2 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW: Battle Of The Belts II

ROH underwhelms; AEW crowns a new TNT Champion; Samoa Joe saves the day.

Thunder Rosa AEW Women's Title
AEW

The second AEW Battle Of The Belts is in the history books.

Tony Khan should really have a think about that name, because it implies that fans will see 'Champion vs. Champion' matches on each show, and that's...not the case. Nope, these are standard 'Champ vs. Challenger' bouts like you'd see on any other broadcast. That's nitpicking though.

Few would care if the quality was consistently high, to be fair. That's another issue - both Battle Of The Belts cards to date have been akin to episodes of Rampage more than a TV special. In other words, they don't come across as must-see or all that special. The company will have to address that if they plan on doing more of these.

On the plus side, you're always guaranteed to see some solid wrestling out of this roster. ROH was also integrated for the first time, and that meant some spotlight for reigning World Champion Jonathan Gresham. Did it work? Hmm, not particularly. This was unsatisfying for Honor hardcores and company newbies alike.

What was that about staying positive? Sadly, it's pretty difficult to be all that chirpy about what All Elite are trying to do on these shows. Here's why...


Downs...

4. Bit Of A Missed Opportunity?

Jonathan Gresham Dalton Castle AEW
AEW

Ring Of Honor's top title just came out looking like a midcard belt.

Sadly, nothing really stood out about the ROH Title bout between reigning champ Jonathan Gresham and Dalton Castle. Both guys worked well enough together, but they only got approx 10 minutes of ring time, and everything felt a tad rushed - that's problematic considering Gresham's usual style.

He's at his best when matches are given time to breathe, but there was no chance of that here. Also, who the f*ck wants to watch ROH World Title clashes with picture-in-picture ad breaks ruining the flow? That's perhaps unavoidable on these specials, but it's bloody irritating and takes one out of the moment.

Consequently, few things these boys did had any real impact. AEW newbies who don't know too much about ROH's rich history would be forgiven for thinking this was some indy fed's belt (no jokes!). It didn't seem big time at all.


3. Scorpio Sky’s Reign

Scorpio Sky AEW TNT Title
AEW

Someone needs to pop a hand up backstage during creative meetings and ask Tony Khan what he's doing with the once-proud TNT Title. Does Tony think he's booking a modern-day complement to WWE's Intercontinental Title, or something? That's how the thing is being handled, and it sucks.

Nobody since Miro has given this strap any steam.

Scorpio Sky won the title on 9 March, and he just dropped it to Sammy Guevara on 15 April. That's hardly a reign fans will remember. The worst thing about all this is that Sky seemed to be enjoying his time in the sun; Dan Lambert and Ethan Page were also cutting some nifty promos about the championship too.

Men Of The Year hadn't even scratched the surface of this push before AEW top brass cruelly pulled it away. They did so to book a title change for the sake of it, and that's not something this promotion should be doing. Not. At. All.


2. The Wrong Main Event

Thunder Rosa AEW Women's Title
AEW

Ready for another mini-moan? You got it.

AEW seems intent on pushing women to the forefront of these specials for the sake of it. No, don't take that as an unnecessary ambush on the division - showcasing female stars like Britt Baker and Thunder Rosa is fine when their matches merit it, but neither Battle Of The Belts main event has hit home.

Britt's match with Riho on the last one was so-so, and Rosa's latest defence against Nyla Rose was hardly pulsating stuff either. This was as routine a title defence as one could imagine. Ask yourself, did you honestly think Rose was leaving with the title here? Probably not.

There are genuine concerns that Thunder is flagging now she has the belt as well. Rosa was way more interesting as the hunter instead of the hunted, and All Elite's creative nucleus really has to start drumming up better challengers for her soon.

Anyone else over Nyla in the monster challenger role?


1. No World Title (Again)

Hangman Page Adam Cole
AEW

Finally from the negatives, this.

Sure, Hangman Page and Adam Cole worked a spirited 'Texas Death Match' on the latest episode of Rampage, but therein lies the problem. No-one should hate the Friday night show getting that first taste of World Title credibility, but AEW booked that on the same weekend as a card called Battle Of The freakin' Belts.

The company's top championship was totally absent from the first instalment, so the sequel could've done with that 'Texas Death Match' itself. Instead, Tony Khan decided that Rampage was the right place for it. Again, fine, although maybe don't format your weekend this way in the future.

Another problem: Battle Of The Belts II didn't feature one rivalry that could touch Hangman vs. Cole. There was the TNT Title situation that everyone's had a hard time getting onboard with, an exhibition-style ROH bout and a hastily-assembled Women's Title feud.

It wasn't quite enough. Get the World Title on there, for crying out loud.


Ups...

2. Samoa Joe Makes The Save

Samoa Joe AEW
AEW

There's something right about seeing Samoa Joe sporting the ROH Television Title and marching to the ring with a lead pipe to kick some heel arse. That happened on Saturday night, and it was glorious. Being brutally honest, it was also one of the only redeeming qualities from the whole Ring Of Honor segment.

Joe is gonna kill you.

The Samoan is also gonna be a vital cog in the machine for AEW chief Khan's revived company, so it's cool he got a taste of the spotlight here at Battle Of The Belts. Further, would somebody please book Joe in a match against Jonathan Gresham? That's the kind of showdown worthy of cards like this.

Stick them in the ring, give them 20+ minutes and watch the pair produce a hard-hitting classic with technical elements that impresses the crap out of everyone. Or, y'know, just book Joe like this. Have him walk to the ring with a weapon and intimidate all comers as live crowds go wild.


1. Signs A Heel Turn Is Incoming

Sammy Guevara Tay Conti AEW TNT Title
AEW

AEW fans have been booing Sammy Guevara and Tay Conti on and off for a while now. Their antics here, despite coming against definite heels like Men Of The Year, suggest that All Elite know they must turn the pair properly soon. It's inevitable, and necessary.

Sammy's smug expressions alone makes him a better heel than face.

Some promo bragging about Guevara being the new TNT Champ and bedding Conti every night should do the trick. It's heel 101, but it'd work due to Sammy's slappable mug. No, it's not great that Scorp just got shoved to the side when he hadn't exactly been tanking as champion, but the Guevara/Tay duo can rescue something out of all this.

Sammy as a brash young heel who knows he's hot sh*t and rubs his lifestyle in everyone's faces would be a neat counterpoint to hardworking everyman Hangman Page at the top of the title tree. It's important that AEW has clear differences between each champ anyway.

What did you think of AEW's Battle Of The Belts II? For more like this, check out 5 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Rampage (April 15) and 10 Things We Learned From Bully Ray On Stone Cold’s Broken Skull Sessions Podcast!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.