20 Absolute Worst Wrestlers EVER (... According To YOU!)
The internet casts its critical eye over the very worst in wrestling history, and nobody's safe!
The internet is a cold and brutal place.
You know that, because you're on it right now reading this, but typically a WhatCulture list is a cosy warm blanket around the shoulders compared to some other sites and platforms. Where you can be rated, you can be slated, and where there are opportunities to praise, there are just as many to punish. Here's where the arbiters and ombudsmen of the online wrestling space Cagematch come in.
Their records lovingly document everything every wrestler has done, allowing legacies to be secured forever amidst walls of fascinating data and details. They also permit users to score everything out of ten, ensuring that the industry's best are showered with yet more plaudits from the hardest of hardcore fans.
This is not that list.
Reversing the filter, here are the 20 wrestlers that account for the lowest scores in the entire database. In the interest of some fairness, the wrestlers in question had to have a minimum of 40 votes to indicate if they'd made enough of a real impact, but beyond that, here are those that the internet's most dedicated user base decided that this lot really were the worst of the worst.
Strap in...
20. Rodney (1.54/10)
As a member of the Mean Street Posse, Rodney was the embodiment of WWE’s late-'90s tendency to throw just about anyone on television, regardless of wrestling ability.
A childhood friend of Shane McMahon, Rodney had the look of a Greenwich rich kid but none of the athleticism or skill required to make a meaningful impact in the ring. His role as part of the Mean Street Posse was to play the cowardly heel alongside Pete Gas and Joey Abs, but Rodney's inexperience was glaring every time he stepped through the ropes.
Lacking any real presence, his matches away from the one storyline he belonged in were tedious, and it became clear that his role should have only ever been to enhance Shane's heel credibility. Rodney’s wrestling was awkward, and his inability to work even basic matches dragged down the quality of the segments he appeared in. He was part of a novelty act, but especially on a 2000 roster stacked with legitimate talent, Rodney felt like dead weight.
19. Mark Madden (1.41/10)
Mark Madden’s WCW tenure is mostly remembered for his over-the-top and sometimes annoying commentary, but any brief glimpses of his in-ring efforts only solidified his status as somebody who should have just stayed in the booth.
Known for his brash personality on the mic, Madden’s on-screen antics were often grating, and when he stepped inside the ring for a couple of novelty outings, things got even worse. Madden wasn’t a wrestler, and his involvement in physical segments felt like yet more desperate attempts by WCW to squeeze more heat from non-wrestling personalities
In an era already drowning in celebrity/novelty appearances, Madden’s in-ring contributions were abysmal. Whether taking a few stiff bumps or awkwardly colliding with his opponents, his performances couldn't elevate the lousy stories WCW attempted to tell. Worse still, the credibility Madden might have gotten across with his controversial commentary vanished whenever he laced up his boots.
18. Rockin' Rebel (1.40/10)
Rockin' Rebel’s early ECW run is a prime example of how far the promotion had to go before it found its true identity as a force for change in an industry that desperately needed it.
In the early '90s, ECW was still a far cry from the hardcore fan haven it became, and Rockin' Rebel's lacklustre performances were emblematic of that awkward era. A bland, unremarkable heel, Rebel was the kind of wrestler whose in-ring work was so forgettable that - against the context of a company trying to reinvent the wheel - it bordered on pointless.
His 1993 feud with The Sandman is a lowlight of ECW's formative years. The matches were slow, plodding, and devoid of the energy or innovation that would soon define the promotion. In particular, their clash at UltraClash 1993 was a disaster, exposing Rebel’s lack of charisma and wrestling skill as he botched simple spots and failed to connect with the ECW crowd. Rockin' Rebel wasn't a horrible wrestler - he was simply a drab relic of a pre-ECW era of wrestling the company was trying to escape from.
17. Eva Marie (1.28/10)
Eva Marie's wrestling career was defined by her lack of ability to wrestle, such was the era for the market leader she emerged during, and the heat that inability was occasionally able to generate.
Regardless of her obvious superstar charisma, she constantly looked out of her depth in WWE's women's division when the bell rang. Her early run was riddled with poorly-received performances; most notably the botch-riddled multi-women matches, where miscommunications led to awkward moments that highlighted her inexperience. It got no better, especially when the division did. The gulf widened, and so too did the opportunity for Marie to ever make it beyond garnering the cheapest heat.
All that said, a December 2015 match with Bayley for the NXT Women’s Championship deserves a peculiar form of credit. Acknowledging the challenger's weaknesses, the match became an exercise in storytelling and smoke-and-mirrors booking. As a master of babyface crowd psychology, Bayley guided Eva through a bout that leaned into the fans' rejection of her, using outside interference and dramatic near-falls to build tension. While it didn’t hide Eva’s lack of skill, it managed to turn her deficiencies into something that could make the best of her shortcomings.
16. Giant Gonzalez (1.22/10)
The late and sometimes inadvertently great Giant Gonzalez literally stood out as one of the worst in-ring performers in wrestling history, with his sheer size not even being that helpful an asset due to how lean and uncoordinated he appeared.
Despite his imposing height, Gonzalez lacked the basic athleticism and coordination required to deliver even a broadly believable match. His WWE tenure is best remembered for his disastrous bouts with The Undertaker, particularly their match at WrestleMania IX. Gonzalez’s movements were painfully slow, his strikes were unconvincing, and the match’s infamous chloroform disqualification finish was a desperate attempt to mask how unworkable it had become.
It wasn't as though his limitations were surprising either. As El Gigante in WCW years earlier, things weren’t much better. His matches exposed his inability to keep up with even the best workers of the era, resulting in plodding, disjointed contests.
15. Eli Cottonwood (1.10/10)
With height and an unnerving aura on his side, Eli Cottonwood had the look of a dominant big man, but he lacked any hint of athleticism or charisma to make it count.
His NXT matches were mostly dismal, with his bout against former ROH icon Kaval being a particular low point. Cottonwood’s clumsy movements and awkward offence made the match feel disjointed, with TAFKA Low-Ki having to do all the work just to keep it watchable.
However, it was his infamous "moustache" promo that truly cemented Cottonwood’s place as a laughing stock, and realistically the moment that's likely earned him the low rating. Asked to cut a promo about a moustache per the horrendous rigged game that was the show's format, Cottonwood stumbled and mumbled his way through an incoherent, bizarre monologue that became an internet punchline.
His wooden delivery and utter lack of confidence in his promos made it clear that Cottonwood was out of his depth in every aspect of WWE’s spotlight, regardless of whether in-ring improvement was even possible.
14. Asya (1.07/10)
Asya’s WCW run was an unfortunate chapter in the company's latter-day attempts to mirror WWE’s successes with cheap knock-offs, particularly with the towering presence of Chyna.
Billed as the opposition's answer to the 'Ninth Wonder of the World', Asya lacked the in-ring ability and star power that made her counterpart a trailblazer. Her matches were awkward, and clunky, and exposed her as someone thrust into the spotlight with little actual wrestling skill.
A notably rotten debut alongside Dean Malenko against Torrie Wilson and David Flair highlighted her inability to work smoothly even in limited action. Singles matches - such as her dismal clash with veteran Madusa from a Saturday Night taping - got no better. While Chyna thrived with her unique blend of power and presence, Asya was a pale imitation, hampered by poor execution and an obvious lack of experience.
13. Chris DeJoseph (1.03/10)
Chris DeJoseph, best known as Big Dick Johnson, was one of WWE’s most infamous creative team members turned in-ring performers, and think of the ground that covers.
His gimmick saw him perform as a greased-up, thong-clad dancer during backstage and in-ring segments was met with widespread disdain from fans and talent alike. Meant to be comedic, the act quickly became a symbol of WWE’s over-reliance on crass and formless humour during the mid-2000s.
DeJoseph’s rare in-ring appearances were just as embarrassing as his pathetic antics. Most notably, his involvement in a segment with DX and Vince McMahon during a 2006 episode of Raw saw him strip down in the ring, leaving the audience cringing rather than laughing. It was painfully clear that DeJoseph was never meant to be a wrestler, and his performances were way beyond the traditional levels of unacceptably bad.
His contributions bell-to-bell were, mercifully, as minuscule as his choice of underwear.
12. Nicole Bass (0.85/10)
Nicole Bass’ brief wrestling career in WWE and ECW is largely remembered for how awkward and ineffective she was during a period when almost everybody found a way to get over.
With her imposing physique, Bass was inevitably compared to WWE’s Chyna, but the similarities ended with their looks. Where Chyna exuded star power and steadily improved her in-ring work when given the chance to work in meaningful matches, Bass struggled to deliver even the basics, with clunky movements and a clear lack of ring awareness.
Matches often fell apart due to Bass’s inability to execute moves smoothly, with opponents working around her far more than against her. Her ECW run was similarly forgettable, with work alongside Justin Credible showcasing her lack of coordination and inability to find a place in a company known as much for misfits as maestros. There'd never been a better time for her to give it a go, but never any evidence that the participation could lead to plaudits.
11. Brakkus (0.76/10)
Brakkus was a prime example of WWE’s misguided obsession with bodybuilders during the late 1990s.
With his chiselled physique, the Vince McMahon dream sequence wrestler looked like a can't-miss, but the moment the bell rang, his in-ring limitations became glaringly obvious. Lacking any real wrestling instincts or athleticism, Brakkus’s brief WWE run was a series of forgettable performances that exposed the veneer performer and promoter strove to create.
Bouts were slow, awkward, and filled with poorly executed spots, as numerous different, dynamic and diverse wrestlers tried and failed to make something - anything - work with the lumbering powerhouse. His time in ECW wasn’t much better, with his CyberSlam 1998 match against Taz being a particularly embarrassing affair. Brakkus was utterly outclassed despite being given power spots over his smaller opponent, and the match was kept relatively brief to avoid further disaster.
More's the pity too - the look was so good and others have gotten by on much less.
10. Hardbody Harrison (0.76/10)
Hardbody Harrison’s time in WCW is largely remembered for how unremarkable and/or downright bad his in-ring performances were. A lower-card fixture in the late ‘90s, Harrison’s matches felt stiff and uninspired, with none of the technical prowess or storytelling ability to stand out in WCW’s deep roster. His matches against more experienced talent exposed his limitations, even, in a one-note role of jobber.
And it didn't get better when he got a match under control - Harrison’s attacks lacked any impact, and his inexperience showed as he often looked lost and seemingly struggled to keep up with the pace of his peers.
Not that much of that would end up mattering. Harrison’s legacy is overshadowed by his shocking personal controversies. In 2007, he was convicted of Peonage, Forced Labor, Human Trafficking, Sex Trafficking, Witness Tampering, Criminal Conspiracy and Obstruction of Justice and sentenced to life in prison. His criminal behaviour outside the ring tainted his already forgettable wrestling career, leaving him known more for his horrific legal issues than anything he ever did inside the squared circle.
9. Eddy Steinblock (0.65/10)
Known (ish) for his time in German wrestling and brief appearances on the international stage, Eddy Steinblock was a clear example of a wrestler whose size and look couldn’t compensate for his lack of ability.
There have been many like him, but perhaps Steinblock earned his negative stripes because Cagematch has roots in Germany. Or perhaps that's generous and the work of his that was visible to the wider world was almost uniformly terrible. Hunt him down on YouTube and the criticisms are consistent - matches are plodding with little-to-no psychology or pacing. Even the shorter shots drag as a result.
His size may have drawn some attention, but his in-ring work consistently failed to deliver, making Steinblock a footnote in wrestling history for all the wrong reasons. And for one of those all-time worst wrong reasons exhibitions, check out his match with another performer who features elsewhere on this list.
8. Chasyn Rance (0.54/10)
Chasyn Rance’s wrestling career is a mix of forgettable in-ring performances and disturbing controversies outside of it. Despite floating around the independent scene for years, Rance never managed to impress between the ropes.
His matches were marked by average-at-best execution, dicey pacing, and a clear lack of standout ability. His appearances in Ring of Honor during the mid-2000s in particular exposed his shortcomings, as he struggled to keep up with more talented competitors, often appearing a step behind in both timing and skill.
However, it's Rance's legal troubles that overshadow his wrestling failures. In 2011, he was convicted of unlawful sexual activity with a minor in 2008 - a charge that shocked the wrestling community and left a dark stain on his reputation. Despite this, Rance has continued to sporadically wrestle, but his legacy is far more defined by his criminal actions than anything he ever did inside the ring.
7. Invader #1 (0.53/10)
José González AKA Invader #1 is undoubtedly more infamous across the wider wrestling landscape for his role in one of wrestling grizzliest tragedies, and his in-ring work left nothing memorable to replace the tales told of what happened on the night of Bruiser Brody's death.
In July 1988, González fatally stabbed professional wrestler Brody backstage, though he was ultimately acquitted of murder a year later after a jury accepted that he was acting in self-defence. It's the story of his life in the industry - the sort of tale a legendary career couldn't overtake, let alone a meek and insignificant one.
Known for his time in Puerto Rico’s World Wrestling Council (WWC), González’s matches were more often than not dull and lifeless. His brawling style, while fitting for the WWC’s blood-soaked atmosphere, was formulaic and devoid of any technical proficiency. Invader #1’s inability to adapt or elevate his game for major matches and brawls left audiences disengaged. Despite Puerto Rican prominence, his in-ring legacy is marked by a lack of memorable performances, and marred by the aforementioned controversy.
6. Jenna Morasca (0.44/10)
Jenna Morasca's brief foray into professional wrestling stands as one of TNA’s most embarrassing low points, and consider just how deep that well actually is.
Finding reality TV fame on Survivor, Morasca had no wrestling experience but was thrust into a high-profile match at Victory Road 2009 against fellow Main Event Mafia cohort Sharmell. The result was one of the worst matches in TNA history; a bout so poorly executed that it became a new shorthand for a worst-of-all-time contender.
The contest was littered with missed spots and moments too inadvertently funny to be competitive. It climaxed (?) with the now-infamous above scene - Morasca awkwardly slaps Sharmell to the ground in her big fire-up, but just happens to do so without a shred of dramatic or athletic impact. It was universally panned by fans and critics alike, cementing Morasca as one of the worst celebrity wrestling experiments in history.
5. Rob Black (0.44/10)
A low vote with Cagematch users won't be the first popularity contest Rob Black has lost, and that all comes down to the reputation he developed as the distasteful owner of the only slightly less distasteful Xtreme Pro Wrestling.
He occasionally stepped into the XPW ring to get physical, but his performances were laughably bad, and the man himself was dislikable enough to earn this score despite only having a single match to his name. Black booked himself in an XPW World Heavyweight Title Losers Leave XPW tag team match in 2001, partnering with: Johnny Webb to defeat Josh Lazie and Sabu, but his name didn't belong with Webb and Lazie, let alone the 'Homicidal, Suicidal, Genocidal Maniac'.
Beyond wrestling, Black's work in pornography via his Extreme Associates organisation has landed him in legal trouble numerous times, and his morally and ethically questionable choices were enough to land him and XPW a Dark Side Of The Ring episode in 2021.
4. Ed Ferrara (0.42/10)
Ed Ferrara’s ill-advised leap from the writer’s room in WWE to the wrestling ring in WCW was a textbook example of why non-wrestlers should stay out of the squared circle. As Oklahoma, Ferrara became a tasteless parody of former colleague and superior Jim Ross, going beyond using Ross' vocal quirks and speech patterns into trivialising and mocking his suffering of Bell's Palsy.
Ferrara’s in-ring work was almost as ill-judged as the gimmick itself. His match against Madusa at Souled Out was yet another low point for a company in total free fall. Supposed to be a comedic intergender mismatch bout, it ended up being an awkward spectacle that exposed Ferrara’s complete lack of in-ring ability despite a handful of mid-90s matches predating his mainstream tenures. Madusa had to carry the entire match en route to a loss that crowned 'OK' the Cruiserweight Champion, burying that division too.
It was significantly damaging to his name despite the high profile he'd held in the industry as late as mid-1999. Ferrara, like the Oklahoma character, is considered one of the figures that expedited WCW’s decline and death.
3. One Warrior Nation (0.25/10)
One Warrior Nation is a hard figure to parse.
More than a rip-off, the character is a rip-off of a rip-off, only with even less presence and platform than the "original". Several of his mostly awful matches are available to view on YouTube, and as is immediately clear, he is a fairly on-the-nose tribute to the Ultimate Warrior. Unfortunately for One Warrior Nation, WCW did this on a national level with Renegade, forever poisoning the well for anybody else who tried to lift aspects of Jim Hellwig's iconic character.
Away from Warrior-ception, One Warrior Nation simply isn't all that great where it matters. He hits the ring and shakes the ropes with approximately half of Warrior's own vim and vigour, and is completely incapable of nailing the press slam and big splash with convincing effect. There have been bigger crimes to independent wrestling than 'OWN', but the sheer audaciousness of the theft seems to have doomed him to this particularly low score.
2. Gable Steveson (0.22/10)
Gable Steveson’s transition from Olympic gold medalist to WWE prospect was a disaster.
Despite his amateur wrestling pedigree, Steveson’s in-ring performances exposed just how difficult the leap to professional wrestling actually is. After several appearances where he struggled to know how to place himself amongst more charismatic colleagues, Steveson's formal debut against Baron Corbin at the Great American Bash 2023 was an unmitigated disaster.
Though Corbin worked hard to guide him through the match, Steveson was stiff, disjointed and oddly uncoordinated for somebody who had such a celebrated amateur background.
His inexperience and ill-preparedness for the role was painfully obvious, and despite WWE’s heavy interest in him, he failed to show any real instincts that could have made good on their investment. A series of NXT and SmackDown dark matches followed but didn't improve his stock, and he was cut alongside his expensive contract in mid-2024.
1. Bubba The Love Sponge (0.11/10)
Bubba The Love Sponge's brief involvement in pro wrestling was nothing short of disastrous, both for his own legacy and for those unfortunate enough to be associated with him.
A radio shock jock with zero wrestling ability or charisma, Bubba somehow found himself inserted into TNA during Hulk Hogan's ill-fated regime, long before their relationship went hideously sour. His presence was baffling and damaging; a reminder of the worst excesses of celebrity involvement in wrestling, not least when it came at the expense of others who deserved television time.
Bubba's on-screen segments were insufferable, but it was behind the scenes where his toxic influence truly shone. Most infamously, his offensive comments toward Awesome Kong led to real-life tension and physical altercations, driving one of TNA’s most beloved talents away. His behaviour represented everything wrong with wrestling’s dated obsession with shock value over substance, and he left TNA worse than he found it. Bubba was a complete failure in wrestling, a blight on a product already struggling with credibility, with a career only survived by this magic shot of Mick Foley shoot chinning him on yet another rotten 2010 edition of Impact.