamura's failed efforts to claim the WWE Championship from AJ Styles brought the 'King Of Strong Style' to his knees...about a dozen times, to punch him in the d*ck.

Styles' 2018 reign in a...ahem...nutshell, this feud delivered disappointment after disappointment with the perplexing post-WrestleMania direction only marginally more interesting as a result of Nakamura's strange new character trait.

A deathblow to him ever being a WWE topliner, the lack of a banger between them was more disheartening than the constant low blows. AJ entered a year so boringly f*cking passable that there's probably a picture of him getting rattled in the plums next to the word in the dictionary. Little was good, little was bad, and for somebody supposedly 'Phenomenal', this was the biggest problem of all.


1. Jinder Mahal: WWE Champion

Jinder Mahal Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE

A profound argument for WWE title belts still having meaning after all, the sight of Jinder Mahal clasping the richest prize in the game remains troubling for those that lived through a truly wretched summer with him on top.

Reducing it in stature just by existing in its orbit, Mahal was almost an innocent victim of the crime being committed in his image. WWE were supposedly keen to milk a market that didn't pay for their product on television (and wouldn't at arenas in a flop of a tour later that year), whilst the 'Modern Day Maharaja's rapidfire physical growth seemed to aid the decision-making process.

Cynical, cynical, cynical, and totally sh*t too - Mahal couldn't remotely work up to the spot in matches or on promos, inspiring less than nothing at best and broad racist anti-comedy at worst. This remains SmackDown Live's saddest timeline.


Ups...

18. The House That AJ Styles Built

john cena aj styles
WWE.com

AJ Styles' remarkable first year in WWE may have arrived nearly two decades after fans wanted, but the 'Phenomenal One' made up for it with a fabulous stint atop the blue brand during a time of great change for the former B-Show.

'The Champ That Runs The Camp' was a stupid name in theory, but absolutely perfect moniker for the sort of tw*t to steal John Cena's arm band and reshape his soccer mom haircut with it.

Delivering in all the big matches to such an extent that he was a babyface within six months, Styles was the original success story of a "Land Of Opportunity" narrative that actually had weight early doors.


17. All In The Family

Randy Orton Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

As noted earlier in this article, this angle collapsing quicker than the shoddy MDF keeping Bray Wyatt's house together was only so disheartening because they'd somehow managed to get it (and both men) way more over than anybody could have expected.

Randy Orton giving himself to Wyatt (and systematically taking everything else away from him in the process) following their tepid feud was inspired - it carried 'The Eater Of Worlds' all the way to the WWE Championship on a wave of momentum he'd not had since arriving on the main roster years earlier.

Over enough to win the Tag Team Championships in a loaded division and go into a Royal Rumble as two of the hot favourites, the pair defied every criticism of the original concept before succumbing to them at the worst possible time.


16. Staking A Claim

Nikki Bella Natalya
WWE.com

Lost to countless other substantially worse programmes for the pair, Nikki Bella and Natalya's late-2016/early-2017 programme provided the latter with a remarkable reinvention as a sh*thouse heel and confirmed that the former's in-ring improvement the prior year had been no fluke.

With neither as tied to the Women's Revolution as the Four Horsewomen or the raft of new talents emerging on SmackDown Live after the brand split, the matches weren't expected to shine as brightly as they did - particularly considering the eyes both must have had for something big at WrestleMania mere months later.

Kicking the f*ck out of each other in several worthy fights, the two kept themselves relevant in a fiercely competitive period, with Natalya later going on to reign as Women's Champion in recognition of these contributions.


15. Happy Rusev Day

Rusev Day
WWE.com

A "YES Movement" for a generation of fans that simply couldn't be a*sed to fight anymore, Rusev Day was a fudged phenomenon for WWE, but hugely enjoyable at the peak of its powers.

Alongside Aiden English, the 'Bulgarian Brute' proved yet again that he's infinitely preferable bouncing off another character than going at it alone. In this case, the former Vaudevillain acting as his doting cheerleader triggered huge t-shirt sales, a weekly running gag, and a push that should have gone further than various secondary title losses on pay-per-views.

Nearly a case of what could have been rather than what it actually was, the journey ultimately proved better than the final destination.


14. Made-For-TV

Andrade Rey Mysterio Canadian Destroyer
WWE.com

A gift to 2019 despite never actually making it on to a Sunday supercard, Rey Mysterio's scintillating SmackDown Live series with Andrade was both a great advert for stem cells and a rare case of really really great wrestling actually being enough.

Their thrilling battles were for little more than recognition and respect, yet stole every show they appeared on. Andrade's marginally better win-loss record over the masked icon served as a small reward for giving his body to the cause as their matches somehow blended silky smooth skill with psychopathic suffering.

Clinging on to lucha libre's rich history whilst chasing 2020 with some eye-popping innovation, the series only lacked an actual issue in the first place. This at least leaves room for revisiting should the company wish to reward such revered work.


13. Daddy Issues

The Miz Shane McMahon
WWE.com

A story that had absolutely no right to get over considering its roots and the people involved, Shane McMahon and The Miz' unlikely bond that began with the problematic Crown Jewel Best In The World tournament ended with heel turn that at long last permitted Shane McMahon to dial up the d*ckhead for evil rather than good.

In between all that was a Tag Team Title reign that genuinely felt earned, the ups and downs of George Mizanin and break-up violent enough to ensure perennial douchebag Miz actually got cheered in time for their WrestleMania showdown.

Malleable work from the most malleable wrestler in the company and the ordinarily stiff son-of-the-owner, this was revelatory in its infancy, even if 'The Money' had to come up trumps every time they fought.


12. 'Mella Is Money

Carmella MITB briefcase
WWE.com

Carmella's record-setting run with the Money In The Bank briefcase helped transfer her from heel irritant to blue brand pet project in a year that wasn't without challenges for the relatively inexperienced NXT graduate.

Her run arguably peaked at the beginning thanks to a Money In The Bank do-over that was one of the best and most important contests from the SmackDown Live era. Making good on a hugely divisive finish to the pay-per-view version weeks earlier, the rematch was free of James Ellsworth's effective interference and loaded with ultra-dangerous spots that justified the overdue women's variant of the match.

Outlasting Enzo and Cass en route to eventually winning the Women's Title from Charlotte Flair before moving in a brand new direction with R-Truth, Carmella's spell atop the division was a case of on-the-job training done right.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.