7 White-Hot Wrestlers That BURNED OUT Overnight
Wrestling's a cyclical industry, but these former WWE stars experienced their own booms and busts...
Pro wrestling is an industry built on a superstar creating momentum for themselves, maintaining that hype train's speed, and riding it all the way to the top of the card and into the hearts of fans around the world. There are superstars that have managed to put in years of hard work and dedication to reach this point, only to somehow manage to nuke their careers in one fell swoop.
There are a whole host of ways superstars find a way to do this. More often than not, there is an incident that plays out in front of the world or in wrestling's 24/7 news cycle that causes fans to meltdown. This is usually followed up by the wrestler's employers terminating that wrestler's contract and putting them out to pasture, or hoping the incident blows over and they can carry on (depending on how head office feels about them).
For whatever reason, this is a list of superstars who managed to take genuine heat and their whole bright future, and flush it headfirst into the toilet in one fell swoop.
7. Matt Riddle
On the surface of things, Matt Riddle had most of the qualities someone needs to succeed at the top of wrestling's food chain. He's athletic, he has a recognisable signature look, and his laidback, stoner personality and brand of humor were infectious. He formed believable and fun bonds with the likes of Randy Orton, and could draw real emotion out of WWE's global audience.
The problem seems to be that Matt Riddle, the man, is a world-class chode. As fans, we like our superstars to give compelling interviews away from the ring and have something of substance to say. Riddle always felt like a company's worst nightmare anytime anyone put a microphone in front of him. He'd say dumb things that soured fans' love for him, and unnecessarily criticise his coworkers.
For example, Riddle would constantly take jabs at Goldberg. It's not even that he was wrong about Goldberg being light on in-ring ability; it's more that it's dickish to say it when he works with you. On that motif, Riddle would also spend time poking Brock Lesnar when he was one of the company's top draws.
It speaks volumes that Riddle's reputation with fans is so low that nobody is lobbying for his return to WWE. AEW Sickos have never clamoured for Tony Khan to secure his signature. Considering Riddle's ability and charisma, that's a damning indictment of where he is in 2026.
6. Tessa Blanchard
Sometimes, the stain on a wrestler's reputation is so bad that it follows them everywhere they go. No matter what ring she steps foot in, Tessa Blanchard gets a nuclear reaction from fans at ringside. Not because of her ability to draw heat, but because of a deplorable 2020 racism scandal that she instigated.
After being picked by WWE, alongside Rhea Ripley and Bianca Belair, to be part of the 2017 Mae Young Classic, Tessa Blanchard eventually became one of the top names in TNA's heavily praised Knockouts Division. This all came grinding to a halt when Blanchard put out a tweet suggesting that women wrestlers need to stand up for one another, only for a whole host of women to step up and accuse Blanchard of abusive behaviour. This wasn't one or two people either. It was a roster's worth of talent.
The worst of the allegations against Blanchard involved her spitting in a black woman's face in Japan and calling her the N-word. This allegation was reaffirmed by many different parties. It has irreparably damaged Blanchard's reputation with fans wherever she goes, with the chant of "she's a racist" being audible whenever she is given TV time in the USA.
5. EC3
A lot of the superstars on this list are victims of their own actions, but spare a little thought for EC3. After years of ripping it up in TNA, Ethan Carter III felt like a man destined for the WWE. His charisma, look, and size all felt like a Vince McMahon wet dream, and when he signed on to NXT, it felt like the start of massive things for the jacked superstar.
Only things didn't turn out that way at all. Performing during a time when NXT was more about great wrestling and felt closer to the indie boom of the time than it did WWE's biggest stages, EC3 felt a little underwhelming for the black and gold brand. The common perception was that bigger things awaited on the main roster, where promos and personality are worth their weight in gold.
Things got even worse for Ethan when he reached the big time. For reasons that make no sense to anybody, WWE decided to make EC3 a mute, rendering his biggest qualities useless. He floundered as a result and was released. So much damage was done to his reputation and (seemingly) confidence that EC3 has failed to capture what made him seem so special prior to signing with WWE.
4. Velveteen Dream
Velveteen Dream was one of the most popular superstars to ever pass through WWE's third brand. Most talent that made their way to the top in NXT were already established indie superstars, but the Dream was a homegrown WWE product who not only had the chops to thrive in NXT, but was everything you could want from a main roster superstar.
Of everyone on this list who nuked their own career, Velveteen Dream's is perhaps the most extreme. In April 2020, pictures of the man born Patrick Clark Jr surfaced online, along with allegations that he was using those images to try and groom underage boys. This was later followed by more allegations that Clark had been sending images to an underage girl, as well as messaging several other minors inappropriately.
The man who played NXT's Velveteen Dream would face further criminal charges in subsequent years for trespassing and first-degree battering, as well as another charge of possessing drug paraphernalia. WWE had no option but to dismiss Velveteen Dream, and a man who was being tipped as a potential future WrestleMania main eventer had self-destructed in the most lamentable and deplorable ways possible.
3. Enzo Amore
Enzo Amore and Big Cass are still in the conversation when debating the most popular act to ever appear in NXT. Their intro featured the loudest and most enjoyable WWE chant-along since The New Age Outlaws, and their 'little and large' double act drew a fanatical response wherever they went. Things started great on the main roster, with the pair having an unforgettable Raw moment with The Dudley Boyz, before Vince McMahon eventually split them up.
Enzo Amore was being used as the antagonist of the Cruiserweight division, but rumours of his obnoxious backstage behaviour grew louder with every passing week. He then faced sexual assault allegations in January 2018, which WWE suspended him for immediately. When it transpired that the allegations had been going on for months, WWE fired Amore for not letting them know he was under police investigation.
Those allegations were later dropped, but Amore had already hindered a WWE return with his insane actions at the 2018 Survivor Series in Los Angeles. He bought a seat in the first few rows on the camera side of the audience and tried hijacking the show by coercing the crowd to join in with his signature intro, before being escorted out by security.
Rumours continue to circulate that Amore might return to WWE, with Big Cass currently back on Raw.
2. Teddy Hart
The Hart family is one of the most decorated and well-respected in wrestling history. Bret, Owen, and Natalya all have a plethora of accolades and are beloved by fans, but Bret and Owen's nephew Teddy is unfortunately a different story. In 1998, WWE signed Teddy as the youngest wrestler to ever sign a developmental deal with the world's biggest wrestling promotion, with big things planned for the latest graduate from the Hart Dungeon.
Things would sour quickly from this dream scenario. For his whole career, Hart has been dogged by accusations of having a bad attitude, including belittling trainers, arriving late for shows or not showing up at all, and a litany of run-ins with the police. He has passed through WWE twice, Ring of Honor twice, and the NWA among others, consistently being fired for behavioral issues.
Hart has remained unable to keep his problems away from the ring in check, including being arrested four times in 2020 alone. He has only wrestled for RCW, Real Canadian Wrestling, in the past four years, as the wrestling business continues to leave Teddy behind.
1. Sexy Star
Lucha Underground remains one of the most beloved companies in wrestling history with good reason. The unique presentation and galaxy of stars that LU produced have seen its reputation grow even more over time, with The Lucha Bros, Penta and Rey Fenix, Chelsea Green, Ricochet, Swerve Strickland and many more getting some of their biggest breaks from that promotion.
One of the biggest and most promising names in LU was that of Sexy Star. Star was the first female Gift of the Gods Champion and the first female Lucha Underground Champion who also built a reputation in AAA, but everything changed overnight due to an in-ring incident at AAA TripleMania XXV in 2017.
In a Fatal Four-Way Match for the Reina de Reinas Championship, Star slapped a shoot armbar on TNA's Rosemary, popping her arm out of place and causing legitimate injury. Further problems stemmed from Star trying to brush it off as an accident, as was vehemently disputed by Rosemary in a lengthy social media post and confirmed by other workers in the business. With high-profile wrestlers like Cody Rhodes and Road Dogg calling for her to be blacklisted, Star's career was ended immediately due to this incident.